Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(04-16-2026, 06:37 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: "No sane person would deem that to be a breach worthy of a points deduction."
I'd argue, based on the argument preceding this line, that any other sort of punishment, such as a fine, should be out of the question as well.
However, I'd be surprised if any of this was taken into account by the judging panel and it will come down to the cold hard facts of whether how we have gone about paying that interest is allowable under PSR. But does PSR prescribe *exactly* how it should be treated? A quick look at the rules suggests not so it is all about judgement and, presumably we took external advice before adding the interest back and this practice was consistent with the business plan and forecasts previously presented to the EFL. If so, this is going to be very contentious and time consuming almost like an HMRC case.
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(04-16-2026, 09:05 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (04-16-2026, 06:37 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: "No sane person would deem that to be a breach worthy of a points deduction."
I'd argue, based on the argument preceding this line, that any other sort of punishment, such as a fine, should be out of the question as well.
However, I'd be surprised if any of this was taken into account by the judging panel and it will come down to the cold hard facts of whether how we have gone about paying that interest is allowable under PSR. But does PSR prescribe *exactly* how it should be treated? A quick look at the rules suggests not so it is all about judgement and, presumably we took external advice before adding the interest back and this practice was consistent with the business plan and forecasts previously presented to the EFL. If so, this is going to be very contentious and time consuming almost like an HMRC case.
I would have thought, if this particular action wasn't clear, we'd have asked the EFL beforehand, especially as we were conversing with them already regarding our PSR position. Unless we are pretty certain that it is clear. Guess the ins and outs of it all will be revealed when the punishment is decided on.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
This loan interest:
Are the EFL saying it’s all chargeable against profit and therefore increases the loss (or the income disallowable - either way a debit to the P&L)? Do they factor in the position of the club and what % of said loan was spent on PSR allowable items? If the money was spent on the academy etc does that mean the loan interest is set that way too and therefore is allowable for PSR calcs?
You’d like to hope the club sought clarity on this when working with the EFL or it was at least shown this way in our budgets and forecasts that we must have been sharing with them. How else could they have sanctioned transfers if they didn’t see our projections? Or have we tried to recategorise afterwards
The silence from the EFL is baffling too, considering the leak must have come from their end on some way. There’s zero benefit in us leaking the story.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 627
Threads: 43
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
0
(04-16-2026, 09:45 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: This loan interest:
Are the EFL saying it’s all chargeable against profit and therefore increases the loss (or the income disallowable - either way a debit to the P&L)? Do they factor in the position of the club and what % of said loan was spent on PSR allowable items? If the money was spent on the academy etc does that mean the loan interest is set that way too and therefore is allowable for PSR calcs?
You’d like to hope the club sought clarity on this when working with the EFL or it was at least shown this way in our budgets and forecasts that we must have been sharing with them. How else could they have sanctioned transfers if they didn’t see our projections? Or have we tried to recategorise afterwards
The silence from the EFL is baffling too, considering the leak must have come from their end on some way. There’s zero benefit in us leaking the story.
Agree re silence from the EFL ,,if they ain't fucked up they would have gone to great lengths by now to clear there name i dont know anything about finances and accounts so i may be wrong ,but this stinks imo .
Posts: 2,182
Threads: 163
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation:
7
(04-17-2026, 04:50 AM)Tom of the Brom Wrote: Agree re silence from the EFL ,,if they ain't fucked up they would have gone to great lengths by now to clear there name i dont know anything about finances and accounts so i may be wrong ,but this stinks imo
It's a fair point. Surely, if the EFL were confident of their position they would have put out a statement at a similar time to the Albion.
The longer it does go on, the more I feel it is arse covering from the EFL. Don't have any facts for that but just feels like they're playing for time.
There is more to this than what we've read and I do wonder if we won't actually hear anything about the situation at all and both the club and EFL are hoping it'll quiet down and they will announce some kind of fine in between some other news.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(04-16-2026, 09:12 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: (04-16-2026, 09:05 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (04-16-2026, 06:37 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: "No sane person would deem that to be a breach worthy of a points deduction."
I'd argue, based on the argument preceding this line, that any other sort of punishment, such as a fine, should be out of the question as well.
However, I'd be surprised if any of this was taken into account by the judging panel and it will come down to the cold hard facts of whether how we have gone about paying that interest is allowable under PSR. But does PSR prescribe *exactly* how it should be treated? A quick look at the rules suggests not so it is all about judgement and, presumably we took external advice before adding the interest back and this practice was consistent with the business plan and forecasts previously presented to the EFL. If so, this is going to be very contentious and time consuming almost like an HMRC case.
I would have thought, if this particular action wasn't clear, we'd have asked the EFL beforehand, especially as we were conversing with them already regarding our PSR position. Unless we are pretty certain that it is clear. Guess the ins and outs of it all will be revealed when the punishment is decided on. Agreed Ray.
Presumably the PSR falls on the club as, from memory, the loan sits in the hold co.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-17-2026, 06:29 AM)Mouse Wrote: (04-17-2026, 04:50 AM)Tom of the Brom Wrote: Agree re silence from the EFL ,,if they ain't fucked up they would have gone to great lengths by now to clear there name i dont know anything about finances and accounts so i may be wrong ,but this stinks imo
It's a fair point. Surely, if the EFL were confident of their position they would have put out a statement at a similar time to the Albion.
The longer it does go on, the more I feel it is arse covering from the EFL. Don't have any facts for that but just feels like they're playing for time.
There is more to this than what we've read and I do wonder if we won't actually hear anything about the situation at all and both the club and EFL are hoping it'll quiet down and they will announce some kind of fine in between some other news.
I think the EFL and WBA have been in discussions, and were probably waiting to see how the season finishes, and at that point, would announce a 1 or 2 point deduction that would not influence the end of season positions.
Someone affiliated with Leicester has heard about it and is kicking up a fuss, and neither us nor the EFL want to say anything until we've got our ducks in a row.
The whole thing is a mess and I am confident there are lawyers on both sides racking up plenty of billed hours
Posts: 7,973
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(04-17-2026, 02:01 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-17-2026, 06:29 AM)Mouse Wrote: (04-17-2026, 04:50 AM)Tom of the Brom Wrote: Agree re silence from the EFL ,,if they ain't fucked up they would have gone to great lengths by now to clear there name i dont know anything about finances and accounts so i may be wrong ,but this stinks imo
It's a fair point. Surely, if the EFL were confident of their position they would have put out a statement at a similar time to the Albion.
The longer it does go on, the more I feel it is arse covering from the EFL. Don't have any facts for that but just feels like they're playing for time.
There is more to this than what we've read and I do wonder if we won't actually hear anything about the situation at all and both the club and EFL are hoping it'll quiet down and they will announce some kind of fine in between some other news.
I think the EFL and WBA have been in discussions, and were probably waiting to see how the season finishes, and at that point, would announce a 1 or 2 point deduction that would not influence the end of season positions.
Someone affiliated with Leicester has heard about it and is kicking up a fuss, and neither us nor the EFL want to say anything until we've got our ducks in a row.
The whole thing is a mess and I am confident there are lawyers on both sides racking up plenty of billed hours 
Heh heh
Perusal. 40 units
|