PSR breach reported by John Percy
(04-14-2026, 06:34 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 05:27 PM)Jerry Wrote: Article from Givemesport says Alan Nixon has said the hearing has been held without Albion present to put their case and there is no appeal. EFL working out how to handle the breach.

If the above is correct the EFL has not followed process and we are stuffed.

Percy's report does not specifically state when Albion were charged. We are all assuming it was very recent due to it coming out now and the word "have" used rather than "had" with regard to the 14-day response period.

It may well be that the club had already responded (in writing) and this was considered at the subsequent hearing.

With Percy stating that the club are understood to be attempting to defer any punishment until next season then this could mean that the response and hearing period have passed and the EFL are now at the stage of considering what punishment to apply.

It would then still need to go to appeal and independent panel
Reply
(04-14-2026, 06:43 PM)CIM Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 06:34 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 05:27 PM)Jerry Wrote: Article from Givemesport says Alan Nixon has said the hearing has been held without Albion present to put their case and there is no appeal. EFL working out how to handle the breach.

If the above is correct the EFL has not followed process and we are stuffed.

Percy's report does not specifically state when Albion were charged. We are all assuming it was very recent due to it coming out now and the word "have" used rather than "had" with regard to the 14-day response period.

It may well be that the club had already responded (in writing) and this was considered at the subsequent hearing.

With Percy stating that the club are understood to be attempting to defer any punishment until next season then this could mean that the response and hearing period have passed and the EFL are now at the stage of considering what punishment to apply.

It would then still need to go to appeal and independent panel

Assuming we appeal, might cut a reduced next season deal to say we don't appeal a d waste time...
Reply
It would be so Albion to somehow break PSR when we went years without paying a fee for any of our players and be closer to the bottom than the top.
Reply
(04-14-2026, 06:50 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 06:43 PM)CIM Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 06:34 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 05:27 PM)Jerry Wrote: Article from Givemesport says Alan Nixon has said the hearing has been held without Albion present to put their case and there is no appeal. EFL working out how to handle the breach.

If the above is correct the EFL has not followed process and we are stuffed.

Percy's report does not specifically state when Albion were charged. We are all assuming it was very recent due to it coming out now and the word "have" used rather than "had" with regard to the 14-day response period.

It may well be that the club had already responded (in writing) and this was considered at the subsequent hearing.

With Percy stating that the club are understood to be attempting to defer any punishment until next season then this could mean that the response and hearing period have passed and the EFL are now at the stage of considering what punishment to apply.

It would then still need to go to appeal and independent panel

Assuming we appeal, might cut a reduced next season deal to say we don't appeal a d waste time...

That's a possibility. We'd also need justifiable grounds for appeal, unless we just decided to fuck about in the hope that, by the time it's done, it would be too late to apply any points deduction this season. Depends how "honourable" Shilen is.
Reply
Given the lack of information to work with in terms of an actual p&l or trial balance for the entirety of the period in question I like the conspiracy and witch hunt angles.

Clearly this is down to Eric Ramsay taking us for every penny he could. I will admit that his compensation is unknown and not even relevant to the period in question but please do not let that get in the way of us finding a scapegoat. i can only assume he found a copy of our accounts, sent them into the EFL and has broken the story in the press too.

What a prick. I knew he was trouble.
Reply
The Guardian is saying the dispute is over the interest payments from the loan taken out to cover the period before Bilkul took over. This was when they saved us from administration (please no more on that as its not my point).

The EFL are culpable for Lai and their "fit and proper" owners test. 

That time and loan kept us out of administration.

What purpose does the EFL serve other than to keep clubs alive?
Reply
(04-14-2026, 09:29 PM)Cornflake Wrote: The Guardian is saying the dispute is over the interest payments from the loan taken out to cover the period before Bilkul took over. This was when they saved us from administration (please no more on that as its not my point).

The EFL are culpable for Lai and their "fit and proper" owners test. 

That time and loan kept us out of administration.

What purpose does the EFL serve other than to keep clubs alive?

I read that too and saw it as interest payments on the very loan that kept us out of administration in the first place before or during the takeover. If this is in fact the case, the EFL should be punishing themselves with a fine. The next thing to query is how did news of this leak out? Maguire says it wasn't from the club?
Reply
(04-14-2026, 09:29 PM)Cornflake Wrote: The Guardian is saying the dispute is over the interest payments from the loan taken out to cover the period before Bilkul took over. This was when they saved us from administration (please no more on that as its not my point).

The EFL are culpable for Lai and their "fit and proper" owners test. 

That time and loan kept us out of administration.

What purpose does the EFL serve other than to keep clubs alive?

2+2=5 here.

The issue that may as I think I suggested Monday, could be maybe that Bilkul covering the Interest or some accumulated Interest and showing it as Revenue. Other Income or Exceptional.

Maybe WBA say Revenue, or allowable due to the circs, EFL say an permissible subsidy.

I've not read the Guardian article yet but that item is curious, but a total shot in the dark by me.

For those interested. Bilkul covering the Interest is great, helps a club out in the hour of need. As Cssh Flow or Equity. 

Cash Interest liabilities being assumed as Revenue though?


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   
Reply
(04-14-2026, 10:45 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 09:29 PM)Cornflake Wrote: The Guardian is saying the dispute is over the interest payments from the loan taken out to cover the period before Bilkul took over. This was when they saved us from administration (please no more on that as its not my point).

The EFL are culpable for Lai and their "fit and proper" owners test. 

That time and loan kept us out of administration.

What purpose does the EFL serve other than to keep clubs alive?

2+2=5 here.

The issue that may as I think I suggested Monday, could be maybe that Bilkul covering the Interest or some accumulated Interest and showing it as Revenue. Other Income or Exceptional.

Maybe WBA say Revenue, or allowable due to the circs, EFL say an permissible subsidy.

I've not read the Guardian article yet but that item is curious, but a total shot in the dark by me.

For those interested. Bilkul covering the Interest is great, helps a club out in the hour of need. As Cssh Flow or Equity. 

Cash Interest liabilities being assumed as Revenue though?

One would hope it's not a categorisation issue within the accounts given the closer working with the EFL to address the issue. That type of thing would surely have been covered during the initial conversations and scene setting so the EFL clearly understood the clubs basis of preparation and that any measures would ensure compliance. Looking at the recharge of interest it's also a significant sum so is unlikely to be related to this aspect otherwise the breach would be significantly higher.

Obviously something has gone wrong and per the guardian it would make a bit more sense if it is over something extraordinary such as the emergency cashflow loan during the ownership transition. But even this is questionable on the basis this happened sometime ago and that they would surely have had plenty of time to look into it and agree the correct accounting treatment. 

I guess this type of situation, while soul destroying, is of interest to anyone with a financial background because it is a pretty spectacular fuck up by someone give the importance. Financial is generally meant to be boring, i.e. as predictable as it can be, cause and effect understood and Y.E outturns managed through numerous projections and scenario planning. Basically you should not manage your numbers in conjunction with a third party, go through an audit cycle, submit your accounts and then have something new come to light such as this. 

Just my two cents / conjecture.
Reply
The Guardian article mentioned above aligns with the view expressed on the Albion Analytics podcast episode with Kieran Maguire - our classification of the recharge of MSD interest to Bilkul as income is likely what the EFL are contesting. The income from the recharge was £5.2m, so disallowing that could tip us above the PSR threshold.

Highly recommend listening to the episode. Maguire’s view was that any sanction will have to apply to next season, as there just isn’t enough time left to conclude this matter after you account for the potential legal challenges from us/those around us. And applying a sanction to this season after the final game would not make sense from a sporting POV given clubs would be going into the final game not knowing what they need to survive.
He’s gorra gew, Franksy!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)