Taking loan players off those seal cunts
#11
(02-22-2026, 11:52 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: As I’ve said on a previous thread, perhaps there is the thought that taking young, immature players on loan (whose development requires game time) - locally - helps them settle-in better. They probably don’t even need to relocate.

It would help a lot more if they were any good though, admittedly.

Which explains why all our loaned out kids seem to end up down south or in Scotland!

You'd think if JJA was any good, then we'd have a bloody better idea than most of which Academy kids were on a par or similar to him and could just go, OK we'll use our own and make them more saleable instead... That requires logic, which El prez never ever had. Hopefully it'll improve now he's gone>?
Reply
#12
(02-23-2026, 07:28 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I would have thought that our issues with psr have something to do with it.

You only have to look at our January signings overall to see that we are still very tight when it comes to conforming with the psr regulations.

A more pertinent question is why Cleary was allowed to go to Barnsley. Was it because the undoubtedly small undisclosed fee was vital for psr compliance or that we underestimated his levels. His goal involvements this season at league 1 in his first full season of first team football  suggest someone who might have been a genuinely useful option on the bench  rather than the paper candidates we currently have there.

I'm not buying PSR as excuse. Whilst I accept it's made things difficult, it doesn't excuse the absolute dross we've signed over the last 12-18 months. 

People talk as if we've had a transfer embargo and can't sign anyone, again, I accept it's been rough, but we have had funds to sign players, but what little funds we've had has been spunked on absolute shite. That's not on PSR, that's because we've had people running the show who haven't a clue what they're doing.
Reply
#13
(02-23-2026, 08:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 07:28 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I would have thought that our issues with psr have something to do with it.

You only have to look at our January signings overall to see that we are still very tight when it comes to conforming with the psr regulations.

A more pertinent question is why Cleary was allowed to go to Barnsley. Was it because the undoubtedly small undisclosed fee was vital for psr compliance or that we underestimated his levels. His goal involvements this season at league 1 in his first full season of first team football  suggest someone who might have been a genuinely useful option on the bench  rather than the paper candidates we currently have there.

I'm not buying PSR as excuse. Whilst I accept it's made things difficult, it doesn't excuse the absolute dross we've signed over the last 12-18 months. 

People talk as if we've had a transfer embargo and can't sign anyone, again, I accept it's been rough, but we have had funds to sign players, but what little funds we've had has been spunked on absolute shite. That's not on PSR, that's because we've had people running the show who haven't a clue what they're doing.

Exactly. Everything comes back to prez and Patel's football related decisions, and they've mostly been utter gash. Heggem is about the only shining light. And that was likely some over-inflated PSR busting deal.
Reply
#14
(02-23-2026, 08:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 07:28 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I would have thought that our issues with psr have something to do with it.

You only have to look at our January signings overall to see that we are still very tight when it comes to conforming with the psr regulations.

A more pertinent question is why Cleary was allowed to go to Barnsley. Was it because the undoubtedly small undisclosed fee was vital for psr compliance or that we underestimated his levels. His goal involvements this season at league 1 in his first full season of first team football  suggest someone who might have been a genuinely useful option on the bench  rather than the paper candidates we currently have there.

I'm not buying PSR as excuse. Whilst I accept it's made things difficult, it doesn't excuse the absolute dross we've signed over the last 12-18 months. 

People talk as if we've had a transfer embargo and can't sign anyone, again, I accept it's been rough, but we have had funds to sign players, but what little funds we've had has been spunked on absolute shite. That's not on PSR, that's because we've had people running the show who haven't a clue what they're doing.

It probably goes along way in explaining why in January, when we needed an injection in quality, we signed 2 18 year old youth players and a 22 year old who had never played at a higher level than league one. Plus a reserve goalie who we only signed on the basis that our reserve goalie left.

You would be right to think that our overall recruitment policy has been weak, but that's worth it's own thread.
Reply
#15
(02-22-2026, 11:19 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Can this be addressed, please? Why is it acceptable we've had two absolute busts from these cunts, yet we don't give our own academy players a chance. 

What is the process of thought within the club for this? Who is signing it off? Who is suggesting these players? 

I'm not saying this is to blame for our pending relegation, but surely this is an issue that needs to be addressed. 

It's so bizarre. 

Someone, somewhere, is taking the absolute piss out of us, and it's no doubt within. Who is it?

Whatever the reason is - you can see why our young talent seems to move on so easily.
Who would want to hang around knowing that they will most probably be made to sit on the bench whilst we chose loaned youth over our own. 
If they were any good, i can see why we play them, but in the predicament we are in now - just use our youth players that we will most likely need to rely on next season. 
Past seasons we have been pretty good at utilising our youth - but the past couple of years it seems not so well.
Reply
#16
Cleary left because he was out of contract, we offered him a new contract and turned us down that’s why he signed for Barnsley and that is why we get a sell on fee.
Nothing untoward done by the Albion Cleary left of his own accord.
Reply
#17
At least the Villa lad is getting a game, wtf was the point of the one from Palace???
Reply
#18
(02-23-2026, 10:35 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: At least the Villa lad is getting a game, wtf was the point of the one from Palace???

I'd rather he was sent back to Villa. 

I wish him all the best in his career, as I do with SIJ, but he's fucking wank.
Reply
#19
(02-23-2026, 10:35 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: At least the Villa lad is getting a game, wtf was the point of the one from Palace???

Don’t you mean 2 from palace, loan a player then change system,though we had to.
Reply
#20
(02-23-2026, 10:43 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 10:35 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: At least the Villa lad is getting a game, wtf was the point of the one from Palace???

I'd rather he was sent back to Villa. 

I wish him all the best in his career, as I do with SIJ, but he's fucking wank.

Rarely agreed with you more Josh.

Not so much on the SFIFJ career wish though, as I honestly think he was taking the piss in terms of effort at times while he was here.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: