From BBC WM
#31
(01-23-2026, 09:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.

His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.

I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut. 

Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.

We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.

Fucking bingo.

Tuesday's result was far more to do with a team that has been trending towards the bottom three for the best part of 12 months under successive managers, with zero confidence finally getting the hiding that had been coming for a number of months rather than anything Ramsay could have done in a week on the training ground.

Let's not forget SW, that aggressive, front foot football is what people had been asking for...

Do not agree. Name any team that doesn’t play with fullbacks (who may be attacking fullbacks). He tries two forward players and surprise we get tanked. As new managers go he is making Pardew look good. 
We have Centre Halves who are slow and not conformable on the ball who need to be close together to get the best out of them but we play them spread wide across the back and wonder why they look so poor.
If the coach do not turn this round in the next couple of games the board need to make the hard decision to get ride or we are relegated.
Reply
#32
(01-23-2026, 10:05 AM)TartanRug Wrote: Not convinced by that. There wasn't a sign a 5-0 battering was coming under Mason. I'm not saying we should never change anything, just that he's tried changing far too much especially when there's little time on the training pitch to get this across.

Is Ramsay associated with aggressive front foot football? I'd thought he was more about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break?

Sit in a structured, organised shape, then when you have the ball attack very directly, it's about as aggressive as you get.

It was coming, we'd lost ten away from home in a row (could quite easily have shipped five at Southampton or QPR off the top of my head), Bristol City went into contain mode when they had us on the ropes at 2-0. We went 2-0 down a lot in Mason's last few games, it's just a trend that has continued regardless of how the team is set up.

SW is right in that it's not an ideal way for a team low on confidence to play, so expect us to retreat further into the bunker tonight in order to try and get a result.
Reply
#33
(01-23-2026, 09:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.

His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.

I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut. 

Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.

We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.

Fucking bingo.

Tuesday's result was far more to do with a team that has been trending towards the bottom three for the best part of 12 months under successive managers, with zero confidence finally getting the hiding that had been coming for a number of months rather than anything Ramsay could have done in a week on the training ground.

Let's not forget SW, that aggressive, front foot football is what people had been asking for...

As usual, both of you have hit the nail squarely on the head. 

Thank you for making me feel I haven't lost the plot totally.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#34
Agree with everything above - I feel that a big loss was always coming under Mason as has been identified in some of the examples above where teams took the foot off the gas.

Right now I pay little attention to the words that are said - more and more bosses come out these days with waffle and no value add to their comments. Its what we see in games that matters, and frankly the come back against Boro showed some positives and a willingness to change (up one on Mason alreadY)

In addition it cant be under stated 2 key facts

1) The lack of the midfield - in any formation with Bielik and Styles as our midfielders we would have significantly struggled. We ave seen a lot how poor we are without Mowatt because there is no alternative. The fact we are over a month since we knew Collyer was leaving and we dont have any one else in is another Nestor and Pearce F-Up

2) The confidence of the players is clearly on the floor - has been for quite a while and that will take more than just 2 weeks to turn around and with such a small squad there are very few options to bring in to try and generate a bounce (ie a striker coming on and starting a run by the ball hitting his backside.

A full training week across the both of next 2 weeks with a couple of additions and then we really have to see an improvement in results IMO
Reply
#35
(01-23-2026, 10:22 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 10:05 AM)TartanRug Wrote: Not convinced by that. There wasn't a sign a 5-0 battering was coming under Mason. I'm not saying we should never change anything, just that he's tried changing far too much especially when there's little time on the training pitch to get this across.

Is Ramsay associated with aggressive front foot football? I'd thought he was more about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break?

Sit in a structured, organised shape, then when you have the ball attack very directly, it's about as aggressive as you get.

It was coming, we'd lost ten away from home in a row (could quite easily have shipped five at Southampton or QPR off the top of my head), Bristol City went into contain mode when they had us on the ropes at 2-0. We went 2-0 down a lot in Mason's last few games, it's just a trend that has continued regardless of how the team is set up.

SW is right in that it's not an ideal way for a team low on confidence to play, so expect us to retreat further into the bunker tonight in order to try and get a result.
The first 15 against Boro was really promising. Yes we sat back, but countered well and should have had at least one. Trouble was we couldn't sustain it and sat back as they got a foothold.
We definitely need to be stronger in the challenge and use turnovers better. MJ right, SIJ left and Heggy in the middle is our best form of attack and now we have Mowatt and Molumby back, for all their faults, they should help that. Drop Price back in with them and use his engine to support any breaks and get in and around the box.

The defence is what it is and will likely concede but I think dropping Styles back to LB and bringing in Bielik and Campbell, gives us more energy. Maybe O'Leary will also stabilise us, but that's an unknown for now.
Reply
#36
(01-23-2026, 10:05 AM)TartanRug Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 09:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.

His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.

I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut. 

Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.

We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.

Fucking bingo.

Tuesday's result was far more to do with a team that has been trending towards the bottom three for the best part of 12 months under successive managers, with zero confidence finally getting the hiding that had been coming for a number of months rather than anything Ramsay could have done in a week on the training ground.

Let's not forget SW, that aggressive, front foot football is what people had been asking for...

Not convinced by that. There wasn't a sign a 5-0 battering was coming under Mason. I'm not saying we should never change anything, just that he's tried changing far too much especially when there's little time on the training pitch to get this across.

Is Ramsay associated with aggressive front foot football? I'd thought he was more about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break?

Same. A lot of the defeats under Mason, Millwall aside, were by single goal margins and we never looked like we'd be completely tonked by anyone. The system we were playing under Mason wasn't completely broken but when there were issues Mason either didn't fix them or was far too slow to react. Ramsay has come in and tried to implement a new formation which simply doesn't suit the players he has at his disposal. Probably the only beneficiary so far has been SIJ. For the rest of the players they look far more comfortable in a 4-2-3-1. We have plenty of central defenders and wide forwards. This needs to dictate how were play rather than playing players out of position.
Reply
#37
(01-23-2026, 11:03 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 10:05 AM)TartanRug Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 09:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.

His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.

I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut. 

Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.

We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.

Fucking bingo.

Tuesday's result was far more to do with a team that has been trending towards the bottom three for the best part of 12 months under successive managers, with zero confidence finally getting the hiding that had been coming for a number of months rather than anything Ramsay could have done in a week on the training ground.

Let's not forget SW, that aggressive, front foot football is what people had been asking for...

Not convinced by that. There wasn't a sign a 5-0 battering was coming under Mason. I'm not saying we should never change anything, just that he's tried changing far too much especially when there's little time on the training pitch to get this across.

Is Ramsay associated with aggressive front foot football? I'd thought he was more about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break?

Same. A lot of the defeats under Mason, Millwall aside, were by single goal margins and we never looked like we'd be completely tonked by anyone. The system we were playing under Mason wasn't completely broken but when there were issues Mason either didn't fix them or was far too slow to react. Ramsay has come in and tried to implement a new formation which simply doesn't suit the players he has at his disposal. Probably the only beneficiary so far has been SIJ. For the rest of the players they look far more comfortable in a 4-2-3-1. We have plenty of central defenders and wide forwards. This needs to dictate how were play rather than playing players out of position.
To be fair, we never looked like coming back either, Swansea aside, a lot of games became a bit of a procession once we went behind. We never seemed to finish a game strongly.

Agree with the rest though, now M&M are fit, go back to a 4231 / 451

And for the love of all that is holy drop Mepham and his borstal haircut.
Reply
#38
(01-23-2026, 11:03 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 10:05 AM)TartanRug Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 09:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2026, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.

His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.

I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut. 

Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.

We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.

Fucking bingo.

Tuesday's result was far more to do with a team that has been trending towards the bottom three for the best part of 12 months under successive managers, with zero confidence finally getting the hiding that had been coming for a number of months rather than anything Ramsay could have done in a week on the training ground.

Let's not forget SW, that aggressive, front foot football is what people had been asking for...

Not convinced by that. There wasn't a sign a 5-0 battering was coming under Mason. I'm not saying we should never change anything, just that he's tried changing far too much especially when there's little time on the training pitch to get this across.

Is Ramsay associated with aggressive front foot football? I'd thought he was more about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break?

Same. A lot of the defeats under Mason, Millwall aside, were by single goal margins and we never looked like we'd be completely tonked by anyone. The system we were playing under Mason wasn't completely broken but when there were issues Mason either didn't fix them or was far too slow to react. Ramsay has come in and tried to implement a new formation which simply doesn't suit the players he has at his disposal. Probably the only beneficiary so far has been SIJ. For the rest of the players they look far more comfortable in a 4-2-3-1. We have plenty of central defenders and wide forwards. This needs to dictate how were play rather than playing players out of position.

Quite… there was never a time we looked like we would get battered as we were against Norwich under Mason. We lost most games for three reasons firstly missing guilt edged chances and poor decision making in the final third, giving cheap goals away through individual mistakes, and a lack of in game management when changes needed to be made. 

It doesn’t require playing a formation and tactics that are alien to the team introduced at a time when there was no time to try and make it work. If Johnson and Price are forced to play RWB again then that makes us weaker because it  weakens us both in attack and defence and for what? The most telling thing from the first two matches is the only player who looked comfortable playing in the way Ramsay set us up was SIJ and why? Because he is the only player it suits.
Reply
#39
One remark is being blown out of proportion IMO. He was asked about his "back to the drawing board" comment after Tuesday's match. He rowed back from that, suggesting that he expressed himself badly. He said he didn't want there to be 46 different Albion stylers of play throughout the season depending on opposition.

So I don't think he's nailing his colours to the mast formation-wise, just trying to answer a question.

I don't know what to expect tonight, but if Mepham plays while Campbell is left out (again) I will be unimpressed.
Reply
#40
They all talk the fucking same don’t they? Banal, bullshit pseudo-management speak-wank.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)