REFEREE GRAHAM SCOTT
#71
My main gripe with shan was in the second game.

Down to ten men, playing against a knackered and already slow defence that we have to hit on the counter and he brings on a Leko fresh back from injury instead of one of the fastest players on the division in Montero. Madness
Reply
#72
(06-21-2019, 09:05 PM)Hopalong Wrote: It may be irrelevant, but how VAR was not in operation for the play-off games is incredulous, when there is so much riding on it. Had it been, there's a possibility that Greasy's penalty would have been ruled out, Holgate's would have been given and Gayle's 2nd yellow would have been ruled out. But it was not to be.  

Yes Scott made a number of controversial decisions in their favour, as outlined above. 

However,some blame has to lie with Shan and Gayle as his sending off really cost us.  Having been warned about time-wasting he then continued to do the same to earn a needless booking.  There was no basic need for us to waste time at this point in the game. 

The next mistake was 3 of our midfielders getting sucked in to jockey greasy with no-one taking responsibility to put a tackle in. there should be no more than two players marking an individual, one to put a tackle in and the second there if the tackle is evaded.  If you watch the reply three get sucked in leaving Hourihane wide open and with a free shot for the equaliser.  

For the pen, Gibbs had just been booked prior to the penalty and whilst the slow motion indicates he never made contact and it was therefore simulation, most refs would have probably given that. 

Gayle then having wound Scott up in my view,  proceeded to go in a bit late on Steer - he did pull out, which VAR would have confirmed - but again he gave Scott the opportunity to give the decision and I bet he was delighted to do so. Lack of professsionalism from Gayle overall.  

What was noticeable in both legs was how demonstrative the Villa players were with the referee on both sending offs - this was clearly a ploy Smith used. 

We had the opportunities to finish them off in the second leg but we didn't and then Brunt puts in needless reckless tackle on McGinn, with Hegazi cuplable.  If we had kept 11 on the pitch the result could have been different. 

Let's not also forget that Robson-Kanu cost us too with his stupid petulance at Derby leaving us threadbare up front.  If we have been able to bring him on when J-Rod went off in the 2nd leg then again that could have made a big difference.  I really do hope for that alone that we make it clear to him that he has no future at the club and get rid of him in the summer.  I can forgive Brunt for his tackle even though it was reckless but you cannot forgive Kanu when we were losing 3-1 in injury time. 

Finally, it came out afterwards that Villa had been practising penalties for 4 weeks prior to the 2nd leg.   Did we? 

We can argue that Scott did for us with the Gayle/Greasy/Holgate decisions but I do think we were the architects of our own self-destruction as both of their goals were preventable as were both sendings off.

Re Gayle and timewasting, he was walking over to take the throw. There is no rule insisting he needs to run. Plus, he had every right to go for the cross and pulled out when he saw he couldn't make it. 
Agree with much of the rest but Scott is still the fly in the ointment.
Reply
#73
(06-21-2019, 11:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(06-21-2019, 09:05 PM)Hopalong Wrote: It may be irrelevant, but how VAR was not in operation for the play-off games is incredulous, when there is so much riding on it. Had it been, there's a possibility that Greasy's penalty would have been ruled out, Holgate's would have been given and Gayle's 2nd yellow would have been ruled out. But it was not to be.  

Yes Scott made a number of controversial decisions in their favour, as outlined above. 

However,some blame has to lie with Shan and Gayle as his sending off really cost us.  Having been warned about time-wasting he then continued to do the same to earn a needless booking.  There was no basic need for us to waste time at this point in the game. 

The next mistake was 3 of our midfielders getting sucked in to jockey greasy with no-one taking responsibility to put a tackle in. there should be no more than two players marking an individual, one to put a tackle in and the second there if the tackle is evaded.  If you watch the reply three get sucked in leaving Hourihane wide open and with a free shot for the equaliser.  

For the pen, Gibbs had just been booked prior to the penalty and whilst the slow motion indicates he never made contact and it was therefore simulation, most refs would have probably given that. 

Gayle then having wound Scott up in my view,  proceeded to go in a bit late on Steer - he did pull out, which VAR would have confirmed - but again he gave Scott the opportunity to give the decision and I bet he was delighted to do so. Lack of professsionalism from Gayle overall.  

What was noticeable in both legs was how demonstrative the Villa players were with the referee on both sending offs - this was clearly a ploy Smith used. 

We had the opportunities to finish them off in the second leg but we didn't and then Brunt puts in needless reckless tackle on McGinn, with Hegazi cuplable.  If we had kept 11 on the pitch the result could have been different. 

Let's not also forget that Robson-Kanu cost us too with his stupid petulance at Derby leaving us threadbare up front.  If we have been able to bring him on when J-Rod went off in the 2nd leg then again that could have made a big difference.  I really do hope for that alone that we make it clear to him that he has no future at the club and get rid of him in the summer.  I can forgive Brunt for his tackle even though it was reckless but you cannot forgive Kanu when we were losing 3-1 in injury time. 

Finally, it came out afterwards that Villa had been practising penalties for 4 weeks prior to the 2nd leg.   Did we? 

We can argue that Scott did for us with the Gayle/Greasy/Holgate decisions but I do think we were the architects of our own self-destruction as both of their goals were preventable as were both sendings off.

Re Gayle and timewasting, he was walking over to take the throw. There is no rule insisting he needs to run. Plus, he had every right to go for the cross and pulled out when he saw he couldn't make it. 
Agree with much of the rest but Scott is still the fly in the ointment.

Correct
Reply
#74
Agree re thrown in , how many times do you see a player go to take a throw in only to see another player come over to take it .
Reply
#75
He will go down in the history books as a tosser.
Reply
#76
I’ve still nowhere near got even the performance of that incompetent wanker in the first leg, even the mention of the play offs sends me off on a tirade

One of the worst performances by an official I’ve seen in a longtime.....cunt!


Cuzer
Reply
#77
(06-21-2019, 11:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(06-21-2019, 09:05 PM)Hopalong Wrote: It may be irrelevant, but how VAR was not in operation for the play-off games is incredulous, when there is so much riding on it. Had it been, there's a possibility that Greasy's penalty would have been ruled out, Holgate's would have been given and Gayle's 2nd yellow would have been ruled out. But it was not to be.  

Yes Scott made a number of controversial decisions in their favour, as outlined above. 

However,some blame has to lie with Shan and Gayle as his sending off really cost us.  Having been warned about time-wasting he then continued to do the same to earn a needless booking.  There was no basic need for us to waste time at this point in the game. 

The next mistake was 3 of our midfielders getting sucked in to jockey greasy with no-one taking responsibility to put a tackle in. there should be no more than two players marking an individual, one to put a tackle in and the second there if the tackle is evaded.  If you watch the reply three get sucked in leaving Hourihane wide open and with a free shot for the equaliser.  

For the pen, Gibbs had just been booked prior to the penalty and whilst the slow motion indicates he never made contact and it was therefore simulation, most refs would have probably given that. 

Gayle then having wound Scott up in my view,  proceeded to go in a bit late on Steer - he did pull out, which VAR would have confirmed - but again he gave Scott the opportunity to give the decision and I bet he was delighted to do so. Lack of professsionalism from Gayle overall.  

What was noticeable in both legs was how demonstrative the Villa players were with the referee on both sending offs - this was clearly a ploy Smith used. 

We had the opportunities to finish them off in the second leg but we didn't and then Brunt puts in needless reckless tackle on McGinn, with Hegazi cuplable.  If we had kept 11 on the pitch the result could have been different. 

Let's not also forget that Robson-Kanu cost us too with his stupid petulance at Derby leaving us threadbare up front.  If we have been able to bring him on when J-Rod went off in the 2nd leg then again that could have made a big difference.  I really do hope for that alone that we make it clear to him that he has no future at the club and get rid of him in the summer.  I can forgive Brunt for his tackle even though it was reckless but you cannot forgive Kanu when we were losing 3-1 in injury time. 

Finally, it came out afterwards that Villa had been practising penalties for 4 weeks prior to the 2nd leg.   Did we? 

We can argue that Scott did for us with the Gayle/Greasy/Holgate decisions but I do think we were the architects of our own self-destruction as both of their goals were preventable as were both sendings off.

Re Gayle and timewasting, he was walking over to take the throw. There is no rule insisting he needs to run. Plus, he had every right to go for the cross and pulled out when he saw he couldn't make it. 
Agree with much of the rest but Scott is still the fly in the ointment.
Gayle was warned before he was booked. I remember thinking at the time that he was walking a tightrope. 

This then led to the 2nd booking plus of course due to Steer's oscaratics and the seals crowding round the ref. 

I would also question why Gayle as a striker is taking throw-ins in the first place? These should have been taken by Holgate/Gibbs.
Reply
#78
GaRsAeHaAlMcSuCnOtT.T
Reply
#79
Just when you are getting to terms over the injustice of it all sky show the vile's goalkeeper saving the two pens (not seen them since the day) and it looks like he clearly jumps a pace forward before the ball is kicked and saved on both!
Nope I can't let go! Especially hearing Puslow (so) has told their fans the EFL have given them a clean bill of health on their finances subject to the final audit.
Reply
#80
(06-22-2019, 12:59 PM)Stig of the Dump Wrote: Just when you are getting to terms over the injustice of it all sky show the vile's goalkeeper saving the two pens (not seen them since the day) and it looks like he clearly jumps a pace forward before the ball is kicked and saved on both!
Nope I can't let go! Especially hearing Puslow (so) has told their fans the EFL have given them a clean bill of health on their finances subject to the final audit.

And we should never let this go and use it to drive us on and off the field next season.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: