Our central defence…
#21
The first was a complete fluke, and the second was a chain of failures through the middle - some really limp challenges going in that allowed them to break the lines, with far too much ease. Third one we just get done on the overlap. But the OP stands - at times it looks like Phillips and Mepham speak different languages.

Hopefully with a bit more time and coaching they can return to their respective heights of form, but it could just be that they aren’t compatible as a pair. It does inexplicably happen sometimes.
Reply
#22
(01-17-2026, 12:13 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: The first was a complete fluke, and the second was a chain of failures through the middle - some really limp challenges going in that allowed them to break the lines, with far too much ease. Third one we just get done on the overlap. But the OP stands - at times it looks like Phillips and Mepham speak different languages.

Hopefully with a bit more time and coaching they can return to their respective heights of form, but it could just be that they aren’t compatible as a pair. It does inexplicably happen sometimes.

Yep.  Eric mentioned us losing personal duels in his presser.  They literally ran through a couple od tackles for two of the goals.  You cant always coach players to technical improvement but you can make sure that never happens again. Missing that challenge always makes the last line defence look worse as they are not expecting that extra man to break through. As an ex defender i would have been rabid in the changing room with whoever missed those challenges.
Reply
#23
Playing 3 at the back, I reckon our best combination would be Phillips,  Campbell and Bielik. SIJ looked good at LWB,  RWB ??? Who knows. Jed maybe? Williams when 100% fit may well be the answer. He looked a superb prospect in the minutes he's had.
Reply
#24
(01-17-2026, 09:14 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Phillips, Mepham and Taylor are significantly inferior to Bartley, Ajayi and Holgate and that says a lot. Hopefully coaching and organisation will help to a degree but Phillips ball watches constantly and the three of them are so slow.

I don't think they are worse, but I don't think they're better either. See what happens under a decent coach.
Reply
#25
(01-17-2026, 01:56 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-17-2026, 09:14 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Phillips, Mepham and Taylor are significantly inferior to Bartley, Ajayi and Holgate and that says a lot. Hopefully coaching and organisation will help to a degree but Phillips ball watches constantly and the three of them are so slow.

I don't think they are worse, but I don't think they're better either. See what happens under a decent coach.

Agree Birdman. Good organisation can make poorer players function above their natural level. Last night showed up exactly the weaknesses. Just watch that late winner. If we can't get a partnership from the multitude of centre backs then we have undone much of the P and S work.
What I would add is that a class centre back can make even poor players appear better, as long as they follow orders. Anyone remember Shaun Teale at villa? Lauded as  England captain material he was perfectly adequate.....until Paul McGrath retired. Then he was exposed as Sandwell Sunday morning standard and vanished through the leagues.
Of course, we may have 4 Shaun Teales..... Confused
Reply
#26
You can't just ignore the fact they were good before. Whilst they may have eventually lost their place in teams that gained promotion or who won the European champions league, they should be playing better than a team that is flirting with relegation.

One obvious conclusion is that we have had two successive coaches where no player has improved and many have gone backwards, so it's hardly surprising that the defenders aren't playing particularly well. 

I'm hopeful they will improve.
Reply
#27
Ajayi is quite literally one of the worst central defenders I've ever seen, but next to Bartley under a good coach he looked somewhat competent at times.

Bielik is a leader and well regarded, Phillips and Mepham should be doing better with the careers they've had, no way we can't get a decent central defensive partnership somehow with a good coach there, if Ramsey is of course capable, I think he is.
Reply
#28
Stacey North and Chris Whyte. A very good centre half pairing.

One went on to be a Champion of England, the other held as a marker to just how shit we’d become. Partnerships are required but also the coaching. I really don’t understand why his needs reiterating when we watched Steve Bruce’s Albion followed by CC’s. I remember that team had a bad attitude and was heading for L1, by the end of the season we lost a play-off place on the last game of the season.

Mepham played 40+ games for last season’s play-off winners and Philips played well at Derby to the point Eustace really wanted to keep him. And now they’re both shit and worse than a half fit Bartley and Ajayi? Are they bollocks. This is the real stick to beat Mason with.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#29
(01-17-2026, 04:11 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Stacey North and Chris Whyte. A very good centre half pairing.

One went on to be a Champion of England, the other held as a marker to just how shit we’d become.  Partnerships are required but also the coaching.  I really don’t understand why his needs reiterating when we watched Steve Bruce’s Albion followed by CC’s. I remember that team had a bad attitude and was heading for L1, by the end of the season we lost a play-off place on the last game of the season.

Mepham played 40+ games for last season’s play-off winners and Philips played well at Derby to the point Eustace really wanted to keep him.  And now they’re both shit and worse than a half fit Bartley and Ajayi?  Are they bollocks.  This is the real stick to beat Mason with.

The proof if they are any good is whether they now improve. I’m sure we can play with more discipline and with a better structure to mitigate some problems but if the same problems persist then is it the players or the coaches? I’m in no way convinced that they are better than Ajayi or Bartley currently.
Reply
#30
(01-17-2026, 04:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-17-2026, 04:11 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Stacey North and Chris Whyte. A very good centre half pairing.

One went on to be a Champion of England, the other held as a marker to just how shit we’d become.  Partnerships are required but also the coaching.  I really don’t understand why his needs reiterating when we watched Steve Bruce’s Albion followed by CC’s. I remember that team had a bad attitude and was heading for L1, by the end of the season we lost a play-off place on the last game of the season.

Mepham played 40+ games for last season’s play-off winners and Philips played well at Derby to the point Eustace really wanted to keep him.  And now they’re both shit and worse than a half fit Bartley and Ajayi?  Are they bollocks.  This is the real stick to beat Mason with.

The proof if they are any good is whether they now improve. I’m sure we can play with more discipline and with a better structure to mitigate some problems but if the same problems persist then is it the players or the coaches? I’m in no way convinced that they are better than Ajayi or Bartley currently.

Bartley was certainly way better than this lot. He only went off during his last year or so because his knee was shot and he couldn’t run properly.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: