Labour's next leader what they need
#11
(05-14-2026, 02:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So what's changed over the last few weeks? You knew all of these things but have still been calling for Starmer to go.

Nothing's changed for me
I said he'd be gone by X date (was it last summer?) but he remained
I said he'd be gone by Easter - wrong again
Maybe I will be wrong a third time.

I suppose a PM's no 1 job is to take the public along with you, inspire them, offer them hope of a better future and something/someone/some people to believe in. He never really did that. The public don't believe in him. If he stays he can't turn that around. Particularly when he thinks it's just a problem of communication.

Streeting's letter chimes with me in the bit around "island of strangers" and the country not knowing who Labour are or what they stand for. As I say, Labour needs to some Labouring and quick - with a leader whose credible. That isn't Starmer.
Reply
#12
Here is the major problem with all that - Streeting has now thrown his tuppence in without having a strategy for who's next. No one in the cabinet can claim to be the solution as they have all been part of the problem, if they weren't then why didn't they speak up earlier, or even take in a more active role in solving the problems. If Streeting had an issue with WFA and 'Island of Strangers' he's sat on his morals for a very long time.

I'm not against change, but FFS have your ducks lined up before you take the leap.
Reply
#13
Disagree with Proth, Streeting wanted to be PM but is intelligent enough to know he is unlikely to get the job, so he has a a contingency plan to try and secure the best possible job in someone else's cabinet.

Burnham wants the job, but has lots of obstacles to clear to get it.

Miliband could get the job, but almost certainly doesn't want it.. Would he want to be someone else's Chancellor. 

Raynes is the mystery. Not sure she wants the job either. There are loads of reasons why she shouldn’t want the job.

There is no one else realistically who could get the job. I know Cairns is seen as a dark horse, but I don't think the membership would be interested in him. An army career and some self promotional videos are not likely to float their noat.

Bit of a mess all round. Less than two years from winning a big majority, this shouldn’t be happening. But we live in an almost permanent febrile atmosphere when it comes to politics, where we need constant change of personnel and intrigue. Plus the big majority was misleading, it really didn't represent the mood of the electorate. Their mandate was defective.
Reply
#14
Would be so funny if Burnham stood but was then beaten by a Green or Reform candidate
Reply
#15
(05-14-2026, 02:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Here is the major problem with all that - Streeting has now thrown his tuppence in without having a strategy for who's next. No one in the cabinet can claim to be the solution as they have all been part of the problem, if they weren't then why didn't they speak up earlier, or even take in a more active role in solving the problems. If Streeting had an issue with WFA and 'Island of Strangers' he's sat on his morals for a very long time.

I'm not against change, but FFS have your ducks lined up before you take the leap.

Quite
Hence my coo in a pigeon loft point.
Reply
#16
Yet, you've been calling for this for weeks. It was obvious this is the position.
Reply
#17
Is it beyond the wit in the Labour hierarchy, ruthless machine that HQ is, to have done all this dirty work behind the scenes. The dogs on the street knew Starmer wasn't cutting it with the public by the end of year 1.

I have just been pointing out what an unnecessary shit show Labour have allowed this to become. And I go back to McSweeney and McFadden as the root cause. The attitude was an ostrich like inability to see what was in front of their noses and plan for a secession.

Denial seems to be an overwhelming emotion and tactic in the LP. Reality catches up eventually and May 7th could have been forseen by a schoolkid doing o level politics.
Reply
#18
So basically you have been calling for Starmer to get out to fuck the Labour party to show them. The situation inherited and the media bias have made an impossible task harder. The long term view should have been for him to carry on until the situation for change was in place. As has been shown over the past few years that the UK being a basket case of fools that treat the PM role as a football manager role has cost us big time, not just us btw but generations to follow.

Labour have delivered better workers rights, renters rights, improved NHS waiting times and abolished non-dom status whilst introducing a wealth tax. They've closed loopholes for the rich to avoid inheritance tax and brought farmers into line with the rest of the population (not quite but moved them towards the normal joe). But hey lets spend months discussing some poor choice of words and lack of entertainment from our PM.
Reply
#19
Is there a Parrott in the room?
Reply
#20
I'm quite amused that I seem to B1's problem.
A simple walk down any street in the whole of the UK, chatting with any random, will tell you how dimly Starmer is viewed.

First B1 says don't change anything
Now, when the world moves on, he says ah, if you must but do it in an orderly way.

I don't know what it would take for you B1 to get your head out of the sand.

Listing a list of things that any Labour govt worthy of the name should be doing hardly adds anything to the centrist dad cause.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)