Posts: 3,822
Threads: 250
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(12-07-2025, 11:48 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (12-07-2025, 10:57 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Well I'm going to South Africa next winter but might reconsider. If I want to watch crap sport I can stay and watch the Albion.
Just go to SA and avoid the cricket, although at least one day of sunshine at Newlands should be tolerable.
I thought I would enjoy that - then Jonah Lomu trampled out entire team!
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Listened to the Ben Stokes post-match comments. Yes, he's showing a hint of humility for a change, but it's still pretty much Billy-Big-Bollocks stuff. "A dressing room that I am captain of is not a place for weak men".
I think, Ben, that you and Baz have created the whole mindset of that dressing room by the force of your own personalities. You have obstinately persisted with certain players who haven't risen to the challenge. You've created a situation where the players don't play much cricket and aren't under any pressure for their places in the side. It's not really fair to call them out for being "weak" when they are creatures of your own making.
Posts: 3,108
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(12-07-2025, 11:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Listened to the Ben Stokes post-match comments. Yes, he's showing a hint of humility for a change, but it's still pretty much Billy-Big-Bollocks stuff. "A dressing room that I am captain of is not a place for weak men".
I think, Ben, that you and Baz have created the whole mindset of that dressing room by the force of your own personalities. You have obstinately persisted with certain players who haven't risen to the challenge. You've created a situation where the players don't play much cricket and aren't under any pressure for their places in the side. It's not really fair to call them out for being "weak" when they are creatures of your own making.
Aye, I've not heard the detail yet, just the headline but I'm thinking this needs to end. Not ITK at all but I know some that watch County Cricket around the country. The story regularly comes back about the England golf clique and you have to fit in. I love Stokes for his belief, for his ability to make things happen, and for inspiring others to achieve what looks impossible. But to me that is starting to look like an amazingly gifted individual thinking everyone can achieve if they just believe. I wouldn't throw the entire plan away, England have lost multiple games in my lifespan by defending or being unadventurous. But if you think you can just throw wickets away and drop catches then claw it all back with a 4th innings run chase you need to stop believing in fairies. Golf is for when the squad is relaxing and shouldn't be the defining selection.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
12-08-2025, 10:27 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-08-2025, 10:35 AM by AnelkasBeard.)
TL;DR - Fuck Key and Baz off, get a proper hard-nosed bastard in as coach, bring back merit-based selection but wholesale changes are not needed yet.
Utterly abject defeat. I won't bother with a post mortem as you've all said it all. Let's look at how we move forward and try and fix this.
Stokes is a very good to great captain. He inspires belief through both action and speech. I think, with the right coach, he'll still be a very good captain. Especially after his post-match interview, I don't think he's the problem, and he should stay on.
The problem is the rot at the top, specifically Key and Baz. Key is an absolute tool. A jobs-for-the-boys, "I know best", fuck your opinion tool. The rot starts with him, and his abject management of the situation (if you can even call it management). He needs to be fucked off into the sun and never seen or heard from again (in the cricketing sense). His vibes based approach to selection and his ruining of the cricket in this country is disgusting. Has to go yesterday and be replaced with someone competent.
Baz is stealing a living at this point. He seemingly does fuck all to prepare them now, and whatever preparation they are doing is completely useless. According to Tresco, the fucking batting coach, they hadn't even talked about not driving on the up in these first two Tests. That's dereliction of duty. Southee is meant to be bowling consultant, have you seen him anywhere this tour? Seriously, no wonder these players look utterly bereft of a plan or any ideas. They aren't being assisted by the "coaching team" even slightly. Clean house.
A comment on what Bazball was when it started. There was method to the madness. They didn't just try and smack everything. If it was a good ball, they defended or left it. If it was too short or full, they whacked it. Look at YJB's innings in the chases against NZ and India, and look at the Pakistan batting performances when we won away. It wasn't see ball, hit ball. They've completed lost their way. Brook is the perfect example, he seems to have believed his own hype and lost the ability to bat properly.
Now, the replacement coach needs to be a hard-nosed pragmatic coach who will tell these fucks to get their houses in order. Someone like Gillespie, Langer, even Ponting if he would do it (yes I know, they're all Aussies). You can then mesh this hard-nosed pragmatism with the aggressive captaincy of Stokes and I think it will be a good recipe for at least competent and proper cricket.
On to the players - I really don't think wholesale changes are needed here, yet. What does need to happen is CC performances need to be taken into account, and when a Test player hasn't performed for 7-10 matches (give them a chance), they need to know their position is under threat. Merit based selection is a must, not fucking release height bullshit.
Batters
Crawley - bang average opener. He's fine, and is capable of a good innings every few matches. But it's time to give the likes of Hameed or Sibley another try.
