Dobbin and our record with loans
#1
Without stealing too much of Squid's thunder I thought I'd have a look and see what the Preston fans thought ahead of the weekends game and found this thread.

https://pne-online.net/forum/threads/lew...n.3443359/

Are they watching the same player?

It did make me think, given it's been so long since we've had a genuine standout loan signing, Imray has been the best for a long while. How and why do we get it so wrong so often? I think as fans we're not sold on loans, compared to the attitude amongst the Preston fans who seem to welcome finding kids from PL clubs and taking them for a season whereas I think in recent times we've had a bit of an aversion to any player that wasn't 'our own'. Or with Dobbin was it purely the fact he came from the Villa that meant he was never going to be given the time of day, see also JJA and SIJ. Either way it's something we have to massively improve on over the next couple of windows.
Reply
#2
We got the one from Rentaghost.
Reply
#3
Barnes and Gallagher probably the last two of any use.
Reply
#4
(04-13-2026, 09:13 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Barnes and Gallagher probably the last two of any use.

Johnston was great on loan.
Reply
#5
Diangana not bad either
Reply
#6
(04-13-2026, 09:13 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Barnes and Gallagher probably the last two of any use.

That Matteus Pereira was a bloody well decent loan
Reply
#7
16 goal contributions in 24.9 90's.

Never saw that coming.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#8
He was never that bad. We just love writing off anyone from Villa as soon as they walk in the door
Reply
#9
(04-13-2026, 11:01 AM)Sliced Wrote: He was never that bad. We just love writing off anyone from Villa as soon as they walk in the door

I think everyone made up their mind on Dobbin very early and any Villa link was never going to help (despite like SIJ having never even actually played for them), however, he contributed nothing for us whatsoever when he did play. Football fans can be very over-the-top in giving criticism but it’s difficult to defend Dobbin at all. He was simply crap for us.
Reply
#10
(04-13-2026, 11:01 AM)Sliced Wrote: He was never that bad. We just love writing off anyone from Villa as soon as they walk in the door

He was truly honking at our place.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)