Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
02-25-2026, 10:19 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-25-2026, 10:19 AM by Birdman1811.)
(02-25-2026, 10:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-25-2026, 10:00 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: If it's so simple, don't know why people stay in low paying jobs and don't go get some coaching badges and get into the sport. Be paid more for sure.
It's a simple game, like chess, as with all simple games, tiny, tiny influences have massive effects, that's part of game theory, which due to designing game's in the past I've studied.
If you want to improve conversion rate, you need to improve the number and quality of chances created, my point us that Molumby isn't going to do that because he doesn't have those skills, again, for the hard of reading, not his fault, the managers. If you don't have first teamers to do that, look at youth, forget "are they ready" do they have the pre-requisite skills? If yes, give them a chance, see if they grow into the level of football. This is exactly what Slav did with Ferguson and O'Shea, he was told by everyone they weren't ready, he felt they had the raw skills and traits needed for the positions that would have been too expensive to buy in.
Hindolo is a highly rated prospect, he's probably very raw, Whitwell was player of the season at a lower level, but had those skills. Play them. May find Mozza does, he's generally open to using youth a lot, it may be what saves us.
Not even mentioned Bostock who has looked capable already when he has played. As did Williams at right back, now forgotten.
The point still stands, you miss your chances you don’t win games, it’s as simple as that. All season we have missed guilt edged chances, not half chances, this is not about a paucity of chances created, not under Mason anyway this is the quality of finishing.
I am baffled at how people get jobs in football management at a semi and professional level. I know one who has managed at Prem level and one who has managed at semi-pro level and neither of them were bright, just good at football. The fact is football pays a lot of money because it’s popular not because it’s a complicated game. The new breed of mangers coming through, hide behind management speak and jargon there is no substance behind the word salad, as we are finding out at every level at the club.
I actually don't disagree with you on some aspects of that. I've said before some have taken data analytics too far and forgot that it's a sport played by humans and sometimes eyes see things data doesn't collect. There's also far too much emphasis placed on playing the game to become a coach. The two are barely connected.
We're actually saying the same thing here, I'm just saying how to fix it, and pushing Molumby into an unsuited role won't fix that, so try to find a solution that might. So look at youth if it's not in the first team squad.
Data is great, it can be used to explain certain intricacies of the game, it can help modify coaching plans and make tactical tweaks, it can't replace watching the game.
Posts: 9,626
Threads: 516
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(02-25-2026, 10:19 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (02-25-2026, 10:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-25-2026, 10:00 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: If it's so simple, don't know why people stay in low paying jobs and don't go get some coaching badges and get into the sport. Be paid more for sure.
It's a simple game, like chess, as with all simple games, tiny, tiny influences have massive effects, that's part of game theory, which due to designing game's in the past I've studied.
If you want to improve conversion rate, you need to improve the number and quality of chances created, my point us that Molumby isn't going to do that because he doesn't have those skills, again, for the hard of reading, not his fault, the managers. If you don't have first teamers to do that, look at youth, forget "are they ready" do they have the pre-requisite skills? If yes, give them a chance, see if they grow into the level of football. This is exactly what Slav did with Ferguson and O'Shea, he was told by everyone they weren't ready, he felt they had the raw skills and traits needed for the positions that would have been too expensive to buy in.
Hindolo is a highly rated prospect, he's probably very raw, Whitwell was player of the season at a lower level, but had those skills. Play them. May find Mozza does, he's generally open to using youth a lot, it may be what saves us.
Not even mentioned Bostock who has looked capable already when he has played. As did Williams at right back, now forgotten.
The point still stands, you miss your chances you don’t win games, it’s as simple as that. All season we have missed guilt edged chances, not half chances, this is not about a paucity of chances created, not under Mason anyway this is the quality of finishing.
I am baffled at how people get jobs in football management at a semi and professional level. I know one who has managed at Prem level and one who has managed at semi-pro level and neither of them were bright, just good at football. The fact is football pays a lot of money because it’s popular not because it’s a complicated game. The new breed of mangers coming through, hide behind management speak and jargon there is no substance behind the word salad, as we are finding out at every level at the club.
I actually don't disagree with you on some aspects of that. I've said before some have taken data analytics too far and forgot that it's a sport played by humans and sometimes eyes see things data doesn't collect. There's also far too much emphasis placed on playing the game to become a coach. The two are barely connected.
We're actually saying the same thing here, I'm just saying how to fix it, and pushing Molumby into an unsuited role won't fix that, so try to find a solution that might. So look at youth if it's not in the first team squad.
Data is great, it can be used to explain certain intricacies of the game, it can help modify coaching plans and make tactical tweaks, it can't replace watching the game.
+1 again, Birdy.
You're on fire today.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I'll say again too.
I don't blame Molumby one bit, he gave his all and tried, as he always does, in fact, I'm going to caveat a lot of what I've said with this, in some circumstances, he could do a job there, if we had two really dynamic box to box midfielders, in a game we'll look to press high and actually want that press triggered quickly, he'd be a strange, inverted defensive midfielder and it could work. He wins the ball high, lays a simple pass to the midfielders who then create the play.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(02-25-2026, 10:19 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (02-25-2026, 10:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-25-2026, 10:00 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: If it's so simple, don't know why people stay in low paying jobs and don't go get some coaching badges and get into the sport. Be paid more for sure.
It's a simple game, like chess, as with all simple games, tiny, tiny influences have massive effects, that's part of game theory, which due to designing game's in the past I've studied.
If you want to improve conversion rate, you need to improve the number and quality of chances created, my point us that Molumby isn't going to do that because he doesn't have those skills, again, for the hard of reading, not his fault, the managers. If you don't have first teamers to do that, look at youth, forget "are they ready" do they have the pre-requisite skills? If yes, give them a chance, see if they grow into the level of football. This is exactly what Slav did with Ferguson and O'Shea, he was told by everyone they weren't ready, he felt they had the raw skills and traits needed for the positions that would have been too expensive to buy in.
Hindolo is a highly rated prospect, he's probably very raw, Whitwell was player of the season at a lower level, but had those skills. Play them. May find Mozza does, he's generally open to using youth a lot, it may be what saves us.
Not even mentioned Bostock who has looked capable already when he has played. As did Williams at right back, now forgotten.
The point still stands, you miss your chances you don’t win games, it’s as simple as that. All season we have missed guilt edged chances, not half chances, this is not about a paucity of chances created, not under Mason anyway this is the quality of finishing.
I am baffled at how people get jobs in football management at a semi and professional level. I know one who has managed at Prem level and one who has managed at semi-pro level and neither of them were bright, just good at football. The fact is football pays a lot of money because it’s popular not because it’s a complicated game. The new breed of mangers coming through, hide behind management speak and jargon there is no substance behind the word salad, as we are finding out at every level at the club.
I actually don't disagree with you on some aspects of that. I've said before some have taken data analytics too far and forgot that it's a sport played by humans and sometimes eyes see things data doesn't collect. There's also far too much emphasis placed on playing the game to become a coach. The two are barely connected.
We're actually saying the same thing here, I'm just saying how to fix it, and pushing Molumby into an unsuited role won't fix that, so try to find a solution that might. So look at youth if it's not in the first team squad.
Data is great, it can be used to explain certain intricacies of the game, it can help modify coaching plans and make tactical tweaks, it can't replace watching the game.
I don’t think within the squad we have currently there is a fix, we’ve tried Maja and Price in that role and they have made no difference to the fact we don’t score enough goals. The most attacking threat we have had all season is when we actually did keep it simple and put crosses into the box for Heggebo to get on the end of. Not very sophisticated approach but it’s the only one that was working. We’ve had two young, hungry, done all their badges, went to uni in Ramsay’s case who either abandoned crossing early into the box from wide or simply decided to not bother, despite the fact our only fit and motivated forward for most of the season thrives on early balls put in the box from wide positions.
The squad is a mess, confidence is low and there hasn’t been a consistent way of playing that hasn’t been abandoned. I just don’t see the attacking midfield position whoever plays there as a huge problem in the grand scheme of this season. I certainly don’t blame Molumby for yesterday’s draw or can even criticise his performance in the position.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(02-25-2026, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-25-2026, 10:19 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (02-25-2026, 10:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-25-2026, 10:00 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: If it's so simple, don't know why people stay in low paying jobs and don't go get some coaching badges and get into the sport. Be paid more for sure.
It's a simple game, like chess, as with all simple games, tiny, tiny influences have massive effects, that's part of game theory, which due to designing game's in the past I've studied.
If you want to improve conversion rate, you need to improve the number and quality of chances created, my point us that Molumby isn't going to do that because he doesn't have those skills, again, for the hard of reading, not his fault, the managers. If you don't have first teamers to do that, look at youth, forget "are they ready" do they have the pre-requisite skills? If yes, give them a chance, see if they grow into the level of football. This is exactly what Slav did with Ferguson and O'Shea, he was told by everyone they weren't ready, he felt they had the raw skills and traits needed for the positions that would have been too expensive to buy in.
Hindolo is a highly rated prospect, he's probably very raw, Whitwell was player of the season at a lower level, but had those skills. Play them. May find Mozza does, he's generally open to using youth a lot, it may be what saves us.
Not even mentioned Bostock who has looked capable already when he has played. As did Williams at right back, now forgotten.
The point still stands, you miss your chances you don’t win games, it’s as simple as that. All season we have missed guilt edged chances, not half chances, this is not about a paucity of chances created, not under Mason anyway this is the quality of finishing.
I am baffled at how people get jobs in football management at a semi and professional level. I know one who has managed at Prem level and one who has managed at semi-pro level and neither of them were bright, just good at football. The fact is football pays a lot of money because it’s popular not because it’s a complicated game. The new breed of mangers coming through, hide behind management speak and jargon there is no substance behind the word salad, as we are finding out at every level at the club.
I actually don't disagree with you on some aspects of that. I've said before some have taken data analytics too far and forgot that it's a sport played by humans and sometimes eyes see things data doesn't collect. There's also far too much emphasis placed on playing the game to become a coach. The two are barely connected.
We're actually saying the same thing here, I'm just saying how to fix it, and pushing Molumby into an unsuited role won't fix that, so try to find a solution that might. So look at youth if it's not in the first team squad.
Data is great, it can be used to explain certain intricacies of the game, it can help modify coaching plans and make tactical tweaks, it can't replace watching the game.
I don’t think within the squad we have currently there is a fix, we’ve tried Maja and Price in that role and they have made no difference to the fact we don’t score enough goals. The most attacking threat we have had all season is when we actually did keep it simple and put crosses into the box for Heggebo to get on the end of. Not very sophisticated approach but it’s the only one that was working. We’ve had two young, hungry, done all their badges, went to uni in Ramsay’s case who either abandoned crossing early into the box from wide or simply decided to not bother, despite the fact our only fit and motivated forward for most of the season thrives on early balls put in the box from wide positions.
The squad is a mess, confidence is low and there hasn’t been a consistent way of playing that hasn’t been abandoned. I just don’t see the attacking midfield position whoever plays there as a huge problem in the grand scheme of this season. I certainly don’t blame Molumby for yesterday’s draw or can even criticise his performance in the position.
Don't disagree with that.
I'd like to see us try youth players if seniors aren't capable though, simply because it doesn't have any drawbacks and it's how teams end up with good young players they can sell or build around. Our fear of using them holds us back so much.
Posts: 9,626
Threads: 516
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(02-25-2026, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'll say again too.
I don't blame Molumby one bit, he gave his all and tried, as he always does, in fact, I'm going to caveat a lot of what I've said with this, in some circumstances, he could do a job there, if we had two really dynamic box to box midfielders, in a game we'll look to press high and actually want that press triggered quickly, he'd be a strange, inverted defensive midfielder and it could work. He wins the ball high, lays a simple pass to the midfielders who then create the play.
Absolutely right again.
If we had 2 flying fullbacks, we could play Mowatt and Molumby. But we don't so we can't.
I think it's really simple I can't believe other can't see it.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 1,131
Threads: 164
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(02-25-2026, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'll say again too.
I don't blame Molumby one bit, he gave his all and tried, as he always does, in fact, I'm going to caveat a lot of what I've said with this, in some circumstances, he could do a job there, if we had two really dynamic box to box midfielders, in a game we'll look to press high and actually want that press triggered quickly, he'd be a strange, inverted defensive midfielder and it could work. He wins the ball high, lays a simple pass to the midfielders who then create the play.
+1. Last night it did work in so much he got our tempo up from where it had been. Got us forward more. But, as has been said, he's not going to create anything up there himself.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
Whichever way you consider it, Molumby was far from the problem last night. Derek is right inasmuch as our finishing is poor. Look at Covs 1st goal against us and compare it to Maja's miss last night. Instinct rather than careful planning. Which leads me to my main concern, concentration. Particularly at the back but also up front. Another huge factor is confidence which is rock bottom. Of course, concentration and confidence can both be helped by good coaching, those boring drills that Roy and SGM loved so much.
Posts: 7,724
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Everyone knows my thoughts on Molumby, he's a fucking yard dog with very limited ability on the ball. Last night he won the ball high, won freekicks high and put a fright up defenders they just don't get from Maja loping towards them. Couple this with last night's xG which was an Albion high under Ramsay and our 3rd highest this season (after Sheffield United at home and Wrexham away). Presumably correlation doesn’t equal causation but to say it failed is just plain wrong.
Posts: 751
Threads: 8
Joined: Nov 2025
Reputation:
1
I would run around a lot if played behind a lone striker. It would get similar net results to Molumby doing it (us not winning).
As stated above, not his fault, he did his best, but if he's selected as our attacking fulcrum we might as well pack up and go home. He will never be a reliable creator or scorer of goals because he does not posses the technical ability, so don't build a system around him.
|