PSR breach reported by John Percy
#41
(04-13-2026, 10:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: They're not Lai so they're seen as the Messiahs and the saviour of all things Albion. Don't you dare be critical or even question their utter brilliance.

Nobody has said this, don't be an idiot.
Reply
#42
(04-13-2026, 09:54 AM)CIM Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 09:53 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Would anyone actually be surprised if Nestor fucked up the figures on his spreadsheet somewhere down the line?

Probably didn't drag the Sum formula down enough cells.

What was that about no need for knee jerk reactions?

That was supposed to be a tongue in cheek post about the use of data and spreadsheets Nestor loved! 

Who knows what's gone on. I'm not ruling out a fuck up by someone at WBA, or someone at EFL being a bell end. Who knows. The timing is appalling, either way.

(04-13-2026, 10:07 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 10:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: They're not Lai so they're seen as the Messiahs and the saviour of all things Albion. Don't you dare be critical or even question their utter brilliance.

Nobody has said this, don't be an idiot.

Of course they have. I'm sick of hearing the 'don't criticise Bikul, we'd be liquidated and out of existence if it wasn't for them'. 

It's there in black and white in a number of threads that certain people constantly hark on about how grateful we should be and wonderful these owners are, and how we shouldn't dare show any negativity towards them.
Reply
#43
(04-13-2026, 10:07 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 09:54 AM)CIM Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 09:53 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Would anyone actually be surprised if Nestor fucked up the figures on his spreadsheet somewhere down the line?

Probably didn't drag the Sum formula down enough cells.

What was that about no need for knee jerk reactions?

That was supposed to be a tongue in cheek post about the use of data and spreadsheets Nestor loved! 

Who knows what's gone on. I'm not ruling out a fuck up by someone at WBA, or someone at EFL being a bell end. Who knows. The timing is appalling, either way.

(04-13-2026, 10:07 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 10:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: They're not Lai so they're seen as the Messiahs and the saviour of all things Albion. Don't you dare be critical or even question their utter brilliance.

Nobody has said this, don't be an idiot.

Of course they have. I'm sick of hearing the 'don't criticise Bikul, we'd be liquidated and out of existence if it wasn't for them'. 

It's there in black and white in a number of threads that certain people constantly hark on about how grateful and wonderful these owners are, and how we shouldn't dare show any negativity towards them.

I do show negativity to them but FINANCIALLY they saved us. A utter fuck up putting his mate Nestor in charge though.
Reply
#44
Let's not pretend they've come in and saved us out of the goodness of their heart as if they're a Samaritan. They'd have taken us on to benefit themselves in some way, probably with the aim of sorting us out and getting us to the Prem and we'll us on so they make a nice profit. They'll no doing be getting something out of us - which is fine if they turn us around and bring some success.

If it wasn't them, it would have been someone else taking us on - I've no doubt about that.

As for the financial side, I've seen zero evidence that they've done anything overly special. They've, as far as I can tell, cut out cloth accordingly and done what needed to be done, which any half decent accountant could do.

As far as on the field side of the club, it's been a cluster fuck, and I'm as far away from grateful to them for the mess they've made on that side of things.

I'm really not sure where the love in of these owners comes from, in all honesty. What evidence do people have to support them? What exactly have they done that's so special and over and beyond what a financial savvy person would have done?
Reply
#45
(04-13-2026, 10:07 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 09:54 AM)CIM Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 09:53 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Would anyone actually be surprised if Nestor fucked up the figures on his spreadsheet somewhere down the line?

Probably didn't drag the Sum formula down enough cells.

What was that about no need for knee jerk reactions?

That was supposed to be a tongue in cheek post about the use of data and spreadsheets Nestor loved! 

Who knows what's gone on. I'm not ruling out a fuck up by someone at WBA, or someone at EFL being a bell end. Who knows. The timing is appalling, either way.

(04-13-2026, 10:07 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 10:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: They're not Lai so they're seen as the Messiahs and the saviour of all things Albion. Don't you dare be critical or even question their utter brilliance.

Nobody has said this, don't be an idiot.

Of course they have. I'm sick of hearing the 'don't criticise Bikul, we'd be liquidated and out of existence if it wasn't for them'. 

It's there in black and white in a number of threads that certain people constantly hark on about how grateful we should be and wonderful these owners are, and how we shouldn't dare show any negativity towards them.

If it’s there in black and white then let’s see some examples. Especially the parts that forbid any criticism.
Reply
#46
(04-13-2026, 09:56 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 09:55 AM)Duffers Wrote: Given that the club has clearly and demonstrably shown willing in working transparently to what we all thought was a clear EFL plan, then even if there was an error in the numbers that should at least be enough mitigation to avoid anything beyond a fine or suspended points deduction.

It's not as if we've been spending willy nilly to gain an advantage is it? We've actually tried to comply, and you would that is factored in.

Apparently Reading followed the EFL's compliance stuff and they still got fucked..

That's the concern. Readings first points deduction (they had subsequent ones as well) was 6 points for a PSR breach. Despite them being on a business plan. I believe there's was a more major breach than Albions though.
Reply
#47
(04-13-2026, 10:04 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: https://archive.is/20260413090402/https:...elegation/

Having a read I’m not too concerned.

Having read it I'm more concerned, guess it is a glass half full / empty thing.  Didn't like this para in particular 

However, after the EFL’s Club Financial Reporting Unit assessed their accounts for compliance, West Brom were informed of an alleged breach. The club have 14 days to respond from the date of the charge. The EFL has declined to comment. 

I am assuming the EFLs Financial Reporting Unit has some expertise and competence.  The timing of this could really stink the place out.
Reply
#48
(Posts from WBA13 don't count as he refuses to accept any criticism of anything to do with the club)
Reply
#49
(04-13-2026, 10:14 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 10:07 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 09:54 AM)CIM Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 09:53 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Would anyone actually be surprised if Nestor fucked up the figures on his spreadsheet somewhere down the line?

Probably didn't drag the Sum formula down enough cells.

What was that about no need for knee jerk reactions?

That was supposed to be a tongue in cheek post about the use of data and spreadsheets Nestor loved! 

Who knows what's gone on. I'm not ruling out a fuck up by someone at WBA, or someone at EFL being a bell end. Who knows. The timing is appalling, either way.

(04-13-2026, 10:07 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-13-2026, 10:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: They're not Lai so they're seen as the Messiahs and the saviour of all things Albion. Don't you dare be critical or even question their utter brilliance.

Nobody has said this, don't be an idiot.

Of course they have. I'm sick of hearing the 'don't criticise Bikul, we'd be liquidated and out of existence if it wasn't for them'. 

It's there in black and white in a number of threads that certain people constantly hark on about how grateful and wonderful these owners are, and how we shouldn't dare show any negativity towards them.

I do show negativity to them but FINANCIALLY they saved us. A utter fuck up putting his mate Nestor in charge though.

Another buyer would have come forward, the club is simply an investment or vanity project or both for wealthy businessmen. Bilkul didn’t spend money as a charitable donation they will expect at some point a return on the money they have spent. How realistic that is, without spending a lot more money is the question they and fans have to ask themselves. 

We don’t know what has happened, Josh only asked the pertinent question, how do we know it’s not the club that has made a mistake? It’s easier for us as fans to blame the EFL as fans love a conspiracy… but let’s wait and see.
Reply
#50
(04-13-2026, 09:58 AM)wba13 Wrote: Here we go again it’s the clubs fault. The owners saved us when are some fans going to realise this, this has come from nowhere so whoever’s fault it is stop the fucking blame game. No one knows anything yet but of course this is why we sold Tom, Dick and Harry and someone inside the club fucked up.
Our fans are fucking worse the the clowns around us.

Good post. You've succinctly said what any same person would. We have some right clowns in our fan base.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)