PSR breach reported by John Percy
Has anyone check if the EFL closed for some sort of obscure religious holiday?

Odd no comment yet.
Reply
(04-22-2026, 05:51 PM)Morley Wrote:
(04-22-2026, 04:33 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(04-22-2026, 04:16 PM)Morley Wrote:
(04-22-2026, 03:41 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(04-22-2026, 03:05 PM)Morley Wrote: How? They have 42 Blackburn have 49 and there are 2 games left?

As Josh said, 4 or more points means Leicester aren't definitely down, we'd be back on 48... Leicester win both and jump to 48... So GD kicks in, unless Oxford win both then we don't care cuz we'd be down anyway...

Can you two add up?  

Leicester can only get 48, Oxford can get 50.  Blackburn have 49, Charlton have 50 and Portsmouth have 51.  No matter what happens to us Leicester are down.  Oxford could stay up at our expense though.

Eh? We get deducted 4 points were on 48... 5 and we are in 47 and so on... Leicester on 42 win 2 games they are then on 48 (assuming we get no more points)... So please explain the flaw in this maths and provide your swimming certificates as proof of your maths skills... Of course it hi ges also on Oxford getting no more points either..

Highly unlikely.

Yes it is highly unlikely, but so was us overturning the Dingles 11 point lead... however the maths is still sound despite what you claimed.
Reply
Slight aside to MrBater's point made above. I actually always believed we would overturn the dings 11 point lead. We had momentum and they had a history of bottling, added to them being overpaid and overhyped. Compare that to my thoughts after Portsmouth and Oxford this season when for the 1st time I not only realised the danger of relegation, I was actually convinced of it.
Now all common sense appears to point to a minor penalty for us but this is football. Common sense doesnt apply. A game where the most prestigious competition is played in Russia, Qatar and other dubious states. Where clubs that have been taken over and working hand in hand with the governing bodies, are retrospectively punished after being wilfully mismanaged by owners that were approved by the same governing bodies.
One point, two or 5? I just want us to see out the season unbeaten so no one can derail us.
Reply
(04-23-2026, 07:51 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Slight aside to MrBater's point made above. I actually always believed we would overturn the dings 11 point lead. We had momentum and they had a history of bottling, added to them being overpaid and overhyped. Compare that to my thoughts after Portsmouth and Oxford this season when for the 1st time I not only realised the danger of relegation, I was actually convinced of it.
Now all common sense appears to point to a minor penalty for us but this is football. Common sense doesnt apply. A game where the most prestigious competition is played in Russia, Qatar and other dubious states. Where clubs that have been taken over and working hand in hand with the governing bodies, are retrospectively punished after being wilfully mismanaged by owners that were approved by the same governing bodies.
One point, two or 5? I just want us to see out the season unbeaten so no one can derail us.

Yes. We're eliding into the "morally inverted" thread here. I'll add that I'm finding it hard to care about the upcoming World Cup (or "FIFA WC" as we're now supposed to call it) because it's being held in  another dubious state - Trump's USA.
I see their latest scam is to kick out Iran, who qualified, and replace them with Italy, who didn't.
Because they're Italy, and the USA wants to get closer politically.
Reply
(04-23-2026, 08:29 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-23-2026, 07:51 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Slight aside to MrBater's point made above. I actually always believed we would overturn the dings 11 point lead. We had momentum and they had a history of bottling, added to them being overpaid and overhyped. Compare that to my thoughts after Portsmouth and Oxford this season when for the 1st time I not only realised the danger of relegation, I was actually convinced of it.
Now all common sense appears to point to a minor penalty for us but this is football. Common sense doesnt apply. A game where the most prestigious competition is played in Russia, Qatar and other dubious states. Where clubs that have been taken over and working hand in hand with the governing bodies, are retrospectively punished after being wilfully mismanaged by owners that were approved by the same governing bodies.
One point, two or 5? I just want us to see out the season unbeaten so no one can derail us.

Yes. We're eliding into the "morally inverted" thread here. I'll add that I'm finding it hard to care about the upcoming World Cup (or "FIFA WC" as we're now supposed to call it) because it's being held in  another dubious state - Trump's USA.
I see their latest scam is to kick out Iran, who qualified, and replace them with Italy, who didn't.
Because they're Italy, and they will make a shed load more money.

Edited for you
Reply
(04-23-2026, 08:29 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-23-2026, 07:51 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Slight aside to MrBater's point made above. I actually always believed we would overturn the dings 11 point lead. We had momentum and they had a history of bottling, added to them being overpaid and overhyped. Compare that to my thoughts after Portsmouth and Oxford this season when for the 1st time I not only realised the danger of relegation, I was actually convinced of it.
Now all common sense appears to point to a minor penalty for us but this is football. Common sense doesnt apply. A game where the most prestigious competition is played in Russia, Qatar and other dubious states. Where clubs that have been taken over and working hand in hand with the governing bodies, are retrospectively punished after being wilfully mismanaged by owners that were approved by the same governing bodies.
One point, two or 5? I just want us to see out the season unbeaten so no one can derail us.

Yes. We're eliding into the "morally inverted" thread here. I'll add that I'm finding it hard to care about the upcoming World Cup (or "FIFA WC" as we're now supposed to call it) because it's being held in  another dubious state - Trump's USA.
I see their latest scam is to kick out Iran, who qualified, and replace them with Italy, who didn't.
Because they're Italy, and the USA wants to get closer politically.
Infantino appears to have kicked back on this one. Said it's not going to happen and Iran are in.

Just to get back on to the subject of the thread - I'm convinced the longer this goes on, the less likely we get a deduction. There is still no confirmation of a charge even and (correctly) nothing more from the Club other than:

 "West Bromwich Albion acknowledges media reports relating to the club's compliance with the EFL's profitability and sustainability (P&S) rules.
The club considers that it has fully complied with the P&S rules. The club will continue to co-operate with the EFL's Club Financial Reporting Unit and looks forward to resolving this matter. It would not be appropriate for the club to comment further at this stage."
Reply
Our current points total would make it much more acceptable for the EFL to now come out and say they've reviewed the situation with the club and in light of the collaboration over the last 18 months they are comfortable that no rules have been breached, and that there will be no punishment this year... Maybe a suspended 2 points for future seasons applied if we do not continue to comply.

It's unlikely even deducing 5 points from us would impact who goes down now!
Reply
The EFL surely have a duty to respond to these reports, even if the statement is… we are aware of x but we do not respond to speculation.
Reply
I still haven't seen where it's been said we've officially been charged.

Is there a chance the whole thing has been made up and is just lazy journalism. Or has there been something official that I've missed in all the BUMF of this Fred?
Reply
The Press Association have a responsibilty too! Although I wouldn't hold my breath.

I used to look on Percy as a respectable and credible journalist not prone the half truths and hyperbole. Unforunately it appears he is no better than some of the Red Top guys ... and in this case, he has sunk even lower.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: