Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final
(05-20-2026, 08:47 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: What a mess - still.

Whilst I think the original decision was disproportionate, the correct decision is to throw out the Southampton appeal.

This isn't over, is it. In terms of a legal challenge.

(05-20-2026, 08:32 PM)Even Flow 2.0 Wrote:
(05-20-2026, 08:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: £5,000 an hour from the office and £80,000 an hour in high court… 

I guess it’s peanuts compared to the £200M they’ve been fined.

To see their faces after they lose the final would almost be worth letting them off!

Latest update is the players are now looking to sue the club for lost earnings…

Apparently relegation resulted in a 40% pay cut with certain amounts of that cut repaid should they win promotion, plus obviously future earnings in the season following promotion. Given how confident their CEO was earlier that they’d win the £200M prize money, they may well be left with a big old bill hitting their SCR calculations next year.

All because an intern couldn’t come up with a convincing lie and bought a coffee Big Grin
Wonder just how big of a sliding doors moment this could be for them. Obviously potentially missing out on the Prem is massive but this could also lead to a good chunk of their squad wanting out.

And who would blame them? 

Imagine working your tits off all year, earning a play-off final spot, only to have it all taken away because a member of staff has breached EFL rules. 

I assume the playing staff aren't complicite in the farce, and had no idea this was going on. Or did they? Who knows!? I'm assuming, until informed otherwise, they didn't know.

Indeed - I doubt Ekhert and his staff went into pre game meetings saying “this is what we’ve seen from their training…” - I’m sure there may have been some suspicions of things that were happening, as I’m sure there’d be some interesting drills, and bits of advice given to them ahead of matches, but I’m not sure their whole squad was in on it and invested into it. I guess the truth will come out if that legal action takes place…

I expect Saints to lose some sponsors over this mess, and there will surely be a drop in ST renewals. Things about to get very interesting.

(05-20-2026, 09:05 PM)sickParrot Wrote:
Quote: In written evidence submitted to the EFL, the whistleblower is understood to have claimed that team meetings included references to opposition data being gathered from the training ground

If this is true, the players don’t have much room for complaint.

Depends, their coaching staff may have told them it was all done legitimately and in accordance with the rules…
Reply
I would be most surprised if Hull haven’t been be training to play either opponent as they have known for a week this was a possible outcome.
But I really don’t know. I just hope Hull win.
Reply
Presumably Eckert's sacking will be announced tonight or early tomorrow.
Reply
I wonder if they managed to spy on Albion. You can bet they did this to more than just Boro, Ipswich & Oxford (they won none of the two league games they've admitted).
Reply
I had a look on the link to that Saints messageboard earlier in the thread and it was mentioned that Boro had identified four other teams who had been spied on but two of them "weren't interested", presumably in giving/providing evidence to the tribunal.
Reply
(05-20-2026, 09:22 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I wonder if they managed to spy on Albion. You can bet they did this to more than just Boro, Ipswich & Oxford (they won none of the two league games they've admitted).

Interesting that the only other two they’ve admitted to were a loss, and a draw which ultimately didn’t cost Ipswich. No way they would admit to spying on a team they beat.
Reply
(05-20-2026, 06:45 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm aware the rules were changed after Leeds, and it's a slightly different scenario in that it was a league game as opposed to a play-off game, but it's some difference to fine Leeds £200k when they were found guilty, and then expel Saints from the final, robbing them a chance to win £200mil. It's a massive difference for similar breaches, isn't it? No matter how you dress it up.

I still feel this is a disproportionate punishment. Yes, I know I'm in the minority in this. And yes, they should face punishment, and yes, they're very much in the wrong, and, yes, they have only themselves to blame for being so dishonourable (I'll state that again!). That's not me trying to be argumentative or contrary, that's my honest feeling. It doesn't feel the right to me.

The whole situation is a mess. I can't see any scenario that doesn't end up messy, and a club(s) initiating some form of legal proceedings. Farcical, from many points of view.

You need to forget about Leeds, there was no spying law in place at that time, this case is the precedent not Leeds/Derby. Then you will understand the sanction.
Reply
(05-20-2026, 09:22 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I wonder if they managed to spy on Albion. You can bet they did this to more than just Boro, Ipswich & Oxford (they won none of the two league games they've admitted).

If we're talking about the Mason game I imagine the spy turned up, saw training for about 5 minutes and went home confident of a home win without needing to make any notes.
Reply
(05-21-2026, 06:23 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(05-20-2026, 06:45 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm aware the rules were changed after Leeds, and it's a slightly different scenario in that it was a league game as opposed to a play-off game, but it's some difference to fine Leeds £200k when they were found guilty, and then expel Saints from the final, robbing them a chance to win £200mil. It's a massive difference for similar breaches, isn't it? No matter how you dress it up.

I still feel this is a disproportionate punishment. Yes, I know I'm in the minority in this. And yes, they should face punishment, and yes, they're very much in the wrong, and, yes, they have only themselves to blame for being so dishonourable (I'll state that again!). That's not me trying to be argumentative or contrary, that's my honest feeling. It doesn't feel the right to me.

The whole situation is a mess. I can't see any scenario that doesn't end up messy, and a club(s) initiating some form of legal proceedings. Farcical, from many points of view.

You need to forget about Leeds, there was no spying law in place at that time, this case is the precedent not Leeds/Derby. Then you will understand the sanction.

The EFL could have retrospectively changed the rules to punish Leeds more severely, if they wanted to. 

I'm sure they've got previous in changing rules retrospectively...
Reply
(05-20-2026, 09:32 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I had a look on the link to that Saints messageboard earlier in the thread and it was mentioned that Boro had identified four other teams who had been spied on but two of them "weren't interested", presumably in giving/providing evidence to the tribunal.

Guessing those two that werent interested might not want to be dragged into being asked if they did it as well. There is no way it is just Southampton, they were just the ones caught
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: