Posts: 8,120
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
03-08-2026, 10:37 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-08-2026, 10:39 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Despite my (many other) ailments sustained playing football, popping my shoulder out the first time was bloody painful. Fair fucks to him for getting up and playing on if so, because it bloody hurts like hell. I played on, and even played later that day, but could barely change gear on the way home with that arm it was so painful. I had to rest it for 2-4 weeks before I was really fit to play again. It’s popped out intermittently a few times since and despite being no less painful it does heal a bit quicker. Wish I’d had the fucker pinned really, but that was the decision of the NHS at the time, and not mine.
Anyway, the problem never really went away until I started doing calisthenics (planks, weight bearing exercise, that kind of thing), and since then it’s been little problem.
So with Bielik, it all depends upon whether or not that is what he did, and how recurrent an issue it’s been for him over his career if so. He looked to be holding his collar bone as much as his shoulder at one point, so who knows, but in spite of his brave decision to play on yesterday I wouldn’t be surprised to see him rested on Wednesday. No matter how many times you pop your shoulder, it always takes a few days (ideally weeks, the luxury of which we don’t have) to settle down fully.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Several footballers have had surgery to fix the "quick release" shoulder problem. Wasn't lAVVro amongst them?
Anyways, interesting that the 22 year old Gilchrist has been so comprehensively written off by some of the experts on here. I'm remembering the 29 year old Bartley having some proper nightmares for us, but now we'd probably be pleased to see the 34 year old Barts hobbling out on his one good leg.
What I'm saying is that it takes longer than 30 seconds to assess a player. Players improve, especially young players. Gilchrist's errors haven't been any worse than the howlers committed by Phillips and Mepham this season, and Alfie has the excuse of being young, with a lot to learn. I've no idea how or if he will fit into our plans (short or long term) but I can't get on board with the knee-jerk "Carp, get rid!!" sentiment.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
I don't think there has been a kneejerk reaction to Gilchrist's capabilities after a brief assessment. Quite the opposite, the more he's played for us the worse he has looked. For any errors other defenders have made this season, Gilchrist looks truly out of his depth which was reflected in his performance and early hooking against Coventry.
Fair point that young players improve. But some players also peak very early before being on a downward trajectory through the leagues. Gilchrist clearly has or had something to make the first team at Chelsea. He played a good amount of games at Sheff United last season before, as I've read anyway, losing his place halfway through the season. I don't think anyone can argue that he's struggled badly in a lot of his appearances though so far for us and it's understandable why Mason used him so sparingly.
I do worry that we've brought in a player who is very much in the category of 'excellent young prospect but never went any further'. I hope not. I don't think anyone wants anything other than players to succeed at the club. But he certianly doesn't look a viable option at present particularly playing in a struggling team where every game is vital now.
Posts: 7,869
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
I fully expect us to sell him and for him to become world class immediately.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 8,120
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
03-08-2026, 02:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-08-2026, 02:04 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(03-08-2026, 12:10 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I fully expect us to sell him and for him to become world class immediately.
It’s inevitable. And, of course - every time he does really well for anyone else in future - someone on here won’t be able to resist posting about it (in a slightly bitter and condescending way). I mean it’s not like these players are paid to do their job here and here only or anything, nor be expected to do well there, opposed to being confined to the non-league dustbin; but it really is an irresistible urge for many.
Posts: 1,274
Threads: 45
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
2
(03-08-2026, 02:03 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (03-08-2026, 12:10 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I fully expect us to sell him and for him to become world class immediately.
It’s inevitable. And, of course - every time he does really well for anyone else in future - someone on here won’t be able to resist posting about it (in a slightly bitter and condescending way). I mean it’s not like these players are paid to do their job here and here only or anything, nor be expected to do well there, opposed to being confined to the non-league dustbin; but it really is an irresistible urge for many.
I call it the curse of Marcus Rosenberg. Scored goals his whole career and was a classy little player with a good work ethic. Joined us from Werder Bremen with a 1 in 3 goal record and despite good movement and work rate failed to score a single goal for us. We sold him to Malmö where he promptly carried on scoring and had a 1 in 2 goal ratio for them!
Some players, for whatever reason, just don't seem to fit. FWIW my best mate is a Chelsea season ticket holder said we'd got a really good player in Gilchrist. Said his best position was playing right CH in a back 3.
There is no denying he has looked properly shit all season and seemingly getting worse!
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(03-08-2026, 02:15 PM)Peachofacross Wrote: (03-08-2026, 02:03 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (03-08-2026, 12:10 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I fully expect us to sell him and for him to become world class immediately.
It’s inevitable. And, of course - every time he does really well for anyone else in future - someone on here won’t be able to resist posting about it (in a slightly bitter and condescending way). I mean it’s not like these players are paid to do their job here and here only or anything, nor be expected to do well there, opposed to being confined to the non-league dustbin; but it really is an irresistible urge for many.
I call it the curse of Marcus Rosenberg. Scored goals his whole career and was a classy little player with a good work ethic. Joined us from Werder Bremen with a 1 in 3 goal record and despite good movement and work rate failed to score a single goal for us. We sold him to Malmö where he promptly carried on scoring and had a 1 in 2 goal ratio for them!
Some players, for whatever reason, just don't seem to fit. FWIW my best mate is a Chelsea season ticket holder said we'd got a really good player in Gilchrist. Said his best position was playing right CH in a back 3.
There is no denying he has looked properly shit all season and seemingly getting worse!
In fairness, Rosenberg would have scored for us had we not been able to get Lukaku on loan… he came to add competition to Odemwingie and Long, but obviously when Lukaku became an option we’d have been stupid not to loan him.
Wish he’d banged that one in during the 5-5 game!
Posts: 8,120
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
03-08-2026, 03:06 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-08-2026, 03:07 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Also in fairness, we have had some players (Wood, Dawson for example) who just had better competition in the squad at the time. Then there have been many we signed because they were decent, but just not what we needed at the time.
But then there are the Saidos and Zahores of this world, so it does balance out. But as frustrating as it is to see ex-Albion players succeed elsewhere, I don’t quite get the fascination with it. It’s been and gone.
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(03-08-2026, 10:37 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Despite my (many other) ailments sustained playing football, popping my shoulder out the first time was bloody painful. Fair fucks to him for getting up and playing on if so, because it bloody hurts like hell. I played on, and even played later that day, but could barely change gear on the way home with that arm it was so painful. I had to rest it for 2-4 weeks before I was really fit to play again. It’s popped out intermittently a few times since and despite being no less painful it does heal a bit quicker. Wish I’d had the fucker pinned really, but that was the decision of the NHS at the time, and not mine.
Anyway, the problem never really went away until I started doing calisthenics (planks, weight bearing exercise, that kind of thing), and since then it’s been little problem.
So with Bielik, it all depends upon whether or not that is what he did, and how recurrent an issue it’s been for him over his career if so. He looked to be holding his collar bone as much as his shoulder at one point, so who knows, but in spite of his brave decision to play on yesterday I wouldn’t be surprised to see him rested on Wednesday. No matter how many times you pop your shoulder, it always takes a few days (ideally weeks, the luxury of which we don’t have) to settle down fully.
I got kicked fuggin hard in the funny bone once. Childbirth, I'd imagine, has nothing on that.
|