Yes Mr Ayotallah, they're pissed off at the central bank and not you
(03-09-2026, 12:22 PM)Protheroe Wrote: This is why I love this place. No one has chosen to take issue with any aspect of that article at all. Merely to deride the writer and the publication. Bravo to you all.

So, I'll ask again. Specifically, what do you disagree with?

And Squid. Your misrepresentations are legendary. My view is absolutely clear - political Islam should have no place in this country, as it's wholly incompatible with liberal democracy. That's it, in a nutshell. It's not racist. It's a statement of fact. And you either want to live in a liberal democracy or you don't.

The whole article is based on a belief that creeping sharia is happening and that block voting is only bad if muslims do it. it's ok if Protestants or Catholics or Jews do it but not muslims. It's also ok if white nationalists do it apparently. People vote for who they believe will benefit themselves or their community most - why is it only being called out now because Muslims are doing it.

It is also stating as a fact that Iran were about to break the threshold for having a nuclear weapon and they would use it because they are the bad guys, and those of us that already have them, many multiple times of what Iran would have, are the good guys and won't use them. And that we were just allowing them to develop them because they are fibbing about it is justification for the big orange blob to fib on the reasons for war.
Reply
What do you mean by political islam?

Obviously a question to proth.

Just read the article, it's a bit all over the place and it appears the author is too timid to say what he actually wants to say and shies away from any firm conclusions and proposals.

And i don't understand what he is saying in relation to the UK muslim population, block voting is bad, but the vast majority of muslims are not islamists. Well if that is the case what does it matter how muslims vote if you take the view that the vast majority of muslims are not 'evil islamists'.

Here's a question for you Proth. Do you think muslims in the UK should have the right to vote in elections. If the answer is yes, what is all this nonsense discourse about. If no, and there are many more that hold that opinion, our problems in the UK are a damned sight bigger than worrying about how muslims vote.
Reply
Proth, do you support the war?
Reply
(03-08-2026, 08:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-08-2026, 05:17 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Israel and Iran have fuck all to do with us

That's simply not true though. There's a great piece by Matthew Syed in the ST today, have a read and tell me what you disagree with.

Thanks to someone else permitting access to it above (I’m fucked if I’m going to spend good money subscribing to one of two - once respected, now effective redtop - broadsheet rags, the other of which now shamelessly so), like others I don’t really know he’s trying (but failing) to say; nor what this has to do with the topic in question. Yes, international politics is all interlinked - it kinda has to be by nature - but it seems you’ve cherry-picked an article to support your argument that the current conflict concerns us beyond our regional interests. It fails to convince me that this war does concern us ideologically. In fact, to me it just reads as paranoia-inducing drivel, broadly translated into traditional western authority = good, creeping sharia (a complete bullshit phrase in real terms, beyond sectors/industries I’ve certainly little to do with anyway) = bad, and - as someone else has said above - seems to be attempting to say something without actually saying it. And if we’re digressing into the territory of talking about voter influencing, why are we supposed to play ‘follow my leader’ with a country whose president accused voting over there of practise that made Cambridge Analytica look like humble doorstepping? 

In fact, the only part of this article I actually agreed with was the (token) middle bit counter argument stating: (if) you are against murderous dictators, why are you cosying up to Putin in naked pursuit of raw materials from Ukraine?

So your article has done precisely zero to persuade me that - besides a (long and detailed) argument I have made above about us being chronically underprepared for the overspill - this conflict (which is essentially down to an existential one between (US-backed) Israel and Iran) has ANYTHING to do with us beyond protecting our own. In fact, it thereby constitutes little more than a shoddy attempt to pull the debate into another direction. And quite why, from where I sit at least, also little more than cheap, right-wing click bait; designed to get its loyal readership worried about something else instead. But hey - we all clicked. Objective achieved.
Reply
To be fair I think you've all hit the nail on the head for me. He's writing about people just like you. I would never have believed the behaviour I saw at the 2024 count in Birmingham if I hadn't witnessed it with my own eyes. The 2029 election will be abject filth in certain parts of the country (and I don't just mean the Muslim bloc vote). For me the most prescient line is:

"If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant… then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." Just as the Leftists who helped the Ayatollah to power in the first place were.

I'm at my limit with a number of sectional / political interests right now. How about you?
Reply
(03-09-2026, 03:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: To be fair I think you've all hit the nail on the head for me. He's writing about people just like you. I would never have believed the behaviour I saw at the 2024 count in Birmingham if I hadn't witnessed it with my own eyes. The 2029 election will be abject filth in certain parts of the country (and I don't just mean the Muslim bloc vote). For me the most prescient line is:

"If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant… then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." Just as the Leftists who helped the Ayatollah to power in the first place were.

I'm at my limit with a number of sectional / political interests right now. How about you?

‘Leftists’? That rabbit hole just keeps getting deeper Proth. For the third time of asking, are you in favour of this war?
Reply
New Ayatollah named. I give him a week.
Reply
(03-09-2026, 11:20 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-09-2026, 11:16 AM)Squid Wrote: It is atrocious writing. The Sunday Times is a serious newspaper and the level of argumentation in this article is sub-GCSE.


It was always the weaker of the two but the credibility and quality of the Sunday Times and it's daily counterpart is down the toilet under their current editors on top of the erosion of the independence from their owner, hence why I've cancelled my subscription. Both are red tops in compact clothing this days.

