Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-02-2026, 11:44 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-02-2026, 11:38 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Wasn’t the 20M loss Coventry buying back their stadium?
Nope, that was separate and further down in the article. Coventry’s relative success is pretty much driven by their owners investing.
FYI Ted - I’m not talking about this season, this season was about surviving and navigating the PSR problems. Which is why I wanted a more experienced manager and that doesn’t mean Bruce, Mowbray etc in charge. This is about next season and the subsequent ones.
The problem with the buy cheap, sell at a profit approach is it doesn’t work on its own without investment for more than a couple of seasons in the Championship. One bad transfer window and you have no more leeway. It’s no more a sustainable model than an owner pumping millions into the club.
The amount of things we need to alter to make us anywhere near sustainable will take a lot of investment in the very best scouting, DoF, management, coaching etc. There is no getting away from the fact that if the owners want to see any return on their money they will have to invest long after the PSR problems are sorted out. You cannot take the Championship as I said months ago for granted, it will chew you up and see you with a new mountain of debt after you sorted out the last one, if you don’t have the best people in the key positions. We haven’t and it’s why we are where we are.
I think ultimately we agree that a bit of both is required. But I will die on the hill that Bilkul wasted a great opportunity to reinvest the Heggem/Fellows money and show the fans what they were all about. It's a mistake that is going to see us relegated.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
03-02-2026, 12:55 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-02-2026, 12:56 PM by Sliced.)
(03-02-2026, 07:53 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2026, 10:04 PM)Sliced Wrote: As I've said before, I genuinely don't put a blame on the players for this situation. It's all from above. For anyone wondering what the strategy is with regards to the players:
1. Get rid of higher earners that we can, replace with cheaper from abroad/youth/lower leagues.
2. Any of those that turn out to be decent, sell those on as well and replace.
3. Repeat.
So who does that leave you with? A team primarily made up of the ones that no one else wants and the less good players we've signed while the decent ones have been sold off.
The managerial strategy is "get in a young up and coming manager without really vetting them". Seemingly because it's progressive, but the manager is the most important decision of the football club and now 3 times in a row we've gotten it completely wrong....and it's quite likely Raphael Wicky would have been a pile of shite too if Nestor chose him.
What we have now is a mish mash of players who hardly know each other; a keeper who's never been particularly good but gets zero protection from a centre back partnership (any of them) that hasn't been coached to be a cohesive unit at any point this season. We have what is likely our best centre back out at right back because all of our other right back options are a million miles away from being adequate at this level, Styles who is arguably first name on the team sheet despite being brought in as a utility backup player. Moving into midfield there's Mowatt and Molumby who loads seem to have a problem with one or the other, they clash when playing together but the only other semi-reasonable alternatives are Diakite who is fine at breaking up play but allergic to passing forwards (actually just passing in general, I don't think I've seen a footballer struggle to kick a ball in a straight line before) and Styles who might be ok but we have no viable alternative at left back, so we have to play them. Price was alright initially but he's clearly not a player for a relegation battle, our wide players are children, OAPs or injured and our striking choices are Maja who's unfit, Dike who's not the same after being injured and Heggebo who's out of form.
Other than that we're alright.
I do take a more che sera sera view than birdy though. I'm not happy with our plight but what will be will be. Eventually we'll get to a League where we start winning some games, even if it's in a few seasons time 
Points 1 and 2 are why Coventry are top the league and why Norwich are the form side this calendar year.
Coventry sold Gyokeres and Hamer and built a title winning team with the proceeds.
Norwich got rid of Sargent and signed Meghoma, Toure and Ahmed and now they look a totally different side, albeit with a better manager. They also signed Makama from League One for cost of a Chris Mepham that we didn't need.
We sold out best players and replaced them with shit, we didn't have to. The £10m we got for Fellows could have signed us those players that Norwich did. Our scouting and player ID has been awful the last 18 months. I've no problem with the method, every issue with the execution.
It works if the focus is on improving the quality of the team, which it wasn't, it was about making (admittedly needed) money. We were never going to replace Fellows with 2 days of the transfer window left and we've bought about 4 downgrades of Heggem with the same cash. Coventry held on to Gjokeres for a second season after he scored 20 odd goals because they didn't get the money they wanted from his sale; we jumped at the opportunity to sell Fellows even though clearly it's going to cost us much more than 10 million when we inevitably go down.
Shocking decision making time and time again. It's like they just assumed it was going to be easy to replace our best players with anyone. It very rarely works.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-02-2026, 12:55 PM)Sliced Wrote: It works if the focus is on improving the quality of the team, which it wasn't, it was about making (admittedly needed) money. We were never going to replace Fellows with 2 days of the transfer window left and we've bought about 4 downgrades of Heggem with the same cash. Coventry held on to Gjokeres for a second season after he scored 20 odd goals because they didn't get the money they wanted from his sale; we jumped at the opportunity to sell Fellows even though clearly it's going to cost us much more than 10 million when we inevitably go down.
Shocking decision making time and time again. It's like they just assumed it was going to be easy to replace our best players with anyone. It very rarely works.
There is a fair argument to say the damage was done prior to the Fellows sale. One player, that you know you need to sell, can absolutely be replaced in two days of a transfer window if you wish. We couldn't even loan someone who played in the right position.
For the price of Heggebo, Phillips and Mepham I can think of a three players from the league below that would have come into our team in the summer and made it better than it is now.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(03-02-2026, 12:55 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-02-2026, 07:53 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2026, 10:04 PM)Sliced Wrote: As I've said before, I genuinely don't put a blame on the players for this situation. It's all from above. For anyone wondering what the strategy is with regards to the players:
1. Get rid of higher earners that we can, replace with cheaper from abroad/youth/lower leagues.
2. Any of those that turn out to be decent, sell those on as well and replace.
3. Repeat.
So who does that leave you with? A team primarily made up of the ones that no one else wants and the less good players we've signed while the decent ones have been sold off.
The managerial strategy is "get in a young up and coming manager without really vetting them". Seemingly because it's progressive, but the manager is the most important decision of the football club and now 3 times in a row we've gotten it completely wrong....and it's quite likely Raphael Wicky would have been a pile of shite too if Nestor chose him.
What we have now is a mish mash of players who hardly know each other; a keeper who's never been particularly good but gets zero protection from a centre back partnership (any of them) that hasn't been coached to be a cohesive unit at any point this season. We have what is likely our best centre back out at right back because all of our other right back options are a million miles away from being adequate at this level, Styles who is arguably first name on the team sheet despite being brought in as a utility backup player. Moving into midfield there's Mowatt and Molumby who loads seem to have a problem with one or the other, they clash when playing together but the only other semi-reasonable alternatives are Diakite who is fine at breaking up play but allergic to passing forwards (actually just passing in general, I don't think I've seen a footballer struggle to kick a ball in a straight line before) and Styles who might be ok but we have no viable alternative at left back, so we have to play them. Price was alright initially but he's clearly not a player for a relegation battle, our wide players are children, OAPs or injured and our striking choices are Maja who's unfit, Dike who's not the same after being injured and Heggebo who's out of form.
Other than that we're alright.
I do take a more che sera sera view than birdy though. I'm not happy with our plight but what will be will be. Eventually we'll get to a League where we start winning some games, even if it's in a few seasons time 
Points 1 and 2 are why Coventry are top the league and why Norwich are the form side this calendar year.
Coventry sold Gyokeres and Hamer and built a title winning team with the proceeds.
Norwich got rid of Sargent and signed Meghoma, Toure and Ahmed and now they look a totally different side, albeit with a better manager. They also signed Makama from League One for cost of a Chris Mepham that we didn't need.
We sold out best players and replaced them with shit, we didn't have to. The £10m we got for Fellows could have signed us those players that Norwich did. Our scouting and player ID has been awful the last 18 months. I've no problem with the method, every issue with the execution.
It works if the focus is on improving the quality of the team, which it wasn't, it was about making (admittedly needed) money. We were never going to replace Fellows with 2 days of the transfer window left and we've bought about 4 downgrades of Heggem with the same cash. Coventry held on to Gjokeres for a second season after he scored 20 odd goals because they didn't get the money they wanted from his sale; we jumped at the opportunity to sell Fellows even though clearly it's going to cost us much more than 10 million when we inevitably go down.
Shocking decision making time and time again. It's like they just assumed it was going to be easy to replace our best players with anyone. It very rarely works.
We didn't jump at the chance. It would be us looking at points deductions if we hadn't sold Fellows and Taylor. The situation re Gyokeres bears no resemblance.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
03-02-2026, 01:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-02-2026, 01:14 PM by Sliced.)
