Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
04-18-2026, 09:31 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-18-2026, 10:17 AM by SW4Baggie.)
Apologies if this has been covered in the other threads, but after a long week of conferences, I've only scanned through the 60+ pages around this, but I thought his interview on the Albion Analysis pod was the closest thing we have to an understanding of the situation...
Through his contacts and manual number crunching, he presumes we have fallen around 1M over the limits for PSR and that's what's triggering this situation. He does not believe this has been done maliciously, and is a genuine mistake and from the sounds of things, it has not been picked up either by us, or the EFL during our business reviews. Had we been acting underhand, there is no shortage of ways we could have cooked the books with cross charges, academy offsets, women's team investments etc where a million quid could easily be hidden, but because we have complied and been transparent throughout, the mistake has tipped us the wrong side of the line.
He was very confident that unless we cut a deal with the EFL, there is no way any punishment can take place this season. There just simply isn't the time to undertake a full investigation plus appeals before the end of the season, unless we agree to a suspended points penalty that only becomes active next season should we not continue to bring our books in line. There will likely be challenges from clubs relegated should we survive by less than the 3 points they will argue we ought to be deducted, but there is precedence where Derby have made payments to relegated clubs to settle out of court and make that situation go away.
In short, the whole thing is a mess, and as has been picked up by the DP's Tweet, and indeed now is becoming more public with the DM article, this is not a club trying to break the rules for a competitive advantage, this is a club desperately trying to comply with the rules and keep itself afloat following years of parasitic ownership actively bleeding the club dry.... a punishment here, which ironically could lead to Leicester, a team that actively cheated the rules, and are expected to again post losses which are non compliant when they get their accounts submitted for the same year we are being punished for, surviving at our expense, really, really would be the icing on the EFL's clusterfuck cake.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Hadn’t seen that thanks SW4
Posts: 1,274
Threads: 45
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
2
(04-18-2026, 09:31 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Apologies if this has been covered in the other threads, but after a long week of conferences, I've only scanned through the 60+ pages around this, but I thought his interview on the Albion Analysis pod was the closest thing we have to an understanding of the situation...
Through his contacts and manual number crunching, he presumes we have fallen around 1M over the limits for PSR and that's what's triggering this situation. He does not believe this has been done maliciously, and is a genuine mistake and from the sounds of things, it has not been picked up either by us, or the EFL during our business reviews. Had we been acting underhand, there is no shortage of ways we could have cooked the books with cross charges, academy offsets, women's team investments etc where a million quid could easily be hidden, but because we have complied and been transparent throughout, the mistake has tipped is the wrong side of the line.
He was very confident that unless we cut a deal with the EFL, there is no way any punishment can take place this season. There just simply isn't the time to undertake a full investigation plus appeals before the end of the season, unless we agree to a suspended points penalty that only becomes active next season should we not continue to bring our books in line. There will likely be challenges from clubs relegated should we survive by less than the 3 points they will argue we ought to be deducted, but there is precedence where Derby have made payments to relegated clubs to settle out of court and make that situation go away.
In short, the whole thing is a mess, and as has been picked up by the DP's Tweet, and indeed now is becoming more public with the DM article, this is not a club trying to break the rules for a competitive advantage, this is a club desperately trying to comply with the rules and keep itself afloat following years of parasitic ownership actively bleeding the club dry.... a punishment here, which ironically could lead to Leicester, a team that actively cheated the rules, and are expected to again post losses which are non compliant when they get their accounts submitted for the same year we are being punished for, surviving at our expense, really, really would be the icing on the EFL's clusterfuck cake.
Interesting. Thanks for posting. Like I said the other day our situation has actually given the EFL an opportunity to use us as an example of how to positively work with the EFL to stay the right side of the line.
They could come out with a strong line about we are only going to receive a fine as we have made every effort to have an open book policy with the EFL and that is the model they want all clubs to adhere to. How we haven't tried to flagrantly break the rules like other clubs.
They won't of course......but they could.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-18-2026, 10:08 AM)Peachofacross Wrote: (04-18-2026, 09:31 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Apologies if this has been covered in the other threads, but after a long week of conferences, I've only scanned through the 60+ pages around this, but I thought his interview on the Albion Analysis pod was the closest thing we have to an understanding of the situation...
Through his contacts and manual number crunching, he presumes we have fallen around 1M over the limits for PSR and that's what's triggering this situation. He does not believe this has been done maliciously, and is a genuine mistake and from the sounds of things, it has not been picked up either by us, or the EFL during our business reviews. Had we been acting underhand, there is no shortage of ways we could have cooked the books with cross charges, academy offsets, women's team investments etc where a million quid could easily be hidden, but because we have complied and been transparent throughout, the mistake has tipped is the wrong side of the line.
He was very confident that unless we cut a deal with the EFL, there is no way any punishment can take place this season. There just simply isn't the time to undertake a full investigation plus appeals before the end of the season, unless we agree to a suspended points penalty that only becomes active next season should we not continue to bring our books in line. There will likely be challenges from clubs relegated should we survive by less than the 3 points they will argue we ought to be deducted, but there is precedence where Derby have made payments to relegated clubs to settle out of court and make that situation go away.
In short, the whole thing is a mess, and as has been picked up by the DP's Tweet, and indeed now is becoming more public with the DM article, this is not a club trying to break the rules for a competitive advantage, this is a club desperately trying to comply with the rules and keep itself afloat following years of parasitic ownership actively bleeding the club dry.... a punishment here, which ironically could lead to Leicester, a team that actively cheated the rules, and are expected to again post losses which are non compliant when they get their accounts submitted for the same year we are being punished for, surviving at our expense, really, really would be the icing on the EFL's clusterfuck cake.
Interesting. Thanks for posting. Like I said the other day our situation has actually given the EFL an opportunity to use us as an example of how to positively work with the EFL to stay the right side of the line.
They could come out with a strong line about we are only going to receive a fine as we have made every effort to have an open book policy with the EFL and that is the model they want all clubs to adhere to. How we haven't tried to flagrantly break the rules like other clubs.
They won't of course......but they could.
Indeed - he also referenced that Chelsea were hit with a fine for their overpayments to agents (in which their defence argued Eden Hazard’s signing didn’t materially boost their chance of success  ) instead of a points deduction, so whilst that is the PL and not the EFL, again there is some precedence for a fine when the club is seen to be complying with the authorities, and wheb the offences took place under a prior ownership.
Posts: 1,801
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
7
Think the key here is "he presumes we have fallen around 1M" and we learnt from the Liquidator podcast this is based on an estimate that our academy costs £6M a year, a number he did not get from West Brom but "from another Championship club" Point is that Maguire has heard nothing from our club or the EFL and while he is an expert his analysis is all based on assumptions and he could be right or he could be wrong. It's all just speculation until we hear something official. As I've said before the biggest concern I have is the impact this off-field car crash has on the morale of the players and I guess that is something we find out about in a few hours time.
Posts: 3,622
Threads: 253
Joined: Apr 2025
Reputation:
1
(04-18-2026, 10:36 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Think the key here is "he presumes we have fallen around 1M" and we learnt from the Liquidator podcast this is based on an estimate that our academy costs £6M a year, a number he did not get from West Brom but "from another Championship club" Point is that Maguire has heard nothing from our club or the EFL and while he is an expert his analysis is all based on assumptions and he could be right or he could be wrong. It's all just speculation until we hear something official. As I've said before the biggest concern I have is the impact this off-field car crash has on the morale of the players and I guess that is something we find out about in a few hours time.
On the flip side it may galvanise them.
|