Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(03-05-2026, 03:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-05-2026, 02:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote: My principal reason for voting to Leave was far more mundane; the EU was not what we were sold when we entered the EEC. The clue is in the names.
Above anything else I'm a democrat, and the prospect of our nation "pooling sovereignty" on an ever increasing basis is not something I was ever comfortable with. If nothing else, Brexit has exposed how unfit our political class is to govern - when they have no one else to blame.
This is exactly what I'm on about, it's a sentiment rooted in a global outlook from 250 years ago where Britain was insulated from economic demands by its economic size and weight. It's completely ignorant of the modern global economic structures, the EU came into existence because of the need for further economic integration in Europe much as other economic blocs have emerged, it's exactly why the woman in your profile picture was foundational in the deeper integration of the EEC and kick-started the transition to the EU via the creation of the single market. Our sovereignty is preserved by pooling it as otherwise it's eroded by being a thrawn to hostile economies bigger than ours and operating counter to liberal values, as seen by the biggest champions of Brexit suddenly wanting us to be dictated by Trump's US.
We've pooled our sovereignty to establish NATO, should we leave that now?
The way I've read this you actually prove Proth's point more than your own.
I was always in favour of a customs union and freedom of movement. However, when it comes to the big stuff, outside of trade, the EU is always found wringing its hands and dithering because of having to get 20 odd states to decide on which way to turn and, in many cases, they all have say "go" otherwise the train doesn't leave the station, usually because Orban or someone else hasn't bought a ticket. And during that time billions are pissed away on a lot of needless bureaucracy.
Trump comes out with a load of shit on a daily basis but occasionally, very, very occasionally he gets one right and that one is that the rest of NATO and, in fact, the EU, has not pulled its weight defensively since its inception. So regardless of where the UK sits, inside or out, the one accord, when it comes down to it, is the one with the US, whether we like it or not.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(03-05-2026, 03:59 PM)Fido Wrote: (03-05-2026, 03:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-05-2026, 02:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote: My principal reason for voting to Leave was far more mundane; the EU was not what we were sold when we entered the EEC. The clue is in the names.
Above anything else I'm a democrat, and the prospect of our nation "pooling sovereignty" on an ever increasing basis is not something I was ever comfortable with. If nothing else, Brexit has exposed how unfit our political class is to govern - when they have no one else to blame.
This is exactly what I'm on about, it's a sentiment rooted in a global outlook from 250 years ago where Britain was insulated from economic demands by its economic size and weight. It's completely ignorant of the modern global economic structures, the EU came into existence because of the need for further economic integration in Europe much as other economic blocs have emerged, it's exactly why the woman in your profile picture was foundational in the deeper integration of the EEC and kick-started the transition to the EU via the creation of the single market. Our sovereignty is preserved by pooling it as otherwise it's eroded by being a thrawn to hostile economies bigger than ours and operating counter to liberal values, as seen by the biggest champions of Brexit suddenly wanting us to be dictated by Trump's US.
We've pooled our sovereignty to establish NATO, should we leave that now?
The way I've read this you actually prove Proth's point more than your own.
I was always in favour of a customs union and freedom of movement. However, when it comes to the big stuff, outside of trade, the EU is always found wringing its hands and dithering because of having to get 20 odd states to decide on which way to turn and, in many cases, they all have say "go" otherwise the train doesn't leave the station, usually because Orban or someone else hasn't bought a ticket. And during that time billions are pissed away on a lot of needless bureaucracy.
Trump comes out with a load of shit on a daily basis but occasionally, very, very occasionally he gets one right and that one is that the rest of NATO and, in fact, the EU, has not pulled its weight defensively since its inception. So regardless of where the UK sits, inside or out, the one accord, when it comes down to it, is the one with the US, whether we like it or not.
The EU is not a monolith, you need only look at defensive contributions in Finland and the Baltics and on the flipside compare that to Ireland. And the likes of Orban and Fico are projections of Russian foreign policy, hence why they're trying to undermine European solidarity and create wedge issues to fracture Europe as it's easier to pick off a divided Europe and undermine liberalism in Europe.
And European defence spending has jumped because of Russia becoming a much more emboldened threat to Europe, not because of Trump. Trump's biggest contribution is pushing European nations and Canada to pursue greater independence with defence policy as the US is no longer a reliable ally.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(03-05-2026, 04:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-05-2026, 03:59 PM)Fido Wrote: (03-05-2026, 03:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-05-2026, 02:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote: My principal reason for voting to Leave was far more mundane; the EU was not what we were sold when we entered the EEC. The clue is in the names.
Above anything else I'm a democrat, and the prospect of our nation "pooling sovereignty" on an ever increasing basis is not something I was ever comfortable with. If nothing else, Brexit has exposed how unfit our political class is to govern - when they have no one else to blame.
This is exactly what I'm on about, it's a sentiment rooted in a global outlook from 250 years ago where Britain was insulated from economic demands by its economic size and weight. It's completely ignorant of the modern global economic structures, the EU came into existence because of the need for further economic integration in Europe much as other economic blocs have emerged, it's exactly why the woman in your profile picture was foundational in the deeper integration of the EEC and kick-started the transition to the EU via the creation of the single market. Our sovereignty is preserved by pooling it as otherwise it's eroded by being a thrawn to hostile economies bigger than ours and operating counter to liberal values, as seen by the biggest champions of Brexit suddenly wanting us to be dictated by Trump's US.
We've pooled our sovereignty to establish NATO, should we leave that now?
The way I've read this you actually prove Proth's point more than your own.
I was always in favour of a customs union and freedom of movement. However, when it comes to the big stuff, outside of trade, the EU is always found wringing its hands and dithering because of having to get 20 odd states to decide on which way to turn and, in many cases, they all have say "go" otherwise the train doesn't leave the station, usually because Orban or someone else hasn't bought a ticket. And during that time billions are pissed away on a lot of needless bureaucracy.
Trump comes out with a load of shit on a daily basis but occasionally, very, very occasionally he gets one right and that one is that the rest of NATO and, in fact, the EU, has not pulled its weight defensively since its inception. So regardless of where the UK sits, inside or out, the one accord, when it comes down to it, is the one with the US, whether we like it or not.
The EU is not a monolith, you need only look at defensive contributions in Finland and the Baltics and on the flipside compare that to Ireland. And the likes of Orban and Fico are projections of Russian foreign policy, hence why they're trying to undermine European solidarity and create wedge issues to fracture Europe as it's easier to pick off a divided Europe and undermine liberalism in Europe.
And European defence spending has jumped because of Russia becoming a much more emboldened threat to Europe, not because of Trump. Trump's biggest contribution is pushing European nations and Canada to pursue greater independence with defence policy as the US is no longer a reliable ally.
It's awoken us from our collective slumber, I agree with you there.
|