Do you need to have played the game at a decent level to comment about football?
#1
Genuinely asking - I've seen this banded around a fair bit, not just here and not just Throstles related. 

For me, obviously having experience and 'inside' knowledge certainly helps, but it doesn't automatically mean your opinion is more valid than someone who hasn't played at a decent level. 

Interesting to see what people think!
Reply
#2
Mark Lawrenson won multiple league titles and the European Cup yet knows absolutely fuck all about the game.
Reply
#3
(12-29-2025, 03:29 PM)Duffers Wrote: Mark Lawrenson won multiple league titles and the European Cup yet knows absolutely fuck all about the game.

I only play 8v8 on a Sunday evening, so this isn't meant to sound like I play at any sort of level, but I do come across players that are really talented, and can run rings around you/control a game, but their football knowledge and awareness is actually so shit, they have to be told where to go off the ball. 

It's something that always frustrates me when I see it. 

I have neither the tactical nous or natural ability Big Grin
Reply
#4
I've played in Upper Highley
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#5
If this was true then all the best managers would've played in World Cup Finals etc... and they don't.

I mean would anyone listen to Billy's opinion?
Reply
#6
(12-29-2025, 03:34 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I've played in Upper Highley

Better standard than me, I only played for Lower Hampton.
Reply
#7
Carlos Alberto - game over
Reply
#8
(12-29-2025, 03:28 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Genuinely asking - I've seen this banded around a fair bit, not just here and not just Throstles related. 

For me, obviously having experience and 'inside' knowledge certainly helps, but it doesn't automatically mean your opinion is more valid than someone who hasn't played at a decent level. 

Interesting to see what people think!

Easy answer for me. No.

I've friends that never kicked a ball growing up but loved football and watched it religiously and can talk tactical sense. I played for the county in my youth and Sunday league to quite a good standard but wouldn't say that gives me more knowledge over them.

If you love the game and watch it and can see patterns of play and how teams set up etc then your opinion is as good as any pro imo. The amount of shit that I see being spouted by ex pro's is laughable sometimes.
Reply
#9
I don't need to have sang on stage at Symphony Hall to know that Frank Sinatra could sing a bit.
Reply
#10
(12-29-2025, 03:50 PM)yeoman lai Wrote: I don't need to have sang on stage at Symphony Hall to know that Frank Sinatra could sing a bit.

Correct. I don’t need to have banged Claudia Schiffer to know she is as fit as fuck
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: