05-11-2026, 09:01 AM
In terms of iconic title winning moments, "after review, the West Ham player...." isn't quite the same as "AGUERRROOOOOOOOOO!" is it?
|
VAR
|
|
05-11-2026, 09:01 AM
In terms of iconic title winning moments, "after review, the West Ham player...." isn't quite the same as "AGUERRROOOOOOOOOO!" is it?
05-11-2026, 09:43 AM
Really dislike var and it gives more and more reasons to dislike it.
I'm not averse to Arsenal winning the title, probably want them to and on balance i think this is a foul. But all season we have seen this kind of incident ignored, not all the time, but enough to make me wonder now what is a foul in the penalty box. Var is having a massive impact on the game, and very little of it good. Definitely having an impact on how the ref on the pitch refs the game, before var i think the ref blows his whistle and disallows that goal. Now he has a fallback and can, subconciously no doubt, delegate the decision to another ref watching on a monitor, who has to work out two things, was the original decision rright, and was it clear and obviously wrong. In realiity can that work. The other massive negative impact of var, is that it is causing a massive fissure between football matches that use var, and the majority of football where there is no var. Ironic that Arsenal got this decision, given they have been the main exponents of pushing the boundaries on set pieces. Even more ironic that now they are starting to move away from those tactics. Perhaps they have been the first to forsee a clampdown on this kind of thing and an understanding that this doesn't wash in european games.
05-11-2026, 09:52 AM
(05-11-2026, 09:43 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Really dislike var and it gives more and more reasons to dislike it. Corners are notoriously difficult to manage given the numbers of players in a small area at any one time. But at least you can start with applying the current rules as they are clearly laid out. If someone has a hold of another player's shirt then if it's a foul anywhere else on the pitch then it's a foul in the area so either a free kick to the defender or a penalty to an attacker. But the key is to be strict and apply it always.
05-11-2026, 09:56 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-11-2026, 09:58 AM by GunsOfNavarone.)
Never a foul. Raya would die of thirst going to ground that easily when trying to get served in the Billiard Hall in West Brom. No sympathy from me. Outfield players get yellow cards for less when dropping to the floor as though shot by a sniper. Fanny.
PS. Arteta is a cunt.
05-11-2026, 10:05 AM
(05-11-2026, 09:52 AM)Fido Wrote:Absolutely. We keep hearing of "grappling" which is shirt tugging that may lead to an "accidental" grabbing of the opponent's hair. There is NO tugging, holding or grabbing that is not foul play. Why the fug this isn't enforced (it ay ard) is baffling and frustrating. None of the commentators or pundits pick sit up, either.(05-11-2026, 09:43 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Really dislike var and it gives more and more reasons to dislike it.
the former linesman who was on MOTD last night had an interesting idea to stop the rugby scrum that now occurs in the six yard box at every corner.
He suggested that only the goal keeper be allowed in the six yard box until the corner kick has actually been taken. I'm not sure if this would displace the scrum to another location, and Shay Given felt that it would give the keeper too much protection. But what goes on now is madness.
05-11-2026, 11:01 AM
(05-10-2026, 06:39 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: There were about 10 simultaneous fouls both ways there, probably all cancel each other out. Just watched the BBC/MOTD highlights. Trossard is manhandling the West Ham player to keep him away from Raya and cleverley slides around from goal side as the ball comes in and, if anything moves him away from goal. I would argue that is a foul. Moreover, Raya moves out towards those two players to meet the ball. Raya initiates contact, the West Ham player is not obliged to move out of the way. It is as likely that the attacker's arm is out as a result of wrestling with Trossard rather than intending to impede the GK. All that said, the arm is definitely across the GK who very much makes the most of it. Overall, I would say 'goal given' (or maybe penalty) due to Trossard's actions.
05-11-2026, 11:02 AM
(05-11-2026, 10:48 AM)Old Fart Wrote: the former linesman who was on MOTD last night had an interesting idea to stop the rugby scrum that now occurs in the six yard box at every corner. I was thinking the same but it would imagine it would lead to a load of blocking right on the edge of the six yard box and ultimately not solve anything. Or a short one would be played and then the cross whipped in and you'd have the same scenario as today.
05-11-2026, 11:50 AM
VAR is shit. This proves it. Still as much argument as if there was no VAR.
All it does is make celebrations of goals muted. Destroys what we've all been brought up with. The ref mistakes are part of the game. 40 years on we are on about the hand of God still but so what. We're human. Regards Arsenal, I'd rather they win the league than Man City and their 100 plus charges. Anyone looking forward to the cup final on Saturday between the 2 clubs that have bought football greed to a new level? Thought not.
05-11-2026, 11:55 AM
I watched the last 10 mins of the game. In real time I shouted that's never a penalty.
VAR did its job. The keeper was fouled twice. 19 had his arm across the neck and another World Cup winner pulling the keepers shirt. As ever. I know nothing. |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|