Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
03-17-2026, 12:57 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-17-2026, 12:59 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(03-17-2026, 10:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Really? you are in complete denial that stripping away the infrastructure and putting contracts, PPP and other sticking plasters in place whilst dishing out dividends to shareholders of that former infrastructure instead of spending on that infrastructure has benefitted anybody. Or stripping out our Police Force and then complaining that organised crime has increased has benefitted anybody. Or adding red tape and costs to anybody that trades with our neighbours has benefitted anybody.
The worse thing about all of this is you have been on the bus cheering at all of these choices and seem confused that the actual drivers have struggled to implement the right type of your choices. So yes, blame the reforms not implemented because that is simple when you have no funds left, or blame the public sector workers, or even blame the immigrants, but don't under any circumstances blame the tax avoiders or the Brexiteers or the austerity campaigners.
And then don't blame the nut in the White House who is the ultimate fantasy of the Brexiteers and Austerity mob. Just blame someone else - whatever you do, don't take any responsibility.
Best post you’ve written in a long time B1.
Proth wanted (I imagine still does) to strip public sector finances to the bone, but isn’t prepared to accept that this has consequences. He wanted more austerity in fact he didn’t even think it really was austerity.,
That means he wanted less Police
Less Doctors and Nurses
Less Armed Forces
Less libraries
Less help for young families
Less help for children and adult hospices
Less money for education
Less help for the disabled
The list goes on…
He then went on to compound this folly with wanting Brexit, which every credible economic expert said would make the country poorer and less relevant on the world stage.
Every big decision Proth has advocated for would make millions of working and middle class families poorer, made the country more dangerous, less healthy, more antisocial, less influential whilst protecting the richest at the expense of everyone else.
Something, something red tape, failure of statecraft, people aren’t really disabled, the wealth creators need protecting etc etc.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(03-17-2026, 10:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Really? you are in complete denial that stripping away the infrastructure and putting contracts, PPP and other sticking plasters in place whilst dishing out dividends to shareholders of that former infrastructure instead of spending on that infrastructure has benefitted anybody. Or stripping out our Police Force and then complaining that organised crime has increased has benefitted anybody. Or adding red tape and costs to anybody that trades with our neighbours has benefitted anybody.
The worse thing about all of this is you have been on the bus cheering at all of these choices and seem confused that the actual drivers have struggled to implement the right type of your choices. So yes, blame the reforms not implemented because that is simple when you have no funds left, or blame the public sector workers, or even blame the immigrants, but don't under any circumstances blame the tax avoiders or the Brexiteers or the austerity campaigners.
And then don't blame the nut in the White House who is the ultimate fantasy of the Brexiteers and Austerity mob. Just blame someone else - whatever you do, don't take any responsibility.
Taking the baseless polemic out of it, I wonder how on Earth you hoped the 2010s would be any different after the manner in which the UK nationalised private debt and then suppressed interest rates and wages for a decade and more?
Labour certainly didn't envisage doing anything different at all from the Tories in 2010, and given their ineptitude on everything from pre-announcing the sale of of our gold reserves, the GFC, persistently calling for longer and deeper lockdowns and current anti-growth fuckwits it would be very brave to suggest that we'd be in a better position today. Hence #LeastWorst
And I've never "blamed immigrants" for anything you cheeky fucker. And you must have missed my post on Tice & the Labour Propco tax affairs yesterday.
And to suggest that Trump is somehow the ultimate fantasy for any thinking person is just cheap and lazy. You're on the Dekka scale of misrepresentation there - no wonder he's clapping like a seal.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-17-2026, 01:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (03-17-2026, 10:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Really? you are in complete denial that stripping away the infrastructure and putting contracts, PPP and other sticking plasters in place whilst dishing out dividends to shareholders of that former infrastructure instead of spending on that infrastructure has benefitted anybody. Or stripping out our Police Force and then complaining that organised crime has increased has benefitted anybody. Or adding red tape and costs to anybody that trades with our neighbours has benefitted anybody.
The worse thing about all of this is you have been on the bus cheering at all of these choices and seem confused that the actual drivers have struggled to implement the right type of your choices. So yes, blame the reforms not implemented because that is simple when you have no funds left, or blame the public sector workers, or even blame the immigrants, but don't under any circumstances blame the tax avoiders or the Brexiteers or the austerity campaigners.