(03-02-2026, 01:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-02-2026, 12:55 PM)Sliced Wrote: It works if the focus is on improving the quality of the team, which it wasn't, it was about making (admittedly needed) money. We were never going to replace Fellows with 2 days of the transfer window left and we've bought about 4 downgrades of Heggem with the same cash. Coventry held on to Gjokeres for a second season after he scored 20 odd goals because they didn't get the money they wanted from his sale; we jumped at the opportunity to sell Fellows even though clearly it's going to cost us much more than 10 million when we inevitably go down.
Shocking decision making time and time again. It's like they just assumed it was going to be easy to replace our best players with anyone. It very rarely works.
There is a fair argument to say the damage was done prior to the Fellows sale. One player, that you know you need to sell, can absolutely be replaced in two days of a transfer window if you wish. We couldn't even loan someone who played in the right position.
For the price of Heggebo, Phillips and Mepham I can think of a three players from the league below that would have come into our team in the summer and made it better than it is now.
One of your best players can not easily be replaced in this time, especially given our lack of alternatives. It was a poor decision.
Look at the past 10-15 years of Albion. How often have we sold on one of our best players and replaced them with better? One of the main reasons that we're in the current mess is because time and time again we shit ourselves and accept and offer rather than make an attempt to negotiate on price, and then fail to replace the outgoing player. I can't think of one instance where we have got rid of a key player and replaced them with better. We're bad at it, but also not easy to do, we were never going to replace the top assister in the league in two days.
(03-02-2026, 01:10 PM)Jacko Wrote: (03-02-2026, 12:55 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-02-2026, 07:53 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2026, 10:04 PM)Sliced Wrote: As I've said before, I genuinely don't put a blame on the players for this situation. It's all from above. For anyone wondering what the strategy is with regards to the players:
1. Get rid of higher earners that we can, replace with cheaper from abroad/youth/lower leagues.
2. Any of those that turn out to be decent, sell those on as well and replace.
3. Repeat.
So who does that leave you with? A team primarily made up of the ones that no one else wants and the less good players we've signed while the decent ones have been sold off.
The managerial strategy is "get in a young up and coming manager without really vetting them". Seemingly because it's progressive, but the manager is the most important decision of the football club and now 3 times in a row we've gotten it completely wrong....and it's quite likely Raphael Wicky would have been a pile of shite too if Nestor chose him.
What we have now is a mish mash of players who hardly know each other; a keeper who's never been particularly good but gets zero protection from a centre back partnership (any of them) that hasn't been coached to be a cohesive unit at any point this season. We have what is likely our best centre back out at right back because all of our other right back options are a million miles away from being adequate at this level, Styles who is arguably first name on the team sheet despite being brought in as a utility backup player. Moving into midfield there's Mowatt and Molumby who loads seem to have a problem with one or the other, they clash when playing together but the only other semi-reasonable alternatives are Diakite who is fine at breaking up play but allergic to passing forwards (actually just passing in general, I don't think I've seen a footballer struggle to kick a ball in a straight line before) and Styles who might be ok but we have no viable alternative at left back, so we have to play them. Price was alright initially but he's clearly not a player for a relegation battle, our wide players are children, OAPs or injured and our striking choices are Maja who's unfit, Dike who's not the same after being injured and Heggebo who's out of form.
Other than that we're alright.
I do take a more che sera sera view than birdy though. I'm not happy with our plight but what will be will be. Eventually we'll get to a League where we start winning some games, even if it's in a few seasons time 
Points 1 and 2 are why Coventry are top the league and why Norwich are the form side this calendar year.
Coventry sold Gyokeres and Hamer and built a title winning team with the proceeds.
Norwich got rid of Sargent and signed Meghoma, Toure and Ahmed and now they look a totally different side, albeit with a better manager. They also signed Makama from League One for cost of a Chris Mepham that we didn't need.
We sold out best players and replaced them with shit, we didn't have to. The £10m we got for Fellows could have signed us those players that Norwich did. Our scouting and player ID has been awful the last 18 months. I've no problem with the method, every issue with the execution.
It works if the focus is on improving the quality of the team, which it wasn't, it was about making (admittedly needed) money. We were never going to replace Fellows with 2 days of the transfer window left and we've bought about 4 downgrades of Heggem with the same cash. Coventry held on to Gjokeres for a second season after he scored 20 odd goals because they didn't get the money they wanted from his sale; we jumped at the opportunity to sell Fellows even though clearly it's going to cost us much more than 10 million when we inevitably go down.
Shocking decision making time and time again. It's like they just assumed it was going to be easy to replace our best players with anyone. It very rarely works.
We didn't jump at the chance. It would be us looking at points deductions if we hadn't sold Fellows and Taylor. The situation re Gyokeres bears no resemblance.
Thank God we didn't maintain the quality of the squad for a 6 point deduction!
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-02-2026, 01:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-02-2026, 01:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-02-2026, 12:55 PM)Sliced Wrote: It works if the focus is on improving the quality of the team, which it wasn't, it was about making (admittedly needed) money. We were never going to replace Fellows with 2 days of the transfer window left and we've bought about 4 downgrades of Heggem with the same cash. Coventry held on to Gjokeres for a second season after he scored 20 odd goals because they didn't get the money they wanted from his sale; we jumped at the opportunity to sell Fellows even though clearly it's going to cost us much more than 10 million when we inevitably go down.
Shocking decision making time and time again. It's like they just assumed it was going to be easy to replace our best players with anyone. It very rarely works.
There is a fair argument to say the damage was done prior to the Fellows sale. One player, that you know you need to sell, can absolutely be replaced in two days of a transfer window if you wish. We couldn't even loan someone who played in the right position.
For the price of Heggebo, Phillips and Mepham I can think of a three players from the league below that would have come into our team in the summer and made it better than it is now.
One of your best players can not easily be replaced in this time, especially given our lack of alternatives. It was a poor decision.
Look at the past 10-15 years of Albion. How often have we sold on one of our best players and replaced them with better? One of the main reasons that we're in the current mess is because time and time again we shit ourselves and accept and offer rather than make an attempt to negotiate on price, and then fail to replace the outgoing player. I can't think of one instance where we have got rid of a key player and replaced them with better. We're bad at it, but also not easy to do, we were never going to replace the top assister in the league in two days.
Like I say, the damage was already done. We compounded the sale of Fellows with other poor signings. If you make one bad move, you can get away with it, if you make bad move after bad move then you're going to get what's coming to you.
It's also worth noting that if we say any semblance of a plan, playing style, tactical idea from Mason or Nestor to suggest we're going to sell Fellows and reinvest in a pair of great wing backs because we want to play a back three, or a couple of different types of wide players it would have been more tolerable than signing a reserve LB from the Villa. The timing wasn't ideal but there was no excuse to manage the squad as badly as we did throughout the summer.
Posts: 7,409
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
I cannot believe some are saying Bilkul should have taken the points deduction and carried on. Boy they should give there heads a wobble.
We have rightly complied with the rules as they stand and rightly. We could not have seen Nestor fucking up the manager side three times 4 if you count Wicky. I still trust I Bilkul and Patel did the right thing by sacking his mate, but now we have to get our next coach/ manager right no matter which league we're in in next season or things could get really tough for all connected to WBA.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(03-02-2026, 01:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-02-2026, 01:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-02-2026, 12:55 PM)Sliced Wrote: It works if the focus is on improving the quality of the team, which it wasn't, it was about making (admittedly needed) money. We were never going to replace Fellows with 2 days of the transfer window left and we've bought about 4 downgrades of Heggem with the same cash. Coventry held on to Gjokeres for a second season after he scored 20 odd goals because they didn't get the money they wanted from his sale; we jumped at the opportunity to sell Fellows even though clearly it's going to cost us much more than 10 million when we inevitably go down.
Shocking decision making time and time again. It's like they just assumed it was going to be easy to replace our best players with anyone. It very rarely works.
There is a fair argument to say the damage was done prior to the Fellows sale. One player, that you know you need to sell, can absolutely be replaced in two days of a transfer window if you wish. We couldn't even loan someone who played in the right position.
For the price of Heggebo, Phillips and Mepham I can think of a three players from the league below that would have come into our team in the summer and made it better than it is now.
One of your best players can not easily be replaced in this time, especially given our lack of alternatives. It was a poor decision.
Look at the past 10-15 years of Albion. How often have we sold on one of our best players and replaced them with better? One of the main reasons that we're in the current mess is because time and time again we shit ourselves and accept and offer rather than make an attempt to negotiate on price, and then fail to replace the outgoing player. I can't think of one instance where we have got rid of a key player and replaced them with better. We're bad at it, but also not easy to do, we were never going to replace the top assister in the league in two days.
(03-02-2026, 01:10 PM)Jacko Wrote: (03-02-2026, 12:55 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-02-2026, 07:53 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-01-2026, 10:04 PM)Sliced Wrote: As I've said before, I genuinely don't put a blame on the players for this situation. It's all from above. For anyone wondering what the strategy is with regards to the players:
1. Get rid of higher earners that we can, replace with cheaper from abroad/youth/lower leagues.
2. Any of those that turn out to be decent, sell those on as well and replace.
3. Repeat.
So who does that leave you with? A team primarily made up of the ones that no one else wants and the less good players we've signed while the decent ones have been sold off.
The managerial strategy is "get in a young up and coming manager without really vetting them". Seemingly because it's progressive, but the manager is the most important decision of the football club and now 3 times in a row we've gotten it completely wrong....and it's quite likely Raphael Wicky would have been a pile of shite too if Nestor chose him.
What we have now is a mish mash of players who hardly know each other; a keeper who's never been particularly good but gets zero protection from a centre back partnership (any of them) that hasn't been coached to be a cohesive unit at any point this season. We have what is likely our best centre back out at right back because all of our other right back options are a million miles away from being adequate at this level, Styles who is arguably first name on the team sheet despite being brought in as a utility backup player. Moving into midfield there's Mowatt and Molumby who loads seem to have a problem with one or the other, they clash when playing together but the only other semi-reasonable alternatives are Diakite who is fine at breaking up play but allergic to passing forwards (actually just passing in general, I don't think I've seen a footballer struggle to kick a ball in a straight line before) and Styles who might be ok but we have no viable alternative at left back, so we have to play them. Price was alright initially but he's clearly not a player for a relegation battle, our wide players are children, OAPs or injured and our striking choices are Maja who's unfit, Dike who's not the same after being injured and Heggebo who's out of form.
Other than that we're alright.
I do take a more che sera sera view than birdy though. I'm not happy with our plight but what will be will be. Eventually we'll get to a League where we start winning some games, even if it's in a few seasons time 
Points 1 and 2 are why Coventry are top the league and why Norwich are the form side this calendar year.
Coventry sold Gyokeres and Hamer and built a title winning team with the proceeds.
Norwich got rid of Sargent and signed Meghoma, Toure and Ahmed and now they look a totally different side, albeit with a better manager. They also signed Makama from League One for cost of a Chris Mepham that we didn't need.
We sold out best players and replaced them with shit, we didn't have to. The £10m we got for Fellows could have signed us those players that Norwich did. Our scouting and player ID has been awful the last 18 months. I've no problem with the method, every issue with the execution.
It works if the focus is on improving the quality of the team, which it wasn't, it was about making (admittedly needed) money. We were never going to replace Fellows with 2 days of the transfer window left and we've bought about 4 downgrades of Heggem with the same cash. Coventry held on to Gjokeres for a second season after he scored 20 odd goals because they didn't get the money they wanted from his sale; we jumped at the opportunity to sell Fellows even though clearly it's going to cost us much more than 10 million when we inevitably go down.
Shocking decision making time and time again. It's like they just assumed it was going to be easy to replace our best players with anyone. It very rarely works.
We didn't jump at the chance. It would be us looking at points deductions if we hadn't sold Fellows and Taylor. The situation re Gyokeres bears no resemblance.
Thank God we didn't maintain the quality of the squad for a 6 point deduction!
We wouldn't have been looking at a 6 point deduction. We were already under an EFL business plan, if we suddenly stopped adhering to it we were in uncharted waters.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
Coventry were literally under a transfer embargo at the end of the 2022 season while Gjokeres played for them due to financial problems and had a 5 point suspended deduction because they postponed so many home games due to stadium issues. "Bears no resemblance", they were arguably more fucked than we were.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(03-02-2026, 01:38 PM)Sliced Wrote: Coventry were literally under a transfer embargo at the end of the 2022 season while Gjokeres played for them due to financial problems and had a 5 point suspended deduction because they postponed so many home games due to stadium issues. "Bears no resemblance", they were arguably more fucked than we were.
They were under a transfer embargo for 2 and a half months. While they were paying HMRC some arrears in 6 instalments from October to December 2022. They sold him at the end of that season.
Rejecting bids for Gyokeres in 21/22 when they had no financial issues other than having a shit owner is why the two cases bear no resemblance to one another.
|