James O’Brien shows no deal Brexiteers idiocy.
#1
Still idiots will say let’s do it!
Reply
#2
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters
Reply
#3
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.
Reply
#4
(06-28-2019, 07:17 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.
lets say we reach October 31st and we have not agreed a deal, the EU don't give us an extension and article 50 isn't revoked, what happens then? Would the EU just boot us out or would they decide to make some kind of concessions / offer an extension at the 18th hour?
I doubt it will reach that point though as i think there may well be a stitch up ; whereby Boris agrees a few cosmetic changes and using the pressure of a ticking clock, to sell what is really May's deal with a few unimportant changes to both parliament and the public as a new deal.
Reply
#5
(06-28-2019, 07:17 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.

If you revoke without another referendum then you are ignoring the democratic vote of the people, you may say the polls now say remain is a majority but that is not a democratic vote, anyway I doubt they could revoke without a vote in Parliament and it seems unlikely that vote would go through.

The Government would almost certainly collapse if no deal becomes a possibility which would lead to a GE in which it is a possible that the Brexit party could get a majority or certainly a large number of seats.

All actions have implications
Reply
#6
(06-28-2019, 07:31 PM)I strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:17 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.

If you revoke without another referendum then you are ignoring the democratic vote of the people, you may say the polls now say remain is a majority but that is not a democratic vote, anyway I doubt they could revoke without a vote in Parliament and it seems unlikely that vote would go through.

The Government would almost certainly collapse if no deal becomes a possibility which would lead to a GE in which it is a possible that the Brexit party could get a majority or certainly a large number of seats.

All actions have implications

As Mark fuckwit Francois would say that’s our choice...
Reply
#7
(06-28-2019, 07:29 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:17 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.
lets say we reach October 31st and we have not agreed a deal, the EU don't give us an extension and article 50 isn't revoked, what happens then? Would the EU just boot us out or would they decide to make some kind of concessions / offer an extension at the 18th hour?
I doubt it will reach that point though as i think there may well be a stitch up ; whereby Boris agrees a few cosmetic changes and using the pressure of a ticking clock, to sell what is really May's deal with a few unimportant changes to both parliament and the public as a new deal.

Then we would no longer be a member of the EU and would be subject to the same rules as any other third country including tariffs etc, although  I believe some contingency plans are in place.
Reply
#8
(06-28-2019, 07:31 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:17 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.

If you revoke without another referendum then you are ignoring the democratic vote of the people, you may say the polls now say remain is a majority but that is not a democratic vote, anyway I doubt they could revoke without a vote in Parliament and it seems unlikely that vote would go through.

The Government would almost certainly collapse if no deal becomes a possibility which would lead to a GE in which it is a possible that the Brexit party could get a majority or certainly a large number of seats.

All actions have implications

Parliament is sovereign, not the people. Our entire democratic structure has been like this since the end of the Commonwealth. It is up to the MPs to decide whether screwing over the country is worth enacting the referendum result. To be honest though this entire thing is utterly pointless, if we want a trade deal with the EU we need to agree to the terms set out in the withdrawal agreement and if we want a trade deal with the US then we will sacrifice our political independence to Washington.

Ultimately it boils down to this, is pissing off half* of the country worth it? That works both ways, whatever they do they are damned. They can revoke Article 50 unilaterally and destroy trust in British democracy, screwing over a significant proportion of leave voters, or they can leave without a deal and piss off those who don't want it and enact the shitshow that will develop as a result.

The Tories are screwed regardless, they cannot survive either action. They need to get the withdrawal agreement through as it is the only way they can hobble on through to 2022 and salvage their party. If the government collapses then the Brexit Party will pick up votes and seats, the issue is so will the Lib Dems. The only party that stands any chance of getting a majority is the Labour party due to FPTP but even then that's very unlikely.

Regardless, the whole thing has been a bodge job of the highest order. The only way to salvage a Brexit deal was to put the initial backstop arrangement (sea border) to a referendum in Northern Ireland who it effects, enact the result and then stay in the single market but introduce Swiss-like immigration schemes. At least we'll get electoral reform out of it though, hey?

*half of the electorate, and even then it isn't half for either side.

(06-28-2019, 07:29 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:17 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.
lets say we reach October 31st and we have not agreed a deal, the EU don't give us an extension and article 50 isn't revoked, what happens then? Would the EU just boot us out or would they decide to make some kind of concessions / offer an extension at the 18th hour?
I doubt it will reach that point though as i think there may well be a stitch up ; whereby Boris agrees a few cosmetic changes and using the pressure of a ticking clock, to sell what is really May's deal with a few unimportant changes to both parliament and the public as a new deal.

The EU will offer us an extension, we will accept it if we aren't stupid. The question then revolves around whether Macron will veto the extension despite being pressured by the EU and particularly Ireland and Cyprus. There is no amending the withdrawal agreement though without an extension, the EU parliament isn't in session until October so it is logistically extremely difficult. If we do end up leaving without a deal we are screwed.

The only thing Boris or Hunt can do is push through the withdrawal agreement and try to dress up the political declaration a bit. The only thing that could be changed in the Withdrawal Agreement is moving the backstop to the Irish Sea but that would likely collapse the government as the DUP don't like that suggestion.
Reply
#9
(06-28-2019, 07:51 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:31 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:17 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.

If you revoke without another referendum then you are ignoring the democratic vote of the people, you may say the polls now say remain is a majority but that is not a democratic vote, anyway I doubt they could revoke without a vote in Parliament and it seems unlikely that vote would go through.

The Government would almost certainly collapse if no deal becomes a possibility which would lead to a GE in which it is a possible that the Brexit party could get a majority or certainly a large number of seats.

All actions have implications

Parliament is sovereign, not the people. Our entire democratic structure has been like this since the end of the Commonwealth. It is up to the MPs to decide whether screwing over the country is worth enacting the referendum result. To be honest though this entire thing is utterly pointless, if we want a trade deal with the EU we need to agree to the terms set out in the withdrawal agreement and if we want a trade deal with the US then we will sacrifice our political independence to Washington.

Ultimately it boils down to this, is pissing off half* of the country worth it? That works both ways, whatever they do they are damned. They can revoke Article 50 unilaterally and destroy trust in British democracy, screwing over a significant proportion of leave voters, or they can leave without a deal and piss off those who don't want it and enact the shitshow that will develop as a result.

The Tories are screwed regardless, they cannot survive either action. They need to get the withdrawal agreement through as it is the only way they can hobble on through to 2022 and salvage their party. If the government collapses then the Brexit Party will pick up votes and seats, the issue is so will the Lib Dems. The only party that stands any chance of getting a majority is the Labour party due to FPTP but even then that's very unlikely.

Regardless, the whole thing has been a bodge job of the highest order. The only way to salvage a Brexit deal was to put the initial backstop arrangement (sea border) to a referendum in Northern Ireland who it effects, enact the result and then stay in the single market but introduce Swiss-like immigration schemes. At least we'll get electoral reform out of it though, hey?

*half of the electorate, and even then it isn't half for either side.

We’ve got our country back... that’s what matters!
Reply
#10
(06-28-2019, 07:29 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:17 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 07:09 PM)strawman Wrote:
(06-28-2019, 06:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Still idiots will say let’s do it!

They keep saying that Parliament wouldn't allow a no deal brexit, except it is not within their gift, it is entirely within the control of the EU.

Unless either 
a) A deal is agreed
b) The EU agree to another extension 
c) Another referendum (no time and what then - best of 3)
d) Another GE

(but c & d would probably depend on the EU granting an extension to allow time for those anyway.)

then on the 31st October we leave with no deal, that is the default and has been stated as so by the EU.

The only exception to this is the improbable and politically suicidal option of revocation of Article 50. (and that would probably have to be linked to another referendum)

So all those politicians who continually voted against any kind of deal, including all SNP MP's are by their actions no-deal Brexiters

If it's a choice between revoking Article 50 and allowing no deal to go forward, then only the former can happen. Revoking may be political suicide but the so is the latter, and I'd rather the UK not become food for the circling vultures.

Also, the government will collapse if no deal becomes a possibility.
lets say we reach October 31st and we have not agreed a deal, the EU don't give us an extension and article 50 isn't revoked, what happens then? Would the EU just boot us out or would they decide to make some kind of concessions / offer an extension at the 18th hour?
I doubt it will reach that point though as i think there may well be a stitch up ; whereby Boris agrees a few cosmetic changes and using the pressure of a ticking clock, to sell what is really May's deal with a few unimportant changes to both parliament and the public as a new deal.

That later outcome won't please the Brexit extreme head bangers and they will turn on Boris in a flash.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: