Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(04-11-2026, 03:23 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (04-11-2026, 02:22 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (04-11-2026, 11:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Keep:
JG
Imray
Campbell
Styles
Diakite
Price
Molumby
Wallace
Grant
Johnston
Heggebø
For number of reasons. But that essentially gives us a nice core to work with and rebuild the squad around.
I'm not saying anyone is must keep, but you can't expect the club to sell/release every player. Some of the above may be sold!
Trouble is that list excludes two of the players least likely to go anywhere - Nat Phillips and Chris Mepham. Experienced "marquee signings", probably on top wages within the squad, long contracts. Neither has done enough to attract offers unless we drop to League One. Neither has done enough to deserve a place in a promotion challenging Championship side. One or both of these liabilities will be playing most weeks next season, and it's not a prospect to relish.
Remember the "old days"? Talbut and Kaye. Wile and Robertson. McAuley and Olsson. Campbell and New Signing is the partnership I want to see next season. This is why we need a savvy Director of Football to handle transfers. I would be quite happy to get rid of Mepham, Bielek, Bony, Mowat and Molumby who are all contracted for next season. A goof DoF could try and loan them out or part exchange them. Would QPR swap any of those for Sam Field?
Why the fuck would a savvy DoF want Sam Field?
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
The way some fans like to do down our players is shocking. Nobody in their right mind would swap Sam Field as he is now for Molumby.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(04-11-2026, 07:07 PM)Squid Wrote: The way some fans like to do down our players is shocking. Nobody in their right mind would swap Sam Field as he is now for Molumby.
Indeed.
Always love fans way of backtracking too "ALL I ask is 100%" No one gives more than Molumby, yet it's still not enough strangely.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
Molumby is great at kicking opponents, getting the ball off them and then giving it away. Added to that is his discipline
Both teams Sam Field has played for this year are above us in the table.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(04-11-2026, 02:22 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (04-11-2026, 11:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Keep:
JG
Imray
Campbell
Styles
Diakite
Price
Molumby
Wallace
Grant
Johnston
Heggebø
For number of reasons. But that essentially gives us a nice core to work with and rebuild the squad around.
I'm not saying anyone is must keep, but you can't expect the club to sell/release every player. Some of the above may be sold!
Trouble is that list excludes two of the players least likely to go anywhere - Nat Phillips and Chris Mepham. Experienced "marquee signings", probably on top wages within the squad, long contracts. Neither has done enough to attract offers unless we drop to League One. Neither has done enough to deserve a place in a promotion challenging Championship side. One or both of these liabilities will be playing most weeks next season, and it's not a prospect to relish.
Remember the "old days"? Talbut and Kaye. Wile and Robertson. McAuley and Olsson. Campbell and New Signing is the partnership I want to see next season.
Agree about Phillips but I think Mepham would be fairly easy to move on. Experienced international, still in his 20s and played virtually all of his career either in the PL or at the top of the Championship. His move to Albion is simply one of those which just hasn’t worked out. I’m more concerned about us being lumbered with Bielik for the next couple of years. Permacrocked and even when he’s fit he is so slow. I can’t for the life of me think why we thought signing a player deemed surplus to requirements by one of the promoted sides would improve us in any way.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-12-2026, 10:40 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (04-11-2026, 02:22 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (04-11-2026, 11:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Keep:
JG
Imray
Campbell
Styles
Diakite
Price
Molumby
Wallace
Grant
Johnston
Heggebø
For number of reasons. But that essentially gives us a nice core to work with and rebuild the squad around.
I'm not saying anyone is must keep, but you can't expect the club to sell/release every player. Some of the above may be sold!
Trouble is that list excludes two of the players least likely to go anywhere - Nat Phillips and Chris Mepham. Experienced "marquee signings", probably on top wages within the squad, long contracts. Neither has done enough to attract offers unless we drop to League One. Neither has done enough to deserve a place in a promotion challenging Championship side. One or both of these liabilities will be playing most weeks next season, and it's not a prospect to relish.
Remember the "old days"? Talbut and Kaye. Wile and Robertson. McAuley and Olsson. Campbell and New Signing is the partnership I want to see next season.
Agree about Phillips but I think Mepham would be fairly easy to move on. Experienced international, still in his 20s and played virtually all of his career either in the PL or at the top of the Championship. His move to Albion is simply one of those which just hasn’t worked out. I’m more concerned about us being lumbered with Bielik for the next couple of years. Permacrocked and even when he’s fit he is so slow. I can’t for the life of me think why we thought signing a player deemed surplus to requirements by one of the promoted sides would improve us in any way.
You’re forgetting his ability as a cheerleader - very few injured players are capable of telling a few jokes on the bench!
Mepham I think will be fine for us under a competent manager. Next season having GC, Phillips, Gilchrist and Mepham as options is a very good place to be if we survive.
I like Bielik when he’s fit, but agree he was a very silly signing to make. He cost money, has big wages and is someone who struggles to do more than 50-60% of games in season. He was actually one of the very few duds we signed under Nestor (no matter what people say, generally our permanent deals have been very good)
Posts: 3,108
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
04-12-2026, 11:58 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-12-2026, 12:02 PM by Tom Joad 25.)
Purely on Mepham's previous, I think there is most likely a player there that a proper manager might turn into an asset.
Hasty edit(!). I've seen no evidence as yet, but....
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
Fans also, as it ever was, underestimating how difficult it is to replace players with equivalent or better quality ones.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(04-12-2026, 10:40 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (04-11-2026, 02:22 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (04-11-2026, 11:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Keep:
JG
Imray
Campbell
Styles
Diakite
Price
Molumby
Wallace
Grant
Johnston
Heggebø
For number of reasons. But that essentially gives us a nice core to work with and rebuild the squad around.
I'm not saying anyone is must keep, but you can't expect the club to sell/release every player. Some of the above may be sold!
Trouble is that list excludes two of the players least likely to go anywhere - Nat Phillips and Chris Mepham. Experienced "marquee signings", probably on top wages within the squad, long contracts. Neither has done enough to attract offers unless we drop to League One. Neither has done enough to deserve a place in a promotion challenging Championship side. One or both of these liabilities will be playing most weeks next season, and it's not a prospect to relish.
Remember the "old days"? Talbut and Kaye. Wile and Robertson. McAuley and Olsson. Campbell and New Signing is the partnership I want to see next season.
Agree about Phillips but I think Mepham would be fairly easy to move on. Experienced international, still in his 20s and played virtually all of his career either in the PL or at the top of the Championship. His move to Albion is simply one of those which just hasn’t worked out. I’m more concerned about us being lumbered with Bielik for the next couple of years. Permacrocked and even when he’s fit he is so slow. I can’t for the life of me think why we thought signing a player deemed surplus to requirements by one of the promoted sides would improve us in any way.
Why would we necessarily want to move on Phillips?
Not sure he's a problem.
Mepham would be more difficult. Think he would be on higher wages, whilst his championship record is decent, he does seem to be either injury prone or left out of sides, as there are very few seasons where he has played over 40 games in a season. In short anyone who could afford him probably wouldn't want him and those who would want him, probably couldn't afford him.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(04-12-2026, 12:05 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-12-2026, 10:40 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (04-11-2026, 02:22 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (04-11-2026, 11:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Keep:
JG
Imray
Campbell
Styles
Diakite
Price
Molumby
Wallace
Grant
Johnston
Heggebø
For number of reasons. But that essentially gives us a nice core to work with and rebuild the squad around.
I'm not saying anyone is must keep, but you can't expect the club to sell/release every player. Some of the above may be sold!
Trouble is that list excludes two of the players least likely to go anywhere - Nat Phillips and Chris Mepham. Experienced "marquee signings", probably on top wages within the squad, long contracts. Neither has done enough to attract offers unless we drop to League One. Neither has done enough to deserve a place in a promotion challenging Championship side. One or both of these liabilities will be playing most weeks next season, and it's not a prospect to relish.
Remember the "old days"? Talbut and Kaye. Wile and Robertson. McAuley and Olsson. Campbell and New Signing is the partnership I want to see next season.
Agree about Phillips but I think Mepham would be fairly easy to move on. Experienced international, still in his 20s and played virtually all of his career either in the PL or at the top of the Championship. His move to Albion is simply one of those which just hasn’t worked out. I’m more concerned about us being lumbered with Bielik for the next couple of years. Permacrocked and even when he’s fit he is so slow. I can’t for the life of me think why we thought signing a player deemed surplus to requirements by one of the promoted sides would improve us in any way.
Why would we necessarily want to move on Phillips?
Not sure he's a problem.
Mepham would be more difficult. Think he would be on higher wages, whilst his championship record is decent, he does seem to be either injury prone or left out of sides, as there are very few seasons where he has played over 40 games in a season. In short anyone who could afford him probably wouldn't want him and those who would want him, probably couldn't afford him.
Phillips has been better under Mozza but given that he's reportedly the highest earner at the club I don't think he's done anything for us to establish such a senior position at the club. We'll still have PSR issues this summer no matter what division we're in so any chance to trim the wage bill by losing players who haven't been value for money should be taken.
|