Things can only get better?
#1
I hope I'm wrong but anyone expecting things to miraculously get better now he's gone might be in for a bit of a shock.

He wasn't good and by last night he was totally lost having abandoned his principles and working with a stodgy squad capable of playing only one way (usually badly). Fact of the matter is, he shouldn't have been sacked... He should never have been appointed. He wasn't even in the top two things that are currently wrong with our football club.

1) Patel and Bilkul. It's really great that they stumped the money up a couple of years ago, it's even better than it looks as though they're going to pay off the MSD loan at the end of this year. But they set the tone for the football club and all we've seen is two years of non-joined-up decision making, panic and in the case of the Ramsay appointment an 'i know better than you attitude' that saw the end of Nestor. Now they have a chance to lay it on the line, it has to be Morrison until the end of the season (ironically a bigger rookie than either of our two permanent managers this season). We are in absolutely no position now to make another long-term appointment, certainly not until we know which league we will be in. 

2) Pearce and the mythical DoF role. Has anyone heard from Dom Price? If rumours are to be believed we're on the verge of another huge own goal by appointing a DoF and then not letting him do 90% of the things a DoF should do. Compounding this by letting the bloke jointly culpable for our most disjointed and unbalanced window in years carry on his duties unobstructed. This is once again a chance to set a tone and vision for the club. Nestor spoke about this but what was the plan? There wasn't a clear focus on youth, technical ability, athleticism - it's left us with this one-speed team who can only score once a month from a corner.

The playing squad has evolved but the malaise around the club has remained the same, we've seen off Mowbray, Mason and now Ramsay in 11 months. A football club off the pitch is like any other business and without a clear plan of what we're trying to do, or how were trying to get there it resembles a piss head fumbling round in the dark for his keys. Managers will continue to come and go as will players, until the structure at the top of this mess is sorted out.
Reply
#2
It’s like what I said a few days ago - it’s as if the whole things needs ripping up and starting again, from top to bottom. With people (not egos) who know what they’re doing.

Can’t comment on the whole Ian Pearce side of things as I don’t know much about all that. If he’s a malign influence then hopefully that veil has been lifted, too. But all of this has at least taught me two things:

1) Patel clearly is taking things very seriously
2) Never, ever to get too excited about what a new incoming manager sounds like during his first presser. Like some above him, it sounded like he had everyone fooled.

Whatever happens, it’s gonna be an interesting few weeks ahead.
Reply
#3
The one constant has been the lack of a plan. We could have accepted a couple of years consolidation and gone down the Eustace route 12 months ago. We could have gone down the youthful exuberance route and given a rookie manager a team with athleticism and pace. We did neither. Until this changes we'll keep churning through players and managers. This is Patel's huge chance to put a marker down and set some expectation around what he expects and what he wants to deliver. The Championship isn't a league you can just exist in and League One certainly isn't either.
Reply
#4
(02-25-2026, 07:03 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I hope I'm wrong but anyone expecting things to miraculously get better now he's gone might be in for a bit of a shock.

He wasn't good and by last night he was totally lost having abandoned his principles and working with a stodgy squad capable of playing only one way (usually badly). Fact of the matter is, he shouldn't have been sacked... He should never have been appointed. He wasn't even in the top two things that are currently wrong with our football club.

1) Patel and Bilkul. It's really great that they stumped the money up a couple of years ago, it's even better than it looks as though they're going to pay off the MSD loan at the end of this year. But they set the tone for the football club and all we've seen is two years of non-joined-up decision making, panic and in the case of the Ramsay appointment an 'i know better than you attitude' that saw the end of Nestor. Now they have a chance to lay it on the line, it has to be Morrison until the end of the season (ironically a bigger rookie than either of our two permanent managers this season). We are in absolutely no position now to make another long-term appointment, certainly not until we know which league we will be in. 

2) Pearce and the mythical DoF role. Has anyone heard from Dom Price? If rumours are to be believed we're on the verge of another huge own goal by appointing a DoF and then not letting him do 90% of the things a DoF should do. Compounding this by letting the bloke jointly culpable for our most disjointed and unbalanced window in years carry on his duties unobstructed. This is once again a chance to set a tone and vision for the club. Nestor spoke about this but what was the plan? There wasn't a clear focus on youth, technical ability, athleticism - it's left us with this one-speed team who can only score once a month from a corner.

The playing squad has evolved but the malaise around the club has remained the same, we've seen off Mowbray, Mason and now Ramsay in 11 months. A football club off the pitch is like any other business and without a clear plan of what we're trying to do, or how were trying to get there it resembles a piss head fumbling round in the dark for his keys. Managers will continue to come and go as will players, until the structure at the top of this mess is sorted out.

Good post, Ted. Exactly how I feel.
Reply
#5
To be a good manager, you have to know what you don't know. Patel doesn't know football and certainly doesn't know Championship football, so his only hope of success is to surround himself with people who do. Ashworth showed how much difference a good DoF can make, far more so than a good coach, so bringing in Price yet limiting his remit, is a massive red flag. Giving more responsibility to Pearce, could break the largest red flag ever record, best phone Norris.
Upshot is, even if Patel has realised what he doesn't know, his approach to dealing with it still seems flawed. It's all to reminiscent of the Sunderland Till I Die scenario, where rich people, with good intentions, just kept fucking up.
Reply
#6
Top post!

I take some solace that there is previous for American owners coming in and thinking they can shape English football to their will through their own genius......then realising they actually know shit and the English game will chew you up and spit you out as it has with Nestor and Ramsey.

Our game bears zero resemblance to the American Socher Leagues, as i think Patel now realises. If he needs to look anywhere for advice its his contacts at Bologna, but even that is a different beast to the Chump.

Bizarrely, the one club where the owners seem to have left the footballing side completely alone is at Wrexham. All razamataz off the field but an old hack English manager who likes playing a big man up top. They are in play-offs.

As has been said above we need a strong DOF who knows the English game and a freshening of the recruitment team. It may be that Price was another of Nestor's bright young things and Patel has got cold feet? He needs to book himself into the Travelodge for a fre months and spend some time with MM working out a real strategy for the playing side....as well as the financials.
Reply
#7
(02-25-2026, 08:55 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: To be a good manager, you have to know what you don't know. Patel doesn't know football and certainly doesn't know Championship football, so his only hope of success is to surround himself with people who do. Ashworth showed how much difference a good DoF can make, far more so than a good coach, so bringing in Price yet limiting his remit, is a massive red flag. Giving more responsibility to Pearce, could break the largest red flag ever record, best phone Norris.
Upshot is, even if Patel has realised what he doesn't know, his approach to dealing with it still seems flawed. It's all to reminiscent of the Sunderland Till I Die scenario, where rich people, with good intentions, just kept fucking up.

Your 1st sentence was exactly what Peace said. He knew nothing about football so he got people in that did know something.
Reply
#8
First thing Peace did was get advice from people more experienced than him, he studied various clubs throughout many leagues, it's why he was an early advocate for the DoF and head Coach set up, he'd seen clubs like us do better under that set up in Italy and Spain, while in England self sufficiency seemed impossible since every manager spunked endless cash.

He then went and got best people for the job in every area he could, he made mistakes, but he was damn quick to rectify them and learn.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)