SIJ
#11
Another Champ club will have him, play him in his correct position (wing back) and he'll rip it up. You knows it.
Reply
#12
Perhaps he'd have been more of a success if we'd have actually tried to play him in his best position as a left sided wing back which is what he described himself as when he signed.

He's got plenty of experience playing in Serie A for Juventus and Bologna and a number of England U-21 caps. He's clearly a talented player and it's a shame we've not managed to coax more out of him.

Whilst he's not been great in terms of performances for us there has been certain match day threads on here where he seems to have been the fall guy with certain posters even when he's been fine or there have been much worse performers. I do think some people are so obsessed about any Villa links (a club he's never actually even played a game for!) that it it clouds any kind of fair judgement of a player.
Reply
#13
I am a bit reticent to hammer him or others too much for their performances under mason as his management was obviously well off. Much like ToMo and Bruce.

If he is to go back, I won't shed any tears. If he stays I will give him the benefit of the doubt.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
If he goes, I wonder what input Eric has had over this?......2 days training probably enough to see how shit he is.
Reply
#15
Whilst his output for us has been unquestionably poor, I am a bit conflicted here.

In his very first interview after signing he said he was a left wing back and not once has he played there, has he even been played wide left?

We now have a manager who appears to favour a system with wing backs and we only have Styles to play out there (new signings pending), part of me wants to see what SIJ could do playing in his natural position. He isn't, wasn't and never should have been the replacement for Fellows.

The real issue here is that we shouldn't, under any circumstances be taking charity from the Villa.
Reply
#16
He tried, he was limited, he's a waste of a loan. Who organised the loan, that's who deserves the ire, crap players gonna be crap.
Reply
#17
I really do hope he goes back he is extremely lazy, and has added very little and I am sure he wont be a cheap loan

Believe majority of the loans have a mid point January cut off point - assume that is in both clubs favour, and I think that deadline would be today.
Reply
#18
(01-16-2026, 09:02 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I am a bit reticent to hammer him or others too much for their performances under mason as his management was obviously well off. Much like ToMo and Bruce.

If he is to go back, I won't shed any tears. If he stays I will give him the benefit of the doubt.

Same. Especially as we are now open to playing wingbacks and that is what he claims is his best position, yet the only one he never played!
I'm sure Ramsay will take a look at him before a decision is made.
Reply
#19
(01-16-2026, 09:14 AM)baggiedave85 Wrote: I really do hope he goes back he is extremely lazy, and has added very little and I am sure he wont be a cheap loan

Believe majority of the loans have a mid point January cut off point - assume that is in both clubs favour, and I think that deadline would be today.

I read in one article that the 16th Jan - So today - Would be the last day they could be recalled or sent back.
Reply
#20
(01-16-2026, 09:14 AM)baggiedave85 Wrote: I really do hope he goes back he is extremely lazy, and has added very little and I am sure he wont be a cheap loan

Believe majority of the loans have a mid point January cut off point - assume that is in both clubs favour, and I think that deadline would be today.

This. Heart never seemed in it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)