Duckett - Has had a poor tour, but he averages over 40 and has generally been very good in the past few years. He stays
Pope - not good enough, never has been. Bethell isn't the answer here either. I think Jordan Cox deserves a chance.
Root - god, enough said.
Brook - get his psyche back to when he started and he's Root's successor. He still averages 55 in Tests. Good mentoring and a reset of his mentality, and he'll be great.
Stokes - should stay and play as captain. He clearly has the mentality and ability still as the last innings showed. We need to see it more.
Smith - Had an abject tour. But he needs some time to see if he can turn it around, and to see if he can actually bat under pressure. If not, then get James Rew in.
Bowlers
Archer - if fit enough, he's in. Treated so much more harshly than the likes of Wood, and we should all know why. He's made such a huge effort to get himself back fit enough for the Test team after being ruined by Root, so I really don't see the angle that he's just going to fuck off to T20. He would've done that already.
Wood - when he's fit, he's in. But we need to have a plan B for when he isn't.
Atkinson - not got the wickets this tour, but he's a very decent bowler who can also bat when his head isn't on Mars. In.
Carse - Again, given the correct direction I think he's fine. Would be 4th choice for me, and the replacement for Archer/Wood when they're injured.
Potts and Fisher are the next cabs of the rank, and deserve a shot through injuries or poor form.
Spinner - I think Dawson should get this position. His CC record is good, and he's your stereotypical average spinner, who can also bat. He's the safe pick until... Rehan Ahmed is ready to step in. His batting form has been really good for a prolonged period now, and his bowling is still decent. He'll only get better with time.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Find it hard to disagree with much of that AB.
I do think in trying to create the ultimate environment for mates, no pressure etc they've removed the one thing that drives truly elite performance.
I think Key needs to go as cult leader full culpability lies with him. Anyone defending him, I suggest reading the first few chapters of Jimmy Anderson's autobiography to see how they dealt with that situation. Very telling.
We need a new coach - I'd be looking to someone like Langer, Ponting, Kirsten or maybe even a Jonathan Trott. Ponting if he wanted the job would be my pick though.
Who are the replacements for Crawley and Pope, I agree I don't think Bethel has played enough FC cricket yet. I'd like to see Tom Haines from Sussex get a go, there is also Emilio Gay (Northants) and Josh Bohannon (Lancs) who has a good record in the top order. Jamie Smith has enough credit in the bank for me, I think he's clearly talented but has gone the same was as Brook. I agree on Dawson, if we're not going back to Jack Leach too.
I think the rest of this series could be a real mess, we've no other options to open and it's Bethel who will replace Pope, unless they pluck someone from the Lions side. Although that seems unlikely given the pummeling they've just had from the Aus Prime Ministers XI.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(12-08-2025, 11:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Find it hard to disagree with much of that AB.
I do think in trying to create the ultimate environment for mates, no pressure etc they've removed the one thing that drives truly elite performance.
I think Key needs to go as cult leader full culpability lies with him. Anyone defending him, I suggest reading the first few chapters of Jimmy Anderson's autobiography to see how they dealt with that situation. Very telling.
We need a new coach - I'd be looking to someone like Langer, Ponting, Kirsten or maybe even a Jonathan Trott. Ponting if he wanted the job would be my pick though.
Who are the replacements for Crawley and Pope, I agree I don't think Bethel has played enough FC cricket yet. I'd like to see Tom Haines from Sussex get a go, there is also Emilio Gay (Northants) and Josh Bohannon (Lancs) who has a good record in the top order. Jamie Smith has enough credit in the bank for me, I think he's clearly talented but has gone the same was as Brook. I agree on Dawson, if we're not going back to Jack Leach too.
I think the rest of this series could be a real mess, we've no other options to open and it's Bethel who will replace Pope, unless they pluck someone from the Lions side. Although that seems unlikely given the pummeling they've just had from the Aus Prime Ministers XI.
Agreed - the original ethos of "we want them to play attacking shots without fear of being dropped instantly" was a good one. It allows them to bat more freely. But they've taken it way way too far. There has to be a line where the player needs to be told they need to start performing better or risk losing their spot.
Agree with all your shouts for the potential replacements. We just have to make sure we give them a good go, not just 1 or 2 Tests as had happened in the past.
Trott is a good shout for the coach. Likewise I'd love it to be Punter, but I just don't see him wanting the full time position.
Another mentality change that has to happen - stop treating the Ashes like it's the be all and end all, to the detriment of every other series.
Play every series with the focus on THAT series. Pick the most in-form players at that time. The by-product will be more wins, players used to playing to win and focusing on the task at hand, and therefore a more competent and battle hardened team. If they always have the excuse of "well it isn't the Ashes, so it doesn't mean as much", when it comes to the Ashes, they just won't have the mental practice to deal with the cauldron the Ashes creates, especially in Aus.
Posts: 9,655
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
Some fantastic posts Anelka. Pretty much spot on.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(12-08-2025, 11:33 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (12-08-2025, 11:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Find it hard to disagree with much of that AB.
I do think in trying to create the ultimate environment for mates, no pressure etc they've removed the one thing that drives truly elite performance.
I think Key needs to go as cult leader full culpability lies with him. Anyone defending him, I suggest reading the first few chapters of Jimmy Anderson's autobiography to see how they dealt with that situation. Very telling.
We need a new coach - I'd be looking to someone like Langer, Ponting, Kirsten or maybe even a Jonathan Trott. Ponting if he wanted the job would be my pick though.
Who are the replacements for Crawley and Pope, I agree I don't think Bethel has played enough FC cricket yet. I'd like to see Tom Haines from Sussex get a go, there is also Emilio Gay (Northants) and Josh Bohannon (Lancs) who has a good record in the top order. Jamie Smith has enough credit in the bank for me, I think he's clearly talented but has gone the same was as Brook. I agree on Dawson, if we're not going back to Jack Leach too.
I think the rest of this series could be a real mess, we've no other options to open and it's Bethel who will replace Pope, unless they pluck someone from the Lions side. Although that seems unlikely given the pummeling they've just had from the Aus Prime Ministers XI.
Agreed - the original ethos of "we want them to play attacking shots without fear of being dropped instantly" was a good one. It allows them to bat more freely. But they've taken it way way too far. There has to be a line where the player needs to be told they need to start performing better or risk losing their spot.
Agree with all your shouts for the potential replacements. We just have to make sure we give them a good go, not just 1 or 2 Tests as had happened in the past.
Trott is a good shout for the coach. Likewise I'd love it to be Punter, but I just don't see him wanting the full time position.
Another mentality change that has to happen - stop treating the Ashes like it's the be all and end all, to the detriment of every other series.
Play every series with the focus on THAT series. Pick the most in-form players at that time. The by-product will be more wins, players used to playing to win and focusing on the task at hand, and therefore a more competent and battle hardened team. If they always have the excuse of "well it isn't the Ashes, so it doesn't mean as much", when it comes to the Ashes, they just won't have the mental practice to deal with the cauldron the Ashes creates, especially in Aus.
Feels as though Stokes has got to that point, when he talks about mentality and losing the key moments this has to be what he means.
There is no fear of losing in this team and all great teams HATED losing. These lot just shrug their shoulders and carry on telling each other how great they are. Stokes post-match comments were the closest thing I've seen in three years to saying it's not good enough and something has to change.
Posts: 159
Threads: 2
Joined: Mar 2025
Reputation:
0
(12-07-2025, 11:42 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (12-07-2025, 11:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Listened to the Ben Stokes post-match comments. Yes, he's showing a hint of humility for a change, but it's still pretty much Billy-Big-Bollocks stuff. "A dressing room that I am captain of is not a place for weak men".
I think, Ben, that you and Baz have created the whole mindset of that dressing room by the force of your own personalities. You have obstinately persisted with certain players who haven't risen to the challenge. You've created a situation where the players don't play much cricket and aren't under any pressure for their places in the side. It's not really fair to call them out for being "weak" when they are creatures of your own making.
Aye, I've not heard the detail yet, just the headline but I'm thinking this needs to end. Not ITK at all but I know some that watch County Cricket around the country. The story regularly comes back about the England golf clique and you have to fit in. I love Stokes for his belief, for his ability to make things happen, and for inspiring others to achieve what looks impossible. But to me that is starting to look like an amazingly gifted individual thinking everyone can achieve if they just believe. I wouldn't throw the entire plan away, England have lost multiple games in my lifespan by defending or being unadventurous. But if you think you can just throw wickets away and drop catches then claw it all back with a 4th innings run chase you need to stop believing in fairies. Golf is for when the squad is relaxing and shouldn't be the defining selection.
I think the same of McCullum too, he was an incredibly talented batsman and probably needed a few balls to play himself back into form. Whereas for the vast majority of batsmen they need as much practice and time in the middle as possible. It seems as though McCullum doesn't see that.
There is a reason that nearly all batters are privately educated (unlike fast bowlers) as they have had much more time dedicated into them with training, coaching and matches.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(12-08-2025, 10:27 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: TL;DR - Fuck Key and Baz off, get a proper hard-nosed bastard in as coach, bring back merit-based selection but wholesale changes are not needed yet.
Utterly abject defeat. I won't bother with a post mortem as you've all said it all. Let's look at how we move forward and try and fix this.
Stokes is a very good to great captain. He inspires belief through both action and speech. I think, with the right coach, he'll still be a very good captain. Especially after his post-match interview, I don't think he's the problem, and he should stay on.
The problem is the rot at the top, specifically Key and Baz. Key is an absolute tool. A jobs-for-the-boys, "I know best", fuck your opinion tool. The rot starts with him, and his abject management of the situation (if you can even call it management). He needs to be fucked off into the sun and never seen or heard from again (in the cricketing sense). His vibes based approach to selection and his ruining of the cricket in this country is disgusting. Has to go yesterday and be replaced with someone competent.
Baz is stealing a living at this point. He seemingly does fuck all to prepare them now, and whatever preparation they are doing is completely useless. According to Tresco, the fucking batting coach, they hadn't even talked about not driving on the up in these first two Tests. That's dereliction of duty. Southee is meant to be bowling consultant, have you seen him anywhere this tour? Seriously, no wonder these players look utterly bereft of a plan or any ideas. They aren't being assisted by the "coaching team" even slightly. Clean house.
A comment on what Bazball was when it started. There was method to the madness. They didn't just try and smack everything. If it was a good ball, they defended or left it. If it was too short or full, they whacked it. Look at YJB's innings in the chases against NZ and India, and look at the Pakistan batting performances when we won away. It wasn't see ball, hit ball. They've completed lost their way. Brook is the perfect example, he seems to have believed his own hype and lost the ability to bat properly.
Now, the replacement coach needs to be a hard-nosed pragmatic coach who will tell these fucks to get their houses in order. Someone like Gillespie, Langer, even Ponting if he would do it (yes I know, they're all Aussies). You can then mesh this hard-nosed pragmatism with the aggressive captaincy of Stokes and I think it will be a good recipe for at least competent and proper cricket.
On to the players - I really don't think wholesale changes are needed here, yet. What does need to happen is CC performances need to be taken into account, and when a Test player hasn't performed for 7-10 matches (give them a chance), they need to know their position is under threat. Merit based selection is a must, not fucking release height bullshit.
Batters
Crawley - bang average opener. He's fine, and is capable of a good innings every few matches. But it's time to give the likes of Hameed or Sibley another try.
Duckett - Has had a poor tour, but he averages over 40 and has generally been very good in the past few years. He stays
Pope - not good enough, never has been. Bethell isn't the answer here either. I think Jordan Cox deserves a chance.
Root - god, enough said.
Brook - get his psyche back to when he started and he's Root's successor. He still averages 55 in Tests. Good mentoring and a reset of his mentality, and he'll be great.
Stokes - should stay and play as captain. He clearly has the mentality and ability still as the last innings showed. We need to see it more.
Smith - Had an abject tour. But he needs some time to see if he can turn it around, and to see if he can actually bat under pressure. If not, then get James Rew in.
Bowlers
Archer - if fit enough, he's in. Treated so much more harshly than the likes of Wood, and we should all know why. He's made such a huge effort to get himself back fit enough for the Test team after being ruined by Root, so I really don't see the angle that he's just going to fuck off to T20. He would've done that already.
Wood - when he's fit, he's in. But we need to have a plan B for when he isn't.
Atkinson - not got the wickets this tour, but he's a very decent bowler who can also bat when his head isn't on Mars. In.
Carse - Again, given the correct direction I think he's fine. Would be 4th choice for me, and the replacement for Archer/Wood when they're injured.
Potts and Fisher are the next cabs of the rank, and deserve a shot through injuries or poor form.
Spinner - I think Dawson should get this position. His CC record is good, and he's your stereotypical average spinner, who can also bat. He's the safe pick until... Rehan Ahmed is ready to step in. His batting form has been really good for a prolonged period now, and his bowling is still decent. He'll only get better with time.
Wood is nearly 36 and I think has played one first game this calendar year
Archer played for Sussex once in the Championship this season, his first First Class game for four years
If you think that is ideal preparation we will beg to differ.
James Rew maybe worth a go, he has a good record for Somerset and can keep
I wonder how some of the very good county seamers e.g. Ben Coad would do in Tests, Nesser seems to do ok. Why have we discarded Robinson, I know he has a bit of a reputation, but he takes wickets.
Not sure about Hameed and Sibley they have been tried before, the latter seems to have developed his game so he now plays T20 so might be worth a recall. Hameed struggles against the quicks.
Bethall needs to play County Championship cricket, it seems strange we are going to pick him, yet he has never scored a First Class hundred. he did well in New Zealand but against an ageing attack, a number of whom are now retired.
Ali Orr might get a mention if he can stay fit.
|