I agree BB

If you think  the Times is bad, try the Telegraph. Written by IMBERSEALS for IMBERSEALS.

I never thought that in my lifetime it would say thank heavens for the FT

(03-09-2026, 03:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: To be fair I think you've all hit the nail on the head for me. He's writing about people just like you. I would never have believed the behaviour I saw at the 2024 count in Birmingham if I hadn't witnessed it with my own eyes. The 2029 election will be abject filth in certain parts of the country (and I don't just mean the Muslim bloc vote). For me the most prescient line is:

"If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant… then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." Just as the Leftists who helped the Ayatollah to power in the first place were.

I'm at my limit with a number of sectional / political interests right now. How about you?

There is known tolerance and unknown tolerance. And there us known intolerance and unknown intolerance.
This is before we get to the unknown unknowns of intolerance and unknown knowns of intolerance.
Not forgetting the unknown knowns of tolerance and the unknown unknowns of tolerance.

What is a known known for me, as ever, is Proth's Islamophobia.
Reply
(03-09-2026, 03:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: To be fair I think you've all hit the nail on the head for me. He's writing about people just like you. I would never have believed the behaviour I saw at the 2024 count in Birmingham if I hadn't witnessed it with my own eyes. The 2029 election will be abject filth in certain parts of the country (and I don't just mean the Muslim bloc vote). For me the most prescient line is:

"If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant… then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." Just as the Leftists who helped the Ayatollah to power in the first place were.

I'm at my limit with a number of sectional / political interests right now. How about you?

Possibly one of the worst responses that you have ever put out there Proth.

"People just like you" as if we are blind to intolerances from certain sections of society, and even ignorant of events around the actions of groups in recent elections. However, the action required is to deal with those issues and manage the minority that are carrying them out. And for the record, the actions of a number of Muslim activists in Birmingham and the North West over the past few years is equally abhorrent as some of the reform activists at events and elections around the country. The arrogance that only you can see these things is quite insightful.

I'm not certain why you consider that we extend unlimited tolerance to those that are intolerant when we have had arrests and charges for those that show this in recent times, or don't they count because they were overseen by that leftist Starmer.

No-one on here agrees, as far as I'm aware, with Iran's approach to global politics and their undermining of the middle east order, but bombing the shit out of them with no plan is not the right approach, and I'm glad we have a PM in place at this moment in time that is calm enough to step back from the charge.

(03-09-2026, 03:53 PM)Jacko Wrote: New Ayatollah named. I give him a week.

Arf, I did think that - "right who wants this gig?, you'll be the supreme leader, not just any leader, the supreme one", 
"Are there any downsides, risks etc?",
"No, you'll be protected by God, your Dad was just unlucky"
Reply
(03-09-2026, 04:06 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(03-09-2026, 03:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: To be fair I think you've all hit the nail on the head for me. He's writing about people just like you. I would never have believed the behaviour I saw at the 2024 count in Birmingham if I hadn't witnessed it with my own eyes. The 2029 election will be abject filth in certain parts of the country (and I don't just mean the Muslim bloc vote). For me the most prescient line is:

"If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant… then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." Just as the Leftists who helped the Ayatollah to power in the first place were.

I'm at my limit with a number of sectional / political interests right now. How about you?

Possibly one of the worst responses that you have ever put out there Proth.

"People just like you" as if we are blind to intolerances from certain sections of society, and even ignorant of events around the actions of groups in recent elections. However, the action required is to deal with those issues and manage the minority that are carrying them out. And for the record, the actions of a number of Muslim activists in Birmingham and the North West over the past few years is equally abhorrent as some of the reform activists at events and elections around the country. The arrogance that only you can see these things is quite insightful.

I'm not certain why you consider that we extend unlimited tolerance to those that are intolerant when we have had arrests and charges for those that show this in recent times, or don't they count because they were overseen by that leftist Starmer.

No-one on here agrees, as far as I'm aware, with Iran's approach to global politics and their undermining of the middle east order, but bombing the shit out of them with no plan is not the right approach, and I'm glad we have a PM in place at this moment in time that is calm enough to step back from the charge.

(03-09-2026, 03:53 PM)Jacko Wrote: New Ayatollah named. I give him a week.

Arf, I did think that - "right who wants this gig?, you'll be the supreme leader, not just any leader, the supreme one", 
"Are there any downsides, risks etc?",
"No, you'll be protected by God, your Dad was just unlucky"

Thanks, baggy1, for replying for me - saves me the hassle of doing it. Meanwhile, also for pointing out referring to “people like me” is an automatic assumption that I’m also finger-eared when it comes to internal issues that may or may not exist domestically. Again, thanks for pointing out to Proth that that’s not the case. 

But once again, this thread, topic and indeed conflict is not about that. And to repeat, a shoddy article and a generalisation based upon my appraisal of it doesn’t sway me any more than it does the (thankfully) cross-party agreement that we need to defend our interests during this conflict and nothing more. 

If it makes people feel better to label those of us in favour of that approach as ignorant to other issues, in favour of other agendas they have, then I think it’s time I exited the debate. Because it is growing increasingly incongruent and agenda-driven.

I have made clear what I think we should have done better and what our limits need to be regarding the ongoing war. There is little more for me to add there, anyway. But if certain religious, factions, lineages are voting en masse one way or another due subversive reasoning then this wouldn’t be the first time nor the last, and again as far as I’m aware not what we’re discussing here.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: