Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(01-23-2026, 07:31 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not that I think Ramsay got it anywhere near right against Boro or Norwich, but I think some of you are deeply underestimating how tough it is to come into a side that's been in relegation form for a year and find a system within 6 days that brings the best out of a squad with zero belief or confidence. Mason needed an entire pre-season to get us started. Ramsay, still has only had about five proper sessions.
Also, what is adaptability? Many managers will change shape but the balance of the team and the principles by which they try and play will remain the same. A 4-4-2, 4-3-3, 4-2-3-1, 3-5-2 under Ramsay will all look to play in much the same way. There isn't a coach in the game who just rips up their model from one game to the next.
Mason's biggest issue is that no one could tell what his was.
The most sensible approach surely is if you don’t have the personnel to play your preferred formation, you look to play a formation and style that works with what you have. You don’t put players like Johnson and Price into roles they aren’t suited to, after a day or two on the training pitch and expect the team to play well. We effectively threw six points away on an experiment.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(01-23-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-23-2026, 07:31 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not that I think Ramsay got it anywhere near right against Boro or Norwich, but I think some of you are deeply underestimating how tough it is to come into a side that's been in relegation form for a year and find a system within 6 days that brings the best out of a squad with zero belief or confidence. Mason needed an entire pre-season to get us started. Ramsay, still has only had about five proper sessions.
Also, what is adaptability? Many managers will change shape but the balance of the team and the principles by which they try and play will remain the same. A 4-4-2, 4-3-3, 4-2-3-1, 3-5-2 under Ramsay will all look to play in much the same way. There isn't a coach in the game who just rips up their model from one game to the next.
Mason's biggest issue is that no one could tell what his was.
The most sensible approach surely is if you don’t have the personnel to play your preferred formation, you look to play a formation and style that works with what you have. You don’t put players like Johnson and Price into roles they aren’t suited to, after a day or two on the training pitch and expect the team to play well. We effectively threw six points away on an experiment.
I'd be more inclined to agree if what we were doing was working, but it wasn't.
He had to try and change something, he went for what he knows. No harm in that. Every single manager we'd have appointed would have done the same. You're effectively asking Ramsay to do in a week what Mason needed two months to do and even then it only lasted about six weeks on the pitch.
It's different to when Bruce took over from Val and ruined a 75% functioning team or Mowbray turning the best defence in the league to shambles overnight. This team has been in relegation form for 12 months now.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(01-23-2026, 09:10 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-23-2026, 07:31 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not that I think Ramsay got it anywhere near right against Boro or Norwich, but I think some of you are deeply underestimating how tough it is to come into a side that's been in relegation form for a year and find a system within 6 days that brings the best out of a squad with zero belief or confidence. Mason needed an entire pre-season to get us started. Ramsay, still has only had about five proper sessions.
Also, what is adaptability? Many managers will change shape but the balance of the team and the principles by which they try and play will remain the same. A 4-4-2, 4-3-3, 4-2-3-1, 3-5-2 under Ramsay will all look to play in much the same way. There isn't a coach in the game who just rips up their model from one game to the next.
Mason's biggest issue is that no one could tell what his was.
The most sensible approach surely is if you don’t have the personnel to play your preferred formation, you look to play a formation and style that works with what you have. You don’t put players like Johnson and Price into roles they aren’t suited to, after a day or two on the training pitch and expect the team to play well. We effectively threw six points away on an experiment.
I'd be more inclined to agree if what we were doing was working, but it wasn't.
He had to try and change something, he went for what he knows. No harm in that. Every single manager we'd have appointed would have done the same. You're effectively asking Ramsay to do in a week what Mason needed two months to do and even then it only lasted about six weeks on the pitch.
It's different to when Bruce took over from Val and ruined a 75% functioning team or Mowbray turning the best defence in the league to shambles overnight. This team has been in relegation form for 12 months now.
Our problem though wasn't the formation before he came. It was not taking chances and lacking discipline/concentration. Changing the formation has just created another problem on top of these.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
I'm going to be controversial, but we didn't need anything drastic to improve. We really weren't far away under Mason. It needed a tweak, some in game management, and picking the right players. We didn't, and don't, need a revolution.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(01-23-2026, 09:32 AM)TartanRug Wrote: (01-23-2026, 09:10 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-23-2026, 07:31 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not that I think Ramsay got it anywhere near right against Boro or Norwich, but I think some of you are deeply underestimating how tough it is to come into a side that's been in relegation form for a year and find a system within 6 days that brings the best out of a squad with zero belief or confidence. Mason needed an entire pre-season to get us started. Ramsay, still has only had about five proper sessions.
Also, what is adaptability? Many managers will change shape but the balance of the team and the principles by which they try and play will remain the same. A 4-4-2, 4-3-3, 4-2-3-1, 3-5-2 under Ramsay will all look to play in much the same way. There isn't a coach in the game who just rips up their model from one game to the next.
Mason's biggest issue is that no one could tell what his was.
The most sensible approach surely is if you don’t have the personnel to play your preferred formation, you look to play a formation and style that works with what you have. You don’t put players like Johnson and Price into roles they aren’t suited to, after a day or two on the training pitch and expect the team to play well. We effectively threw six points away on an experiment.
I'd be more inclined to agree if what we were doing was working, but it wasn't.
He had to try and change something, he went for what he knows. No harm in that. Every single manager we'd have appointed would have done the same. You're effectively asking Ramsay to do in a week what Mason needed two months to do and even then it only lasted about six weeks on the pitch.
It's different to when Bruce took over from Val and ruined a 75% functioning team or Mowbray turning the best defence in the league to shambles overnight. This team has been in relegation form for 12 months now.
Our problem though wasn't the formation before he came. It was not taking chances and lacking discipline/concentration. Changing the formation has just created another problem on top of these.
Read my first post again. Formation will not drastically alter the way a team plays. The issue that remains is the balance of the team is wrong, one of the reasons I gave Mason more slack than others. A 4-4-2 under Ramsay will try and play the same way. There are subtle in-game changes of formations many times during 90 minutes.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
01-23-2026, 09:45 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-23-2026, 09:46 AM by SW4Baggie.)
(01-23-2026, 09:32 AM)TartanRug Wrote: (01-23-2026, 09:10 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-23-2026, 07:31 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not that I think Ramsay got it anywhere near right against Boro or Norwich, but I think some of you are deeply underestimating how tough it is to come into a side that's been in relegation form for a year and find a system within 6 days that brings the best out of a squad with zero belief or confidence. Mason needed an entire pre-season to get us started. Ramsay, still has only had about five proper sessions.
Also, what is adaptability? Many managers will change shape but the balance of the team and the principles by which they try and play will remain the same. A 4-4-2, 4-3-3, 4-2-3-1, 3-5-2 under Ramsay will all look to play in much the same way. There isn't a coach in the game who just rips up their model from one game to the next.
Mason's biggest issue is that no one could tell what his was.
The most sensible approach surely is if you don’t have the personnel to play your preferred formation, you look to play a formation and style that works with what you have. You don’t put players like Johnson and Price into roles they aren’t suited to, after a day or two on the training pitch and expect the team to play well. We effectively threw six points away on an experiment.
I'd be more inclined to agree if what we were doing was working, but it wasn't.
He had to try and change something, he went for what he knows. No harm in that. Every single manager we'd have appointed would have done the same. You're effectively asking Ramsay to do in a week what Mason needed two months to do and even then it only lasted about six weeks on the pitch.
It's different to when Bruce took over from Val and ruined a 75% functioning team or Mowbray turning the best defence in the league to shambles overnight. This team has been in relegation form for 12 months now.
Our problem though wasn't the formation before he came. It was not taking chances and lacking discipline/concentration. Changing the formation has just created another problem on top of these.
I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.
His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.
I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut.
Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.
We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
01-23-2026, 09:49 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-23-2026, 09:54 AM by Ted Maul.)
(01-23-2026, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.
His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.
I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut.
Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.
We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.
Fucking bingo.
Tuesday's result was far more to do with a team that has been trending towards the bottom three for the best part of 12 months under successive managers, with zero confidence finally getting the hiding that had been coming for a number of months rather than anything Ramsay could have done in a week on the training ground.
Let's not forget SW, that aggressive, front foot football is what people had been asking for...
Posts: 7,863
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(01-23-2026, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.
His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.
I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut.
Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.
We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.
Spot on, people complain about dinosaur managers but there are a great deal of dinosaur fans as well who refuse to believe the game has moved on.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(01-22-2026, 09:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We're not going to see huge swings from game to game in terms of how the team plays because, ultimately, I have a vision that I think will stand the team in good stead in the long run.
Eric Ramsay
'West Bromwich Albion' on BBC Sounds
Is it not hypocritical that you're seeking at every opportunity to undermine Ramsay from the very beginning, when you were critical for months of those who were criticising Mason as we slid down the table?
Ramsay's been here 5 minutes and has had one game after another, so let's give the guy a chance to catch his breath and get some decent time on the training pitch before people start piling on.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(01-23-2026, 09:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2026, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think we are getting too hung up on the formation - it does not have anywhere near as much impact as people make out. The collapse against Norwich was not because we went to three at the back, we have played that formation several times under Mason this season without conceding 5 goals. The issue is the roles certain players are being asked to play, when and where we press from, and the aggressive/risky forward passing Ramsay wants.
His big mistake is that he's tried to make a team that is rock bottom in terms of confidence and making regular mistakes an aggressive team, and that requires a lot of confidence and positivity and in a high pressure game like midweek, it led to a crash.
I really, really hope Tuesday was us bottoming out, but this run of 2 game weeks is giving ER no time to just reset. The team really needs an international break, a warm weather get away, just take players out of this negativity. You can say what you want about them needing a leader, needing someone to kick them up the arse, but those days are gone. PASHUN won't players out of this kind of rut.
Ramsay needs to start with the basics... select a settled defence and build some confidence. Shield it with a protective midfield. Work on set pieces. Go to Derby knowing that 0-0 would be brilliant. Bit by bit, just edge some confidence into the players, don't ask a squad to play aggressive, confident football when they're on the floor.
We also cannot overlook the fact that he has been without 4 central midfielders for these games... Collyer leaving, Mowatt and Molumby's fitness, and then Diakite cannot be in the best mental state.
Fucking bingo.
Tuesday's result was far more to do with a team that has been trending towards the bottom three for the best part of 12 months under successive managers, with zero confidence finally getting the hiding that had been coming for a number of months rather than anything Ramsay could have done in a week on the training ground.
Let's not forget SW, that aggressive, front foot football is what people had been asking for...
Not convinced by that. There wasn't a sign a 5-0 battering was coming under Mason. I'm not saying we should never change anything, just that he's tried changing far too much especially when there's little time on the training pitch to get this across.
Is Ramsay associated with aggressive front foot football? I'd thought he was more about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break?
|