Tim Iroegbunam
#21
(05-05-2026, 10:00 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 09:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 09:20 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think any manager, hoping to hold on to his job, would ever think “I’m not going to play the kids” They will be thinking “I’ve a bunch of professional footballers here, young and old and I’m going to pick the best team based on what I see in training” .  I really don’t believe there’s any cultural aspect or policy at our club that stops us playing academy players, or giving youth a chance, it’s  just like at every club a managers decision.

The problem being it seems to be a consistent trend at the Albion over many years. Tom Fellows and Dara O'Shea are the only recent examples I can think of, and they didn't play much til they were 19/20. Palmer didn't play for us until he was 24/25!

Plenty of other clubs blood their youngsters when they're teenagers. And it can't be that our players aren't good enough, as has been discussed in the thread, many former Albion youth players are performing at or above Champ level.

So why does it seem to continually happen?

People have very short memories. Nathan Ferguson, Kyle Edwards, Rakeen Harper and Jon Leko all had first team football, especially the first three. They were given plenty of opportunities but for various reasons, none are playing at Championship level.

Rogers was sold so we could bring in Slav and his team.

Finn Azaz was offered a new contract by us and turned it down.

Sam Field was blighted by injuries for much of his time with us.

If we are going to keep having the same conversation about playing can we at least use consistent facts?

Gardner-Hickman got plenty of first team action as well before being sold.

I think it's fair to say that if Ferguson hadn't been blighted by injury, he wouldn't have been playing in the championship for positive reasons.

What has always bothered me with Ferguson is not the shenanigans around his move to Palace. But the impression that if it hadn’t been for Bilic arriving at the club, Ferguson would not have got a sniff of first team football at such an early age, despite him being clearly ready.

Same with Azaz, he never got a sniff of the first team. From his perspective moving when he did was the best step for the advancement of his career.

Are we good at developing players, but not so good at working out who are the most talented of our academy players?

Totally agree, Shabby. There comes a point when if we are not playing them they either go stale or go elsewhere.
Reply
#22
(05-05-2026, 10:00 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 09:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 09:20 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think any manager, hoping to hold on to his job, would ever think “I’m not going to play the kids” They will be thinking “I’ve a bunch of professional footballers here, young and old and I’m going to pick the best team based on what I see in training” .  I really don’t believe there’s any cultural aspect or policy at our club that stops us playing academy players, or giving youth a chance, it’s  just like at every club a managers decision.

The problem being it seems to be a consistent trend at the Albion over many years. Tom Fellows and Dara O'Shea are the only recent examples I can think of, and they didn't play much til they were 19/20. Palmer didn't play for us until he was 24/25!

Plenty of other clubs blood their youngsters when they're teenagers. And it can't be that our players aren't good enough, as has been discussed in the thread, many former Albion youth players are performing at or above Champ level.

So why does it seem to continually happen?

People have very short memories. Nathan Ferguson, Kyle Edwards, Rakeen Harper and Jon Leko all had first team football, especially the first three. They were given plenty of opportunities but for various reasons, none are playing at Championship level.

Rogers was sold so we could bring in Slav and his team.

Finn Azaz was offered a new contract by us and turned it down.

Sam Field was blighted by injuries for much of his time with us.

If we are going to keep having the same conversation about playing can we at least use consistent facts?

Gardner-Hickman got plenty of first team action as well before being sold.

I think it's fair to say that if Ferguson hadn't been blighted by injury, he wouldn't have been playing in the championship for positive reasons.

What has always bothered me with Ferguson is not the shenanigans around his move to Palace. But the impression that if it hadn’t been for Bilic arriving at the club, Ferguson would not have got a sniff of first team football at such an early age, despite him being clearly ready.

Same with Azaz, he never got a sniff of the first team. From his perspective moving when he did was the best step for the advancement of his career.

Are we good at developing players, but not so good at working out who are the most talented of our academy players?

This articulates what I was trying to say far more effectively, I think. The original point is around not giving clearly talented enough players the chance to play, whether out on loan (and leaving them there, attn Whitwell) or with the Albion. Why?

Rich's point around contract management is well received, this surely HAS to improve if we're going to reap the on-field benefits of our academy.

Are we now seen as the ideal place to learn and develop from 5/6/7 to 15/16, but then as the stepping stone to first team football elsewhere? If so, that is not good.
Reply
#23
(05-05-2026, 07:46 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 07:07 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-04-2026, 10:13 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: We haven't produced 'that group' again yet.

We spent that long neglecting the academy. We had 5/6 years of nothing.

The u18s are the next lot really. But they are 3/4 years away most likely.

How old were Rooney, Owen or Bellingham when they started playing for their clubs?? It's this mindset that holds us back I think. I have no idea about any of our U20s U 18s or whatever. It's also how Sunderland overcame the money problem to get promoted. if you don't play them you'll never know, and of course there's always a chance that our Academy actually, just isn't all that.

Agree, if you're good enough, you are old enough. That's where the coaches come in to assist with confidence, physical strengths etc. when the guys take a step up. But disagree on our Academy, it's widely respected. So much so that villa came in for half the kids and ALL of the coaches. The league is littered with our Academy products. It seems just Albion are reluctant to use them.

Yes, so a couple of years ago we were producing some quality, BUT nowadays who is there? Nobody seems to be poaching them anymore, are they not good enough or have we taken steps to stop the poaching?

(05-05-2026, 11:44 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 07:46 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 07:07 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-04-2026, 10:13 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: We haven't produced 'that group' again yet.

We spent that long neglecting the academy. We had 5/6 years of nothing.

The u18s are the next lot really. But they are 3/4 years away most likely.

How old were Rooney, Owen or Bellingham when they started playing for their clubs?? It's this mindset that holds us back I think. I have no idea about any of our U20s U 18s or whatever. It's also how Sunderland overcame the money problem to get promoted. if you don't play them you'll never know, and of course there's always a chance that our Academy actually, just isn't all that.

Agree, if you're good enough, you are old enough. That's where the coaches come in to assist with confidence, physical strengths etc. when the guys take a step up. But disagree on our Academy, it's widely respected. So much so that villa came in for half the kids and ALL of the coaches. The league is littered with our Academy products. It seems just Albion are reluctant to use them.

Yes, so a couple of years ago we were producing some quality, BUT nowadays who is there? Nobody seems to be poaching them anymore, are they not good enough or have we taken steps to stop the poaching?

I firmly believe that without parachutes we simply have to trust the kids more and get them up to speed and then sell them on to keep us going. Unless we get some ridiculous fee for a player we've bought and I can't think who we have now that would command that.
All the names mentioned so far have been a few years ago, with none really filling the Academy regular void since.
Reply
#24
There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.

I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.

Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.
Reply
#25
(05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.

I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.

Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.

I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.

Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.

Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.

I can't even remember Taylor Big Grin
Reply
#26
(05-05-2026, 12:03 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.

I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.

Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.

I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.

Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.

Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.

I can't even remember Taylor Big Grin

Azaz went to Saints for 15M.
Reply
#27
(05-05-2026, 12:29 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 12:03 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.

I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.

Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.

I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.

Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.

Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.

I can't even remember Taylor Big Grin

Azaz went to Saints for 15M.

He also didn't sign a contract that was offered to him and left to join Villa.  

We loaned him for a year to L2, then he fucked off to the Villa and never played a game for them.  He did another season long loan to L2, then L1 at Plymouth and went there again in the Champo. It was part way through the 23/24 Champo season he got the perm move to Boro.  Did a further 18 months with them and then got his move to Saints.

I'd say he's worked his waty through the league system, not burst onto the scene.  And certainly not our fault for "not giving him a chance".
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#28
(05-05-2026, 01:42 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 12:29 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 12:03 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.

I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.

Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.

I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.

Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.

Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.

I can't even remember Taylor Big Grin

Azaz went to Saints for 15M.

He also didn't sign a contract that was offered to him and left to join Villa.  

We loaned him for a year to L2, then he fucked off to the Villa and never played a game for them.  He did another season long loan to L2, then L1 at Plymouth and went there again in the Champo. It was part way through the 23/24 Champo season he got the perm move to Boro.  Did a further 18 months with them and then got his move to Saints.

I'd say he's worked his waty through the league system, not burst onto the scene.  And certainly not our fault for "not giving him a chance".

Exactly. There's a real fondness for gnashing of teeth over our apparent mistreatment of a glittering array of youth players, when most are either playing at lower levels or have been released. Remember when everyone was tending their garments over Louie Barry?
Reply
#29
George Thorne anyone?
Reply
#30
(05-05-2026, 12:29 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 12:03 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.

I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.

Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.

I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.

Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.

Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.

I can't even remember Taylor Big Grin

Azaz went to Saints for 15M.

Eventually he did... He wasn't worth more than 1m when he left us
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)