Posts: 1,802
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
7
(01-20-2026, 08:10 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (01-20-2026, 07:03 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think there’s a manager on the planet that could do anything with this lot, with the sole exception of MJ don’t think any one of them would get into a decent championship team.
This is just patently ridiculous. Give your head a wobble!
Just wobbled my head and y’know what I still think they’re all shite, I’d love them to prove me wrong tonight.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(01-20-2026, 11:20 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: (01-20-2026, 08:10 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (01-20-2026, 07:03 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Don’t think there’s a manager on the planet that could do anything with this lot, with the sole exception of MJ don’t think any one of them would get into a decent championship team.
This is just patently ridiculous. Give your head a wobble!
Just wobbled my head and y’know what I still think they’re all shite, I’d love them to prove me wrong tonight.
Deserved arf for the post, but I just don't agree they're all shite. That's facile thinking.
Playing shite at the moment? Sure, quite a few of them are, or at least making boneheaded mistakes that is costing us games. But there's clearly plenty of Champ pedigree in the squad and with the right management (which hopefully we have if you're bullish on Ramsay), they'll show this.
Posts: 9,655
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
I'd also argue Phillips is a top Championship centre half, if played in the correct system and with good coaching. He has fucked up a lot of late though. So that's why I didn't include him in my above post.
Posts: 210
Threads: 19
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
1
I'm with Vine on this: the way they are currently playing I'd only have Johnston, Grant and Price (bench) in any other championship squad.
As has been said numerous times the defence is especially atrocious. Phillips has lost all confidence and Taylor's legs seem tied together. Amazingly for the own goal he actually tried to clear the ball but ended up shanking it into the net - not easy to execute! Mepham just runs out of defence into no man's land and well Gilchrist was just amazingly bad against Swansea.
The only 2 who look like they might be ok are Campbell and Beilik.
Ramsay has a heck of a job sorting this lot out. Unlike Meggo who arrived when the team was in a similar state he will be unable to bring in reinforcements.
Sorry to say I've been snapping up the 18/1 on offer for relegation. Some form of compensation but I'd prefer to lose my stakes.
Really,really hope we can get something tonight - even a point to stop the rot.
Posts: 8,130
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
01-20-2026, 02:47 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-20-2026, 02:58 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
I don’t think that the side are as bad as all that. MJ is a real asset, Aune (now settled) also looks good business. When on song Grant is a real handful and works hard regardless, and isn’t it funny that we saw the best of Sammy Sealion when - in January (yes, with the season into its sixth month) - he first got to play where suits him best?
Our CHs have more than capable CVs, Stiles is usually dependable and versatile, I have no qualm with JG. All in all, that’s the nucleus of a good side.
Which brings me to the concerns, which again are symptomatic of bad coaching rather than bad players. The easy place to start is Price - everyone can see that there is a great footballer in there, who came with plaudits, and whom also began the season with pomp and confidence. And has steadily got worse. Why? For the same reason that that CHs did the same, I wonder? For the same reason we only see limited bits of Diakite’s value, why Dike, Maja and Bany have been mismanaged, that Mowatt and Molumby can have a stinker one game and then look bitterly missed when absent? I’d say consistency is key here more than personnel, and I bet if many of these players had better counterparts we’d be seeing the same problems. Better loans though in future, please, would be nice. And bloody hell we lack a natural leader. The semi-fit Jed is the closest thing we have to that, and he’s hardly McInnes or Scharner in respective presence or stature.
Yes, there are holes in an unbalanced squad, but I think for large parts of Friday night we showed that that can be mitigated with the correct approach and tactics, and against a very good side indeed.
So - provided that he isn’t Mason MkII (God forbid, in which case somebody kidnap Nestor and ship him in a tariff-free box to wherever the hell he came from) - Ramsey just needs more time, and a few more fit and available numbers to choose from. Although I can fully appreciate why many might see and say otherwise, I maintain that this side isn’t as bad as all that.
Look what Bruce was doing to what Corberan had, and delivered upon. Mason was doing exactly the same, in just a more moment-laden, less root vegetable-faced way. Losing Fellows, Barts and Furlong are not the only reason we’ve become shite, and - although it hasn’t helped one bit - it is so easy to forget that they all had their off days too. There are two people at fault for this situation right now, and that is the former boss, and the zero-watt bulb who employed him. Personally I’m thankful that it is still easily fixable, and I very much hope to witness the beginning of that tonight (if we didn’t already see glimpses on Friday night).
In summary, COYB.
Posts: 5,323
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
I think the squad is chic full of decent championship players. The kind of players who were if they were in a team that had 6 or 7 very good championship players, would be capable of playing their part in a bid for automatic promotion.
But we don't have 6 0r 7 very good championship players.
I'm relaxed about a relegation battle, we have enough to not get seriously involved. But we are not near a club who could finish top 2.
