Posts: 516
Threads: 23
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
1
We have to face the facts that the main cause of our problem is poor recruitment over the last two years
Plus by and large the loan signings have been awful.a succession of managers have done nothing to get any sort of creativity into midfield causing sideways backwards boring football
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Got a bit derailed by Nat Phillips playing career.
What i meant to say that our defending this season has for long stretches been very good... but we manage to concede goals in games where we have defended well, sometimes either due to catastrophic error, bad luck or opposition their once in a career worldie.
Last night's xg was !.96 for us and 0.3 for Charlton, looked up the game at the valley, 0.85 for us and 0.31 (excluding penalty) for Charlton.
If you are restricting your opponents to 0.3xg in consecutive games you are defending well and should expect at least one clean sheet and really it should be 2. Not to get one needs some explaining.
On Phillips, he is what he is, average championship defender, not as bad as he is being described on here, but not one you would ideally want to spend £3m on. But there was a lot of work to do in central defence last summer and how many options did we have?
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(02-25-2026, 10:26 AM)garryowensneck Wrote: (02-25-2026, 09:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (02-25-2026, 09:35 AM)garryowensneck Wrote: And he's on £40k a week!!!
He's not
Plenty of data online suggesting he is, whatever, we overpaid for him and we're over paying him.
There is absolutely zero chance, given the financial state of the club last summer, that anyone is on anywhere near £40k a week.
Posts: 751
Threads: 8
Joined: Nov 2025
Reputation:
1
The problem we have are the whopping bollocks we drop. It's either the midfield going AWOL and allowing 50+ yard unchallenged runs to the edge of the box, or one of our carthorse centre halves switching off at some point in the 90 to gift a goal
Case in point being last night - as ambitionless and limited an opposition as you are ever going to see, yet we contrive to concede to one of their 3 shots because their forward is clean through. Compare that to our chances and our lack of conversion.
We have consistently ben making game changing mistakes at both ends of the pitch all year. I'm inclined to put it down to a lack of concentration and coaching given how often it has cost us points. Never happened under Megson or Corberan with similar journeymen defenders.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
I remember Derby fans saying he was much better in a 3 centre backs system and worried he might struggle in a 2. I did think at the time is this really a good signing when we aren't going to play the way that suits him. It's typical of the lack of logical thought that goes into our recruitment
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
02-25-2026, 11:41 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-25-2026, 11:41 AM by AnelkasBeard.)
(02-25-2026, 10:28 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh wage data online is hilariously wrong, it's not actually ever shared outside a club and agents don't tend to ever leak genuine numbers.
I think these sites are probably an attempt to replicate American sports wage sites (eg Spotrac, OverTheCap)
The difference being their salaries are actually reported, and are very relevant to the salary cap systems they have there. Here, it doesn't really matter.
Posts: 7,717
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(02-25-2026, 09:23 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I just watched the highlights. Charlie Taylor gets a lot of abuse on here, but I can hardly find words to explain how completely, totally and utterly the Charlton goal was Phillips' fault. The scorer was in front of Phillips, but behind Taylor. Definitely Phillips' man to mark. As the man made his move, Phillips stepped up and stood still waving his arm for the offside. Why? Why not just do your job, go with him and get a challenge in? Idle and arrogant. Taylor gave him some serious verbals afterwards, but too late. 2 points thrown away. How on earth did we manage such a catastrophic downgrade on Barts, Semi and Holgate?
You had me until you mentioned Ajayi and fucking Holgate hahaha.
The goal last night should have been strangled at birth, but Heggebø couldn't be arsed. Then getting in behind Charlie Taylor shouldn't surprise anyone, what would have surprised us would have been O'Leary actually making a save.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
02-25-2026, 11:51 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-25-2026, 11:53 AM by Cheshire East Baggie.)
(02-25-2026, 09:40 AM)Fido Wrote: (02-25-2026, 09:23 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I just watched the highlights. Charlie Taylor gets a lot of abuse on here, but I can hardly find words to explain how completely, totally and utterly the Charlton goal was Phillips' fault. The scorer was in front of Phillips, but behind Taylor. Definitely Phillips' man to mark. As the man made his move, Phillips stepped up and stood still waving his arm for the offside. Why? Why not just do your job, go with him and get a challenge in? Idle and arrogant. Taylor gave him some serious verbals afterwards, but too late. 2 points thrown away. How on earth did we manage such a catastrophic downgrade on Barts, Semi and Holgate?
I've not watched it back again since last night but for me Taylor commits himself, misses it, and then that means Dykes then has a run on goal. Now if Phillips is trying to play him offside and fuggs it up then he is also to blame as well as O'leary for starting to run back to his goaline instead of being up in Dykes' face.
I think you're being unduly generous to Phillips when you share the blame with Taylor and O'Leary. Yes, maybe Taylor should have stretched a bit further and cleared the ball, O'Leary could have blocked the shot, but the scorer was Phillips' man to mark all day long.
He's truly awful - you can only measure players by the incidents that count - being an "average Championship defender" for all but a few seconds counts for nothing if the missing seconds cost you goals. There's a reason this guy hasn't played many games for his age, and it's not just injuries. He and Mepham strolled into the club thinking they'd be the dog's bollocks. Instead they've both been dog shit. Disappointing that they're on 3 year contracts or whatever.
(02-25-2026, 11:47 AM)Jacko Wrote: (02-25-2026, 09:23 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I just watched the highlights. Charlie Taylor gets a lot of abuse on here, but I can hardly find words to explain how completely, totally and utterly the Charlton goal was Phillips' fault. The scorer was in front of Phillips, but behind Taylor. Definitely Phillips' man to mark. As the man made his move, Phillips stepped up and stood still waving his arm for the offside. Why? Why not just do your job, go with him and get a challenge in? Idle and arrogant. Taylor gave him some serious verbals afterwards, but too late. 2 points thrown away. How on earth did we manage such a catastrophic downgrade on Barts, Semi and Holgate?
You had me until you mentioned Ajayi and fucking Holgate hahaha.
The goal last night should have been strangled at birth, but Heggebø couldn't be arsed. Then getting in behind Charlie Taylor shouldn't surprise anyone, what would have surprised us would have been O'Leary actually making a save.
Again, we're blaming Charlie Taylor and Max O'Leary. What about the player who let the scorer get into space?
Posts: 7,717
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(02-25-2026, 11:51 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (02-25-2026, 09:40 AM)Fido Wrote: (02-25-2026, 09:23 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I just watched the highlights. Charlie Taylor gets a lot of abuse on here, but I can hardly find words to explain how completely, totally and utterly the Charlton goal was Phillips' fault. The scorer was in front of Phillips, but behind Taylor. Definitely Phillips' man to mark. As the man made his move, Phillips stepped up and stood still waving his arm for the offside. Why? Why not just do your job, go with him and get a challenge in? Idle and arrogant. Taylor gave him some serious verbals afterwards, but too late. 2 points thrown away. How on earth did we manage such a catastrophic downgrade on Barts, Semi and Holgate?
I've not watched it back again since last night but for me Taylor commits himself, misses it, and then that means Dykes then has a run on goal. Now if Phillips is trying to play him offside and fuggs it up then he is also to blame as well as O'leary for starting to run back to his goaline instead of being up in Dykes' face.
I think you're being unduly generous to Phillips when you share the blame with Taylor and O'Leary. Yes, maybe Taylor should have stretched a bit further and cleared the ball, O'Leary could have blocked the shot, but the scorer was Phillips' man to mark all day long.
He's truly awful - you can only measure players by the incidents that count - being an "average Championship defender" for all but a few seconds counts for nothing if the missing seconds cost you goals. There's a reason this guy hasn't played many games for his age, and it's not just injuries. He and Mepham strolled into the club thinking they'd be the dog's bollocks. Instead they've both been dog shit. Disappointing that they're on 3 year contracts or whatever.
(02-25-2026, 11:47 AM)Jacko Wrote: (02-25-2026, 09:23 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I just watched the highlights. Charlie Taylor gets a lot of abuse on here, but I can hardly find words to explain how completely, totally and utterly the Charlton goal was Phillips' fault. The scorer was in front of Phillips, but behind Taylor. Definitely Phillips' man to mark. As the man made his move, Phillips stepped up and stood still waving his arm for the offside. Why? Why not just do your job, go with him and get a challenge in? Idle and arrogant. Taylor gave him some serious verbals afterwards, but too late. 2 points thrown away. How on earth did we manage such a catastrophic downgrade on Barts, Semi and Holgate?
You had me until you mentioned Ajayi and fucking Holgate hahaha.
The goal last night should have been strangled at birth, but Heggebø couldn't be arsed. Then getting in behind Charlie Taylor shouldn't surprise anyone, what would have surprised us would have been O'Leary actually making a save.
Again, we're blaming Charlie Taylor and Max O'Leary. What about the player who let the scorer get into space?
I'm not blaming anyone, once Heggebø shirked his challenge the way the play developed just seemed like a nailed on goal given the personnel involved.
Posts: 9,642
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
The majority of the squad are shit! I don't disagree with the criticisms here, btw. But you could have a Fred like this about most of the team.
|