Harper
#11
(06-23-2019, 10:08 AM)WWHO Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: I wouldn’t blame him for jumping. He’ll have grown up watching the super clubs, both here and in Europe, changes are it was watching those clubs that inspired him to become a footballer. If one of them shows an interest what are you going to do: Join or spend your career wondering what if? If he goes to Liverpool for example he’ll go there believing he can make it, if he doesn’t then so be it, he’ll drop back down the pyramid to his natural level, but at least he gave it a go. And of course he’ll make a lot of money out of it too.

Take club loyalties out of the equation and how many people on here can genuinely say they’d stay in his situation? It’s the same reason I have never understood the eagerness of folk on here to bash Izzy Brown. All a bit small minded and parochial if you ask me.

Which is the entire basis of football fandom.

True.
Reply
#12
(06-23-2019, 10:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: I wouldn’t blame him for jumping. He’ll have grown up watching the super clubs, both here and in Europe, chances are it was watching those clubs that inspired him to become a footballer. If one of them shows an interest what are you going to do: Join or spend your career wondering what if? If he goes to Liverpool for example he’ll go there believing he can make it, if he doesn’t then so be it, he’ll drop back down the pyramid to his natural level, but at least he gave it a go. And of course he’ll make a lot of money out of it too.

Take club loyalties out of the equation and how many people on here can genuinely say they’d stay in his situation? It’s the same reason I have never understood the eagerness of folk on here to bash Izzy Brown. All a bit small minded and parochial if you ask me.

Maybe I’m old fashioned but players that have been trained since they were in primary school to become the players they are when they are 16-21yrs should recognise the loyalty and investment clubs have given them. If they prove themselves with teams like ourselves they will get their big moves and be perhaps more grounded, focused and appreciative of their good fortune. Their talent alone did not get them to thr position they found themselves. I’ve no idea what the appeal of sitting on your arse in the bench or getting rented by other clubs constantly has when they could be playing regularly. For what a few thousand more in their account?
Reply
#13
(06-23-2019, 10:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: I wouldn’t blame him for jumping. He’ll have grown up watching the super clubs, both here and in Europe, chances are it was watching those clubs that inspired him to become a footballer. If one of them shows an interest what are you going to do: Join or spend your career wondering what if? If he goes to Liverpool for example he’ll go there believing he can make it, if he doesn’t then so be it, he’ll drop back down the pyramid to his natural level, but at least he gave it a go. And of course he’ll make a lot of money out of it too.

Take club loyalties out of the equation and how many people on here can genuinely say they’d stay in his situation? It’s the same reason I have never understood the eagerness of folk on here to bash Izzy Brown. All a bit small minded and parochial if you ask me.

Maybe I’m old fashioned but players that have been trained since they were in primary school to become the players they are when they are 16-21yrs should recognise the loyalty and investment clubs have given them. If they prove themselves with teams like ourselves they will get their big moves and be perhaps more grounded, focused and appreciative of their good fortune. Their talent alone did not get them to thr position they found themselves. I’ve no idea what the appeal of sitting on your arse in the bench or getting rented by other clubs constantly has when they could be playing regularly. For what a few thousand more in their account?

Loyalty works two ways, the club unceremoniously bins anyone considered not good enough. They haven’t invested in Harper for philanthropic reasons. They expect something back, either a player or a transfer fee, if they didn’t think they could either he would have been canned too.
Reply
#14
(06-23-2019, 10:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: I wouldn’t blame him for jumping. He’ll have grown up watching the super clubs, both here and in Europe, chances are it was watching those clubs that inspired him to become a footballer. If one of them shows an interest what are you going to do: Join or spend your career wondering what if? If he goes to Liverpool for example he’ll go there believing he can make it, if he doesn’t then so be it, he’ll drop back down the pyramid to his natural level, but at least he gave it a go. And of course he’ll make a lot of money out of it too.

Take club loyalties out of the equation and how many people on here can genuinely say they’d stay in his situation? It’s the same reason I have never understood the eagerness of folk on here to bash Izzy Brown. All a bit small minded and parochial if you ask me.

Maybe I’m old fashioned but players that have been trained since they were in primary school to become the players they are when they are 16-21yrs should recognise the loyalty and investment clubs have given them. If they prove themselves with teams like ourselves they will get their big moves and be perhaps more grounded, focused and appreciative of their good fortune. Their talent alone did not get them to thr position they found themselves. I’ve no idea what the appeal of sitting on your arse in the bench or getting rented by other clubs constantly has when they could be playing regularly. For what a few thousand more in their account?

Although I largely agree, I'm not sure how much they 'owe us' - doesn't the club get around 1/4 million in compensation even if he goes abroad - more if he stays in this country?

If this is the case, granted its not much in footballing terms, but in education terms, it's still the equivalent of a very top end independent school. If I was the player I would be grateful, but I would consider the club has been more than adequately compensated by the 'nominal' transfer fee.

If we can't run the academy based on one coming to us and one going to a premier league club every year - equating to at the very least a couple of million per year - then surely something is going wrong? We should either change it or stop doing it. As it happens, the money we got for the defective 'genius' that is Berahino, probably paid for the whole thing for a good few years

In my view, although the compensation is low for football, this just hides the main problem. Despite all the hype, the academy hasn't actually produced anybody of note - for us or anybody else.
Reply
#15
I think the problem is we are producing the wrong types of players.

We are either producing kids that everyone wants, or kids that aren't good enough. We aren't producing the next generation of Brunts and Mozzas, which is the kind we need and the kind that might stay.
Reply
#16
(06-23-2019, 10:38 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: I wouldn’t blame him for jumping. He’ll have grown up watching the super clubs, both here and in Europe, chances are it was watching those clubs that inspired him to become a footballer. If one of them shows an interest what are you going to do: Join or spend your career wondering what if? If he goes to Liverpool for example he’ll go there believing he can make it, if he doesn’t then so be it, he’ll drop back down the pyramid to his natural level, but at least he gave it a go. And of course he’ll make a lot of money out of it too.

Take club loyalties out of the equation and how many people on here can genuinely say they’d stay in his situation? It’s the same reason I have never understood the eagerness of folk on here to bash Izzy Brown. All a bit small minded and parochial if you ask me.

Maybe I’m old fashioned but players that have been trained since they were in primary school to become the players they are when they are 16-21yrs should recognise the loyalty and investment clubs have given them. If they prove themselves with teams like ourselves they will get their big moves and be perhaps more grounded, focused and appreciative of their good fortune. Their talent alone did not get them to thr position they found themselves. I’ve no idea what the appeal of sitting on your arse in the bench or getting rented by other clubs constantly has when they could be playing regularly. For what a few thousand more in their account?

Although I largely agree, I'm not sure how much they 'owe us' - doesn't the club get around 1/4 million in compensation even if he goes abroad - more if he stays in this country?

If this is the case, granted its not much in footballing terms, but in education terms, it's still the equivalent of a very top end independent school. If I was the player I would be grateful, but I would consider the club has been more than adequately compensated by the 'nominal' transfer fee.

If we can't run the academy based on one coming to us and one going to a premier league club every year - equating to at the very least a couple of million per year - then surely something is going wrong? We should either change it or stop doing it. As it happens, the money we got for the defective 'genius' that is Berahino, probably paid for the whole thing for a good few years

In my view, although the compensation is low for football, this just hides the main problem. Despite all the hype, the academy hasn't actually produced anybody of note - for us or anybody else.

Agree.  Plus we need to start looking at why these players have their heads turned.  Is it a wider societal issue or should we be doing more on the pastoral side to convince them (and their advisers) that their future lies with us?
Reply
#17
When it comes to loyalty and respect the youngsters look at what the club does for people who have stayed with them for years and reflect on how they have been treated. Darren was always going to break a few hearts when he was sacked. Surprised it didn't appear to make senior people at the club stop and think before appointing him?
Reply
#18
(06-23-2019, 10:42 AM)WWHO Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:38 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: I wouldn’t blame him for jumping. He’ll have grown up watching the super clubs, both here and in Europe, chances are it was watching those clubs that inspired him to become a footballer. If one of them shows an interest what are you going to do: Join or spend your career wondering what if? If he goes to Liverpool for example he’ll go there believing he can make it, if he doesn’t then so be it, he’ll drop back down the pyramid to his natural level, but at least he gave it a go. And of course he’ll make a lot of money out of it too.

