Posts: 6,719
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
I worship at the altar of the NHS
But it can and must do better. And we should be looking at other countries.
https://www.internationalinsurance.com/h...I442X44bI3
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(04-13-2026, 03:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-13-2026, 02:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's ideological.
Yes, it is. Just like the NHS is now an unaffordable ideological anachronism (and the State Pension for that matter).
I would like to recreate the relationship between the individual and the state, that's all. In that respect I doubt I'm that far removed from Beveridge.
That's the point, you bang on about funding models when all the evidence says we need to fix primary and social care and that changing the funding model makes zero difference because we have universal healthcare obligations already. Unless you want us to go for what the Swiss have with the removal of universal healthcare.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
04-13-2026, 03:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-13-2026, 03:36 PM by Protheroe.)
(04-13-2026, 03:15 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I worship at the altar of the NHS
But it can and must do better. And we should be looking at other countries.
https://www.internationalinsurance.com/h...I442X44bI3
Precisely. The Commonwealth Study consistently cites the UK as being incredibly efficient at producing poor outcomes. My family has received the dubious benefit of such outcomes in several occasions, which is the ONLY reason I now supplement NHS care with an exceptionally good value family policy through the company.
(04-13-2026, 03:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (04-13-2026, 03:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-13-2026, 02:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's ideological.
Yes, it is. Just like the NHS is now an unaffordable ideological anachronism (and the State Pension for that matter).
I would like to recreate the relationship between the individual and the state, that's all. In that respect I doubt I'm that far removed from Beveridge.
That's the point, you bang on about funding models when all the evidence says we need to fix primary and social care and that changing the funding model makes zero difference because we have universal healthcare obligations already. Unless you want us to go for what the Swiss have with the removal of universal healthcare.
It's not just the funding model. It's the whole relationship between the individual and the state:
Beveridge stated that social security must be a joint effort. The state offers security, but it is earned through service and contribution. While Beveridge proposed a primarily contribution-based system, the post-war welfare state evolved to be funded significantly by taxpayers, moving away from his original vision.
Beveridge said The state's role is to provide a comprehensive system of social insurance (combining the "five giants" of Want, Disease, Ignorance, Squalor, and Idleness) that guarantees a subsistence-level income. Contrast that with the Triple Lock.
The system was based on contributions rather than charity, often referred to as "stamping the card," which was meant to encourage a feeling of partnership and entitlement. There is now just entitlement.
Beveridge emphasized that in establishing a national minimum, the state should not stifle "incentive, opportunity, [or] responsibility". The state was intended to leave "room and encouragement for voluntary action by each individual to provide more than that minimum for himself and his family". The system was not meant to create dependence but to provide a safety net for people to "build freely upon".
While establishing a comprehensive system, the state should not create a totalising, restrictive monopoly, but rather foster a "mixed economy" of welfare that includes voluntary action.
I'm with Beveridge.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
04-13-2026, 03:40 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-13-2026, 03:40 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
So you now suddenly want a single-payer system like Denmark (Beveridge Model), not social insurance (curious why you've never said we should go for what the Danes or Spanish have before if that's the case), and you've completely ignored the thing I raised about fixing the actual issues (primary and social care) but bang on about nonsense unrelated to my point.
Seems like a weak attempt at a gotcha to avoid addressing the point to be honest.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
There are several points to be addressed including the one you've made.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
04-13-2026, 03:58 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-13-2026, 04:00 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
There is no point to be made for the funding model when it comes to healthcare reform, there's no evidence to suggest it will make any difference and whenever it's looked into the conclusion is it would be spending loads of money to ignore the actual problems. This goes both ways, under universal healthcare there's no point in pursuing the Bismarck Model as a Beveridge Model country and vice versa.
The issues with the state of healthcare in this country are primary care, social care, digital and management. None of that relates to the funding model and the two biggest issues are the first two. We've had primary care spending cut massively since 2015 and the social care can has been kicked into the long grass, but let's talk about whether the money to fund universal healthcare is taken out of your salary as tax to the government or taken out of your salary as a social insurance contribution to the government (via a private healthcare trust).
The great irony is the worst performing part of the UK healthcare system (primary care) is a hold over from the old system when we had social insurance.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
I accept your view, but I don't agree that the change that is necessary can happen without individuals' relationship with the state becoming a lot clearer. As it is there is hugely deferential attitude to the NHS when we ought be a lot more demanding for the £200bn thrown at healthcare each year. People think it's free, and abuse it to detriment of us all. That has to change.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-13-2026, 04:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I accept your view, but I don't agree that the change that is necessary can happen without individuals' relationship with the state becoming a lot clearer. As it is there is hugely deferential attitude to the NHS when we ought be a lot more demanding for the £200bn thrown at healthcare each year. People think it's free, and abuse it to detriment of us all. That has to change.
I agree with the principle of rights and responsibilities and somewhere down the line we have forgotten the latter and not just in healthcare. However there a a lot of people who will never be able to be look after family members without the support of the government. Many disabled people require extremely expensive equipment, use more heating and electricity and need round the clock care. The fact most regular families struggle to make ends meet each month, suggests that if you abandon them to a US or even insurance based model, you will impoverish the most vulnerable in society.
Given this country is increasingly selfish, exploitative and self absorbed, the idea that there will be a system that would support those with disabled family members for the greater good of society voluntarily is naive or ambivalently callous. Trust me if some could opt out of helping others less fortunate than themselves they would like a shot and that’s includes business’s which are supposed to be healthcare providers. Want predictable a look at private care providers for the vulnerable.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
04-13-2026, 05:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-13-2026, 05:04 PM by WorcsWBA.)
Trump has claimed this afternoon that the now-deleted Trump-Jesus image (good news - there was plenty of time for it to be reposted all across the globe!) was depicting him as a doctor "making people better", rather than as a Jesus-like figure. He accused the media of having come up with that narrative. Even if you accept his nonsensical explanation, you might reasonably ask what qualifications he has as a doctor to make people better, particularly using beams of supernatural light as shown in the image. Perhaps this is the light-shining treatment he was blathering on about during the pandemic...
I'm sure all sane people will be able to make their own minds up as to what the image really depicts.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(04-13-2026, 04:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I accept your view, but I don't agree that the change that is necessary can happen without individuals' relationship with the state becoming a lot clearer. As it is there is hugely deferential attitude to the NHS when we ought be a lot more demanding for the £200bn thrown at healthcare each year. People think it's free, and abuse it to detriment of us all. That has to change.
Primary care is about supporting people to take personal responsibility to avoid issues, this covers early scans, regular medical check ups, going to the GP as soon as possible through to stuff like making sure you're active and eating healthily. It's exactly how you avoid creating worse issues that then end up bogging down the NHS which then needs to spend money to address avoidable issues.
|