A captain on the pitch.
#11
(03-04-2026, 10:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Not needed these days. Games changed. You need players with clear technical attributes that help achieve a result. Whether that's, ace, strength, height, bravery what ever.

But the old style "leader of men" just isn't as important now sadly.

Add "we lack leaders" to the same pile as "front foot football" in terms of throw away, desperate, sayings.

Another little peek into football how you think it should be, Lurker. In life, everybody should be a leader, but they aren't. Of course you need someone to calm team mates down, gee them up, communicate sensibly with the ref. And you can't measure that with stats, which is maybe why you don't believe it's needed.
Reply
#12
(03-04-2026, 10:08 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 09:26 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 08:37 PM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: We need a natural leader. Someone vocal who can dish out some verbals if needed. Mowatt is not the one. Jed shouldn't be near the team now. So who? Molumby fits the profile, but he really shouldn't be in the team on talent. So who? I can't think of any stand out candidate !

Molumby doesnt fit the bill at all. He's the first to be head down, shoulders slumped. The first to point the finger at others when he makes mistakes. Christ, the perception of this guy beggars belief.

That's really not true, Jacko. He was the one trying to gee the players up after we went behind at Oxford. The anti-Molumby vibe on here is amazing. He's a fairly ordinary footballer for sure, but he's portayed on here as the personification of everything that's wrong in our club and the game as a whole.

You know on balance, through good times and bad, we as a fan base are far more likely to criticise and even crucify our own players than praise them. It's charmless and nasty. I don't see other fans doing this to the same extent. It must be our superpower.

I was at Oxford that's simply not true.
Reply
#13
(03-04-2026, 10:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Not needed these days. Games changed. You need players with clear technical attributes that help achieve a result. Whether that's, ace, strength, height, bravery what ever.

But the old style "leader of men" just isn't as important now sadly.

Add "we lack leaders" to the same pile as "front foot football" in terms of throw away, desperate, sayings.

Another little peek into football how you think it should be, Lurker. In life, everybody should be a leader, but they aren't. Of course you need someone to calm team mates down, gee them up, communicate sensibly with the ref. And you can't measure that with stats, which is maybe why you don't believe it's needed.

See bold above. 

Nothing to do with how I think it should be. Just how it is at the elite level. IMO of course. The finer the margins are the less those 'ham and egg' characteristics matter. We ran more in 2 games under ER than any other game this year. Alas we had the wrong players on the pitch so it failed.

Phillips, Mowatt and Wallace never stop communicating with their teammates. Sadly it isnt enough. 

It's just another lazy throw away terms like "lacking bottle" or "not working hard enough". Often it's a lack  of tactical, physical or technical proficiency. 

Listen to Carrick's interview tonight. He said very similar in terms of their poor performance tonight, shut the interviewer down when she questioned the "character" of his team because they've lost.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
The characteristics mentioned in this thread with regards to being a good leader are only useful when combined, as Lurker says with being a good footballer. I think there are a few downplaying how effective McInnes was as a midfielder, he was no yard dog. He was a proper footballer. Unlike the aforementioned Molumby who is shit.

If it's effort and shouting that will keep us up, why don't we just pick eleven guys out of the Brummie Road?
Reply
#15
(03-04-2026, 10:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Not needed these days. Games changed. You need players with clear technical attributes that help achieve a result. Whether that's, ace, strength, height, bravery what ever.

But the old style "leader of men" just isn't as important now sadly.

Add "we lack leaders" to the same pile as "front foot football" in terms of throw away, desperate, sayings.

Another little peek into football how you think it should be, Lurker. In life, everybody should be a leader, but they aren't. Of course you need someone to calm team mates down, gee them up, communicate sensibly with the ref. And you can't measure that with stats, which is maybe why you don't believe it's needed.

See bold above. 

Nothing to do with how I think it should be. Just how it is at the elite level. IMO of course. The finer the margins are the less those 'ham and egg' characteristics matter. We ran more in 2 games under ER than any other game this year. Alas we had the wrong players on the pitch so it failed.

Phillips, Mowatt and Wallace never stop communicating with their teammates. Sadly it isnt enough. 

It's just another lazy throw away terms like "lacking bottle" or "not working hard enough". Often it's a lack  of tactical, physical or technical proficiency. 

Listen to Carrick's interview tonight. He said very similar in terms of their poor performance tonight, shut the interviewer down when she questioned the "character" of his team because they've lost.

See bold above. I wouldn't describe WBA at elite level right now, the team is full of players without character and confidence. They absolutely would benefit from a true leader on the pitch as opposed to someone who has been with us for a while and is simply less shit than some of the other players. Jed for all his faults does display much better leadership characteristics in terms of effort and communication - People don't want to hear it but at least he has the bollocks to come out and talk as well as chase balls and put tackles in. Shame he's on the decline. 

Several managers have also spoken about the team needing to show bravery yet the captain is one of the first to scurry down the tunnel, never does media interviews and lets his team mates take the abuse in front of travelling away fans. On the pitch he often slows down the play and is found amongst the back line i.e. no bravery whatsoever. IMHO I do not believe he displays leadership qualities, this might not detract from his teammates capability but it sure as shit doesn't enhance it. 

Also - reference the elite level comment, one could make the same argument reference company boardrooms and talented c-suites. However without a good leader on top there is still very much the potential for miscommunications, unclear objectives, mixed priorities etc. and for the company to achieve naff all.
Reply
#16
(03-05-2026, 07:16 AM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Not needed these days. Games changed. You need players with clear technical attributes that help achieve a result. Whether that's, ace, strength, height, bravery what ever.

But the old style "leader of men" just isn't as important now sadly.

Add "we lack leaders" to the same pile as "front foot football" in terms of throw away, desperate, sayings.

Another little peek into football how you think it should be, Lurker. In life, everybody should be a leader, but they aren't. Of course you need someone to calm team mates down, gee them up, communicate sensibly with the ref. And you can't measure that with stats, which is maybe why you don't believe it's needed.

See bold above. 

Nothing to do with how I think it should be. Just how it is at the elite level. IMO of course. The finer the margins are the less those 'ham and egg' characteristics matter. We ran more in 2 games under ER than any other game this year. Alas we had the wrong players on the pitch so it failed.

Phillips, Mowatt and Wallace never stop communicating with their teammates. Sadly it isnt enough. 

It's just another lazy throw away terms like "lacking bottle" or "not working hard enough". Often it's a lack  of tactical, physical or technical proficiency. 

Listen to Carrick's interview tonight. He said very similar in terms of their poor performance tonight, shut the interviewer down when she questioned the "character" of his team because they've lost.

See bold above. I wouldn't describe WBA at elite level right now, the team is full of players without character and confidence. They absolutely would benefit from a true leader on the pitch as opposed to someone who has been with us for a while and is simply less shit than some of the other players. Jed for all his faults does display much better leadership characteristics in terms of effort and communication - People don't want to hear it but at least he has the bollocks to come out and talk as well as chase balls and put tackles in. Shame he's on the decline. 

Several managers have also spoken about the team needing to show bravery yet the captain is one of the first to scurry down the tunnel, never does media interviews and lets his team mates take the abuse in front of travelling away fans. On the pitch he often slows down the play and is found amongst the back line i.e. no bravery whatsoever. IMHO I do not believe he displays leadership qualities, this might not detract from his teammates capability but it sure as shit doesn't enhance it. 

Also - reference the elite level comment, one could make the same argument reference company boardrooms and talented c-suites. However without a good leader on top there is still very much the potential for miscommunications, unclear objectives, mixed priorities etc. and for the company to achieve naff all.

Try and play 45 minutes of Championship football and tell me it isn't elite.
Reply
#17
(03-05-2026, 07:16 AM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-04-2026, 10:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Not needed these days. Games changed. You need players with clear technical attributes that help achieve a result. Whether that's, ace, strength, height, bravery what ever.

But the old style "leader of men" just isn't as important now sadly.

Add "we lack leaders" to the same pile as "front foot football" in terms of throw away, desperate, sayings.

Another little peek into football how you think it should be, Lurker. In life, everybody should be a leader, but they aren't. Of course you need someone to calm team mates down, gee them up, communicate sensibly with the ref. And you can't measure that with stats, which is maybe why you don't believe it's needed.

See bold above. 

Nothing to do with how I think it should be. Just how it is at the elite level. IMO of course. The finer the margins are the less those 'ham and egg' characteristics matter. We ran more in 2 games under ER than any other game this year. Alas we had the wrong players on the pitch so it failed.

Phillips, Mowatt and Wallace never stop communicating with their teammates. Sadly it isnt enough. 

It's just another lazy throw away terms like "lacking bottle" or "not working hard enough". Often it's a lack  of tactical, physical or technical proficiency. 

Listen to Carrick's interview tonight. He said very similar in terms of their poor performance tonight, shut the interviewer down when she questioned the "character" of his team because they've lost.

See bold above. I wouldn't describe WBA at elite level right now, the team is full of players without character and confidence. They absolutely would benefit from a true leader on the pitch as opposed to someone who has been with us for a while and is simply less shit than some of the other players. Jed for all his faults does display much better leadership characteristics in terms of effort and communication - People don't want to hear it but at least he has the bollocks to come out and talk as well as chase balls and put tackles in. Shame he's on the decline. 

Several managers have also spoken about the team needing to show bravery yet the captain is one of the first to scurry down the tunnel, never does media interviews and lets his team mates take the abuse in front of travelling away fans. On the pitch he often slows down the play and is found amongst the back line i.e. no bravery whatsoever. IMHO I do not believe he displays leadership qualities, this might not detract from his teammates capability but it sure as shit doesn't enhance it. 

Also - reference the elite level comment, one could make the same argument reference company boardrooms and talented c-suites. However without a good leader on top there is still very much the potential for miscommunications, unclear objectives, mixed priorities etc. and for the company to achieve naff all.

Great points raised re: Mowatt. I completely agree. He doesn't show any leadership characteristics. Oh for a John Wile at centre half. Out of the current bunch, I'd be tempted to give it to Campbell, who always gives his all and doesn't shirk his responsibilities.

I appreciate it's only for a fleeting moment, but when my lad went to the Christmas party, and we met the players Mowatt was very disengaged, bordering on arrogant, whereas Jed was talkative and pleasant, as were a few others such as Grant, Molumby and Griffiths.
Reply
#18
Pearce only signs "Geldings"
Reply
#19
Seems to me that the armband is allocated mostly on the basis of seniority, which is why the very withdrawn Mowatt gets the gig on a regular basis. Since when was life a democracy, eh? The skipper needs to front up to the ref, to his team mates and to the press. The fact that Campbell was made available for interview after Oxford shows that most of the players were hiding.

Sport is a profession for extroverts. Cowards and shrinking violets are less successful, but we seem to have more than our share.
Reply
#20
(03-05-2026, 08:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Seems to me that the armband is allocated mostly on the basis of seniority, which is why the very withdrawn Mowatt gets the gig on a regular basis. Since when was life a democracy, eh? The skipper needs to front up to the ref, to his team mates and to the press. The fact that Campbell was made available for interview after Oxford shows that most of the players were hiding.

Sport is a profession for extroverts. Cowards and shrinking violets are less successful, but we seem to have more than our share.

Not too sure about that. Bryan Robson may have been (be?) a drinker but he was no extrovert. He was a leader by example but his shouting and ordering was concise and to the point, especially at United. I think what you're talking about is a far more modern convention than historical. Don't remember Bobby Moore being much of an extrovert. Willie Johnston on the other hand …!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)