He's still here.
#21
That's a fair post SW.
Reply
#22
I was a lone voice re Nestor a few months back but looking at the points Lurker has highlighted I would have to conceed that he’s generally improved things as a whole around the club.

However, his managerial selections so far, have been bad (borderline disastrous if we continue on as we are) which for me should be the bare minimum expected for his job.

Despite the good he’s done, I still think he’s part of the problem, esspecially if he keeps turning a blind eye to the problem.

He can’t be trusted to get the next manager right and for that reason alone he shouldn’t be involved in the selection of the next manager/head coach (whenever that may be).
Reply
#23
(12-27-2025, 11:09 AM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote: Squad lacks balance, sure.

It doesn't lack defenders and we're crap in defence so that does make things a little bit awkward.

It doesn’t lack defenders and yet at the same time we don’t actually have any decent natural full backs. The best options by far are Styles and Campbell who could be better utilised elsewhere on the pitch.

I think it’s fair to say we’ve made some good signings, some where the jury is out and others who have been pretty awful. Thankfully the majority of our worse signings have only been on loan. Bany is increasingly looking a complete waste of money and given his poor performances, lack of re-sale value and the fact he is reportedly our highest earner, I’m no more convinced about Phillips that I was in the summer when we signed him.

I really don’t get the attitude in places that the owners are beyond criticism. It seems to be part of modern culture where everything or everyone has to be seen as either brilliant or useless nowadays. There can’t be anything in between. Personally I think there are question marks over Nestor. Mason was his choice and is having to work with the players given to him. Nothing is solely the blame of one person. In certain respects both Mason and Nestor are responsible for the issues with the playing side at present.
Reply
#24
I don't think anyone can argue the club is in a better place now than when they took over, but they couldn't really do much worse, could they? I'm grateful for the work done to get us within PSR and save us from admin, but there's only so long they can live behind that without fair criticism. And how much of that financial work is really down to Nestor? All, some, none?
Reply
#25
For me, Nessie’s statement sought to impart two core messages: the first an appeal for patience given what they ‘inherited’ (er, willingly bought), secondly aren’t we great for sorting it. With an added dollop of the usual corporate filler caveats of ‘competitive league’ and ‘difficult trading conditions’ thrown in to a smug mix of self-aggrandising turd polish. And that is all great, but nothing we didn’t know, and I don’t see how it is right, fair or indeed apposite for him to praise the bean counting whilst being quite so ignorant of the malaise and cluelessness with regard to a first team that every week seems to be going into battle with its guns pointing the wrong way. It was very much a statement of justification opposed to optimism - which embodies completely a malaise we are seeing week after week - and in contrast did absolutely nothing to inspire, rally or galvanise. In essence, just a ‘look what we got, had to do, and aren’t we great for doing it’.

So yes, whilst we are all grateful that the Lai era is gone and that someone at least has come in to make some sensible, longer term decisions, financially that has been OK but it completely assumes that ALL of these decisions have been good, when two key ones have far from been. In fact, they have been disastrous. Tony Mowbray was not the only candidate, and nor was Ryan Mason. The latter is proving to be a bigger flop than the former, and the regression of some existing and the underperformance levels of other newbies is really quite staggering. This isn’t so much a ‘where’s the money gone, Tom’ concern so much as ‘what the fuck are you doing with it’, and as I said earlier this week trading on the sins of the past regime to excuse the poor performance since the departure of Corberan can and will only wash for so long. It will be two years in February since they came aboard, and - once again - whilst I fully appreciate the financial restrictions I do not accept that as an excuse for recruiting a dinosaur and then offering the YTS kid a three-year deal, and then publicly backing him to the hilt to save your own, sorry frat-boy ass.

If poor results continue, this could all be put right by a swift decision and third-time-lucky replacement. But I strongly doubt that that will happen. The corporate reacharound within the club has given Nestor sufficient sway to remain in the seat regardless of this season’s outcome, and if and when he finally wakes up to his recruitment error it’ll be at the expense of an MJ or a Griffiths having to depart to pay for it.

So excuse me for not wanting to get the bunting out for Nestor. Just like the man he’s appointed, he’s an absolute imposter.
Reply
#26
(12-27-2025, 11:26 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(12-27-2025, 11:09 AM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote: Squad lacks balance, sure.

It doesn't lack defenders and we're crap in defence so that does make things a little bit awkward.

It doesn’t lack defenders and yet at the same time we don’t actually have any decent natural full backs. The best options by far are Styles and Campbell who could be better utilised elsewhere on the pitch.

I think it’s fair to say we’ve made some good signings, some where the jury is out and others who have been pretty awful. Thankfully the majority of our worse signings have only been on loan. Bany is increasingly looking a complete waste of money and given his poor performances, lack of re-sale value and the fact he is reportedly our highest earner, I’m no more convinced about Phillips that I was in the summer when we signed him.

I really don’t get the attitude in places that the owners are beyond criticism. It seems to be part of modern culture where everything or everyone has to be seen as either brilliant or useless nowadays. There can’t be anything in between. Personally I think there are question marks over Nestor. Mason was his choice and is having to work with the players given to him. Nothing is solely the blame of one person. In certain respects both Mason and Nestor are responsible for the issues with the playing side at present.

Totally agree. I think most people are unpacking what we're seeing week in week out and trying to work out their stance on a variety of different issues that we're currently facing as a club.

No one person is to blame, they rarely are. Reading the majority of what's on here I think generally most agree:

We expected the club to be doing better in the league
The squad may not be the best but it's better than 16th
The drop off in form has been astonishing
Mason has walked into a difficult job but he should be exhibiting signs of learning - he is not
The players look jaded and our signings are generally underperforming 
Performances suggest we should be looking down not up
Nestor has done some good things and some bad - none of the good stuff will matter if we get relegated or the stadium end up half empty

We need a catalyst to change things up and give an impetus. For me that's now got to be Mason moving on...maybe that's after the appointment of the TD so they can ensure it's not another fuck up.
Reply
#27
(12-27-2025, 11:38 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: For me, Nessie’s statement sought to impart two core messages: the first an appeal for patience given what they ‘inherited’ (er, willingly bought), secondly aren’t we great for sorting it. With an added dollop of the usual corporate filler caveats of ‘competitive league’ and ‘difficult trading conditions’ thrown in to a smug mix of self-aggrandising turd polish. And that is all great, but nothing we didn’t know, and I don’t see how it is right, fair or indeed apposite for him to praise the bean counting whilst being quite so ignorant of the malaise and cluelessness with regard to a first team that every week seems to be going into battle with its guns pointing the wrong way. It was very much a statement of justification opposed to optimism - which embodies completely a malaise we are seeing week after week - and in contrast did absolutely nothing to inspire, rally or galvanise. In essence, just a ‘look what we got, had to do, and aren’t we great for doing it’.

So yes, whilst we are all grateful that the Lai era is gone and that someone at least has come in to make some sensible, longer term decisions, financially that has been OK but it completely assumes that ALL of these decisions have been good, when two key ones have far from been. In fact, they have been disastrous. Tony Mowbray was not the only candidate, and nor was Ryan Mason. The latter is proving to be a bigger flop than the former, and the regression of some existing and the underperformance levels of other newbies is really quite staggering. This isn’t so much a ‘where’s the money gone, Tom’ concern so much as ‘what the fuck are you doing with it’, and as I said earlier this week trading on the sins of the past regime to excuse the poor performance since the departure of Corberan can and will only wash for so long. It will be two years in February since they came aboard, and - once again - whilst I fully appreciate the financial restrictions I do not accept that as an excuse for recruiting a dinosaur and then offering the YTS kid a three-year deal, and then publicly backing him to the hilt to save your own, sorry frat-boy ass.

If poor results continue, this could all be put right by a swift decision and third-time-lucky replacement. But I strongly doubt that that will happen. The corporate reacharound within the club has given Nestor sufficient sway to remain in the seat regardless of this season’s outcome, and if and when he finally wakes up to his recruitment error it’ll be at the expense of an MJ or a Griffiths having to depart to pay for it.

So excuse me for not wanting to get the bunting out for Nestor. Just like the man he’s appointed, he’s an absolute imposter.
Interesting you mention Griffiths. Is anyone else worried that he’s been dropped to prevent injury so that he can be sold in Jan?
Reply
#28
(12-27-2025, 11:27 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't think anyone can argue the club is in a better place now than when they took over, but they couldn't really do much worse, could they? I'm grateful for the work done to get us within PSR and save us from admin, but there's only so long they can live behind that without fair criticism. And how much of that financial work is really down to Nestor? All, some, none?

"they couldn't do a lot worse" is a dangerous statement Josh - it's the same reason why people think Reform are worth a crack at government as they couldn't be any worse than Starmer.

You're underselling the job that Bilkul have done IMO - we've cut our wage bill by around 25% this year, but still assembled what ought to be a competitive squad, and they've invested where they've been able to under the league constraints. I do think they've done a very good job all things said, but they are woefully undermining all their good progress by remaining loyal to Mason when everyone can see he's woefully out of his depth. 

This squad should have 10 more points on the board, and with a capable manager, they would have - and if that was the case we'd be widely praising what Nestor and co have done. Unfortunately, Mason's absolute incompetence is bringing all the good work that's been done around him, down with him.
Reply
#29
SW - Maybe my ire is misplaced, but that's where it's lying right now. In my mind I'm separating the financial side of what Patel has achieved here, and the football side which Nestor is overseeing. I'm happy, generally, with what the new owners have brought to this club, it's a step in the right direction. But footballing wise, Nestor is the head of it, and he's ultimately accountable, in my mind. 

I don't even know who is to blame. I think the post above saying it's not one specific person, is correct. Players, Nestor, Mason, they're all making or have made, errors that is causing this shishow.

I'm just lashing out a little, because I'm pissed off. I'm more than likely way off, but what I'm certain of is that what we're seeing is not good enough. It's not as if I expect too much, I was firmly of the belief we weren't good enough for the play-offs and a 8-12th place finish was about right, but we're a million miles off that, and it's looking more and more likely we'll be embroiled in a relegation dog fight. That is not good enough, and I'm pissed off with it.
Reply
#30
The squad is weaker than it’s been in years, where this argument that it’s on a par with the last five or so years is barmy.

Palmer or Griffith - Palmer
Furlong or Campbell - Furlong
Kipre or Mephan - Kipre
Heggem or Phillips - Heggem
O’Shea or Bielik - O’Shea
Townsend or erm Styles - possibly Styles but he’s wasted at full back.
Price or Fellows (that’s where the money went) - Fellows
Bany or Fellows - Fellows

I’ve missed out loads of players as I have to go out but can we stop pretending that we have replaced with anywhere near the quality we have had to sell, because it’s a load of bollocks, that allows the myopic to vent at Mason whilst not addressing the inevitable drop off in results as we continually sell our best players and replace with less quality.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: