Tim Iroegbunam
#11
(05-05-2026, 07:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Using generational talents to prove that we don't give our young players a chance is always a strange one for me.

We have never produced a; Rooney, Owen or Bellingham. If we did have one they would play.

Bostock and Whitwell are key examples, the best of their cohort from a few years ago that are left after the Villa launched the rest. But they are sadly not good enough. We do need to get the next lot right though. We are putting some really good results together in the U18s a lot like we did years ago, so it shows that they might have some talent.

Generational? Bryan Robson. The most effective English player I've seen.
Bostock was filling a shirt last Saturday,  playing in that strange Molumby/right wing mode. I won't judge him on that, he has got 2 valuable starts (both in Sheffield) and that is what we ask as fans.
Reply
#12
(05-05-2026, 08:04 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 07:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Using generational talents to prove that we don't give our young players a chance is always a strange one for me.

We have never produced a; Rooney, Owen or Bellingham. If we did have one they would play.

Bostock and Whitwell are key examples, the best of their cohort from a few years ago that are left after the Villa launched the rest. But they are sadly not good enough. We do need to get the next lot right though. We are putting some really good results together in the U18s a lot like we did years ago, so it shows that they might have some talent.

Generational? Bryan Robson. The most effective English player I've seen.
Bostock was filling a shirt last Saturday,  playing in that strange Molumby/right wing mode. I won't judge him on that, he has got 2 valuable starts (both in Sheffield) and that is what we ask as fans.

So the last generational talents we had was Robson, 1975. And he played. 

I get the urge to play more of our own youth players. I call for it too. But the ones who have been around it this year, Whitwell and Bostock aren't the ones unfortunately. 

I have more hope for Mohammed, Mandey and Francis-Caesar.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#13
Don’t think any manager, hoping to hold on to his job, would ever think “I’m not going to play the kids” They will be thinking “I’ve a bunch of professional footballers here, young and old and I’m going to pick the best team based on what I see in training” . I really don’t believe there’s any cultural aspect or policy at our club that stops us playing academy players, or giving youth a chance, it’s just like at every club a managers decision.
Reply
#14
(05-05-2026, 08:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think any manager, hoping to hold on to his job, would ever think “I’m not going to play the kids” They will be thinking “I’ve a bunch of professional footballers here, young and old and I’m going to pick the best team based on what I see in training” . I really don’t believe there’s any cultural aspect or policy at our club that stops us playing academy players, or giving youth a chance, it’s just like at every club a managers decision.

The problem being it seems to be a consistent trend at the Albion over many years. Tom Fellows and Dara O'Shea are the only recent examples I can think of, and they didn't play much til they were 19/20. Palmer didn't play for us until he was 24/25!

Plenty of other clubs blood their youngsters when they're teenagers. And it can't be that our players aren't good enough, as has been discussed in the thread, many former Albion youth players are performing at or above Champ level.

So why does it seem to continually happen?
Reply
#15
Alex Williams showed more than promise. Should be a good option for the first team if recovered.
Reply
#16
(05-05-2026, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think any manager, hoping to hold on to his job, would ever think “I’m not going to play the kids” They will be thinking “I’ve a bunch of professional footballers here, young and old and I’m going to pick the best team based on what I see in training” . I really don’t believe there’s any cultural aspect or policy at our club that stops us playing academy players, or giving youth a chance, it’s just like at every club a managers decision.

The problem being it seems to be a consistent trend at the Albion over many years. Tom Fellows and Dara O'Shea are the only recent examples I can think of, and they didn't play much til they were 19/20. Palmer didn't play for us until he was 24/25!

Plenty of other clubs blood their youngsters when they're teenagers. And it can't be that our players aren't good enough, as has been discussed in the thread, many former Albion youth players are performing at or above Champ level.

So why does it seem to continually happen?

People have very short memories. Nathan Ferguson, Kyle Edwards, Rakeen Harper and Jon Leko all had first team football, especially the first three. They were given plenty of opportunities but for various reasons, none are playing at Championship level.

Rogers was sold so we could bring in Slav and his team.

Finn Azaz was offered a new contract by us and turned it down.

Sam Field was blighted by injuries for much of his time with us.

If we are going to keep having the same conversation about playing can we at least use consistent facts?
Reply
#17
(05-05-2026, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think any manager, hoping to hold on to his job, would ever think “I’m not going to play the kids” They will be thinking “I’ve a bunch of professional footballers here, young and old and I’m going to pick the best team based on what I see in training” .  I really don’t believe there’s any cultural aspect or policy at our club that stops us playing academy players, or giving youth a chance, it’s  just like at every club a managers decision.

The problem being it seems to be a consistent trend at the Albion over many years.

Plenty of other clubs blood their youngsters. And it can't be that these players aren't good enough, as has been discussed in the thread, many former Albion youth players are performing at or above Champ level.

So why does it seem to continually happen?

You say many former Albion youth are playing at or above champ level but the majority of these were either stolen at a young age by Villa or sold to balance appalling finances. Can't think of many out there that we didn't give a chsnce too that have gone on to flourish.

That's not to say I don't think we haven’t mismanaged areas of youth development. We historically haven't managed contract management well, allowing Villa to nip in far too easily. I don't think we have secured enough effective loans for our better kids and often mismanaged them, such as Whitwell this year.

Having said all that, the harsh truth is we have had a period recently where the quality coming through hasn't been that strong. 5, very different managers have been in charge over the last 3 years. None of them have embraced the young blood. Only Fellows has shone brightly. We should have utilised Caleb Taylor more but over the last 3 years, nobody else has looked anywhere near ready in my opinion. Whitwell, of the current older kids may have what it takes but even Jimmy has been hesitant. Bostock has looked very lightweight and I'm yet to be convinced. Both need league 1 loans next year.
 
The current u18s and younger are potentially better than the group Whitwell and Bostock came through with. Hopefully we manage the contracts well, keep the predators away and use loans well for the most promising.
Reply
#18
(05-05-2026, 09:20 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think any manager, hoping to hold on to his job, would ever think “I’m not going to play the kids” They will be thinking “I’ve a bunch of professional footballers here, young and old and I’m going to pick the best team based on what I see in training” .  I really don’t believe there’s any cultural aspect or policy at our club that stops us playing academy players, or giving youth a chance, it’s  just like at every club a managers decision.

The problem being it seems to be a consistent trend at the Albion over many years. Tom Fellows and Dara O'Shea are the only recent examples I can think of, and they didn't play much til they were 19/20. Palmer didn't play for us until he was 24/25!

Plenty of other clubs blood their youngsters when they're teenagers. And it can't be that our players aren't good enough, as has been discussed in the thread, many former Albion youth players are performing at or above Champ level.

So why does it seem to continually happen?

People have very short memories. Nathan Ferguson, Kyle Edwards, Rakeen Harper and Jon Leko all had first team football, especially the first three. They were given plenty of opportunities but for various reasons, none are playing at Championship level.

Rogers was sold so we could bring in Slav and his team.

Finn Azaz was offered a new contract by us and turned it down.

Sam Field was blighted by injuries for much of his time with us.

If we are going to keep having the same conversation about playing can we at least use consistent facts?

Gardner-Hickman got plenty of first team action as well before being sold.
Reply
#19
(05-05-2026, 09:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 09:20 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-05-2026, 08:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think any manager, hoping to hold on to his job, would ever think “I’m not going to play the kids” They will be thinking “I’ve a bunch of professional footballers here, young and old and I’m going to pick the best team based on what I see in training” .  I really don’t believe there’s any cultural aspect or policy at our club that stops us playing academy players, or giving youth a chance, it’s  just like at every club a managers decision.

The problem being it seems to be a consistent trend at the Albion over many years. Tom Fellows and Dara O'Shea are the only recent examples I can think of, and they didn't play much til they were 19/20. Palmer didn't play for us until he was 24/25!

Plenty of other clubs blood their youngsters when they're teenagers. And it can't be that our players aren't good enough, as has been discussed in the thread, many former Albion youth players are performing at or above Champ level.

So why does it seem to continually happen?

People have very short memories. Nathan Ferguson, Kyle Edwards, Rakeen Harper and Jon Leko all had first team football, especially the first three. They were given plenty of opportunities but for various reasons, none are playing at Championship level.

Rogers was sold so we could bring in Slav and his team.

Finn Azaz was offered a new contract by us and turned it down.

Sam Field was blighted by injuries for much of his time with us.

If we are going to keep having the same conversation about playing can we at least use consistent facts?

Gardner-Hickman got plenty of first team action as well before being sold.

I think it's fair to say that if Ferguson hadn't been blighted by injury, he wouldn't have been playing in the championship for positive reasons.

What has always bothered me with Ferguson is not the shenanigans around his move to Palace. But the impression that if it hadn’t been for Bilic arriving at the club, Ferguson would not have got a sniff of first team football at such an early age, despite him being clearly ready.

Same with Azaz, he never got a sniff of the first team. From his perspective moving when he did was the best step for the advancement of his career.

Are we good at developing players, but not so good at working out who are the most talented of our academy players?
Reply
#20
Not heard much about Williams after he got injured playing for Wales after a bright debut for the first team, is he in contention for next year at all?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: