PSR breach reported by John Percy
(05-13-2026, 06:24 PM)ElbowGrease73 Wrote: My standpoint still remains consistent: 'Fuck the EFL'

Amen to that
Reply
Had a quick read. 69 Pages for a small overspend is ridiculous in general. As is over 2.5 weeks for publication 

The Community Expenditure element seems pretty objectionable by the EFL. The Interest element I have no issue with them challenging that specific point. It could be open to abuse and nonsense by less scrupulous owners..see the Bournemouth £71m Net debt waiver in 2023 in the PL which the PL basically permitted on takeover.

Has the Community bit been accepted given the circs combined with the Interest recharge element being disallowed that would seem balanced to me and may have meant narrow compliance tbh to 2024-25..I would have to look again at the numbers.

For balance the Club Statement post Sanction didn't reference Interest as a point of dispute at all.

Finally a Silver Lining among the cloud could be that the £37m Pre Tax minus Allowables becomes £13m plus Allowables for a future Assessment as the EFL have a provision vs double jeopardy. Eg if the FFP loss was £28m, £29m it becomes £13m thereby making compliance a lot easier to 2025-26 and 2026-27
Reply
Sounds like a case of our Lawyers are bigger than yours

The club seem to be arguing the interest of the loan is payable
By the holding company not the club and that seems a reasonable option
In general business terms but not being an expert in accountancy
Who knows?

I like the way the Patel’s have stood their ground on this matter
And show’s they have bought into the club and have it’s interests at heart
Fair play to them.
Reply
(05-13-2026, 07:07 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Had a quick read. 69 Pages for a small overspend is ridiculous in general. As is over 2.5 weeks for publication 

The Community Expenditure element seems pretty objectionable by the EFL. The Interest element I have no issue with them challenging that specific point. It could be open to abuse and nonsense by less scrupulous owners..see the Bournemouth £71m Net debt waiver in 2023 in the PL which the PL basically permitted on takeover.

Has the Community bit been accepted given the circs combined with the Interest recharge element being disallowed that would seem balanced to me and may have meant narrow compliance tbh to 2024-25..I would have to look again at the numbers.

For balance the Club Statement post Sanction didn't reference Interest as a point of dispute at all.

Finally a Silver Lining among the cloud could be that the £37m Pre Tax minus Allowables becomes £13m plus Allowables for a future Assessment as the EFL have a provision vs double jeopardy. Eg if the FFP loss was £28m, £29m it becomes £13m thereby making compliance a lot easier to 2025-26 and 2026-27

Nice one. Sounds reasonable.
In the form of his life.
Reply
Having struggled to read through both the panel report, the EFL report and the club statement I'm now convinced it is a lottery you only win by staying awake the longest. The fine structure is A + B - C - D ÷E, then times it by the number you first thought of minus your mother's maiden name, or maybe that is the points deduction? Safe to say this level of legal-ese is the reason Man City aren't due in the dock any time soon.
Reply
(05-13-2026, 07:07 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Had a quick read. 69 Pages for a small overspend is ridiculous in general. As is over 2.5 weeks for publication 

The Community Expenditure element seems pretty objectionable by the EFL. The Interest element I have no issue with them challenging that specific point. It could be open to abuse and nonsense by less scrupulous owners..see the Bournemouth £71m Net debt waiver in 2023 in the PL which the PL basically permitted on takeover.

Has the Community bit been accepted given the circs combined with the Interest recharge element being disallowed that would seem balanced to me and may have meant narrow compliance tbh to 2024-25..I would have to look again at the numbers.

For balance the Club Statement post Sanction didn't reference Interest as a point of dispute at all.

Finally a Silver Lining among the cloud could be that the £37m Pre Tax minus Allowables becomes £13m plus Allowables for a future Assessment as the EFL have a provision vs double jeopardy. Eg if the FFP loss was £28m, £29m it becomes £13m thereby making compliance a lot easier to 2025-26 and 2026-27

Re the last paragraph. As unpalatable the ruling was, the double jeopardy rule works in our favour and we would be daft to appeal.
Reply
First point: whoever is doing Comms for the club at the moment is doing a very good job. Excellently worded statement.