And then don't blame the nut in the White House who is the ultimate fantasy of the Brexiteers and Austerity mob. Just blame someone else - whatever you do, don't take any responsibility.
Taking the baseless polemic out of it, I wonder how on Earth you hoped the 2010s would be any different after the manner in which the UK nationalised private debt and then suppressed interest rates and wages for a decade and more?
Labour certainly didn't envisage doing anything different at all from the Tories in 2010, and given their ineptitude on everything from pre-announcing the sale of of our gold reserves, the GFC, persistently calling for longer and deeper lockdowns and current anti-growth fuckwits it would be very brave to suggest that we'd be in a better position today. Hence #LeastWorst
And I've never "blamed immigrants" for anything you cheeky fucker. And you must have missed my post on Tice & the Labour Propco tax affairs yesterday.
And to suggest that Trump is somehow the ultimate fantasy for any thinking person is just cheap and lazy. You're on the Dekka scale of misrepresentation there - no wonder he's clapping like a seal.
What in my post misrepresents your position over the last couple of decades?
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(03-17-2026, 01:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (03-17-2026, 10:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Really? you are in complete denial that stripping away the infrastructure and putting contracts, PPP and other sticking plasters in place whilst dishing out dividends to shareholders of that former infrastructure instead of spending on that infrastructure has benefitted anybody. Or stripping out our Police Force and then complaining that organised crime has increased has benefitted anybody. Or adding red tape and costs to anybody that trades with our neighbours has benefitted anybody.
The worse thing about all of this is you have been on the bus cheering at all of these choices and seem confused that the actual drivers have struggled to implement the right type of your choices. So yes, blame the reforms not implemented because that is simple when you have no funds left, or blame the public sector workers, or even blame the immigrants, but don't under any circumstances blame the tax avoiders or the Brexiteers or the austerity campaigners.
And then don't blame the nut in the White House who is the ultimate fantasy of the Brexiteers and Austerity mob. Just blame someone else - whatever you do, don't take any responsibility.
Taking the baseless polemic out of it, I wonder how on Earth you hoped the 2010s would be any different after the manner in which the UK nationalised private debt and then suppressed interest rates and wages for a decade and more?
Labour certainly didn't envisage doing anything different at all from the Tories in 2010, and given their ineptitude on everything from pre-announcing the sale of of our gold reserves, the GFC, persistently calling for longer and deeper lockdowns and current anti-growth fuckwits it would be very brave to suggest that we'd be in a better position today. Hence #LeastWorst
And I've never "blamed immigrants" for anything you cheeky fucker. And you must have missed my post on Tice & the Labour Propco tax affairs yesterday.
And to suggest that Trump is somehow the ultimate fantasy for any thinking person is just cheap and lazy. You're on the Dekka scale of misrepresentation there - no wonder he's clapping like a seal.
Arf, the 'cheeky fucker' bit does mek me off. I'm not suggesting you blamed immigrants (although I do recall a conversation about driver wages not being suppressed any more after leaving the EU and it's a price worth paying' conversation), it's a general commentary on the whole picture. You can't expect to use the nationalist card thrown by Farage because it served your purpose without letting the genie out of the bottle.
You view the 2010s as a whole when in fact it was clear by the mid decade point that austerity was failing, hence the rise of Corbyn and Brexit as the ultimate protest vote. But you demanded more cuts to the NHS and public services and wanted less services to enable less taxation. If you want a get out of jail free card for the 1st half of the decade then take it, but 2015 onwards were the shitshow that has reduced the face and culture of Britain to an angry hateful mob culture played out on social media.
And once again, lots of noise but not one little bit of contrition. Someone else's fault.
Posts: 8,125
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
03-17-2026, 04:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-17-2026, 04:58 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Going back to the conflict, fair play to the US’s own Joe Kent:
The director of the US's National Counterterrorism Center has announced his resignation on social media - saying he "cannot in good conscience support the ongoing war in Iran".
The Senate confirmed Joe Kent as Trump's pick for the role last July.
Addressing Trump in his resignation letter, Kent says: "Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby.
"I support the values and the foreign policies that you campaigned on in 2016, 2020, 2024, which you enacted in your first term.
"Until June of 2025, you understood that the wars in the Middle East were a trap that robbed America of the precious lives of our patriots and depleted the wealth and prosperity of our nation.
"As a veteran who deployed to combat 11 times and as a Gold Star husband who lost my beloved wife Shannon in a war manufactured by Israel, I cannot support sending the next generation off to fight and die in a war that serves no benefit to the American people nor justifies the cost of American lives."
I know it’s obviously personal to him for his reasons cited, but it nonetheless reinforces the UK position on this.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
03-17-2026, 05:00 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-17-2026, 05:20 PM by Protheroe.)
(03-17-2026, 04:54 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Going back to the conflict, fair play to the US’s own Joe Kent:
The director of the US's National Counterterrorism Center has announced his resignation on social media - saying he "cannot in good conscience support the ongoing war in Iran".
The Senate confirmed Joe Kent as Trump's pick for the role last July.
Addressing Trump in his resignation letter, Kent says: "Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby.
"I support the values and the foreign policies that you campaigned on in 2016, 2020, 2024, which you enacted in your first term.
"Until June of 2025, you understood that the wars in the Middle East were a trap that robbed America of the precious lives of our patriots and depleted the wealth and prosperity of our nation.
"As a veteran who deployed to combat 11 times and as a Gold Star husband who lost my beloved wife Shannon in a war manufactured by Israel, I cannot support sending the next generation off to fight and die in a war that serves no benefit to the American people nor justifies the cost of American lives."
I know it’s obviously personal to him for his reasons cited, but it nonetheless reinforces the UK position on this.
That's very powerful. I also wonder what the wider armed forces in the States think of this (and other) ongoing adventures. Given how useless the Democrats will be until at least the Mid Terms, maybe the world's best hope is the US Military keeping Trump in check.
(03-17-2026, 01:56 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What in my post misrepresents your position over the last couple of decades?
All of it. You can't have anything you want without growth and risk taking. The state can help create the conditions for growth, that is all.
Governments of all hues have suppressed company failure and risk taking by keeping interest rates artificially low leading to all sorts of bad outcomes. Why bother to invest in productivity when you can buy income producing real estate at negative real interest rates? Or pay people poverty wages because it's still cheaper than buying tech or machinery?
Without innovation and growth above recent trends we will never have enough for what you want Dekka. All that will happen is people like you will be taxed even more and receive even less. Have you not worked that out yet?
(03-17-2026, 02:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Arf, the 'cheeky fucker' bit does mek me off. I'm not suggesting you blamed immigrants (although I do recall a conversation about driver wages not being suppressed any more after leaving the EU and it's a price worth paying' conversation), it's a general commentary on the whole picture. You can't expect to use the nationalist card thrown by Farage because it served your purpose without letting the genie out of the bottle.
You view the 2010s as a whole when in fact it was clear by the mid decade point that austerity was failing, hence the rise of Corbyn and Brexit as the ultimate protest vote. But you demanded more cuts to the NHS and public services and wanted less services to enable less taxation. If you want a get out of jail free card for the 1st half of the decade then take it, but 2015 onwards were the shitshow that has reduced the face and culture of Britain to an angry hateful mob culture played out on social media.
And once again, lots of noise but not one little bit of contrition. Someone else's fault.
I refer you to the answer to Dekka above. You can't have real terms increases in public spending without growth. You cannot have growth when the state strangles investment and innovation through fiscal policy, over regulation and the misallocation of resources - you only have to look at the housing market to see that.
I don't recall having called for NHS cuts, though I'm fine with those who can afford it getting tax relief to opt out of the state system so there's more to go round for those who really need it.
What do you want from me? It wasn't me who resigned after the Brexit Vote. It wasn't me who spent 4 years avoiding a decision on Brexit. It wasn't me that sowed the seeds for a debt explosion, underemployment and ensuing mental health epidemic during Covid. It wasn't me that spaffed thousands of pounds to millions who didn't need energy price support. It certainly wasn't me that voted for the growth extinguishing Budgets of the last two years, or the ridiculous increase in the Minimum Wage.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Someone else's fault and it's like you'e answered another question. I talk of selling off the infrastructure and cutting spend directly leading to the problems we have and you talk of growth and wrong type of Brexit. It's about time you faced the reality of a fact that Brexit was never going to work and only won because of racism rearing it's ugly head to get it over the line. You were comfortable for that to happen to get what you wanted, that doesn't mean that you are racist btw, just that on this occasion you turned a blind eye because it suited your needs ultimately.
Brexit has failed and was always going to fail. The only way we can get to the growth you talk of by rejoining the EU. Let's start by accepting that shall we?
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-17-2026, 05:32 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Someone else's fault and it's like you'e answered another question. I talk of selling off the infrastructure and cutting spend directly leading to the problems we have and you talk of growth and wrong type of Brexit. It's about time you faced the reality of a fact that Brexit was never going to work and only won because of racism rearing it's ugly head to get it over the line. You were comfortable for that to happen to get what you wanted, that doesn't mean that you are racist btw, just that on this occasion you turned a blind eye because it suited your needs ultimately.
Brexit has failed and was always going to fail. The only way we can get to the growth you talk of by rejoining the EU. Let's start by accepting that shall we?
It’s never going to happen… it’ll just be the same ‘failure of statecraft’ bollocks
Posts: 6,722
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(03-17-2026, 02:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-17-2026, 01:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (03-17-2026, 10:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Really? you are in complete denial that stripping away the infrastructure and putting contracts, PPP and other sticking plasters in place whilst dishing out dividends to shareholders of that former infrastructure instead of spending on that infrastructure has benefitted anybody. Or stripping out our Police Force and then complaining that organised crime has increased has benefitted anybody. Or adding red tape and costs to anybody that trades with our neighbours has benefitted anybody.
The worse thing about all of this is you have been on the bus cheering at all of these choices and seem confused that the actual drivers have struggled to implement the right type of your choices. So yes, blame the reforms not implemented because that is simple when you have no funds left, or blame the public sector workers, or even blame the immigrants, but don't under any circumstances blame the tax avoiders or the Brexiteers or the austerity campaigners.
And then don't blame the nut in the White House who is the ultimate fantasy of the Brexiteers and Austerity mob. Just blame someone else - whatever you do, don't take any responsibility.
Taking the baseless polemic out of it, I wonder how on Earth you hoped the 2010s would be any different after the manner in which the UK nationalised private debt and then suppressed interest rates and wages for a decade and more?
Labour certainly didn't envisage doing anything different at all from the Tories in 2010, and given their ineptitude on everything from pre-announcing the sale of of our gold reserves, the GFC, persistently calling for longer and deeper lockdowns and current anti-growth fuckwits it would be very brave to suggest that we'd be in a better position today. Hence #LeastWorst
And I've never "blamed immigrants" for anything you cheeky fucker. And you must have missed my post on Tice & the Labour Propco tax affairs yesterday.
And to suggest that Trump is somehow the ultimate fantasy for any thinking person is just cheap and lazy. You're on the Dekka scale of misrepresentation there - no wonder he's clapping like a seal.
Arf, the 'cheeky fucker' bit does mek me off. I'm not suggesting you blamed immigrants (although I do recall a conversation about driver wages not being suppressed any more after leaving the EU and it's a price worth paying' conversation), it's a general commentary on the whole picture. You can't expect to use the nationalist card thrown by Farage because it served your purpose without letting the genie out of the bottle.
You view the 2010s as a whole when in fact it was clear by the mid decade point that austerity was failing, hence the rise of Corbyn and Brexit as the ultimate protest vote. But you demanded more cuts to the NHS and public services and wanted less services to enable less taxation. If you want a get out of jail free card for the 1st half of the decade then take it, but 2015 onwards were the shitshow that has reduced the face and culture of Britain to an angry hateful mob culture played out on social media.
And once again, lots of noise but not one little bit of contrition. Someone else's fault.
Proth never admits that he is wrong about anything.
A very juvenile characteristic.
He just says that he has changed his mind.
Posts: 7,472
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
“You can't expect to use the nationalist card thrown by Farage because it served your purpose without letting the genie out of the bottle”
Absolute nail on the head. Well put.
Proths the fella who stands baiting a riot then moans about the mess it’s caused in the morning.
Raw Sausage
|