No identity, no clarity...
#21
(01-31-2026, 09:03 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

I disagree, we did not have to employ two managers without Championship or league 1 or 2 experience or similar from Europe. I don’t understand the need to take such risks with the clubs future. If that is looking down my nose at the process, so be it.

No we didn't, but Steve Bruce was just as bad and we needed Carlos to turn us round. Neither approach has worked for us which is why I'm starting to think we need to go down in order to really flush the chain on a pretty miserable decade.

This is a weak argument, we didn’t have to go from Bruce/Mowbray to Mason. Going down will put us back years, I doubt we would be spending our way out of the division and all the time we will lose touch with our local rivals. This season has been avoidable, it is either arrogance or naivety that we thought we could put a rookie manager in charge of a weakened squad in such a pivotal season.

Course we didn't. I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, I'm just in a never ending cycle of trying to get to the bottom of what you'd be happy with. You talk a lot in end results without any acceptance that good process is what enables the result. I agreed that given the timing I don't think I'd have sacked Mason. You're also arguing directly against the sort of method that got us halfway up the PL without a wealthy backer. Agree with the rest of what you say, there is no room for positively around a relegation to the third tier. Fact remains we've tried one experienced manager and two rookies, albeit one who's managed abroad and we've been heading towards the bottom three under all of them.

He’s never happy. Live with it.
Reply
#22
(01-31-2026, 09:03 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

I disagree, we did not have to employ two managers without Championship or league 1 or 2 experience or similar from Europe. I don’t understand the need to take such risks with the clubs future. If that is looking down my nose at the process, so be it.

No we didn't, but Steve Bruce was just as bad and we needed Carlos to turn us round. Neither approach has worked for us which is why I'm starting to think we need to go down in order to really flush the chain on a pretty miserable decade.

This is a weak argument, we didn’t have to go from Bruce/Mowbray to Mason. Going down will put us back years, I doubt we would be spending our way out of the division and all the time we will lose touch with our local rivals. This season has been avoidable, it is either arrogance or naivety that we thought we could put a rookie manager in charge of a weakened squad in such a pivotal season.

Course we didn't. I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, I'm just in a never ending cycle of trying to get to the bottom of what you'd be happy with. You talk a lot in end results without any acceptance that good process is what enables the result. I agreed that given the timing I don't think I'd have sacked Mason. You're also arguing directly against the sort of method that got us halfway up the PL without a wealthy backer. Agree with the rest of what you say, there is no room for positively around a relegation to the third tier. Fact remains we've tried one experienced manager and two rookies, albeit one who's managed abroad and we've been heading towards the bottom three under all of them.

Here you go… 

Choose a manager with Champ experience that has had some degree of success, such as Eustace or Rowett etc for example. Not exciting, not cool bro, not even that imaginative but we just needed stability. 

Employ a decent DoF who has a handle on the reality of the Champ and has a clear plan for improving the football department. Not next season but this one, this was always going to be the squeaky bottom season and to not prioritise the position baffles me. 

Owners to listen to them and accept they know more about the league than they do. 

That isn’t too much to ask of new owners, just to steady the ship and see us through choppy waters. Instead we bring in Mowbray on some spurious stats, a completely untried Mason and now a stubborn and limited experienced Ramsay. None of this is hindsight, I’ve argued these points before many times and got shot down many times by people saying we could afford to take the risk. 

The owners clearly know about finance, they clearly don’t understand the competitiveness of the Championship. Even if we survive this season, this has been a needless experiment when we just needed calm, boring, pragmatic decisions made by those who have experience of the league, whilst the owners did what they are best at and that is clearly managing money not footballers.
Reply
#23
(01-31-2026, 09:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:03 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I disagree, we did not have to employ two managers without Championship or league 1 or 2 experience or similar from Europe. I don’t understand the need to take such risks with the clubs future. If that is looking down my nose at the process, so be it.

No we didn't, but Steve Bruce was just as bad and we needed Carlos to turn us round. Neither approach has worked for us which is why I'm starting to think we need to go down in order to really flush the chain on a pretty miserable decade.

This is a weak argument, we didn’t have to go from Bruce/Mowbray to Mason. Going down will put us back years, I doubt we would be spending our way out of the division and all the time we will lose touch with our local rivals. This season has been avoidable, it is either arrogance or naivety that we thought we could put a rookie manager in charge of a weakened squad in such a pivotal season.

Course we didn't. I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, I'm just in a never ending cycle of trying to get to the bottom of what you'd be happy with. You talk a lot in end results without any acceptance that good process is what enables the result. I agreed that given the timing I don't think I'd have sacked Mason. You're also arguing directly against the sort of method that got us halfway up the PL without a wealthy backer. Agree with the rest of what you say, there is no room for positively around a relegation to the third tier. Fact remains we've tried one experienced manager and two rookies, albeit one who's managed abroad and we've been heading towards the bottom three under all of them.

Here you go… 

Choose a manager with Champ experience that has had some degree of success, such as Eustace or Rowett etc for example. Not exciting, not cool bro, not even that imaginative but we just needed stability. 

Employ a decent DoF who has a handle on the reality of the Champ and has a clear plan for improving the football department. Not next season but this one, this was always going to be the squeaky bottom season and to not prioritise the position baffles me. 

Owners to listen to them and accept they know more about the league than they do. 

That isn’t too much to ask of new owners, just to steady the ship and see us through choppy waters. Instead we bring in Mowbray on some spurious stats, a completely untried Mason and now a stubborn and limited experienced Ramsay. None of this is hindsight, I’ve argued these points before many times and got shot down many times by people saying we could afford to take the risk. 

The owners clearly know about finance, they clearly don’t understand the competitiveness of the Championship. Even if we survive this season, this has been a needless experiment when we just needed calm, boring, pragmatic decisions made by those who have experience of the league, whilst the owners did what they are best at and that is clearly managing money not footballers.

Almost like a championship pulis  Big Grin
Reply
#24
(01-31-2026, 09:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:03 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I disagree, we did not have to employ two managers without Championship or league 1 or 2 experience or similar from Europe. I don’t understand the need to take such risks with the clubs future. If that is looking down my nose at the process, so be it.

No we didn't, but Steve Bruce was just as bad and we needed Carlos to turn us round. Neither approach has worked for us which is why I'm starting to think we need to go down in order to really flush the chain on a pretty miserable decade.

This is a weak argument, we didn’t have to go from Bruce/Mowbray to Mason. Going down will put us back years, I doubt we would be spending our way out of the division and all the time we will lose touch with our local rivals. This season has been avoidable, it is either arrogance or naivety that we thought we could put a rookie manager in charge of a weakened squad in such a pivotal season.

Course we didn't. I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, I'm just in a never ending cycle of trying to get to the bottom of what you'd be happy with. You talk a lot in end results without any acceptance that good process is what enables the result. I agreed that given the timing I don't think I'd have sacked Mason. You're also arguing directly against the sort of method that got us halfway up the PL without a wealthy backer. Agree with the rest of what you say, there is no room for positively around a relegation to the third tier. Fact remains we've tried one experienced manager and two rookies, albeit one who's managed abroad and we've been heading towards the bottom three under all of them.

Here you go… 

Choose a manager with Champ experience that has had some degree of success, such as Eustace or Rowett etc for example. Not exciting, not cool bro, not even that imaginative but we just needed stability. 

Employ a decent DoF who has a handle on the reality of the Champ and has a clear plan for improving the football department. Not next season but this one, this was always going to be the squeaky bottom season and to not prioritise the position baffles me. 

Owners to listen to them and accept they know more about the league than they do. 

That isn’t too much to ask of new owners, just to steady the ship and see us through choppy waters. Instead we bring in Mowbray on some spurious stats, a completely untried Mason and now a stubborn and limited experienced Ramsay. None of this is hindsight, I’ve argued these points before many times and got shot down many times by people saying we could afford to take the risk. 

The owners clearly know about finance, they clearly don’t understand the competitiveness of the Championship. Even if we survive this season, this has been a needless experiment when we just needed calm, boring, pragmatic decisions made by those who have experience of the league, whilst the owners did what they are best at and that is clearly managing money not footballers.

I'd agree in that Nestor has been their failing. He should have gone with Mason. Notwithstanding the fact that at the time the Mowbray choice seemed to make perfect sense, especially given the job he did in roughly similar circumstances at Sunderland. It's not a perfect science, Dekka.

Can you imagine our fans if we'd have appointed Rowett in the summer?!
Reply
#25
(01-31-2026, 10:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:03 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: No we didn't, but Steve Bruce was just as bad and we needed Carlos to turn us round. Neither approach has worked for us which is why I'm starting to think we need to go down in order to really flush the chain on a pretty miserable decade.

This is a weak argument, we didn’t have to go from Bruce/Mowbray to Mason. Going down will put us back years, I doubt we would be spending our way out of the division and all the time we will lose touch with our local rivals. This season has been avoidable, it is either arrogance or naivety that we thought we could put a rookie manager in charge of a weakened squad in such a pivotal season.

Course we didn't. I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, I'm just in a never ending cycle of trying to get to the bottom of what you'd be happy with. You talk a lot in end results without any acceptance that good process is what enables the result. I agreed that given the timing I don't think I'd have sacked Mason. You're also arguing directly against the sort of method that got us halfway up the PL without a wealthy backer. Agree with the rest of what you say, there is no room for positively around a relegation to the third tier. Fact remains we've tried one experienced manager and two rookies, albeit one who's managed abroad and we've been heading towards the bottom three under all of them.

Here you go… 

Choose a manager with Champ experience that has had some degree of success, such as Eustace or Rowett etc for example. Not exciting, not cool bro, not even that imaginative but we just needed stability. 

Employ a decent DoF who has a handle on the reality of the Champ and has a clear plan for improving the football department. Not next season but this one, this was always going to be the squeaky bottom season and to not prioritise the position baffles me. 

Owners to listen to them and accept they know more about the league than they do. 

That isn’t too much to ask of new owners, just to steady the ship and see us through choppy waters. Instead we bring in Mowbray on some spurious stats, a completely untried Mason and now a stubborn and limited experienced Ramsay. None of this is hindsight, I’ve argued these points before many times and got shot down many times by people saying we could afford to take the risk. 

The owners clearly know about finance, they clearly don’t understand the competitiveness of the Championship. Even if we survive this season, this has been a needless experiment when we just needed calm, boring, pragmatic decisions made by those who have experience of the league, whilst the owners did what they are best at and that is clearly managing money not footballers.

I'd agree in that Nestor has been their failing. He should have gone with Mason. 

Can you imagine our fans if we'd have appointed Rowett in the summer?!

Yes we would have had the usual suspects saying it’ll be boring etc, thankfully we are having a very exciting season, what more could they want?
Reply
#26
I think it’s time to go back to basics
Let the manager buy the players he wants to work with
This Nestor guy don’t seem to have a clue
The last few into the building
Phillips
Mepham
That Junior guy
Collyer
Gilchrist
O’Leary
The guy today 45 Minutes Binned

I’ve still got a bit of hope for Heggebo & even Price although I want to punch his lights out after today

It’s been a disaster
Reply
#27
(01-31-2026, 10:13 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:03 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: This is a weak argument, we didn’t have to go from Bruce/Mowbray to Mason. Going down will put us back years, I doubt we would be spending our way out of the division and all the time we will lose touch with our local rivals. This season has been avoidable, it is either arrogance or naivety that we thought we could put a rookie manager in charge of a weakened squad in such a pivotal season.

Course we didn't. I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, I'm just in a never ending cycle of trying to get to the bottom of what you'd be happy with. You talk a lot in end results without any acceptance that good process is what enables the result. I agreed that given the timing I don't think I'd have sacked Mason. You're also arguing directly against the sort of method that got us halfway up the PL without a wealthy backer. Agree with the rest of what you say, there is no room for positively around a relegation to the third tier. Fact remains we've tried one experienced manager and two rookies, albeit one who's managed abroad and we've been heading towards the bottom three under all of them.

Here you go… 

Choose a manager with Champ experience that has had some degree of success, such as Eustace or Rowett etc for example. Not exciting, not cool bro, not even that imaginative but we just needed stability. 

Employ a decent DoF who has a handle on the reality of the Champ and has a clear plan for improving the football department. Not next season but this one, this was always going to be the squeaky bottom season and to not prioritise the position baffles me. 

Owners to listen to them and accept they know more about the league than they do. 

That isn’t too much to ask of new owners, just to steady the ship and see us through choppy waters. Instead we bring in Mowbray on some spurious stats, a completely untried Mason and now a stubborn and limited experienced Ramsay. None of this is hindsight, I’ve argued these points before many times and got shot down many times by people saying we could afford to take the risk. 

The owners clearly know about finance, they clearly don’t understand the competitiveness of the Championship. Even if we survive this season, this has been a needless experiment when we just needed calm, boring, pragmatic decisions made by those who have experience of the league, whilst the owners did what they are best at and that is clearly managing money not footballers.

I'd agree in that Nestor has been their failing. He should have gone with Mason. 

Can you imagine our fans if we'd have appointed Rowett in the summer?!

Yes we would have had the usual suspects saying it’ll be boring etc, thankfully we are having a very exciting season, what more could they want?

Apologies as I'd edited that post to add about Mowbray making sense yet backfiring. Your approach with this current group of players would have been just as likely to fail. The top of the league is currently jammed with clubs who've gone down the data route. Your issue is not the method, it's the execution, which I'm sure we'd all agree has been awful. 

Eustace was available last January as well...
Reply
#28
(01-31-2026, 10:35 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:13 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:03 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Course we didn't. I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, I'm just in a never ending cycle of trying to get to the bottom of what you'd be happy with. You talk a lot in end results without any acceptance that good process is what enables the result. I agreed that given the timing I don't think I'd have sacked Mason. You're also arguing directly against the sort of method that got us halfway up the PL without a wealthy backer. Agree with the rest of what you say, there is no room for positively around a relegation to the third tier. Fact remains we've tried one experienced manager and two rookies, albeit one who's managed abroad and we've been heading towards the bottom three under all of them.

Here you go… 

Choose a manager with Champ experience that has had some degree of success, such as Eustace or Rowett etc for example. Not exciting, not cool bro, not even that imaginative but we just needed stability. 

Employ a decent DoF who has a handle on the reality of the Champ and has a clear plan for improving the football department. Not next season but this one, this was always going to be the squeaky bottom season and to not prioritise the position baffles me. 

Owners to listen to them and accept they know more about the league than they do. 

That isn’t too much to ask of new owners, just to steady the ship and see us through choppy waters. Instead we bring in Mowbray on some spurious stats, a completely untried Mason and now a stubborn and limited experienced Ramsay. None of this is hindsight, I’ve argued these points before many times and got shot down many times by people saying we could afford to take the risk. 

The owners clearly know about finance, they clearly don’t understand the competitiveness of the Championship. Even if we survive this season, this has been a needless experiment when we just needed calm, boring, pragmatic decisions made by those who have experience of the league, whilst the owners did what they are best at and that is clearly managing money not footballers.

I'd agree in that Nestor has been their failing. He should have gone with Mason. 

Can you imagine our fans if we'd have appointed Rowett in the summer?!

Yes we would have had the usual suspects saying it’ll be boring etc, thankfully we are having a very exciting season, what more could they want?

Apologies as I'd edited that post to add about Mowbray making sense yet backfiring. Your approach with this current group of players would have been just as likely to fail. The top of the league is currently jammed with clubs who've gone down the data route. Your issue is not the method, it's the execution, which I'm sure we'd all agree has been awful. 

Eustace was available last January as well...

There is no way of proving whether that bringing in a decent and DoF and manager with experience of keeping teams in the Championship would be successful but I think I’d rather have gone down that route than the direction we have. Explain what data was used to bring in Mason or Ramsay that is relevant to Championship? I have no problem with data btw, I have a problem with those who think it is anything other than a tool that helps make decisions, rather than dictates them.
Reply
#29
(01-31-2026, 11:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:35 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:13 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Here you go… 

Choose a manager with Champ experience that has had some degree of success, such as Eustace or Rowett etc for example. Not exciting, not cool bro, not even that imaginative but we just needed stability. 

Employ a decent DoF who has a handle on the reality of the Champ and has a clear plan for improving the football department. Not next season but this one, this was always going to be the squeaky bottom season and to not prioritise the position baffles me. 

Owners to listen to them and accept they know more about the league than they do. 

That isn’t too much to ask of new owners, just to steady the ship and see us through choppy waters. Instead we bring in Mowbray on some spurious stats, a completely untried Mason and now a stubborn and limited experienced Ramsay. None of this is hindsight, I’ve argued these points before many times and got shot down many times by people saying we could afford to take the risk. 

The owners clearly know about finance, they clearly don’t understand the competitiveness of the Championship. Even if we survive this season, this has been a needless experiment when we just needed calm, boring, pragmatic decisions made by those who have experience of the league, whilst the owners did what they are best at and that is clearly managing money not footballers.

I'd agree in that Nestor has been their failing. He should have gone with Mason. 

Can you imagine our fans if we'd have appointed Rowett in the summer?!

Yes we would have had the usual suspects saying it’ll be boring etc, thankfully we are having a very exciting season, what more could they want?

Apologies as I'd edited that post to add about Mowbray making sense yet backfiring. Your approach with this current group of players would have been just as likely to fail. The top of the league is currently jammed with clubs who've gone down the data route. Your issue is not the method, it's the execution, which I'm sure we'd all agree has been awful. 

Eustace was available last January as well...

There is no way of proving whether that bringing in a decent and DoF and manager with experience of keeping teams in the Championship would be successful but I think I’d rather have gone down that route than the direction we have. Explain what data was used to bring in Mason or Ramsay that is relevant to Championship? I have no problem with data btw, I have a problem with those who think it is anything other than a tool that helps make decisions, rather than dictates them.

It makes no sense. There is no data on either!
Reply
#30
(01-31-2026, 11:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:35 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:13 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 10:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 09:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Here you go… 

Choose a manager with Champ experience that has had some degree of success, such as Eustace or Rowett etc for example. Not exciting, not cool bro, not even that imaginative but we just needed stability. 

Employ a decent DoF who has a handle on the reality of the Champ and has a clear plan for improving the football department. Not next season but this one, this was always going to be the squeaky bottom season and to not prioritise the position baffles me. 

Owners to listen to them and accept they know more about the league than they do. 

That isn’t too much to ask of new owners, just to steady the ship and see us through choppy waters. Instead we bring in Mowbray on some spurious stats, a completely untried Mason and now a stubborn and limited experienced Ramsay. None of this is hindsight, I’ve argued these points before many times and got shot down many times by people saying we could afford to take the risk. 

The owners clearly know about finance, they clearly don’t understand the competitiveness of the Championship. Even if we survive this season, this has been a needless experiment when we just needed calm, boring, pragmatic decisions made by those who have experience of the league, whilst the owners did what they are best at and that is clearly managing money not footballers.

I'd agree in that Nestor has been their failing. He should have gone with Mason. 

Can you imagine our fans if we'd have appointed Rowett in the summer?!

Yes we would have had the usual suspects saying it’ll be boring etc, thankfully we are having a very exciting season, what more could they want?

Apologies as I'd edited that post to add about Mowbray making sense yet backfiring. Your approach with this current group of players would have been just as likely to fail. The top of the league is currently jammed with clubs who've gone down the data route. Your issue is not the method, it's the execution, which I'm sure we'd all agree has been awful. 

Eustace was available last January as well...

There is no way of proving whether that bringing in a decent and DoF and manager with experience of keeping teams in the Championship would be successful but I think I’d rather have gone down that route than the direction we have. Explain what data was used to bring in Mason or Ramsay that is relevant to Championship? I have no problem with data btw, I have a problem with those who think it is anything other than a tool that helps make decisions, rather than dictates them.

Spot on Dekka. However, it's been relegation form for 12 months under three different managers, experienced and rookie.

Sadly we needed another Carlos to keep us afloat.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: