PSR breach reported by John Percy
(04-13-2026, 12:51 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 12:41 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Everyone is going on about how great Bilkul are, and how they’ve ‘saved’ us. The WBA damsel in distress, rescued from the jaws of liquidity by hunky hero Shilen and his magnanimous investment.

When the truth is:

- He didn’t rate CC;
- He appointed a has-been flop, still being paid by the club;
- He appointed, and then in a heartbeat promoted to ‘President’ the utter fucktard who is Nestor;
- He appointed a Spurs serial loser kid and then stripped his right side bare days before the campaign began. And is still paying him;
- He appointed a Soccerball no-mark who couldn’t win a game of padel against a leper on a windy day, and is still paying him too;
- Therefore, beyond Nestor’s somewhat meaningless and self-serving statement to the contrary, done fuck all to save us. We were a play-off team when he came in. Where are we now?

I’m sorry to say it, but however well-meaning their intentions may be, their competence remains MASSIVELY in question. And if people are going to use such conjecture as ‘someone at the EFL really doesn’t like us’, well we really are clutching at straws. The fact of the matter is that he’s failed in every appointment he’s had to make, and we’ve only begun improving again with a guy in charge who’s been here all along.

Forgive me for not thinking he’s Flash Gordon. Even if he only has 14 days to save the Earth, he’d probably save Mars instead, because he still seems pretty clueless from where I’m sitting.
Each to their own you think what you want. Yes managers have been crap and Nestor a disaster but he still saved the club.

Yes, each indeed to their own. But if we go down as a result of either poor performance or a points deduction, then that to me is hardly saving us. How have they saved us? By selling our best players on the cheap, and not renewing those only a fool would have? I think you’re making them out to be what we all want them to be - I certainly do - but I’m not seeing it. 

Instead all I’m seeing is a managerless club in a flat spin. On the pitch just about salvaged via a Mozza minor miracle, but off the pitch? Just a myriad of lies, inside appointments and par-for-the-course work. Hell, even our Head of Marketing is a dingle! Just how had to things have to become?

In fact, compared to May 2024 - ahead of being 3 matches away from being in the top tier once again - it feels a world away, and ALL on their watch. 

They are not saving us. They are failing. And the only real success I see out of any of this is the sale of Heggem, and even that wasn’t enough (even if you throw in a Palmer, a Furlong, and an underpriced Fellows). 

Unless we somehow survive this season I am yet to be convinced - despite their good nature - that they are not wholly out of their depth. 

Perhaps relegation could be a good thing. Who knows. Didn’t hurt last time in the long run, but I’d much prefer not to take that route because it’s a slightly different game now to what it was last time around.
Reply
(04-13-2026, 01:27 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 12:51 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 12:41 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Everyone is going on about how great Bilkul are, and how they’ve ‘saved’ us. The WBA damsel in distress, rescued from the jaws of liquidity by hunky hero Shilen and his magnanimous investment.

When the truth is:

- He didn’t rate CC;
- He appointed a has-been flop, still being paid by the club;
- He appointed, and then in a heartbeat promoted to ‘President’ the utter fucktard who is Nestor;
- He appointed a Spurs serial loser kid and then stripped his right side bare days before the campaign began. And is still paying him;
- He appointed a Soccerball no-mark who couldn’t win a game of padel against a leper on a windy day, and is still paying him too;
- Therefore, beyond Nestor’s somewhat meaningless and self-serving statement to the contrary, done fuck all to save us. We were a play-off team when he came in. Where are we now?

I’m sorry to say it, but however well-meaning their intentions may be, their competence remains MASSIVELY in question. And if people are going to use such conjecture as ‘someone at the EFL really doesn’t like us’, well we really are clutching at straws. The fact of the matter is that he’s failed in every appointment he’s had to make, and we’ve only begun improving again with a guy in charge who’s been here all along.

Forgive me for not thinking he’s Flash Gordon. Even if he only has 14 days to save the Earth, he’d probably save Mars instead, because he still seems pretty clueless from where I’m sitting.
Each to their own you think what you want. Yes managers have been crap and Nestor a disaster but he still saved the club.

Yes, each indeed to their own. But if we go down as a result of either poor performance or a points deduction, then that to me is hardly saving us. How have they saved us? By selling our best players on the cheap, and not renewing those only a fool would have? I think you’re making them out to be what we all want them to be - I certainly do - but I’m not seeing it. 

Instead all I’m seeing is a managerless club in a flat spin. On the pitch just about salvaged via a Mozza minor miracle, but off the pitch? Just a myriad of lies, inside appointments and par-for-the-course work. Hell, even our Head of Marketing is a dingle! Just how had to things have to become?

In fact, compared to May 2024 - ahead of being 3 matches away from being in the top tier once again - it feels a world away, and ALL on their watch. 

They are not saving us. They are failing. And the only real success I see out of any of this is the sale of Heggem, and even that wasn’t enough (even if you throw in a Palmer, a Furlong, and an underpriced Fellows). 

Unless we somehow survive this season I am yet to be convinced - despite their good nature - that they are not wholly out of their depth. 

Perhaps relegation could be a good thing. Who knows. Didn’t hurt last time in the long run, but I’d much prefer not to take that route because it’s a slightly different game now to what it was last time around.

We were always going to drop down the table this season we were in such a dire state financially that we had to do things we didn't want to do for example sell Fellows at the last minute for the only offer available. This has been discussed time and again. The main issues have been dire managerial appointments from Nestor who has been now cleared off. 

We're seeing at the moment with a manager that has a clue that whilst there are still plenty of weaknesses in the squad as expected seeing as we could barely spend anything, some of the signings on this limited budget don't look bad after all.  

They're starting at last to get in some proper football expertise in so I'm hopeful we can move forward.

Of course if we've fugged up with this latest situation then they deserve criticism for that, but noone knows yet what has happened.
Reply
(04-13-2026, 12:41 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Everyone is going on about how great Bilkul are, and how they’ve ‘saved’ us. The WBA damsel in distress, rescued from the jaws of liquidity by hunky hero Shilen and his magnanimous investment.

When the truth is:

- He didn’t rate CC;
- He appointed a has-been flop, still being paid by the club;
- He appointed, and then in a heartbeat promoted to ‘President’ the utter fucktard who is Nestor;
- He appointed a Spurs serial loser kid and then stripped his right side bare days before the campaign began. And is still paying him;
- He appointed a Soccerball no-mark who couldn’t win a game of padel against a leper on a windy day, and is still paying him too;
- Therefore, beyond Nestor’s somewhat meaningless and self-serving statement to the contrary, done fuck all to save us. We were a play-off team when he came in. Where are we now?

I’m sorry to say it, but however well-meaning their intentions may be, their competence remains MASSIVELY in question. And if people are going to use such conjecture as ‘someone at the EFL really doesn’t like us’, well we really are clutching at straws. The fact of the matter is that he’s failed in every appointment he’s had to make, and we’ve only begun improving again with a guy in charge who’s been here all along.

Forgive me for not thinking he’s Flash Gordon. Even if he only has 14 days to save the Earth, he’d probably save Mars instead, because he still seems pretty clueless from where I’m sitting.

Absolutely bizarre post.

They literally saved the club. Without their investment, we would have gone into admin and probably defunct. Fact - they saved the club.

They've absolutely made many mistakes since, which deserve plnety of criticism (fucking Eric Ramsay?!). But we verifiably still have a club.
Reply
It’s not a “fact” that they saved the club at all. As Sheffield Wednesday are proving - Administration does not equal instant death.

They acquired the club with a view to making a return at some point in future - they aren’t a fucking charity. Thus far, they’ve made an almighty bollocks of the majority of key decisions that affect the club’s performance on the pitch. I’m not sure how anyone could argue otherwise.
Reply
(04-13-2026, 01:53 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 12:41 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Everyone is going on about how great Bilkul are, and how they’ve ‘saved’ us. The WBA damsel in distress, rescued from the jaws of liquidity by hunky hero Shilen and his magnanimous investment.

When the truth is:

- He didn’t rate CC;
- He appointed a has-been flop, still being paid by the club;
- He appointed, and then in a heartbeat promoted to ‘President’ the utter fucktard who is Nestor;
- He appointed a Spurs serial loser kid and then stripped his right side bare days before the campaign began. And is still paying him;
- He appointed a Soccerball no-mark who couldn’t win a game of padel against a leper on a windy day, and is still paying him too;
- Therefore, beyond Nestor’s somewhat meaningless and self-serving statement to the contrary, done fuck all to save us. We were a play-off team when he came in. Where are we now?

I’m sorry to say it, but however well-meaning their intentions may be, their competence remains MASSIVELY in question. And if people are going to use such conjecture as ‘someone at the EFL really doesn’t like us’, well we really are clutching at straws. The fact of the matter is that he’s failed in every appointment he’s had to make, and we’ve only begun improving again with a guy in charge who’s been here all along.

Forgive me for not thinking he’s Flash Gordon. Even if he only has 14 days to save the Earth, he’d probably save Mars instead, because he still seems pretty clueless from where I’m sitting.

Absolutely bizarre post.

They literally saved the club. Without their investment, we would have gone into admin and probably defunct. Fact - they saved the club.

They've absolutely made many mistakes since, which deserve plnety of criticism (fucking Eric Ramsay?!). But we verifiably still have a club.

There are and were other buyers out there. It wasn’t Bilkul or nothing. The idea there would be no other parties interested is a tad unrealistic.

(04-13-2026, 01:57 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: It’s not a “fact” that they saved the club at all. As Sheffield Wednesday are proving - Administration does not equal instant death.

They acquired the club with a view to making a return at some point in future - they aren’t a fucking charity. Thus far, they’ve made an almighty bollocks of the majority of key decisions that affect the club’s performance on the pitch. I’m not sure how anyone could argue otherwise.

Exactly but no matter how many times this is said by various posters, it’s never seems to register with those who seem to think the club would have ceased to exist.
Reply
The fact is, at this point we don't know whether we've breached PSR or not or the FACTS of the claim, although I'm sure that someone will come along to claim they know much more than they actually do any minute now.

IF we have breached PSR despite the weakening of our squad then it's hard to say anything other than Bilkul's ownership has been a complete shitshow. Zero redeeming features.

TWO OR THREE point deduction if found guilty according to the BBC. If the reports are true that we breached by less than 2m then it would be a two point deduction. Less than 4m would be a three point deduction because we have reduced our losses.
Reply
(04-13-2026, 02:17 PM)Sliced Wrote: TWO OR THREE point deduction if found guilty according to the BBC

You can be banned from driving for speeding, you can also end up with an awareness course.
Reply
This is for those who don’t believe our owners don’t care and haven’t done much since they arrived.
ByBy Steve Hermon, BBC Radio WM
West Brom have been treading a precarious line for a while.
It was my understanding, when their latest financial report was published less than a month ago, that they were confident they would not break any rules.
So if they are to be charged it would be a hammer blow to those behind the scenes at the Hawthorns who have poured their heart and soul into trying to help the club recover from the darkest period in their modern history.
That includes chairman Shilen Patel, who has ploughed tens of millions of pounds into Albion - mainly to cover debts left by the previous owner - since completing his takeover in February 2024.
These reports will also come as a shock to the supporters, whose nerves were already shredded after Oxford United and Portsmouth reduced West Brom's gap to the relegation zone to only two points over the weekend.
Reply
(04-13-2026, 02:17 PM)Sliced Wrote: The fact is, at this point we don't know whether we've breached PSR or not or the FACTS of the claim, although I'm sure that someone will come along to claim they know much more than they actually do any minute now.

IF we have breached PSR despite the weakening of our squad then it's hard to say anything other than Bilkul's ownership has been a complete shitshow. Zero redeeming features.

TWO OR THREE point deduction if found guilty according to the BBC. If the reports are true that we breached by less than 2m then it would be a two point deduction. Less than 4m would be a three point deduction because we have reduced our losses.

On that basis Leicester should have had a 30 point deduction
Reply
(04-13-2026, 02:27 PM)CIM Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 02:17 PM)Sliced Wrote: The fact is, at this point we don't know whether we've breached PSR or not or the FACTS of the claim, although I'm sure that someone will come along to claim they know much more than they actually do any minute now.

IF we have breached PSR despite the weakening of our squad then it's hard to say anything other than Bilkul's ownership has been a complete shitshow. Zero redeeming features.

TWO OR THREE point deduction if found guilty according to the BBC. If the reports are true that we breached by less than 2m then it would be a two point deduction. Less than 4m would be a three point deduction because we have reduced our losses.

On that basis Leicester should have had a 30 point deduction

Big Grin

I guess beyond a certain point it's just "fuck it, 6 is enough"
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)