The Ashes
I don't follow cricket closely but the article below is an interesting read.  

There's an idea put forward by Malcolm Gladwell that you need to practise something for 10,000 hours to become a world class expert in that skill.  Reading the below it look like some of the test team have little experience of county cricket let alone the rigour of test cricket.  The lack of planning and preparation smacks of arrogance or incompetence and probably both. 


The litany of mistakes that led to England’s Ashes humiliation

Simon Wilde
Cricket Correspondent, Adelaide
Saturday December 20 2025, 8.30pm, The Sunday Times

......................................................................


For too long management have overpromoted players on potential, tolerated their lack of cricket and prepared casually. McCullum, Key and Stokes can’t all survive fallout

The positions of Stokes, Key and McCullum must be reassessed

There is a memorable scene in Succession in which Logan Roy, the family patriarch, laments the lack of killer instinct among his children as they resist taking what he insists is the most pragmatic business deal. “I love you,” he says. “But you are not serious people.”

And so with Brendon McCullum’s regime. Under him, the England cricket team have become a fundamentally unserious operation, even if people admired — and perhaps loved — what they originally set out to do. Thinking he could liberate the players from pressure by creating a freewheeling environment, and being a convert to no-consequence cricket himself, McCullum tried to insulate them from the jeopardy that lies at the heart of all top-class competition.

There had been warnings as to the risks of this approach but it is only now, up against Australia in their own conditions — where they know how to turn themselves into one of the most ruthlessly efficient teams in all sport — that the flaws in McCullum’s approach have been laid bare.

McCullum and Stokes began their tenures as head coach and captain respectively in 2022 and quickly set about trying to change the mindset of England’s players
The backlash has scarcely begun but it is coming hard. One senior county figure, who was watching in Adelaide, said waspishly: “Well, I’ll say one thing for them. They have improved their golf handicaps. And they have done it at our expense.”

Fail to prepare, prepare to fail

McCullum’s relaxed style originally appeared to be a virtue as he took over a team that had lost their joy in the game, but what became clear with time was how pervasive this philosophy would be.

There was an impression that England had been preparing for this Ashes tour for three years but it turned out that the plans were, in many respects, always casual and flexible. McCullum enjoys horse racing and loves a punt, and he has taken those gambling instincts into the way he runs his team.

The pre-Ashes white-ball tour to New Zealand was the primary warm-up for a number of players. They lost the ODI series 3-0

Quite what preparations they could have chosen before the first Test is a matter of debate but it seems they were offered a game against a state side in Melbourne or Adelaide. The problem was that this would have involved a rush in arriving from the white-ball tour of New Zealand, plus England wanted to get on to the Perth time zone — so they declined. They also thought the white-ball games in New Zealand would be of value, but for various reasons — not all of them foreseeable — they were not.

Given the inexperienced nature of their squad, England should definitely have looked to play against Australian opposition rather than the internal warm-up they opted for against the Lions. McCullum and Rob Key, the managing director of England men’s cricket, got this wrong and may pay a heavy price. Richard Gould, the ECB chief executive, has a military background and it would be odd if he was soft on botched preparation.

Lack of mental toughness

Ben Stokes has tacitly admitted that some of his players found the hostility they encountered in the first and second Tests a shock, hence his calls for more fight and talk of there being no room for weak men. All too late when you are 2-0 down.

Smith’s lack of red-ball experience as a wicketkeeper has been exposed and he has possibly struggled with Australia’s aggression
Stokes and McCullum should have twigged that their policy of backing youth — and often youth with little experience of regular county cricket, let alone exposure to Australian aggression — was in danger of leading them to select personalities who were insufficiently game-hardened. Gus Atkinson, Shoaib Bashir, Jamie Smith and Jacob Bethell may all fall into this category.

McCullum himself had only ever toured Australia with his native New Zealand, a completely different proposition to England coming here with the Ashes on the line.
This lack of strategic or tactical awareness was evident when England toured India in early 2024 and lost 4-1. They seemed unaware that big runs in the first innings was the way to forge victories there — unlike in England, where pitches stay true for longer — hence Ben Duckett’s absurd comment in Rajkot that India could “have as many as they want, and we will go and get them”. Similarly, the way to win in Australia is to first get comfortable with the constant aggro.

Unserious selection and staffing blunders

Surely only a management group that have completely underestimated the task at hand would back a spinner in Bashir who does not even hold a county contract and has not bowled in a competitive match for months, a wicketkeeper who does not keep regularly for his county in Smith, and a spare batsman in Bethell who is only 22 and has never scored a first-class century.

Bethell, right, has been mooted as a replacement at No3 for the struggling Ollie Pope, but the 22-year-old is short on game-time and has never scored a first-class century
Meanwhile, all of the Australians bar Pat Cummins prepared for this series by playing at least one Sheffield Shield match, and in most cases two or three. For too long McCullum has allowed a culture to exist where not playing cricket seemed wholly acceptable. That cannot be right.

Few would dispute that England have played well below their potential here and the head coach is going to have to outline why. If the explanation is a shortage of cricket, he has a problem.

He and Key (who leads on selection) have also been reluctant to drop their favoured players even when their returns have been thin. Alternatives have been given very little chance to show what they can do — Bethell got his chance in New Zealand only in an emergency — and this loyalty may well have done much to create a cosseted atmosphere that falls apart when they are outplayed, as they have been here.

No one knows if there are batsmen out there who could score more runs, or spinners with a resilience Bashir may lack, because so few players have been tried.
England gambled on Wood’s fitness in the pursuit of all-out pace but Australia have displayed the value of line-and-length bowling

The plan to come to Australia with a hostile pace attack was perhaps fair enough but there is still no substitute for repeatedly hitting a good line and length, as the Australians have done. England’s bowlers — with one or two notable exceptions — have been unable to do that. Mark Wood was a gamble that did not pay off, as was fairly clear would be the case several months ago.

Yes, James Anderson was forcibly retired but Chris Woakes was never going to feature here and was allowed to stay so long that it denied others much-needed exposure.
One area in which McCullum acted ruthlessly was in paring down his backroom staff. He wanted players to think for themselves but this move also denied them the kind of training they needed from fielding coaches who are no longer around. Sure enough, dropped catches have been a part of what has gone wrong.

Loss of faith in Bazball

The management should also have known that trying to play their high-octane game of aggression was at risk of unravelling on Australia’s bouncy pitches. Australia knew how England were going to play and — as Scott Boland effectively said — all their bowlers had to do was stick the ball outside off stump and let the batsmen hang themselves. The tourists had no plan B.

Persisting with playing high-octane cricket has not worked out for the likes of Duckett

Even before the team got to Australia, there were signs of some players — including Joe Root and even Stokes himself — making their own adjustments. The way England’s run chase petered out against India at the Oval in the final Test of the summer suggested a team that were losing their nerve, and in the course of the past month we have seen their nerves break completely.

Watching this England team now, no one would think they were so original that it was necessary to invent a name to describe them. Stokes’s half-century on Friday was England’s slowest of the “Bazball” era.

The messy fallout

The damage could be widespread. The counties have been asked to produce players in England’s mould — Stokes said in 2022 that the new way England played “sent a message to anyone who wants to play Test cricket for England” and that Sir Alastair Cook would not get in his side — but where do things stand now? If Bazball no longer works, and is no longer being followed by the central actors, then what is the point? How are people supposed to play?

Key’s biggest mistake was perhaps putting McCullum in charge of the white-ball sides as well as the Test team. White-ball cricket needs detail but McCullum is a broad-brush man, not a details one. Within days of the Ashes ending, McCullum needs to throw himself into a white-ball tour to Sri Lanka and a T20 World Cup. If McCullum is sacked, is he sacked from everything or just red-ball cricket?

Key, McCullum and Stokes got their jobs on the back of demands for improvement after the disastrous tour to Australia four years ago. But this one has arguably been worse, and certainly more careless.


 They can’t all survive.
Reply
Thanks for posting that OF. I'll have to study it later when I am home. Another good read is on the BBC website, Booze, Beach, Beaten. This defeat hurts so much more than the many others. 30 years ago we were up against one of the best cricket teams in history, it was no disgrace to lose. Currently this Aussie side is weak on many levels, to surrender so meekly is unforgivable. For me, Key and McCullum should fall on their swords.
Reply
Sir Alistair Cook wouldn`t get in Stokes side? I bet he would get in the current Aussie side.
Reply
(12-22-2025, 11:14 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Sir Alistair Cook wouldn`t get in Stokes side? I bet he would get in the current Aussie side.

Quite.
Reply
Cummins now ruled out for the rest of the series.

If we get rolled 5-0 by an Australian side with no Cummins, Hazelwood, a half fit Nathan Lyon, an opening partnership picked as a bit of a joke, an English specialist mid-on batting seven and Michael Neser taking 5fers then they ought to be made to swim home.
Reply
(12-23-2025, 07:51 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Cummins now ruled out for the rest of the series.

If we get rolled 5-0 by an Australian side with no Cummins, Hazelwood, a half fit Nathan Lyon, an opening partnership picked as a bit of a joke, an English specialist mid-on batting seven and Michael Neser taking 5fers then they ought to be made to swim home.

No half fit Lyon either. Ruled out of the series.
Reply
Nesser has a good Test record and would have played more had Australia not had so many good bowlers.

Who would you pick instead? I would have Leach over Bashir but most of the players suggested e.g. Hameed, Sibley, Jennings and Dawson have played Test cricket and do not have great records. Sam Hain and Sam Northeast are probably a bit too old and do not bat in the top 3 where the vacancies are. Coad at Yorkshire has the best domestic record of English bowlers yet is deemed not quick enough. Is he much slower than Boland and Nesser?
Reply
(12-23-2025, 09:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Nesser has a good Test record and would have played more had Australia not had so many good bowlers.

Who would you pick instead? I would have Leach over Bashir but most of the players suggested e.g. Hameed, Sibley, Jennings and Dawson have played Test cricket and do not have great records. Sam Hain and Sam Northeast are probably a bit too old and do not bat in the top 3 where the vacancies are. Coad at Yorkshire has the best domestic record of English bowlers yet is deemed not quick enough. Is he much slower than Boland and Nesser?

I don't think other than the omission of Dawson or Leach it's a selection issue.

I wouldn't have spent the previous three years preparing roads so we can score runs freely against inferior opposition and paper over huge holes in players techniques. 
I wouldn't have picked some of the bowlers we've given test caps out to just because they bowl 85mph.
I wouldn't have turned the team into some moral crusade to save something that works just fine in other countries.
I'd have probably tried to reward some other county players rather than the likes of Bethel who's done nothing to warrant being in the squad and also means we're now unable to drop Ollie Pope who is cooked.
Prior to the Perth test I'd have probably tried to get the WACA for practice, it was available. Rather than the club ground at Lilac Hill. Would have probably taken than game a bit more seriously too. 
I'd not have sacked all our specialist coaches, especially the fielding one, or allowed our bowling coach to disappear to a T10 tournament mid-series before returning back for the Sydney test.

This is probably the most talented group we've taken there since 10-11, if they had the mindset and the preparation of that group, playing against this Australia side I do not think we'd be sitting 3-0 right now. This team is capable, Duckett, Brook notably are wasting potential. 

I see Baz has come out and said that he wants to continue... I'm not sure Key is the man to sack him either.
Reply
(12-23-2025, 10:11 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-23-2025, 09:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Nesser has a good Test record and would have played more had Australia not had so many good bowlers.

Who would you pick instead? I would have Leach over Bashir but most of the players suggested e.g. Hameed, Sibley, Jennings and Dawson have played Test cricket and do not have great records. Sam Hain and Sam Northeast are probably a bit too old and do not bat in the top 3 where the vacancies are. Coad at Yorkshire has the best domestic record of English bowlers yet is deemed not quick enough. Is he much slower than Boland and Nesser?

I don't think other than the omission of Dawson or Leach it's a selection issue.

I wouldn't have spent the previous three years preparing roads so we can score runs freely against inferior opposition and paper over huge holes in players techniques. 
I wouldn't have picked some of the bowlers we've given test caps out to just because they bowl 85mph.
I wouldn't have turned the team into some moral crusade to save something that works just fine in other countries.
I'd have probably tried to reward some other county players rather than the likes of Bethel who's done nothing to warrant being in the squad and also means we're now unable to drop Ollie Pope who is cooked.
Prior to the Perth test I'd have probably tried to get the WACA for practice, it was available. Rather than the club ground at Lilac Hill. Would have probably taken than game a bit more seriously too. 
I'd not have sacked all our specialist coaches, especially the fielding one, or allowed our bowling coach to disappear to a T10 tournament mid-series before returning back for the Sydney test.

This is probably the most talented group we've taken there since 10-11, if they had the mindset and the preparation of that group, playing against this Australia side I do not think we'd be sitting 3-0 right now. This team is capable, Duckett, Brook notably are wasting potential. 

I see Baz has come out and said that he wants to continue... I'm not sure Key is the man to sack him either.

Great post, Ted. I'd suggest reading through that BBC website article I posted upthread for another page of things we could have done differently.
Reply
Some pretty dire footage of Ben Duckett from the trip to Noosa before the Adelaide test.

Find it hard to see how he plays the rest of the series after that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)