Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
12-27-2025, 10:58 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-27-2025, 11:00 AM by Lurker#3.)
(12-27-2025, 10:55 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Agree to disagree, chap. Nestor is absolutely part of the issue, and needa to go. I'm fully aware he's a Patel lapdog so won't go anywhere, but it doesn't stop me criticising him, for what a perceive as being inept at his role.
Finances - Improved
Communication - Improved
Womens team - Improved
Squad - Reduced the average age and signed some long term assets in really challenged circumstances.
Negatives: Managerial recruitment retrospectively - But that happens.
So yep, deffo an agree to disagree on this one, pal.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(12-27-2025, 10:58 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:55 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Agree to disagree, chap. Nestor is absolutely part of the issue, and needa to go. I'm fully aware he's a Patel lapdog so won't go anywhere, but it doesn't stop me criticising him, for what a perceive as being inept at his role.
Finances - Improved
Communication - Improved
Women team - Improved
Squad - Reduced the average age and signed some long term assets in really challenged circumstances.
Negatives: Managerial recruitment retrospectively - But that happens.
So yep, deffo an agree to disagree on this one, pal.
All very good but all very much offset if we get relegated. And the most likely cause of that relegation is Nestor’s blind backing of Mason. He should have been sacked weeks ago. Instead we got affirmation of the club’s support for him despite tge weight if evidence clearly showing he’s not capable.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
No arguments from me about Mason, CC. Should have been tinned after 6 games. But I understand the club wanting to show patience if they believe, between them that he doesn't have the squad. They will have to die on that hill though.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(12-27-2025, 10:52 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:45 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Nestor has headed up the biggest rebuild in the clubs history, dealing with some of the toughest financial situations in the pyramid.
We have managed to lower costs, raise money and still sign players that will improve and are keeping us competitive. Yes the balance of the squad is out, I said it on the day the window closed, and it's good to see them highlight that in the statement (a bit I missed, tbh).
This summer is a huge window, because we need to do business at the sharp end of the pitch, and that's always what will make and break opinions from fans.
Nestor and Bilkul are hugely in credit and I am absolutely gob smacked that so many are pointing thie finger their way. The only blight on their record at the moment is maybe not binned Mason.
I appreciate cutting costs like we have had to will lead to a lower quality squad. And that fact has been reflected in my leniency with Mason.
However, Nestor is the head of it all. He's ultimately accountable. Cutting costs doesn't excuse complete incompetency of his role. His signings, Heggebø the exception, have been piss poor.
Does cost cutting excuse the poor loan signings of Villa Cunt & Taylor? Does cost cutting excuse what has been two poor managerial appointments?
Our financial position does have our hands tied somewhat, but it's not an excuse for incompetence and the state of the club on the pitch right now. We should be seeing a damn sight better than what we are currently getting. From both Mason on the pitch, and Nestor off it.
The signings haven't been piss poor at all, Josh lad.
Price, Heggem, Heggebo, Johnston - All brilliant signings.
Phillips, Mepham, Campbell, Gilchrist - I believe will all be absolutely fine. regarding the likes of SIJ and Taylor - Yes it kinda does excuse them. They needed dirt cheap, low risk, squad fillers when we run out of money.
Yes we lack balance and haven't addressed the top end of the pitch, but that's the most expensive bit, and I hope they have just tried to kick that can down the road so they can do it properly this summer. All good signings if we didn’t have the worst manager in the league…
Ultimately football stewards are judged on their team’s results so if we go down…..
Disagree about signings and also what Nestor said: where is the upside of signings like Mepham and Phillips? Clearly large investments in terms of transfer fees and wages and limited resale value. You could say the same about Taylor and Bielik arguably. Had we appointed a quality manager and got the front six right then Phillips and Mepham could have been the cherry on top and propelled us to top three but not in this situation.
Posts: 1,020
Threads: 31
Joined: Nov 2025
Reputation:
3
Squad lacks balance, sure.
It doesn't lack defenders and we're crap in defence so that does make things a little bit awkward.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
12-27-2025, 11:10 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-27-2025, 11:12 AM by Josh1873.)
(12-27-2025, 10:58 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:55 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Agree to disagree, chap. Nestor is absolutely part of the issue, and needa to go. I'm fully aware he's a Patel lapdog so won't go anywhere, but it doesn't stop me criticising him, for what a perceive as being inept at his role.
Finances - Improved
Communication - Improved
Womens team - Improved
Squad - Reduced the average age and signed some long term assets in really challenged circumstances.
Negatives: Managerial recruitment retrospectively - But that happens.
So yep, deffo an agree to disagree on this one, pal.
Finances - Improved - not if we have to sack Mason, they won't. They certainly won't if we get relegated! I'm not really sure it should be seen as a positive action for Nestor. It's something we simply had to do.
Communication - Improved - I'd argue the latest communication was self serving. I'd rather see actions than communication.
Womens team - Improved - not really relevant to the mens team. I'm all for women's football, and I enjoy watching the Lionesses, but let's be blunt, very few people actually care about our women's team. All the best to them, but I couldn't give a monkeys whether that's improved, or not.
Squad - Reduced the average age - Comes with a reduction in squad value, really. Younger players tend to be cheaper signings, especially when you use the loan market. Again, that's more of a consequence of us having to be more of a selling club to comply with PSR. It's not necessarily something I'd give Nestor credit for.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(12-27-2025, 11:09 AM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote: Squad lacks balance, sure.
It doesn't lack defenders and we're crap in defence so that does make things a little bit awkward.
Exactly.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
12-27-2025, 11:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-27-2025, 11:17 AM by SW4Baggie.)
(12-27-2025, 11:08 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:52 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:45 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Nestor has headed up the biggest rebuild in the clubs history, dealing with some of the toughest financial situations in the pyramid.
We have managed to lower costs, raise money and still sign players that will improve and are keeping us competitive. Yes the balance of the squad is out, I said it on the day the window closed, and it's good to see them highlight that in the statement (a bit I missed, tbh).
This summer is a huge window, because we need to do business at the sharp end of the pitch, and that's always what will make and break opinions from fans.
Nestor and Bilkul are hugely in credit and I am absolutely gob smacked that so many are pointing thie finger their way. The only blight on their record at the moment is maybe not binned Mason.
I appreciate cutting costs like we have had to will lead to a lower quality squad. And that fact has been reflected in my leniency with Mason.
However, Nestor is the head of it all. He's ultimately accountable. Cutting costs doesn't excuse complete incompetency of his role. His signings, Heggebø the exception, have been piss poor.
Does cost cutting excuse the poor loan signings of Villa Cunt & Taylor? Does cost cutting excuse what has been two poor managerial appointments?
Our financial position does have our hands tied somewhat, but it's not an excuse for incompetence and the state of the club on the pitch right now. We should be seeing a damn sight better than what we are currently getting. From both Mason on the pitch, and Nestor off it.
The signings haven't been piss poor at all, Josh lad.
Price, Heggem, Heggebo, Johnston - All brilliant signings.
Phillips, Mepham, Campbell, Gilchrist - I believe will all be absolutely fine. regarding the likes of SIJ and Taylor - Yes it kinda does excuse them. They needed dirt cheap, low risk, squad fillers when we run out of money.
Yes we lack balance and haven't addressed the top end of the pitch, but that's the most expensive bit, and I hope they have just tried to kick that can down the road so they can do it properly this summer. All good signings if we didn’t have the worst manager in the league…
Ultimately football stewards are judged on their team’s results so if we go down…..
Disagree about signings and also what Nestor said: where is the upside of signings like Mepham and Phillips? Clearly large investments in terms of transfer fees and wages and limited resale value. You could say the same about Taylor and Bielik arguably. Had we appointed a quality manager and got the front six right then Phillips and Mepham could have been the cherry on top and propelled us to top three but not in this situation.
I don't disagree that we should be questionning some of the transfer business this summer - we didn't need both Gilchrist and Campbell for example, and that last 1m could have made a much bigger difference if it was spent on some pace in wide areas, or given us the option we sorely need in midfield. And, for all our much lauded new investment in scouting, the fact we missed players like Galbraith who is EXACTLY what we needed and well within budget remains a concern.
However, I agree with Lurker on the whole, Nestor's role should certainly be being questioned, but there's not been enough to justify sacking him IMO. We've made big profits in the market, reduced the age and cost of the squad, and we now have far more saleable assets going forward. Overall, I think we've done a lot of the right things behind the scenes considering the constraints we're operating under, but every week we persist with Mason undoes a month of positive work.
With a competent manager this squad, even with its limitations, would be in the play-off conversation. Whilst we may not be in the top 6, we should be within a few points of it. Unfortunately it is being woefully underutilised and that's making the work that's been done on turning over the squad seem far less effective than it has been.
Mason HAS to go... Nestor has to get the next appointment right, and then the TD that's being recruited needs to absolutely understand this division, and needs to have contacts within PL and lower league clubs.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
Perfect post, SW4.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(12-27-2025, 11:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (12-27-2025, 11:08 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:52 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (12-27-2025, 10:45 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Nestor has headed up the biggest rebuild in the clubs history, dealing with some of the toughest financial situations in the pyramid.
We have managed to lower costs, raise money and still sign players that will improve and are keeping us competitive. Yes the balance of the squad is out, I said it on the day the window closed, and it's good to see them highlight that in the statement (a bit I missed, tbh).
This summer is a huge window, because we need to do business at the sharp end of the pitch, and that's always what will make and break opinions from fans.
Nestor and Bilkul are hugely in credit and I am absolutely gob smacked that so many are pointing thie finger their way. The only blight on their record at the moment is maybe not binned Mason.
I appreciate cutting costs like we have had to will lead to a lower quality squad. And that fact has been reflected in my leniency with Mason.
However, Nestor is the head of it all. He's ultimately accountable. Cutting costs doesn't excuse complete incompetency of his role. His signings, Heggebø the exception, have been piss poor.
Does cost cutting excuse the poor loan signings of Villa Cunt & Taylor? Does cost cutting excuse what has been two poor managerial appointments?
Our financial position does have our hands tied somewhat, but it's not an excuse for incompetence and the state of the club on the pitch right now. We should be seeing a damn sight better than what we are currently getting. From both Mason on the pitch, and Nestor off it.
The signings haven't been piss poor at all, Josh lad.
Price, Heggem, Heggebo, Johnston - All brilliant signings.
Phillips, Mepham, Campbell, Gilchrist - I believe will all be absolutely fine. regarding the likes of SIJ and Taylor - Yes it kinda does excuse them. They needed dirt cheap, low risk, squad fillers when we run out of money.
Yes we lack balance and haven't addressed the top end of the pitch, but that's the most expensive bit, and I hope they have just tried to kick that can down the road so they can do it properly this summer. All good signings if we didn’t have the worst manager in the league…
Ultimately football stewards are judged on their team’s results so if we go down…..
Disagree about signings and also what Nestor said: where is the upside of signings like Mepham and Phillips? Clearly large investments in terms of transfer fees and wages and limited resale value. You could say the same about Taylor and Bielik arguably. Had we appointed a quality manager and got the front six right then Phillips and Mepham could have been the cherry on top and propelled us to top three but not in this situation.
I don't disagree that we should be questionning some of the transfer business this summer - we didn't need both Gilchrist and Campbell for example, and that last 1m could have made a much bigger difference if it was spent on some pace in wide areas, or given us the option we sorely need in midfield. And, for all our much lauded new investment in scouting, the fact we missed players like Galbraith who is EXACTLY what we needed and well within budget remains a concern.
However, I agree with Lurker on the whole, Nestor's role should certainly be being questioned, but there's not been enough to justify sacking him IMO. We've made big profits in the market, reduced the age and cost of the squad, and we now have far more saleable assets going forward. Overall, I think we've done a lot of the right things behind the scenes considering the constraints we're operating under, but every week we persist with Mason undoes a month of positive work.
With a competent manager this squad, even with it's limitations, would be in the play-off conversation. Whilst we may not be in the top 6, we should be within a few points of it. Unfortunately it is being woefully underutilised and that's making the work that's been done on turning over the squad seem far less effective than it has been.
Mason HAS to go... Nestor has to get the next appointment right, and then the TD that's being recruited needs to absolutely understand this division, and needs to have contacts within PL and lower league clubs. I don’t think he should or will be sacked and he appears to have recognised the need for a TD, but the two managerial appointments have been farcical and then to ignore youngsters like Galbraith, Pye etc and the clear need for pace was shocking.
|