Poll: Who would you keep?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Max O’Leary
15.96%
15 15.96%
Joe Wildshit
2.13%
2 2.13%
Jed Wallace
3.19%
3 3.19%
Karlan Grant
23.40%
22 23.40%
Josh Maja
4.26%
4 4.26%
Daryl Dike
51.06%
48 51.06%
Total 94 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Out of contract players…. Who to keep?
#1
Next season we will need 3-4 starting attacking players if everyone leaves, and that’s a lot of work required, and that’s factoring in Whitwell and Bostock replacing the minutes we’ve lost with the 2 departing seal pricks and Hindolo.

Granted we may have the Bany wildcard but I wouldn’t write off a couple of our players being renewed on more favourable terms.
Reply
#2
Grant is the only one I'd definitely keep but it would have to be on reduced terms. Tbh I can't see him attracting a particularly better offer elsewhere unless we did get relegated.

It's certainly time to say goodbye to Wildsmith and Wallace.

Whilst they have contributed recently I think injuries have really taken their toll on Maja and Dike and I think the significant money sunk into those two can be better used. Maja has talent but simply can't run anymore. As much as everyone wants Dike to do well, I don't think judgement should be clouded by the fact that he isn't the player he could have been. Not many players can come back from so many years of constant, and differing, serious injuries. It would be nice for him to just be leaving the club on a relative high.

O'Leary I wouldn't be against giving him another year but again, I'd hope with could do better.
Reply
#3
I suspect Jed may be the only one we can afford to keep who the club would be interested in doing so. Perhaps O Leary too.

I wouldn’t be against any of them staying, but all would have to be on reduced terms, which they aren’t going to do.
Reply
#4
I'm convinced Dike has a good few years in him, but then again I was always hopeful that Jimmy Quinn would come good.
Reply
#5
I've gone for Grant, but wouldn't be against Dike and O'Leary also signing. Grant and Dike would be on much reduced terms though, so they may look elsewhere for their next contract....
Reply
#6
All bar wildshit
Reply
#7
I've been against offering Dike a new deal because of his appalling luck with injuries but I'd be lying if I wasn't wavering. I just keep having this nagging doubt what if he has finally overcome them and he is going to turn into beast mode!

As long as the deal was sensible in wages then I wouldn't be averse to it.
Reply
#8
Until the points deduction is implemented its very difficult to second guess who we can afford to keep.
If we get relegated we may well have to sell anyone who can fetch a fee.
Hence I would only put Wildsmith and Seal loans on the way out list.
Reply
#9
I would keep Dike on a one year deal + 1
He owes for the last couple of seasons if he stays
Fit will be a big asset in this league next season.

Also would offer Grant something but no more money
And only 2 year deal if he stays

The rest time to go.
Reply
#10
I meant to set 2 responses…. But didn’t.

I’d offer Grant an extension provided the terms worked, he’s the one out of all 6 I know will definitely get a decent Champ move if he wants it, but as his age, and in his prime, on a free, I expect he will be looking for a 3-4 year deal on decent terms and we can’t stretch to that currently.

It’s probably more sentiment than anything but I’m convinced there is still a player in Dike so want there to be some kind of deal.

Maja is starting to show what he can do again, so won’t be against that, but I think he’s the type of player who makes a decent living out of bosman moves and signing on fees so fair play to him.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: