Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(02-21-2026, 03:13 PM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Fourth, even better! Absolute barmy decisions. And we’ve just got worse and worse since.
How anyone blames Bilkul for this is beyond me. Are they saints, god no. But the stick is nuts.
Carlos was 100% the only thing that prevented this happening under Lai, and even then that was a massive gamble and a healthy slice of hindsight. He didn’t exactly light up the league with previous roles, nor roles since.
The “pros” Bruce and Mowbray didn’t do any better. It’s too simplistic.
Didn’t he take Huddersfield to a play off final?
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
02-21-2026, 03:19 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-21-2026, 03:20 PM by MrBater.)
(02-21-2026, 03:18 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (02-21-2026, 03:13 PM)MrBater Wrote: (02-21-2026, 03:08 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: 100%.
Squad with no pace and technical ability in not scoring shocker.
Carlos was propping things up, left and they were clueless. The summer signings were garbage on the whole and they decided two novices should come in when we were in freefall.
thing is on paper the defence we've got really should not be as shit as it is... that has to be the managers, surely? Fugging you can't be that bad and play for Liverpool in Europe not long ago, can you!? Surely?! He was playing for Derby last season don’t forget and, with the right partner, would be fine. He looked good with Heggem v Blackburn. Question is why you would buy a slow right footer to play alongside him and the slow right footer at RB (Gilchrist).
I think what happened was they got lucky with Heggem, and the underhand dodgy deal when selling him that they thought this club lark was easy. they showed with Fellows that they had no real clue.
(02-21-2026, 03:19 PM)Duffers Wrote: (02-21-2026, 03:13 PM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Fourth, even better! Absolute barmy decisions. And we’ve just got worse and worse since.
How anyone blames Bilkul for this is beyond me. Are they saints, god no. But the stick is nuts.
Carlos was 100% the only thing that prevented this happening under Lai, and even then that was a massive gamble and a healthy slice of hindsight. He didn’t exactly light up the league with previous roles, nor roles since.
The “pros” Bruce and Mowbray didn’t do any better. It’s too simplistic.
Didn’t he take Huddersfield to a play off final?
Yeah, but didn't val also take Barnsley to the POs? Champo is always open to surprise packages sneaking in. Look at the top 6 this year.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(02-21-2026, 03:19 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (02-21-2026, 03:13 PM)MrBater Wrote: (02-21-2026, 03:08 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: 100%.
Squad with no pace and technical ability in not scoring shocker.
Carlos was propping things up, left and they were clueless. The summer signings were garbage on the whole and they decided two novices should come in when we were in freefall.
thing is on paper the defence we've got really should not be as shit as it is... that has to be the managers, surely? Fugging you can't be that bad and play for Liverpool in Europe not long ago, can you!? Surely?!
Correct.
Ramsey briefly started getting it right defensively, but still wasn't great, but hasn't been able to create any form of attacking intent or ability, which admittedly is a squad weakness but he's not helped it with the same stupid mistakes Mason made. TBF Birdie Carlos kept us solid but we couldn’t score.
Mowbray tried to be more attacking and we start shipping goals.
Mason made us solid again but in time we started to leak goals and stopped scoring.
In the meantime we lost the best RW in the league to be replaced by a left wing back and Maja lost interest / confidence / form.
Posts: 10,435
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Ramsay out tonight.
Woy and Megson now in to save us
If we go down the owners should give us away to someone who knows how to run a football club.
Posts: 1,636
Threads: 52
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
11
(02-21-2026, 03:13 PM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Fourth, even better! Absolute barmy decisions. And we’ve just got worse and worse since.
How anyone blames Bilkul for this is beyond me. Are they saints, god no. But the stick is nuts.
Carlos was 100% the only thing that prevented this happening under Lai, and even then that was a massive gamble and a healthy slice of hindsight. He didn’t exactly light up the league with previous roles, nor roles since.
The “pros” Bruce and Mowbray didn’t do any better. It’s too simplistic.
Appointed Mowbray FACT
Appointed Mason FACT
Appointed Ramsay FACT
Got a dreadful price for fellows FACT
Appointed Nestor FACT
Filled this squad with square pegs for round holes FACT
The only fucking thing they have done is paint the bastard stadium and gave us a little flag. It’s 100 percent on them
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Kept us out of administration, prevented inevitable points deductions. As someone else said, without Carlos this drop off would have happened under Bruce 4 years ago.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Not sure there’s much more point in going down the road of blaming the owner. Unless you've got very deep pockets what are you going do about them.
An owners main responsibility is to ensure the financial viability of the club, and unless they have some specialist knowledge of football, keep your distance from the playing side of the club.
It's very early days in Bikul's ownership of the club and they didn't inherit a positive situation from the previous owners.
My view is that both the owners and us fans are guilty of having totally unrealistic expectations of the club, which has led to managers being dismissed too soon, when they may have been doing as close to as good a job as was possible given the circumstances.
This season has been a perfect storm of bad things happening. From injuries, having to sell some of our best players, having to concentrate in the transfer window on one area of the squad when other areas needed attention, to catastrophic errors on the pitch which have meant we have not got as many points as our performances warranted.
If Bikul are at fault for one thing, it would be the appointment if Ramsey, who seems to be totally unsuited to the role of manager of a championship club. How they rectify that mistake will be telling. At this stage I have no idea what the right thing to do is. No solutions look palatable to me.
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(02-21-2026, 03:34 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kept us out of administration, prevented inevitable points deductions. As someone else said, without Carlos this drop off would have happened under Bruce 4 years ago.
Still think we’re comfortably staying up, Jacko?
Posts: 95
Threads: 2
Joined: Feb 2026
Reputation:
0
Have no money. FACT
No one in for Fellows but have absolutely no choice but to sell on account of point one. FACT
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(02-21-2026, 03:34 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kept us out of administration, prevented inevitable points deductions. As someone else said, without Carlos this drop off would have happened under Bruce 4 years ago.
The owners brought a business investment, they didn’t do it as an act of charity and there would have been other buyers if they hadn’t become the preferred buyer. Since then they have made some absolutely atrocious decisions, that aren’t hindsight they were blatantly obvious and avoidable.
Mowbray - whether you believe the bobbins about his amazing stats or not was the complete opposite of Corberan, open, flimsy football, allowing players ‘express themselves’. Or more accurately as ever allowing the team to predictably become disorganised, easy to play against and look as fragile as Bambi.
Mason - never managed a club in the EFL or any major league (a handful of caretaker games for Tottenham doesn’t count), in the most difficult, transitional year in decades given to a fucking novice manager. The decision made even worse by the fact we could have had Eustace!
Ramsey- a manager whose highest playing achievement is the Welsh leagues and managing in a glorified exhibition league in the MSL. Again
What was the ‘data driven’ analysis that brought these three managers to the club?
No DoF even though it was a pivotal season in the clubs history, where a clear and coherent strategy was needed and the very best should have been in place from the get go.
The squad has a handful of players still in it from when Corberan was managing the club, it’s a moot point to compare before and after he went, with so little of the squad being the same. What is comparable is the players we’ve brought in after selling our best players, and it’s clearly disjointed, incoherent, and poorer than it’s been not just in the last few season but for the last 20 years. Yes we needed to reduce the wage bill and age of the team but we did spend money and just as much as our rivals bar those with parachute money or extremely wealthy owners, and it’s a complete dogs dinner. What was the plan? Players that fit a possession based system, fast, strong running counter attack suited players? If you can tell me what type of football our squad is cut out for you’re a better coach than those we’ve employed this season.
The key positions this season to fill were DoF, Manager and improve the scouting network significantly… have we done any of this well? This is a pivotal and transitional season and I’m at a complete loss not just in hindsight at how we have tried to navigate it with novices and gaping holes in the football department.
Whatever happens this season, huge changes need to be made at the club, and the owners need to employ the very best people who know football to oversee those changes, because not doing so is why they are staring League One and yet more financial woes in the face.
|