The Grown-ups
Spot on at every point TJ
Raw Sausage
Reply
(04-19-2026, 02:01 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Oh I fully understand the predicament.  It actually isn't anything like difficult to understand.  Spending much more than you earn is not wise. Doing it for years is ridiculous. Expecting future generations to foot the bill is immoral. This is the reason I get vocal when I see corruption,  cronyism, incompetence, it is also the reason I detest populism. But if you think Starmer has done this damage in 2 years, or even can put it right in 2 years then you are kidding yourself and anyone that listens to you. As for the banking crash, I didn't approve of the way that was tackled either. But I'm certain had it been a tory government, they would have done the same. Fact remains, for a large majority of the years we have been alive the country has been Tory. My criticism of the current government is that they are underwhelming. But still hugely preferable to the last lot. Let's be honest, the last election was a good one to lose.

Well we agree about that. 

And Labour is doing as much as it possibly can to make future generations foot the bill.

It is putting nothing "right". If anything it's making things a whole lot worse in the long term for everybody. Except current pensioners.
Reply
(04-19-2026, 11:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-19-2026, 02:01 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Oh I fully understand the predicament.  It actually isn't anything like difficult to understand.  Spending much more than you earn is not wise. Doing it for years is ridiculous. Expecting future generations to foot the bill is immoral. This is the reason I get vocal when I see corruption,  cronyism, incompetence, it is also the reason I detest populism. But if you think Starmer has done this damage in 2 years, or even can put it right in 2 years then you are kidding yourself and anyone that listens to you. As for the banking crash, I didn't approve of the way that was tackled either. But I'm certain had it been a tory government, they would have done the same. Fact remains, for a large majority of the years we have been alive the country has been Tory. My criticism of the current government is that they are underwhelming. But still hugely preferable to the last lot. Let's be honest, the last election was a good one to lose.

Well we agree about that. 

And Labour is doing as much as it possibly can to make future generations foot the bill.

It is putting nothing "right". If anything it's making things a whole lot worse in the long term for everybody. Except current pensioners.

We probably agree on a lot and just disagree on where the blame lies. As I see it the party you blame for the situation has only been in power for around 30 of the last 100 years meantime the party you actively campaigned for governed for 70 of them. By those standards. James Morrison is to blame for Albion currently being in danger of relegation. Labour are not my ideal government,  they are just infinitely preferable to the alternatives.
Reply
(04-20-2026, 08:45 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-19-2026, 11:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-19-2026, 02:01 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Oh I fully understand the predicament.  It actually isn't anything like difficult to understand.  Spending much more than you earn is not wise. Doing it for years is ridiculous. Expecting future generations to foot the bill is immoral. This is the reason I get vocal when I see corruption,  cronyism, incompetence, it is also the reason I detest populism. But if you think Starmer has done this damage in 2 years, or even can put it right in 2 years then you are kidding yourself and anyone that listens to you. As for the banking crash, I didn't approve of the way that was tackled either. But I'm certain had it been a tory government, they would have done the same. Fact remains, for a large majority of the years we have been alive the country has been Tory. My criticism of the current government is that they are underwhelming. But still hugely preferable to the last lot. Let's be honest, the last election was a good one to lose.

Well we agree about that. 

And Labour is doing as much as it possibly can to make future generations foot the bill.

It is putting nothing "right". If anything it's making things a whole lot worse in the long term for everybody. Except current pensioners.

We probably agree on a lot and just disagree on where the blame lies. As I see it the party you blame for the situation has only been in power for around 30 of the last 100 years meantime the party you actively campaigned for governed for 70 of them. By those standards. James Morrison is to blame for Albion currently being in danger of relegation. Labour are not my ideal government,  they are just infinitely preferable to the alternatives.

This
Reply
(04-20-2026, 08:45 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-19-2026, 11:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-19-2026, 02:01 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Oh I fully understand the predicament.  It actually isn't anything like difficult to understand.  Spending much more than you earn is not wise. Doing it for years is ridiculous. Expecting future generations to foot the bill is immoral. This is the reason I get vocal when I see corruption,  cronyism, incompetence, it is also the reason I detest populism. But if you think Starmer has done this damage in 2 years, or even can put it right in 2 years then you are kidding yourself and anyone that listens to you. As for the banking crash, I didn't approve of the way that was tackled either. But I'm certain had it been a tory government, they would have done the same. Fact remains, for a large majority of the years we have been alive the country has been Tory. My criticism of the current government is that they are underwhelming. But still hugely preferable to the last lot. Let's be honest, the last election was a good one to lose.

Well we agree about that. 

And Labour is doing as much as it possibly can to make future generations foot the bill.

It is putting nothing "right". If anything it's making things a whole lot worse in the long term for everybody. Except current pensioners.

We probably agree on a lot and just disagree on where the blame lies. As I see it the party you blame for the situation has only been in power for around 30 of the last 100 years meantime the party you actively campaigned for governed for 70 of them. By those standards. James Morrison is to blame for Albion currently being in danger of relegation. Labour are not my ideal government,  they are just infinitely preferable to the alternatives.

We can agree about that too. The Tory Governments from 2010 were very much #LeastWorst from my perspective (I may have mentioned that before). Most posters on here conveniently forget that all major parties campaigned on the basis of Austerity in 2010, with Labour refusing to rule out real terms cuts in NHS Spending.

I also said that Labour was the #LeastWorst outcome in 2024, albeit in a crowded field of awful potential outcomes. The fact that Starmer's government has descended into a high tax, big state, low growth, high welfare, no philosophy disaster area brings me no joy. Just the depressing judgement that however long you spend out of government cannot prepare you for the challenges you face - particularly if your backbenchers won't face those challenges, which clearly they won't.

The certainties of my youth are gone. Like them or loath them You knew where you stood with the Thatcher governments, equally you knew where you were with the first couple of terms under Blair. 

The unfortunate series of events from 2008 to now have exposed the recent and current political class on all sides as wholly inadequate. Britain is, IMO, rapidly becoming ungovernable until a Leader actually levels with the public. The last person strong enough to do so led the country through a horrible and bitter period between 1979-81, which would eventually lead to huge opportunities for those of all classes and backgrounds willing (and able) to take them. Only an idiot would suggest there weren't victims, call me unempathetic - but would you rather endure an amputation or a slow bleed out?

I consider we're back in the foothills of 70s style perma-crisis under Heath & Callaghan. I don't see anyone on the horizon who is capable of being the antidote to that death spiral - and certainly not the charlatans further to the left or right.
Reply
Got say I agree with a lot of that. I disagree that the change in high tax, big state, low growth, high welfare has happened under this government and has been in place for years, or at least on the trajectory of getting to here - that is very little to do with Starmer or anything he could do about it.
Reply
(04-20-2026, 11:25 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Got say I agree with a lot of that. I disagree that the change in high tax, big state, low growth, high welfare has happened under this government and has been in place for years, or at least on the trajectory of getting to here - that is very little to do with Starmer or anything he could do about it.

It has been on steroids since Covid. 

Starmer promised to do "something" about welfare in the Manifesto, but has since overseen a further long term real terms increase in the welfare budget. There was / is also a case for additional taxation, but Labour has made a political choice to tax individual incomes, payroll taxes, ludicrous increases in the worst tax in the world (business rates) and APR / BPR. 

All they had to do was reverse the Bear Trap NI cut and establish a Land Value Tax which anyone sentient in the country believes could entirely replace SDLT (bad Tax), IHT (bad tax), Council Tax (bad tax), Business Rates (truly awful tax) and mean no changes to BPR / APR - with money left over.

There must be a hugely effective lobby group that is preventing this becoming a reality.
Reply
Again you suggest that the trend and trajectory of the welfare spending is something that could be controlled. In fact you suggest that it is because of Starmer ("overseen a further one term real terms increase in the welfare budget") as opposed to would be happening no matter who is in power.

You then add some vague wording to suggest that individuals ("choice to tax individual incomes") will be bearing the brunt, when in fact it sin't any taxation on the individual.

I don't have any issue with your solution, but the wording for the position that they found themselves in and actions they have taken is simply disingenuous. This is where you just come across as politically motivated in your wording, especially seeing as all of the current situation has been caused by the parties you supported.
Reply
(04-20-2026, 12:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Again you suggest that the trend and trajectory of the welfare spending is something that could be controlled. In fact you suggest that it is because of Starmer ("overseen a further one term real terms increase in the welfare budget") as opposed to would be happening no matter who is in power.

You then add some vague wording to suggest that individuals ("choice to tax individual incomes") will be bearing the brunt, when in fact it sin't any taxation on the individual.

I don't have any issue with your solution, but the wording for the position that they found themselves in and actions they have taken is simply disingenuous. This is where you just come across as politically motivated in your wording, especially seeing as all of the current situation has been caused by the parties you supported.

But that's not the case. Starmer came in with a plan to cut £5bn in Welfare by 2030. He also, rightly, cut the anachronistic Winter Fuel Allowance (until he didn't). He could also, rightly, stop the Triple Lock but he'd be lynched by his backbenchers.

There is additional taxation on the individual by way of fiscal drag and the removal of salary sacrifice. You are seriously living in cloud cuckoo land if you don't consider fiscal drag an increase in personal taxation when inflation between 2020 and the end of he decade is likely to be 45% - 50%. It's fiscal drag that's doing a huge amount of heavy lifting. 

The salary sacrifice changes are just mean spirited to the poor PAYE saps trying the do the right thing at the same time as avoid egregious amounts of tax.

Labour has agency, it was not forced to punish individuals in the way that it has.
Reply
The WFA should have stayed cut but the political madness that is today had reasonable individuals, and ex-copper mate of mine who's gone very right wing since brexit, exclaiming to me loudly in the pub that people will die because of it. The fact that is nonsense makes no difference to the perception allowed these days because of political motivation. The choice for doing that and the triple lock review was available to all of the preceding governments who also cost to ignore them because of political reasons rather than practical - hardly Starmer's fault. The biggest issue I have with him is making the decision and then allowing the backbenchers to bully him out of it. Same with the tightening of the welfare measures - those that need it wouldn't be impacted a jot, but political voices again made out they would.

You are stretching when you talk of fiscal drag, something that has gone on for all of the last few years and your comment on salary sacrifice. SS has not changed for the vast majority of people at all and doesn't come in until 2029 anyway. At that point you will not be exempt on NI if you contribute more than £2k a year - the likelihood is that this impacted will be on the higher rate and therefore only suffering an extra 2% on the amount about £2k.

An example - if you earn 50k and pay 5% into your pension then each year you will pay in £2.5k - that means that £500 will be NI able (no change in IT btw) costing the individual £10 a year. Hardly the end of the world and worthy of making it the big point that you appear to.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)