Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final
#71
(05-17-2026, 05:53 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 05:11 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it

(05-17-2026, 12:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: Regardless of which is subjectively "worse" in terms of severity of cheating, the rules were put in place to outlaw spying after the Leeds situation, so that stands on its own terms.  For credible enforcement, the result of the first game ought to be 3-0 Boro.

Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.

The EFL did just that and said you’d breached PSR limits, and almost everyone here defended the club and blamed the EFL instead. So pardon me for not believing you about your thoughts on rules and being livid with Albion had breached the same rules and put you at risk of sanctions

One is subjective and one is very black and white. It’s not really a comparison to make IMO

He is being tendentious. And tarsome.
Reply
#72
Asphalt as I can see, it's out of order.
Reply
#73
(05-17-2026, 05:48 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 05:11 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it

(05-17-2026, 12:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: Regardless of which is subjectively "worse" in terms of severity of cheating, the rules were put in place to outlaw spying after the Leeds situation, so that stands on its own terms.  For credible enforcement, the result of the first game ought to be 3-0 Boro.

Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.

The EFL did just that and said you’d breached PSR limits, and almost everyone here defended the club and blamed the EFL instead. So pardon me for not believing you about your thoughts on rules and being livid with Albion had breached the same rules and put you at risk of sanctions
Hang on that is not the same thing. The belief was that we had worked within the rules and even then the EFL moved the 
Goalposts. If the club had erred literally in error I would blame the club anyway. We still dont know full situation. But if the club deliberately flouted the spying rules I would be livid for such an obvious breach.  Try again.

You're arguing with a bloke who flatly refuses to admit that, despite his side spending 15 times more than the rest of the division put together, that Blues didn't buy their way to the Division 1 title! 

Pre relegation KRO used to be a reasoned poster but ever since their "World record winning" (his words) season he seems to have lost his scruples....
Reply
#74
(05-17-2026, 07:08 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 05:48 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 05:11 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it


Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.

The EFL did just that and said you’d breached PSR limits, and almost everyone here defended the club and blamed the EFL instead. So pardon me for not believing you about your thoughts on rules and being livid with Albion had breached the same rules and put you at risk of sanctions
Hang on that is not the same thing. The belief was that we had worked within the rules and even then the EFL moved the 
Goalposts. If the club had erred literally in error I would blame the club anyway. We still dont know full situation. But if the club deliberately flouted the spying rules I would be livid for such an obvious breach.  Try again.

You're arguing with a bloke who flatly refuses to admit that, despite his side spending 15 times more than the rest of the division put together, that Blues didn't buy their way to the Division 1 title! 

Pre relegation KRO used to be a reasoned poster but ever since their "World record winning" (his words) season he seems to have lost his scruples....

You’re lying mate. About what I said and what Blues spent.

We outspent the rest of the comfortably. About 70% tops though of the total spend was by us, though we started pre season with 7 senior players so built a new squad, maybe spending more than we intended as we lost 5-0 in our first pre season game to Paderborn under a rookie manager playing kids who were out of their depth. We spent £30m plus if you believe the sites out of £50m plus in total. That’s not 15 times more than the rest of the division put together though.
I always said we’d putspend everyone and win the league based on that. And backed us at 4/1, 7/2 and 3/1. So buying the league seems apt. But theres no guarantee we’d win it, I thought we would comfortably though.
Where I disagreed with people on here was that getting the world record 111 was the least we should do. The league was won in game 40 and we still won the last 6. That’s not easy. Nor is 111 points, because no team has done it before in a professional league anywhere in the world.
Budget helps. So does cost of squad but League One with Wrexham wasn’t a gimme. And Wrexham and Charlton finished in front of you. Charlton especially with a vastly smaller wage bill and squad cost. Wrexham finished above us.
I’m as reasoned as I was before, but you just disagree with more things I type.

What I will say is what Lincoln did this season was incredible. But still well short in terms of points. But achievement wise for them greater. Amazingly playing low possession, counter attacking and direct football. Interesting to see if they keep Skubala and how they do in this league
Reply
#75
(05-17-2026, 05:04 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it

(05-17-2026, 12:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:21 PM)KRO Wrote: I’m not equating the same. Diving is way worse and influences results of games and sometimes subsequent games of players get red carded due to cheating/diving players, more than watching a team train does imo. You disagree.
Regardless of which is subjectively "worse" in terms of severity of cheating, the rules were put in place to outlaw spying after the Leeds situation, so that stands on its own terms.  For credible enforcement, the result of the first game ought to be 3-0 Boro.

Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.

Exactly.....

My mate is a Saints season ticket holder and he is absolutely fuming that the club have put themselves in this position. He is expecting the worst and he has a ticket for the final.

Same, except it's my brother in law. He can't how they can be allowed to stay in the playoffs, because they've clearly cheated.
Reply
#76
KRO, the reason Albion fans were against the EFL wasn’t because they punished us for breaching PSR, it was because of the retrospective rule change to include charity donations which even the most anti-Albion fan can see was dubious.

And the “World Record” is for 24 team fully professional leagues, of which there are 3 on the planet The Championship, League One and League Two. Maybe to you that’s a world record, but to me it’s akin to the winners of the Super Bowl claiming to be the world champions.
Reply
#77
There’s always a pedant.
The world record sounds better and does trigger people Big Grin
Reply
#78
(05-18-2026, 09:43 AM)KRO Wrote: There’s always a pedant.
The world record sounds better and does trigger people Big Grin

I mean that’s true Big Grin
Reply
#79
Honestly it’s mad when you say it to a viler and you see the anger. We do need Freiburg to do the business on Wednesday though to keep them quiet
Reply
#80
(05-18-2026, 10:29 AM)KRO Wrote: Honestly it’s mad when you say it to a viler and you see the anger. We do need Freiburg to do the business on Wednesday though to keep them quiet

Im having Currywurst and Pilsner for tea on Wednesday.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)