Jenrick
#11
The truth of that matter is that Proth is like most other Tories at the moment. More obsessed with Labour being blasted at the next election than anything worthwhile. He’s like a parrot of the day to day Daily Mail stuff on Burnham. Which warms my heart - because they fear, quite rightly, that he can turn the titanic around. Not that he will. But he might. And that is the long and short of all the child like squealing here.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#12
(05-20-2026, 07:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And Lets be honest here, he really isn't in the BoJo league of fucking the country for personal gain. 

I never suggested he was. But the soft-left outsider shtick is fucking laughable to those of us who have been students of this game for 30 years or more.

(05-20-2026, 08:01 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The truth of that matter is that Proth is like most other Tories at the moment. More obsessed with Labour being blasted at the next election than anything worthwhile. He’s like a parrot of the day to day Daily Mail stuff on Burnham. Which warms my heart - because they fear, quite rightly, that he can turn the titanic around. Not that he will. But he might. And that is the long and short of all the child like squealing here.

More tiresome bollocks. Because I'm a fucking adult I absolutely hope that Burnham, if he wins, can do some good for the country. The alternative down the road is far far worse.

But the fact of the matter is that a vote for Burnham is a vote for a fella who changes his stance as often as he changes his underpants. That is a FACT, whether you like it or not.
Reply
#13
How does supporting the idea of a Palestinian state contradict support for Israel to exist as a democracy with equal rights for minorities exactly?
Reply
#14
(05-20-2026, 08:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-20-2026, 07:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And Lets be honest here, he really isn't in the BoJo league of fucking the country for personal gain. 

I never suggested he was. But the soft-left outsider shtick is fucking laughable to those of us who have been students of this game for 30 years or more.

(05-20-2026, 08:01 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The truth of that matter is that Proth is like most other Tories at the moment. More obsessed with Labour being blasted at the next election than anything worthwhile. He’s like a parrot of the day to day Daily Mail stuff on Burnham. Which warms my heart - because they fear, quite rightly, that he can turn the titanic around. Not that he will. But he might. And that is the long and short of all the child like squealing here.

More tiresome bollocks. Because I'm a fucking adult I absolutely hope that Burnham, if he wins, can do some good for the country. The alternative down the road is far far worse.

But the fact of the matter is that a vote for Burnham is a vote for a fella who changes his stance as often as he changes his underpants. That is a FACT, whether you like it or not.

The world evolves and peoples views evolve with it. Give it a try.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#15
Thanks for highlighting BB but this is one of the greatest frustrations with Proth, he will cherry pick the parts of any post for the one's he can answer and ignore the ones that make him either look foolish or would result in him accepting anyone else has a point. Yesterday I asked a reasonable question which was ignored and then got lost in the daily Dekka / Proth 50 post black is white discussion.
Reply
#16
(05-20-2026, 08:36 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How does supporting the idea of a Palestinian state contradict support for Israel to exist as a democracy with equal rights for minorities exactly?

It doesn't necessarily. But all it illustrates is Burnhams desire to appeal to whichever audience he's addressing. The EU funk he's got himself into already is far more fundamental.

Starmer is rightly criticised for not having a position on pretty much anything. Burnham has professed at least two opinions on pretty much everything.

(05-20-2026, 08:41 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Thanks for highlighting BB but this is one of the greatest frustrations with Proth, he will cherry pick the parts of any post for the one's he can answer and ignore the ones that make him either look foolish or would result in him accepting anyone else has a point. Yesterday I asked a reasonable question which was ignored and then got lost in the daily Dekka / Proth 50 post black is white discussion.

What was the question?
Reply
#17
I'm really struggling to see how supporting the right for Israel to exist and the right for Palestine to exist as states is two different positions?

The EU position is predicated on the difference between what you want and what you can do.
Reply
#18
(05-20-2026, 08:52 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm really struggling to see how supporting the right for Israel to exist and the right for Palestine to exist as states is two different positions?

The EU position is predicated on the difference between what you want and what you can do.

I don't think Burnham ever questioned the right of Israel to exist, he was very effusive in 2015 almost likening Israel to a shining beacon of democracy in a desert of despotism. 

The EU position is entirely predicated on short term electoral expedience, please don't insult my intelligence.
Reply
#19
Again, I don't see how that contradicts wanting a Palestinian state to exist.

And I don't really see what the hell your response on the EU has to do with anything, Burnham thinks the UK being in the EU is best for the UK but knows that because of politics that isn't feasible in the immediate term. Gladstone wanted to abolish income tax but knew he had to balance spending in the Exchequer. DLG wanted a land value tax but knew that the Tory landowners propping up post-WWI coalition would collapse the government over it. Jenkins wanted to cut taxes in the late 1960s but knew the fiscal position meant that couldn't happen to ensure movement towards a surplus and resistance from the Labour Party to cut spending too much. That's the whole point of politics.
Reply
#20
Agree, BB. But imagine the political traction you could get from implementing a land tax now. The entitled rich (usually those who've had it handed down or large businesses) have to pay more and would potentially free up land for housing. Sort housing, increase the tax yield and the rest of the political vitriol will start to ebb away.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)