The club are exactly right not to appeal. Arguing with the stupid and unscrupulous is a waste of time and money.
Reply
(05-13-2026, 07:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 07:07 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Had a quick read. 69 Pages for a small overspend is ridiculous in general. As is over 2.5 weeks for publication 

The Community Expenditure element seems pretty objectionable by the EFL. The Interest element I have no issue with them challenging that specific point. It could be open to abuse and nonsense by less scrupulous owners..see the Bournemouth £71m Net debt waiver in 2023 in the PL which the PL basically permitted on takeover.

Has the Community bit been accepted given the circs combined with the Interest recharge element being disallowed that would seem balanced to me and may have meant narrow compliance tbh to 2024-25..I would have to look again at the numbers.

For balance the Club Statement post Sanction didn't reference Interest as a point of dispute at all.

Finally a Silver Lining among the cloud could be that the £37m Pre Tax minus Allowables becomes £13m plus Allowables for a future Assessment as the EFL have a provision vs double jeopardy. Eg if the FFP loss was £28m, £29m it becomes £13m thereby making compliance a lot easier to 2025-26 and 2026-27

Re the last paragraph. As unpalatable the ruling was, the double jeopardy rule works in our favour and we would be daft to appeal.

Yep. Smart thing to do..plausibly could  look to appeal on one point ie the Charitable bit not the Interest bit but could work out for the best.
Reply
(05-13-2026, 08:25 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 07:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 07:07 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Had a quick read. 69 Pages for a small overspend is ridiculous in general. As is over 2.5 weeks for publication 

The Community Expenditure element seems pretty objectionable by the EFL. The Interest element I have no issue with them challenging that specific point. It could be open to abuse and nonsense by less scrupulous owners..see the Bournemouth £71m Net debt waiver in 2023 in the PL which the PL basically permitted on takeover.

Has the Community bit been accepted given the circs combined with the Interest recharge element being disallowed that would seem balanced to me and may have meant narrow compliance tbh to 2024-25..I would have to look again at the numbers.

For balance the Club Statement post Sanction didn't reference Interest as a point of dispute at all.

Finally a Silver Lining among the cloud could be that the £37m Pre Tax minus Allowables becomes £13m plus Allowables for a future Assessment as the EFL have a provision vs double jeopardy. Eg if the FFP loss was £28m, £29m it becomes £13m thereby making compliance a lot easier to 2025-26 and 2026-27

Re the last paragraph. As unpalatable the ruling was, the double jeopardy rule works in our favour and we would be daft to appeal.

Yep. Smart thing to do..plausibly could  look to appeal on one point ie the Charitable bit not the Interest bit but could work out for the best.

Being dumb here but can someone explain how it becomes £13 million?
Reply
(05-13-2026, 09:12 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 08:25 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 07:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 07:07 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Had a quick read. 69 Pages for a small overspend is ridiculous in general. As is over 2.5 weeks for publication 

The Community Expenditure element seems pretty objectionable by the EFL. The Interest element I have no issue with them challenging that specific point. It could be open to abuse and nonsense by less scrupulous owners..see the Bournemouth £71m Net debt waiver in 2023 in the PL which the PL basically permitted on takeover.

Has the Community bit been accepted given the circs combined with the Interest recharge element being disallowed that would seem balanced to me and may have meant narrow compliance tbh to 2024-25..I would have to look again at the numbers.

For balance the Club Statement post Sanction didn't reference Interest as a point of dispute at all.

Finally a Silver Lining among the cloud could be that the £37m Pre Tax minus Allowables becomes £13m plus Allowables for a future Assessment as the EFL have a provision vs double jeopardy. Eg if the FFP loss was £28m, £29m it becomes £13m thereby making compliance a lot easier to 2025-26 and 2026-27

Re the last paragraph. As unpalatable the ruling was, the double jeopardy rule works in our favour and we would be daft to appeal.

Yep. Smart thing to do..plausibly could  look to appeal on one point ie the Charitable bit not the Interest bit but could work out for the best.

Being dumb here but can someone explain how it becomes £13 million?
I'm also a bit thick. What's this double jeopardy all about?
Is it written in stone that we have an advantage going forward?
Or will it be something they move the goalposts on in the future?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)