Posts: 3,108
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(01-20-2026, 02:47 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I don’t think that the side are as bad as all that. MJ is a real asset, Aune (now settled) also looks good business. When on song Grant is a real handful and works hard regardless, and isn’t it funny that we saw the best of Sammy Sealion when - in January (yes, with the season into its sixth month) - he first got to play where suits him best?
Our CHs have more than capable CVs, Stiles is usually dependable and versatile, I have no qualm with JG. All in all, that’s the nucleus of a good side.
Which brings me to the concerns, which again are symptomatic of bad coaching rather than bad players. The easy place to start is Price - everyone can see that there is a great footballer in there, who came with plaudits, and whom also began the season with pomp and confidence. And has steadily got worse. Why? For the same reason that that CHs did the same, I wonder? For the same reason we only see limited bits of Diakite’s value, why Dike, Maja and Bany have been mismanaged, that Mowatt and Molumby can have a stinker one game and then look bitterly missed when absent? I’d say consistency is key here more than personnel, and I bet if many of these players had better counterparts we’d be seeing the same problems. Better loans though in future, please, would be nice. And bloody hell we lack a natural leader. The semi-fit Jed is the closest thing we have to that, and he’s hardly McInnes or Scharner in respective presence or stature.
Yes, there are holes in an unbalanced squad, but I think for large parts of Friday night we showed that that can be mitigated with the correct approach and tactics, and against a very good side indeed.
So - provided that he isn’t Mason MkII (God forbid, in which case somebody kidnap Nestor and ship him in a tariff-free box to wherever the hell he came from) - Ramsey just needs more time, and a few more fit and available numbers to choose from. Although I can fully appreciate why many might see and say otherwise, I maintain that this side isn’t as bad as all that.
Look what Bruce was doing to what Corberan had, and delivered upon. Mason was doing exactly the same, in just a more moment-laden, less root vegetable-faced way. Losing Fellows, Barts and Furlong are not the only reason we’ve become shite, and - although it hasn’t helped one bit - it is so easy to forget that they all had their off days too. There are two people at fault for this situation right now, and that is the former boss, and the zero-watt bulb who employed him. Personally I’m thankful that it is still easily fixable, and I very much hope to witness the beginning of that tonight (if we didn’t already see glimpses on Friday night).
In summary, COYB.
Good post. I'm not ready to go anti Nestor yet though, the playing side signings are still either a plus or a not yet there. The managerial choices issue will be decided by ER. New manager, roll your sleeves up chaps and let's see how we go.
Posts: 210
Threads: 19
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
1
I guess the key word in my post is “currently”.
Over to you Eric - hopefully you can restore the lost confidence and get them playing to the standard that they have played to in the past. Playing a totally new system I guess will make it harder but let’s hope he can do it!
Posts: 8,007
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
I reckon we could pick at least 8 players tonight who have had motm performances this season, so they are good enough, they just don’t have the structure or confidence to do it on a weekly basis or do it in synergy and I’m hoping, and convinced, that this is down to poor coaching and lack of “clarity”.
We need a win fawshaw, by any means, to restore the players belief in the process. Crucially we need to follow it up, which has been the biggest issue this season. I know it seems a lot to ask, but, back to back results could see this squad in a different light.
That’s why I believe Ramsay is the right sort of coach at this time.
Hope I’m right!
Coyb.
Posts: 1,021
Threads: 31
Joined: Nov 2025
Reputation:
3
01-20-2026, 04:26 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-20-2026, 04:30 PM by HeggebøsBarnDoor.)
(01-20-2026, 02:24 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: I'm with Vine on this: the way they are currently playing I'd only have Johnston, Grant and Price (bench) in any other championship squad.
As has been said numerous times the defence is especially atrocious. Phillips has lost all confidence and Taylor's legs seem tied together. Amazingly for the own goal he actually tried to clear the ball but ended up shanking it into the net - not easy to execute! Mepham just runs out of defence into no man's land and well Gilchrist was just amazingly bad against Swansea.
The only 2 who look like they might be ok are Campbell and Beilik.
Ramsay has a heck of a job sorting this lot out. Unlike Meggo who arrived when the team was in a similar state he will be unable to bring in reinforcements.
Sorry to say I've been snapping up the 18/1 on offer for relegation. Some form of compensation but I'd prefer to lose my stakes.
Really,really hope we can get something tonight - even a point to stop the rot.
Was really tempted by the Betway 67/1 that was on offer a few weeks back but I thought it would be like throwing money down the drain. Little did I know we'd continue to be so shite.
Up until very recently I've been of the opinion that the squad is good enough to maybe finish just outside of the play offs with good coaching. However, recently they have done their very best to shake that belief by demonstrating that they are incapable of focusing for a full 90 minutes and avoiding individual errors. I hope this is the low point and now under Ramsay we start to look more solid. We shall see.
But I do think there's some serious work needed on the squad with 5-10 arrivals needed in the summer if we're not doing much business in Jan.
|