Take club loyalties out of the equation and how many people on here can genuinely say they’d stay in his situation? It’s the same reason I have never understood the eagerness of folk on here to bash Izzy Brown. All a bit small minded and parochial if you ask me.

Maybe I’m old fashioned but players that have been trained since they were in primary school to become the players they are when they are 16-21yrs should recognise the loyalty and investment clubs have given them. If they prove themselves with teams like ourselves they will get their big moves and be perhaps more grounded, focused and appreciative of their good fortune. Their talent alone did not get them to thr position they found themselves. I’ve no idea what the appeal of sitting on your arse in the bench or getting rented by other clubs constantly has when they could be playing regularly. For what a few thousand more in their account?

Although I largely agree, I'm not sure how much they 'owe us' - doesn't the club get around 1/4 million in compensation even if he goes abroad - more if he stays in this country?

If this is the case, granted its not much in footballing terms, but in education terms, it's still the equivalent of a very top end independent school. If I was the player I would be grateful, but I would consider the club has been more than adequately compensated by the 'nominal' transfer fee.

If we can't run the academy based on one coming to us and one going to a premier league club every year - equating to at the very least a couple of million per year - then surely something is going wrong? We should either change it or stop doing it. As it happens, the money we got for the defective 'genius' that is Berahino, probably paid for the whole thing for a good few years

In my view, although the compensation is low for football, this just hides the main problem. Despite all the hype, the academy hasn't actually produced anybody of note - for us or anybody else.

Agree.  Plus we need to start looking at why these players have their heads turned.  Is it a wider societal issue or should we be doing more on the pastoral side to convince them (and their advisers) that their future lies with us?

I’m not sure what can be done to stop a teenager having their head turned when the likes of Liverpool, Chelsea, etc are mentioned. We can say all we want but unless there is an emotional attachment to the club (ie childhood fan) then they are going to choose the glitz, glamour and money a bigger club will offer.

That’s before you consider the possibility of a better footballing education elsewhere. For too long we have been too poor at bringing young players through. The much maligned Izzy Brown has twice as many first team appearances under his belt as Sam Field, and that is despite losing a whole season to injury.
Reply
#19
(06-23-2019, 10:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: I wouldn’t blame him for jumping. He’ll have grown up watching the super clubs, both here and in Europe, chances are it was watching those clubs that inspired him to become a footballer. If one of them shows an interest what are you going to do: Join or spend your career wondering what if? If he goes to Liverpool for example he’ll go there believing he can make it, if he doesn’t then so be it, he’ll drop back down the pyramid to his natural level, but at least he gave it a go. And of course he’ll make a lot of money out of it too.

Take club loyalties out of the equation and how many people on here can genuinely say they’d stay in his situation? It’s the same reason I have never understood the eagerness of folk on here to bash Izzy Brown. All a bit small minded and parochial if you ask me.


What rubbish. We should be partisan as supporters, especially when we talk about a player, who apart from the winner against a relegated team, has done very little for us. Izzy Brown should tell anyone that moving like he did is ridiculous.
Reply
#20
(06-23-2019, 11:16 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote:
(06-23-2019, 10:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: I wouldn’t blame him for jumping. He’ll have grown up watching the super clubs, both here and in Europe, chances are it was watching those clubs that inspired him to become a footballer. If one of them shows an interest what are you going to do: Join or spend your career wondering what if? If he goes to Liverpool for example he’ll go there believing he can make it, if he doesn’t then so be it, he’ll drop back down the pyramid to his natural level, but at least he gave it a go. And of course he’ll make a lot of money out of it too.

Take club loyalties out of the equation and how many people on here can genuinely say they’d stay in his situation? It’s the same reason I have never understood the eagerness of folk on here to bash Izzy Brown. All a bit small minded and parochial if you ask me.


What rubbish. We should be partisan as supporters, especially when we talk about a player, who apart from the winner against a relegated team, has done very little for us. Izzy Brown should tell anyone that moving like he did is ridiculous.

Izzy Brown has played twice as many games as Sam Field.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)