Caleb Taylor
#1
Not slagging off the sale, because 2.5 million is a decent fee (if that's what it was) but it looks like he was Championship standard afterall. Milwall fans are impressed and he's now cemented himself as a starting centreback.
Reply
#2
I'd prefer Taylor in our back four to Phillips or Mepham on current form. Wasn't given a decent chance here in terms of a run of games. The sale made sense if he wasn't going to play though.
Reply
#3
Had to be done as he’s been brought through by us so in terms of PSR it would add double the value of the sale. What we brought in was of lower value and can be split over the contract.
Reply
#4
Another example of Nestor thinking he is clever by getting 'pure profit' for an academy player when in reality he's letting good players go for cheap
Reply
#5
He would have also given us the aerial dominance we lack at the back.

We would then have saved the money on Mepham or Beilik. He would also have been on lower wages. Watch Milwall sell on for big bucks.
Reply
#6
(12-27-2025, 12:44 PM)B12Baggie Wrote: Another example of Nestor thinking he is clever by getting 'pure profit' for an academy player when in reality he's letting good players go for cheap

What a ridiculous post. He’s not being clever, the system is forcing all clubs to sell academy players. It’s like people read that Nestor statement and just think we can ignore the financial reality of it. Selling Taylor and Fellows (don’t moan about the fee) are one do the reasons we aren’t facing a points deduction. 

Anyone that thinks Taylor changes the defensive dynamic here has lost it. Mepham was a rock last year in a promoted side and Nat started the season on fire. Our defensive problems are down to form, confidence and frankly coaching.
Reply
#7
(12-27-2025, 12:29 PM)MrFizz Wrote: I'd prefer Taylor in our back four to Phillips or Mepham on current form. Wasn't given a decent chance here in terms of a run of games. The sale made sense if he wasn't going to play though.

He really should have been given a chance though rather than us trying to stockpile as many centre halfs as possible. Said at the time I had doubts about selling him. I can see the argument in terms of PSR but the money brought in hasn’t necessarily improved us at all.
Reply
#8
(12-27-2025, 12:49 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 12:44 PM)B12Baggie Wrote: Another example of Nestor thinking he is clever by getting 'pure profit' for an academy player when in reality he's letting good players go for cheap

What a ridiculous post. He’s not being clever, the system is forcing all clubs to sell academy players. It’s like people read that Nestor statement and just think we can ignore the financial reality of it. Selling Taylor and Fellows (don’t moan about the fee) are one do the reasons we aren’t facing a points deduction. 

Anyone that thinks Taylor changes the defensive dynamic here has lost it. Mepham was a rock last year in a promoted side and Nat started the season on fire. Our defensive problems are down to form, confidence and frankly coaching.
Ay it.  Taylor would have looked shit under Mason.
Reply
#9
Well done to him, he’s playing in a functioning side who know how they play and know how to recruit to make it work.

We say we’re adopting a front footed attacking ‘game model’ and sign Nat Phillips, Charlie Taylor, George Campbell and Alfie Gilchrist
Reply
#10
Taylor is a very good player and yet we wasted money on no better imo. We talk a great game about building a young team and have flogged most of our best young players.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: