The Steve Bruce Defence
#31
(01-02-2026, 07:26 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Very similar to Big Sam, Corberan was never a defensive coach. He just managed teams without much attacking talent and still got results.

Pep focussed on fullbacks and a goalkeeper before he won his first PL. His team always have one of the best defensive records. Why? Because top coaches can control the defensive side of the game, they then put patterns of play in their team to get enough players into positions to hurt teams through overloads and create high quality chances.

Corberan did this by getting Fellows isolated time and time again against his fullback. It was deliberate and planned.
Agree. Wasn’t always great to watch but was efficient and players always looked assured and confident. You didn’t “expect” us to concede every week.
Mason looked like he may have similar principles early on, with us looking decent defensively. Gone out the window now though and the biggest difference is players improved under CC whereas under Mason they regress.
Reply
#32
We do look a far cry from where we were earlier on in the season. It is an interesting aspect - how can we go from looking reasonably well organised and having a game plan to where we are currently, which I think most ppl agree is devoid of having any real game plan, no ability to change and error prone?

Did he just abandon everything? does he overcomplicate stuff? Do the players know whether they're coming or going? Is his man management shite?

I suppose it doesn't matter much - at this point he just needs to go.
Reply
#33
From what I've seen of the players they look knackered, which leads to lapses, fouls, misses, and all the rest of it.

You could argue that the drop off has resulted from a lack of squad rotation and running out of steam as the games rack up. No idea if the stats bear it out, but the midfield and attack seem to be the same old faces.

I'm sure Ryan would argue it's the fault of having a small squad. On the other hand, it's his job to manage that (eg if El Presidente bought a load of defenders, you better pick a defence heavy formation and keep it tight at the back).

But what do I know? Didn't think Bruce or Mogga would be as awful as they were, so maybe a case of careful what you wish for giving Ryan the boot?
Reply
#34
(01-02-2026, 08:27 PM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: From what I've seen of the players they look knackered, which leads to lapses, fouls, misses, and all the rest of it.

You could argue that the drop off has resulted from a lack of squad rotation and running out of steam as the games rack up. No idea if the stats bear it out, but the midfield and attack seem to be the same old faces.

I'm sure Ryan would argue it's the fault of having a small squad. On the other hand, it's his job to manage that (eg if El Presidente bought a load of defenders, you better pick a defence heavy formation and keep it tight at the back).

But what do I know? Didn't think Bruce or Mogga would be as awful as they were, so maybe a case of careful what you wish for giving Ryan the boot?
The only lesson learned from Bruce is that we held on too long. We are already making the same mistake.
Reply
#35
I think the players are starting to tire of the whole thing and RM’s remarks in the last few games have started to suggest a few cracks between him and the squad.

As keeps being said, we are not far from being a good team. We haven’t been losing games heavily, and we’ve been creating chances in most, and indeed a fairer reflection of our performances would probably have us with another 7-8 points on the board, however the constant mistakes, and players missing that bit of confidence in the final third is costing us dearly in both boxes and sadly that’s the fault of the management team. The odd mistake is bad luck, but the sheer volume of missed chances and defensive errors scream of a side that’s not confident in their jobs, don’t have the attention to detail they had with previous managers, and now the constant chopping and changing of formations is compounding everything.

We’ve also got Mason moaning about fitness, blaming the players for missing chances when his game plans are just not opening up clear opportunities. Add to this his baffling comments about having Bielik on the bench for morale, the flogging Heggebø and Price to death, his reluctance to give Dike, Bostock or even any of the kids minutes, and his whole handling of Wildshit/Griffith and it points to a man clutching at straws… and all of this is before we get to his farcical game management.

The experiment has to end. Mason may well become a good manager as a result of this experience but it will not happen here, he is too far gone, and we are just delaying the inevitable.

This squad isn’t the best, granted, but it has quality, and that quality is what is grinding out results despite what we have in the dugout. Get a manager who can help us keep a clean sheet, can help us get the ball out wide and into the box quickly, and we will start moving up the table.
Reply
#36
Corberan’s tenure was the only time in recent years the squad hasn’t looked unmotivated and ill disciplined.
Reply
#37
It does seem we've needed something of a disciplinarian bastard in charge to get any semblence of progress this century.
Reply
#38
The squad isn’t the bleeding same as it was two or three seasons ago and neither is the league. Making comparisons with then and now is pointless navel gazing. We have weakened the squad in line with lowering the wage bill and selling our best young players. I’m sure with another manager we could be doing better but until next season I don’t even think we know the extent of investment the club can or are prepared to pump into the squad to make it a genuine promotion contender.

This is sadly what happens to most teams who miss promotion whilst wasting the advantage of parachute payments and or over spending (we did both Wink ). Fans didn’t need to be Nostradamus to work out this might be where we end up. We have had both Wolves and Blues right on our doorstep as examples of where things can go after the money runs out or can’t be spent. Whilst Mason is getting hammered, I think the problems are far broader and difficult to navigate for some to accept. Just one more manager and it’ll be ok, just one, two, three more transfer windows and the squad will be promotion candidates. Unless we invest in the squad, and the club put together a better backroom/football dept asap then we will be having similar arguments for the next five seasons bobbling around in the Championship at best.

We shall see, Mason leaving might make the squad perform better, I imagine it will but to what degree I don’t know. This season was always going to be messy and frankly I’m not seeing a long term plan transpiring if we continually looking to replace managers and selling our best players every season.
Reply
#39
(01-01-2026, 05:28 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(01-01-2026, 05:26 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Yep, and he's a superb coach. I'd genuinely doubt whether we'd be play-off contenders even with him still here. This squad is poor.

Mason has to get more out of them, I can't stress that enough, but it is bad.

I agree, hence why I said top ten. I don't think Corberan would have done wildly better, but I think a lot of the losses would have been draws and some of the wins probably would have been too... I'd guesstimate we'd be about 7 points better off.

Hypothetical but
-Griffiths would probably be in goal
-He would have Heggebo and Price in the squad
-The defence would be a lot better organized  than it is under Mason
-MJ would probably have replaced Fellows on the right
-Substitutes take place in the 60th minute!
Reply
#40
(01-02-2026, 09:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The squad isn’t the bleeding same as it was two or three seasons ago and neither is the league. Making comparisons with then and now is pointless navel gazing. We have weakened the squad in line with lowering the wage bill and selling our best young players. I’m sure with another manager we could be doing better but until next season I don’t even think we know the extent of investment the club can or are prepared to pump into the squad to make it a genuine promotion contender.

This is sadly what happens to most teams who miss promotion whilst wasting the advantage of parachute payments and or over spending (we did both Wink ). Fans didn’t need to be Nostradamus to work out this might be where we end up. We have had both Wolves and Blues right on our doorstep as examples of where things can go after the money runs out or can’t be spent. Whilst Mason is getting hammered, I think the problems are far broader and difficult to navigate for some to accept. Just one more manager and it’ll be ok, just one, two, three more transfer windows and the squad will be promotion candidates.  Unless we invest in the squad, and the club put together a better backroom/football dept asap then we will be having similar arguments for the next five seasons bobbling around in the Championship at best.

We shall see, Mason leaving might make the squad perform better, I imagine it will but to what degree I don’t know. This season was always going to be messy and frankly I’m not seeing a long term plan transpiring if we continually looking to replace managers and selling our best players every season.

Excellent post.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: