PSR breach reported by John Percy
(04-20-2026, 07:01 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Thank you all, pleased to hear O'Leary is doing nicely ticking along. He split opinion with us but he could be prone to error and wasn't great technically but is a serviceable keeper in the Championship.

In terms of FFP,  don't see how it could be 5. If it is a 3 Points overspend after deducting Recharged Interest, 1 back for falling losses maybe even one back for strong cooperation..2 Points or even perhaps 1 IMO.

One factor I suppose, have WBA done it in 2025-26, that could have a longer term knock-on effect if hypothetically done and done again given 3 Year Rule etc or was it a purely one-off.
Good post and it is a worry for the period just ended too and that may yield a bigger penalty.
Reply
(04-20-2026, 09:56 AM)CIM Wrote:
(04-20-2026, 08:35 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(04-19-2026, 09:41 PM)throstle Wrote: Under the EFL sentencing guidelines, a loss of £5m receives a 5 point deduction. So, it is possible in the worst case scenario that Albion receive this punishment. A few articles - including unsurprisingly the Leicester press - have pointed this out.

https://www.leicestermercury.co.uk/sport...m-10919388

If that's the case it'll be reduced to 4 because of the financial improvements we've made...

The Leicester Mercury are guessing as much as anyone

And Leicester got 6 points for a £20m overspend?! Seems fair.....
Reply
And worth pointing out that the earlier reports indicated a PSR shortfall of around 1 million. The 5 million quoted was the total amount of the loan interest and it is likely that some (or much) of this would have been covered by some headroom in our PSR calculations.
Reply
(04-20-2026, 10:18 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: And worth pointing out that the earlier reports indicated a PSR shortfall of around 1 million. The 5 million quoted was the total amount of the loan interest and it is likely that some (or much) of this would have been covered by some headroom in our PSR calculations.

I'd expect that to be the actual case, given the initial reports of us looking at a 2-3 point deduction.
Reply
This is a question, and I'm aware the comments are very much guesswork, so don't shoot me!

If the PSR breach relates to the loan, then surely the club would have known the interest amounts, and how to account for it, especially after liaising with the EFL on where on the balance sheet it goes.

How could the club mess that up if it is the loan, it seems pretty basic accounting? If we've asked the EFL how to account for it, then I can't see how their response would be difficult to interpret.

Genuine questions, these. I just can't get my head around how preparing a set of accounts can be made so difficult if you're following guidance?

It may not have anything to do with the loan, I still believe no one really knows what the craic is.
Reply
(04-20-2026, 07:51 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(04-20-2026, 07:01 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Thank you all, pleased to hear O'Leary is doing nicely ticking along. He split opinion with us but he could be prone to error and wasn't great technically but is a serviceable keeper in the Championship.

In terms of FFP,  don't see how it could be 5. If it is a 3 Points overspend after deducting Recharged Interest, 1 back for falling losses maybe even one back for strong cooperation..2 Points or even perhaps 1 IMO.

One factor I suppose, have WBA done it in 2025-26, that could have a longer term knock-on effect if hypothetically done and done again given 3 Year Rule etc or was it a purely one-off.
Good post and it is a worry for the period just ended too and that may yield a bigger penalty.

I think with the sales that we'll have come in under PSR for the last 3 years, so it should t be an issue with the next period.
Reply
From what I have seen Josh it is not about the payment of the loan interest itself, it is the introduction of the funds to pay the interest that is the problem. What is not clear is if this was discussed, and the method of introduction, prior to them putting the money in.
Reply
(04-21-2026, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: This is a question, and I'm aware the comments are very much guesswork, so don't shoot me!

If the PSR breach relates to the loan, then surely the club would have known the interest amounts, and how to account for it, especially after liaising with the EFL on where on the balance sheet it goes.

How could the club mess that up if it is the loan, it seems pretty basic accounting? If we've asked the EFL how to account for it, then I can't see how their response would be difficult to interpret.

Genuine questions, these. I just can't get my head around how preparing a set of accounts can be made so difficult if you're following guidance?

It may not have anything to do with the loan, I still believe no one really knows what the craic is.

From what I've read it's the how we've accounted for it rather than the actual numbers. We e done something to charge the interest to Bikul, but the EFL are saying it should be against the club or something akin to that.

It sounds like we found a loophole, but unlike every other club who found a loophole they're trying to nail us for it...instead of fixing it after it's been found.
Reply
(04-21-2026, 09:21 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(04-21-2026, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: This is a question, and I'm aware the comments are very much guesswork, so don't shoot me!

If the PSR breach relates to the loan, then surely the club would have known the interest amounts, and how to account for it, especially after liaising with the EFL on where on the balance sheet it goes.

How could the club mess that up if it is the loan, it seems pretty basic accounting? If we've asked the EFL how to account for it, then I can't see how their response would be difficult to interpret.

Genuine questions, these. I just can't get my head around how preparing a set of accounts can be made so difficult if you're following guidance?

It may not have anything to do with the loan, I still believe no one really knows what the craic is.

From what I've read it's the how we've accounted for it rather than the actual numbers. We e done something to charge the interest to Bikul, but the EFL are saying it should be against the club or something akin to that.

It sounds like we found a loophole, but unlike every other club who found a loophole they're trying to nail us for it...instead of fixing it after it's been found.

That makes sense, but my question would then be, surely the club would have liaised with the EFL and seemed clarification on where to charge the interest and what impacts that would on the PSR. You'd hope!

I don't understand why it's so difficult? It's a black and white answer, if that's the case. Isn't it?

I'm also aware that the accounting isn't as simple as entering a few numbers on a spreadsheet, btw!
Reply
(04-21-2026, 09:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-21-2026, 09:21 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(04-21-2026, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: This is a question, and I'm aware the comments are very much guesswork, so don't shoot me!

If the PSR breach relates to the loan, then surely the club would have known the interest amounts, and how to account for it, especially after liaising with the EFL on where on the balance sheet it goes.

How could the club mess that up if it is the loan, it seems pretty basic accounting? If we've asked the EFL how to account for it, then I can't see how their response would be difficult to interpret.

Genuine questions, these. I just can't get my head around how preparing a set of accounts can be made so difficult if you're following guidance?

It may not have anything to do with the loan, I still believe no one really knows what the craic is.

From what I've read it's the how we've accounted for it rather than the actual numbers. We e done something to charge the interest to Bikul, but the EFL are saying it should be against the club or something akin to that.

It sounds like we found a loophole, but unlike every other club who found a loophole they're trying to nail us for it...instead of fixing it after it's been found.

That makes sense, but my question would then be, surely the club would have liaised with the EFL and seemed clarification on where to charge the interest and what impacts that would on the PSR. You'd hope!

I don't understand why it's so difficult? It's a black and white answer, if that's the case. Isn't it?

I'm also aware that the accounting isn't as simple as entering a few numbers on a spreadsheet, btw!

It's simple, but like all things involving accountants they have to make it complicated.

I'm beginning to think the EFL's overview amounted to, can we buy this player? No, sell that one first. And that was it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)