New gk?
#11
I think Palmer's performances were enhanced when Corberan brought in the Spanish GK coach. Maybe Griffiths needs some new ideas too.
Reply
#12
Couple of things for those that are comparing Griffiths to Palmer. Palmer is 5 years older and got in the Albion side at 26 years old. He also played in a Corberan well drilled defence. That should not be underestimated. Look at the upheaval Griffiths has had to endure in terms of changing managers, defensive structures and players.

I think we'd massively regret selling Griffiths if we were to do it now.

Thems my onions.....
Reply
#13
i dont think we should sell him. we should get rid of wildsmith and bring a new no1 in that competes with JG
Reply
#14
(01-07-2026, 12:25 PM)Wimborne Baggie Wrote: i dont think we should sell him. we should get rid of wildsmith and bring a new no1 in that competes with JG

Maybe there is a possible taker and that's why we played him before the transfer window. There's always hope.
Reply
#15
(01-07-2026, 12:25 PM)Wimborne Baggie Wrote: i dont think we should sell him. we should get rid of wildsmith and bring a new no1 in that competes with JG

Oh I have no problem with replacing Wildshit! The tea lady will do....
Reply
#16
Would be wrong to sell JG - I believe he has the attributes and is still young in keeping terms. Like I said, a new coach would make a difference (the point about Palmer improving under the GK coach CC brought in is also valid) as would someone who could catch a ball and compete with JG which would kick him on
Reply
#17
Palmer was a better keeper, for me that's not even debateable. I said before that I thought Griffiths made too many game losing mistakes, before he was switched to number 1. All keepers will make a mistake, but some cost you points. Whilst Griffiths is way better than Wildsmith and infinitely better than Button, he's just an average keeper for me.

However a good keeper makes the defence better, a bad one and the defence does what we've been seeing. And yes, Palmer was the cause of shaky defence at times, but since he's gone neither keeper is giving the defence belief, and in turn they're making the keeper look worse (yes, actually think Wildsmith is better than he's looked for us, but no, not Button, he was gash), leading to keeper errors, which feed to defensive mistakes, and around and around it goes.

We should be looking at spending on a midfield leader rather than a keeper. If we went oh we've just signed the best keeper in the division below to compete with JG we'd all probably go, good move... that;s what we did with Wildsmith and look where that's gone.

Improve the midfield, get someone with drive and energy in there, and the defence will improve... and then the keeper will look better too. We simply shouldn't be conceding as many as we are with the on paper quality of our defenders, they *should* be making any standard keeper look good, but they're nto because we've got fuck all in the middle to shield them and drive us on.
Reply
#18
Palmer was 26, he wasn't young when he became our number 1, at 22 Palmer was looking ok in League 2 with Plymouth. Just OK, Cooper was already pushing him hard then.
Reply
#19
(01-07-2026, 12:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Palmer was 26, he wasn't young when he became our number 1, at 22 Palmer was looking ok in League 2 with Plymouth. Just OK, Cooper was already pushing him hard then.

Not bothered about the age when it comes to keepers, they can go on for a lot longer than other positions.
Reply
#20
(01-07-2026, 12:42 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(01-07-2026, 12:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Palmer was 26, he wasn't young when he became our number 1, at 22 Palmer was looking ok in League 2 with Plymouth. Just OK, Cooper was already pushing him hard then.

Not bothered about the age when it comes to keepers, they can go on for a lot longer than other positions.

No, but they also develop slower, keepers don't hit their peak until near 30. The point is, Griffiths is ahead of where Palmer was at the same age, he'll still develop a lot and probably further than Palmer.

But yet another example our fans don't actually want to develop players, they want fancy new signings only.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)