Cancelling Elections
#51
(02-18-2026, 06:28 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It needs to be funded by the individuals in receipt of it by asset sales or a form of insurance product. The safety net should only exist for those who need it.

So what is the point of building assets or getting insurance?
Do nothing. Have the state pension. The state fund your care anyway. Kerching.
Reply
#52
(02-18-2026, 07:11 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(02-18-2026, 06:28 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It needs to be funded by the individuals in receipt of it by asset sales or a form of insurance product. The safety net should only exist for those who need it.

So what is the point of building assets or getting insurance?
Do nothing. Have the state pension. The state fund your care anyway. Kerching.

So the rich get to keep their assets to pass on to their children and grandchildren because they can afford care without impacting their estate that much, but those who have built up a modest amount of pension and own a house etc, should lose everything.
Reply
#53
(02-18-2026, 08:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-18-2026, 07:11 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(02-18-2026, 06:28 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It needs to be funded by the individuals in receipt of it by asset sales or a form of insurance product. The safety net should only exist for those who need it.

So what is the point of building assets or getting insurance?
Do nothing. Have the state pension. The state fund your care anyway. Kerching.

So the rich get to keep their assets to pass on to their children and grandchildren because they can afford care without impacting their estate that much, but those who have built up a modest amount of pension and own a house etc, should lose everything.

Ah yes, of course. Keeping the middle classes in their.lane.
Reply
#54
A strange dichotomy on this bored of folk on one hand telling Proth his assets, pensions etc are for using himself after retirement, not passing on to his beneficiaries (several other threads), then on this thread saying it would be grossly unfair for folk who can afford it to use their assets, pensions etc to fund their care following retirement instead of the State, because there would be nothing left to pass on (they'd lose everything).
Reply
#55
As above

"So the rich get to keep their assets to pass on to their children and grandchildren because they can afford care without impacting their estate that much, but those who have built up a modest amount of pension and own a house etc, should lose everything. "


What I find odd is Proths mewling and wailing about what's the point of working or paying into pensions etc if they're gonna take it in tax. But it's ok to take it off you for your care home fees.

I can only conclude he has a majority stake in HC One or Barchester Healthcare
Reply
#56
It’s a minority of us that will need long term care. At the moment the majority of local government finance goes to a tiny minority of people, many of whom have substantial assets. When you are saving for your old age who are you saving for? I’m saving for me and Mrs P, whilst making provision for my kids where I can.

My kids don’t have any right to an inheritance. Nor does the state have any moral claim on what I have saved using post tax income.

What on Earth is the world coming to when the most affluent generations in our history would rather their poorer kids paid for their long term care? What a bunch of cunts.
Reply
#57
(02-19-2026, 07:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote: It’s a minority of us that will need long term care. At the moment the majority of local government finance goes to a tiny minority of people, many of whom have substantial assets. When you are saving for your old age who are you saving for? I’m saving for me and Mrs P, whilst making provision for my kids where I can.

My kids don’t have any right to an inheritance. Nor does the state have any moral claim on what I have saved using post tax income.

What on Earth is the world coming to when the most affluent generations in our history would rather their poorer kids paid for their long term care? What a bunch of cunts.

Completely agree. Like a lot of things in life today there needs to be a refocus. Inheritance should be seen as a "bonus" not a right. You don't need a four-bedroom house as an elderly couple and as you say, the expectation that you get to keep that and expect others to pick up the tab for your partner's care when they need it is obscene, quite frankly.
Reply
#58
So the lower middle class and working class who have built up some modest assets should lose 80,90,100% of them, but the wealthy who can afford to put money aside and in a lot of cases thanks to generations of inheritance, privilege and connections via private education rather than anything particularly that they have achieved get to continue to pass on wealth to their kids. Meanwhile those who have come from working class or lower working class backgrounds and bought a house and saved a bit can have that wiped out on their care so their children can start the process all over again.

The right of centre on this board are going to have to explain how this proposed system bridges the massive inequality in this country. It seems this plan would merely cement the class system and create an ever widening gap between the rich and the rest of the country. It doesn’t surprise me that they’d rather punch down than up, but depressing all the same.
Reply
#59
I'm not sure whether you are spectacularly missing the point or just thought you'd get out your first rant of the day (with no actual idea as how to move anything forwards, as per usual). 

Anyway, let's give you a not uncommon example. A couple are sat in a 4-bed house worth £800k. One of them needs to go into care. The income/wealth is taken into consideration but not the house, let's say it is £30k per year in a pension and they have about £30k in savings. I might not be completely right on the figures but their care will be pretty much be 100% taken care of by the state. The couple around the corner have lived at home for ten years in order to build up a deposit to buy their own home and now have an enormous mortgage and as both of them need to work they pay for childcare too. They both have student loans that they are paying off. No final salary scheme and chances are their pension earning power will be slowly eroded over the years. Their £2500 grand a year in council tax is pretty much eaten up by social care for the people mentioned before. For me, this isn't fair.

The game has changed and the cans that have been kicked down the road for so long need picking up. Those will the deepest pockets will need to contribute having not had to pay for student fees, have had the advantage of very low house prices and have earned a lot of wealth purely through sitting in their own front lounge but feel they have a right to keep that whilst most young families are struggling. There should be incentives for those that can afford it to make provisions for themselves and for their care in old age and, so, when it comes to it, they have the money (or at least most it) to do so.
Reply
#60
(02-19-2026, 09:42 AM)Fido Wrote: I'm not sure whether you are spectacularly missing the point or just thought you'd get out your first rant of the day (with no actual idea as how to move anything forwards, as per usual). 

Anyway, let's give you a not uncommon example. A couple are sat in a 4-bed house worth £800k. One of them needs to go into care. The income/wealth is taken into consideration but not the house, let's say it is £30k per year in a pension and they have about £30k in savings. I might not be completely right on the figures but their care will be pretty much be 100% taken care of by the state. The couple around the corner have lived at home for ten years in order to build up a deposit to buy their own home and now have an enormous mortgage and as both of them need to work they pay for childcare too. They both have student loans that they are paying off. No final salary scheme and chances are their pension earning power will be slowly eroded over the years. Their £2500 grand a year in council tax is pretty much eaten up by social care for the people mentioned before. For me, this isn't fair.

The game has changed and the cans that have been kicked down the road for so long need picking up. Those will the deepest pockets will need to contribute having not had to pay for student fees, have had the advantage of very low house prices and have earned a lot of wealth purely through sitting in their own front lounge but feel they have a right to keep that whilst most young families are struggling. There should be incentives for those that can afford it to make provisions for themselves and for their care in old age and, so, when it comes to it, they have the money (or at least most it) to do so.


  • [b]Over £23,250 (Self-funder):[/b] If you have savings, investments, or assets (including the value of your home if you move into residential care) worth more than £23,250, you must pay the full cost of your care.


  • [b]Between £14,250 and £23,250:[/b] You will pay a contribution from your income plus a "tariff" income of £1 a week for every £250 of capital you have between these limits.


  • [b]Under £14,250:[/b] The local authority will pay for your care, but you will still contribute most of your income (such as pensions). 
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: