PSR breach reported by John Percy
(04-20-2026, 08:02 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-20-2026, 07:51 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: So our "small" breach (which is the whole of the £5m interest payments on the MSD loan?) attracts a 5 point deduction as standard? I wouldn't call that small.

I presume we have done the same thing with the interest payments this season. I presume, if we fail in our argument that that is permissible, we might be facing a points deduction next season as well (unless we've generated enough income to offset our losses through "normal" trading in 25/26).

Genuine question. Isn't it the interest payments on the bridging loan? 5m loan incurring around 1m in interest? I understand Kieran Maguire alluded to this.

The gross MSD loan was £28M

Interest of £5.2M was recharged to Bilkul
Reply
There is only one charge and that is we have gone over the allowable £39m losses allowed under PSR over this 3-year reporting period.

What we don't know is by how much, how far down the process we are, how far we have yet to go and at what point we "call the whole thing off".

Edit : somebody may be able to work out by how much we are over by going through the accounts and applying some educated guesswork as to what losses are deductible under PSR.
Reply
(04-19-2026, 09:41 PM)throstle Wrote: Under the EFL sentencing guidelines, a loss of £5m receives a 5 point deduction. So, it is possible in the worst case scenario that Albion receive this punishment. A few articles - including unsurprisingly the Leicester press - have pointed this out.

https://www.leicestermercury.co.uk/sport...m-10919388

If that's the case it'll be reduced to 4 because of the financial improvements we've made...
Reply
(04-20-2026, 08:07 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(04-20-2026, 08:02 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-20-2026, 07:51 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: So our "small" breach (which is the whole of the £5m interest payments on the MSD loan?) attracts a 5 point deduction as standard? I wouldn't call that small.

I presume we have done the same thing with the interest payments this season. I presume, if we fail in our argument that that is permissible, we might be facing a points deduction next season as well (unless we've generated enough income to offset our losses through "normal" trading in 25/26).

Genuine question. Isn't it the interest payments on the bridging loan? 5m loan incurring around 1m in interest? I understand Kieran Maguire alluded to this.

The MSD loan is the bridging loan isn't it? The loan we had to take to cover running costs? Isn't that the only loan we've taken out? As in the club has taken out.
I may be off here but I believed there was the 20m msd loan, then the club needed another 5m to get through the takeover period. Maguire is suggesting the charges relate to just the accounting of interest on the latter, approx 1m. Of course, I'm only gleaning this from what I have read and it could be any of the loan interest, could be all of it, or could be some of it! Clear as mud, eh?
Reply
I don't want to sound completely naive but aside from John Percy's article I have not seen anything that says we have been charged. In Percy's original article it states that the EFL have notified us of an alleged breach and that we had 14 days to respond.

Based on the statement on the OS we have responded and one assumes the 14 days are up this week.

It is then up to the EFL to charge us if they believe we are in breach, and apply a penalty (whatever that looks like) and at which point we will no don't appeal and the matters ends up with the independent panel as it did with Leicester.

Percy stated in his article that we asked for any penalty to be deferred to next season but that goes against the statement on the OS. The speculation is utter shite but for a multi-million pound business the EFL is woefully underfunded to manage 72 clubs.
Reply
(04-20-2026, 08:30 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: There is only one charge and that is we have gone over the allowable £39m losses allowed under PSR over this 3-year reporting period.

What we don't know is by how much, how far down the process we are, how far we have yet to go and at what point we "call the whole thing off".

Edit : somebody may be able to work out by how much we are over by going through the accounts and applying some educated guesswork as to what losses are deductible under PSR.

Thing is, the 39M allowable losses have been increased to allow for inflation - but there's nowhere which states what the current amount allowable is - it's assumed to be around 41-42M - so depending on what number it's taken from, we could have missed by 2 or 5 million!

Again, there is no way 5 points will get deducted this season - there is just not the time for this level of punishment to be applied, and to do this to us would completely undermine the EFL given they only deducted -6 from Leicester.
Reply
People are all over the shop here. It’s not a £5m breach, it’s the apportionment of the interest in the last FY that’s the issue. Not the interest over the rolling term. It’s less that £2m on respect of any potential breach.
Reply
Very thorough article in the link below (you can read it for free by downloading Substack app), which sets out the potential seriousness of Albion's position.

https://swissramble.substack.com/
Reply
Personally I'd rather listen to Kieran Maguire's reknown national expertise rather than an anonymous bloke from Greets Green known only for very low marks on player ratings.
It's clearly a minor breach with mitigating circumstances. My hope and expectation is we now push on and get well clear of the drop zone. 3-4 points from the last 3 games should be enough to cover all eventualities.
Reply
(04-20-2026, 08:53 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-20-2026, 08:07 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(04-20-2026, 08:02 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(04-20-2026, 07:51 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: So our "small" breach (which is the whole of the £5m interest payments on the MSD loan?) attracts a 5 point deduction as standard? I wouldn't call that small.

I presume we have done the same thing with the interest payments this season. I presume, if we fail in our argument that that is permissible, we might be facing a points deduction next season as well (unless we've generated enough income to offset our losses through "normal" trading in 25/26).

Genuine question. Isn't it the interest payments on the bridging loan? 5m loan incurring around 1m in interest? I understand Kieran Maguire alluded to this.

The MSD loan is the bridging loan isn't it? The loan we had to take to cover running costs? Isn't that the only loan we've taken out? As in the club has taken out.
I may be off here but I believed there was the 20m msd loan, then the club needed another 5m to get through the takeover period. Maguire is suggesting the charges relate to just the accounting of interest on the latter, approx 1m. Of course, I'm only gleaning this from what I have read and it could be any of the loan interest, could be all of it, or could be some of it! Clear as mud, eh?

As I understand it, and I'm no accountant, the extra loan was a top-up to the original loan so it all counts as one loan.

Recharging is a standard legitimate business practice (so AI tells me) so there would appear to be no issues with us recharging those interest payments to Bilkul (or whatever it is exactly that we have done) effectively meaning the club didn't incur that expense. I assume this is something that hasn't cropped up with PSR before, hence the dialogue. It may be another of them loopholes that end up getting closed if the EFL cannot argue against it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: